Introduction of Evidence Flashcards
(15 cards)
Jury decides questions of ____ and the judge decides questions of _____
fact; law
Evidence admissibility is a question of?
law
-judge decides whether evidence is admissible
Many evidentiary issues are decided prior to trial through?
motions in limine or preliminary hearings
For preliminary factual decisions, the court is not bound by?
the federal rules of evidence (FRE)
Preliminary hearings
conducted outside the presence of the jury in 3 circumstances:
1.when the issue is the admissibility of a confession in a criminal trial
2.when the defendant in a criminal case is a witness and makes that request; and
- when the interests of justice otherwise require
Evidentiary ruling can be reversed on appeal only if:
- a substantial right of a party was affected and
- the judge was notified of the mistake at trial and given a chance to correct it
Plain error rule
Plain error is an error that was obvious to the reviewing court
Two ways to notify the court to preserve it for appeal
- Objection
- Offer of proof
Objection
If the court admits evidence that should have been excluded, must object or make a motion to strike and explain why the evidence should have been excluded
Offer of proof
If the court excludes evidence that should have been admitted, must make an offer of proof on the record
(offer of proof is an explanation of the relevance and admissibility of the evidence)
Limited admissibility (Rule 105)
Evidence may be admissible for one purpose, but not for another purpose, or against one party, but not against another party
Rule of completeness (Rule 106)
Allows relevant portions of documents or recording to be admitted as necessary to complete other evidence
Judicial notice
The courts acceptance of a fact as true w/o requiring formal proof (can happen at any stage of the proceeding)
Judicial notice may not be taken against a?
criminal defendant on appeal
How is judicial notice instructed to the jury in civil v. criminal cases
-Civil: court will instruct the jury that it must accept the fact as proven
-Criminal: court will instruct the jury that it may find that fact (not required)