Learning Theories Flashcards
(54 cards)
What is meant by Thematic Analysis?
- the aim of thematic analysis is to analyse the data without losing its meaningfulness but making the data more manageable by reducing it into patterns, trends and themes
- A technique used when analysing quantitative data - Data is produced, for e.g., from the transcripts of an interview, and then themes or categories are identified
- researcher then goes through transcripts and notes where each theme/category is found and might draw out a few examples
What are the main aims of thematic analysis?
- to impose some order on the data
- to ensure that the order represents the participants perspective
- to summarise the data so that hundreds of pages or text or pictures, or hours of recordings can be reduced to something more meaningful
- to enable general conclusions to be drawn
There are 2 approaches that can be taken when carrying out thematic analysis, what are they?
Inductive approach- researcher would read and re-read the qualitative data gathered and themes would emerge, WITHOUT the researcher imposing their ideas or expectations
Deductive approach- researcher would specify the themes that they will look in the data before analysing the data
What are the 10 steps to carrying out thematic analysis?
- Gather - gather quantitative data using suitable tool such as questionnaire or interview
- Journal- begin a reflexive journal, this is to log the process of carrying out a thematic analysis
- Prepare- transcribe the data carefully, using no interpretation, prepare the data ready for analysis
- Appoint- appoint coders, researcher can be a coder but does not have to be
- Familiarise- The data have to become well known and familiar to the coder
- Ideas- each piece of data has to be identified as an idea, to shorten what is said or found into something manageable
- Identifying Themes- From the ideas, the coder will identify themes, an idea can theme in its own right
- Naming Themes- Themes are named and then the analysis can be reviewed to check where the data fits and to reconsider ideas in the light
- Reliability/Validity check- review journal to look for any interpretations, and put that right so that the data is valid
- Report of the results- write up the report of the results , a report would include a description of the analysis process, as well as issues raised by the reflective journal
What are strengths of thematic analysis?
- well suited to large data sets
- great for multiple researchers
- interpretation of themes supported by data
- allows for categories to emerge from data
- flexibility it allows researchers, in that multiple theories can be applied to this process across
- discovery and verification of themes and codes mesh
- allows researchers to expand range of study past individual experiences
- applicable to research questions that go beyond an individual’s experience
What are weaknesses of thematic analysis?
- limited interpretive power if analysis excludes theoretical framework
- flexibility makes it difficult to concentrate on what aspect of the data to focus on
- reliability is a concern due to the wide variety of interpretations from multiple researchers
- difficult to maintain sense of continuity of data in individual accounts
what is meant by content analysis?
(indirect observation)
- type of observational study in which behaviour is seen indirectly in written or verbal material that considers the content of articles, newspapers, media programs and books - auditory or visual material
- it involves exploring articles to find out key terms or instances, generating categories (themes-possibly using thematic analysis) and then instances are in each category can be counted so that quantitative data is produced
what are the three types of content analysis?
- conventional content analysis= picking categories out from the data
- directive content analysis= theory drives the categories
- summative content analysis= searching for key words and then counting them before interpreting the data
what are the strengths of content analysis?
- content analysis is a readily understood, inexpensive research method. It is unobtrusive, and doesn’t require contact with people
- researchers can learn much about a media production’s policies, target audience, politics and financial support. becomes a more powerful tool when combined with other research methods such as interviews, observation, and use of archival records. it is useful for analysing historical material, especially for documenting trends over time
- establishing reliability is easy and straightforward. Of all the research methods, content analysis scores highest regarding ease of replication. usually the materials can be made available for others to use
- tends to have high ecological validity because it is based on observations of what people actually do- real communications that are current and relevant
what are the weaknesses of content analysis?
- content analysis is a purely descriptive method. it describes what is there but may not reveal the underlying motives for the observed pattern (“what” but not “why”)
- the analysis is limited by availability of material. observed trends in media may not be an accurate reflection of reality; for example, catastrophic events receive more coverage than less dramatic occurrences
- observer bias reduces the objectivity and ecological validity of findings because different observers may interpret the meaning of the categories differently
- likely to be culture-bound because source material is rooted in culture and behavioural categories are likely to be determined by culture and the observer
animal research: the use of animals in laboratory experiments, what are the guidelines for using animals?
bps has published guidelines based on animals
- the document refers to the 3rs, replacing, reducing and refining
guideline for using animals:
A appropriate use of anaesthetic and pain killers to keep suffering to a minimum
N non - animal methods cannot be done (replacing)
I important enough to justify its use (refining)
M minimum number of animals is used (reducing)
A accommodation has the right facilities to look after the animals properly
L legislation is followed from bps
S skills, experience and training of all competent staff involved
animal research: what is the cost benefit analysis?
the bateson’s decision cube is useful to decide when to use an animal which is based around 3 issues:
- usefulness of findings
- distress to the animal,
reliability of the research
the cost to the animal must be taken into account and the benefits of the study must be weighed up against the costs
- if the findings do not have validity, reliability, or generalizability then perhaps it is not a good research and cannot be justified
what are 3 arguments for the use of animals?
