lesson 11

Question 1

Impacts of Statutory Interpretation

Answer 1

-wording/phrases are narrowed
-wording/phrases are broadened
-establishes precedeny

Question 2

Wording/Phrases Narrowed

Answer 2

Wording/Phrases Narrowed:
The scope of certain words is limited.
Example: “Public places” doesn’t include schools, as they are limited to students, parents, and teachers.

Question 3

Wording/Phrases Broadened

Answer 3

The scope of certain words is expanded.
Example: “Man” can include individuals not biologically male.

Question 4

Establishes precedent

Answer 4

The court’s interpretation forms a binding or persuasive precedent for future similar cases, depending on the court’s position in the hierarchy.

Question 5

Strengths of Statutory Interpretation

Answer 5

Efficient Updates: Judges update laws quickly without waiting for Parliament.

Freedom: Judges can apply meanings without political pressure.

Expertise: Judges’ legal expertise makes their interpretations more trusted.

Question 6

Weaknesses of Statutory Interpretation

Answer 6

Not Elected: Judges aren’t elected, so their decisions may not reflect public opinion.

Reversible: Decisions can be overruled on appeal.

Abrogation: Parliament can change laws to override court decisions (except High Court rulings).