- Bateson’s cube is useful - decisions about carrying out a study using animals have to take into account 3 issues
1. how useful the findings are going to be
2. what distress will be caused
3. how sound the research is (e.g. in terms of reliability) - Gray 1991- argued we have moral responsibility to our own species to understand as much as we can, which is on the side of using animals
- Singer 1975- argues research should take place if for the greatest good of the greatest number
Darwin showed through his ideas about evolution that findings from animals can be generalised to humans
what are 3 arguments against the use of animals
singer 1975- argues that we should not carry out anything on animals that we would not carry out on ourselves- speciesism
- findings from animals may not be generalisable so there is no justification for doing studies using animals
- the cost-benefit argument does not work as the cost to animals might not be known at the start and neither might the benefit of the findings
what are some ethical issues regarding the use of animals in laboratory experiments?
- physical harm
- psychological harm
- stress and neglect
- people might not be qualified to work with animals
- animals are used for makeup - testing
evaluating the use of animals in laboratory experiments, what are the strengths?
- animal are relatively small and usually easy to handle so procedures can be more feasible than if using humans
- some animals have short gestation periods and reproductive cycles so generations and genes can be studied more easily than with humans
- some animals have similar brain structure (e.g. rats and mice) to humans and so there is value in using animals in studies and relating the findings to humans
evaluating the use of animals in laboratory experiments, what are the weaknesses?
- the brains of animals are not exactly the same as humans so generalizing findings to humans might not be valuable
- using animals in studies and then drawing conclusions about humans does not address the complexity of human processing and behaviour
methods: observations
observations can be used within research methods such as case studies and laboratory experiments or they can be used on their own
- their is no IV to manipulate
- all data is gathered by simply observing
you could gather QUANTITATIVE DATA e.g. observing how many times people act aggressively or QUALITATIVE DATA e.g. describing how people acted aggressively
what are the 3 ways to collect data in observations?
- Tallying: making a mark on a piece of paper or somehow, to record each instance of something happening, such as someone holding a door open for another person with shopping in a busy shopping centre
- Event Sampling: choosing which events are to be observed and then noting down each time that event occurs e.g. watching instances of door - holding for people with shopping
- Time Sampling: observing for certain periods of time e.g. every 5 minutes. This can make observations more manageable
observations can be carried out in numerous ways, what are they?
- structured
- naturalistic
what is meant by a structured observation?
In the observation, the situation is set up and then what happens is observed (can be covert, overt, participant or non - participant)
EVIDENCE=
Mary Ainsworth used structured observations.
- she set up a situation that she could called the “strange situation”
- she observed interactions between mothers and their children to examine attachment patterns
- interactions were watched through a one way mirror and all data was gathered by observation
- the “strange situation” involved a mother and child together “normally” in a strange place and then a stranger entering the room
- wanted to see what the child would do when the child was both in and out of the room, with or without the stranger being present
- main focus was to see how the child behaved in the 2 reunions to the mother, when she re - entered the room to be with the child
what is meant by a Naturalistic observation?
observations take place in the participants natural setting (can be covert, overt, participant or non - participant)
EVIDENCE= GRADY ET AL (2012)
- looked at parents dropping off children at preschool to look at parental behaviour, the length of time the separation
between the child and parents took and how the child interacted with peers
- the aim was to see the effect of parental lingering when dropping their child off at school
there were set categories for recording such as “parental hug”, “hover” and “walk away”
- it was found that when parents took longer to leave, children stayed longer near them and spent less time with peers and in social interaction
what is meant by Participant (overt or covert)
Covert participant observation is whereby the observer takes part and the study is not known about
Over participant observation is whereby the observer takes part and the study is known about
What is meant by Non - participant (covert or overt)
Covert non - participant observation is whereby the observer does not take part and the study is not known about
Overt non - participant observation is whereby the observer does not take part but the study is known about