MBB6346 Genetic pathways from zygote to organism Flashcards

(438 cards)

1
Q

How can asymmetric division occur in response to intrinsic factors?

A
  • A factor within the maternal cell is asymmetrically distributed before division which is then inherited asymmetrically between the two daughter cells
  • This then drives the change in cell fate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

How can asymmetric division occur in response to extrinsic factors?

A
  • The two daughter cells encounter different environmental signals which change their fate.
  • The cells respond differently to signals. This could be due to polarity in the system (gradients) or due to the cells differing competence (intrinsic)
  • This is often associated with tissues
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What is a morphogen?

A

A molecule that acts in a concentration dependant manner to determine cell fate

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What can a morphogen be?

A
  • Does not have to be a transcription factor just has to be able to activate a signalling cascade
  • It can also be a metabolite or an extracellular peptide
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What is meant by a cell being competent to perceive a morphogen?

A
  • Morphogens must be capable of being perceived by cells to elicit a response
  • A cell must be able to respond to it through the correct receptors/transporters
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Is it just the morphogen concentration that decides morphogen activity?

A
  • It is the overall output
  • If there is a morphogen inhibitor present then this will affect the overall morphogen activity and change the cell fate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Why are C. Elegans a major model organism used in developmental biology?

A

The complete lineage of all cells has been mapped

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Outline the first divisions of the C. Elegans zygote?

A
  • The C. elegans’ zygote, after fertilisation, undergoes an asymmetric division to give AB and P1 daughter cells.
  • AB gives rise to somatic cells, in particular, the hypodermis and neurons, while P1 gives rise to the germ line in one division path and muscles and gut in another. P lineage cells are germline cells.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What are the cell fate determinants in the C.elegans zygote?

A

The cell fate determinate for AB is MEX5 and for P1 is PIE-1

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

How do MEX5 and PIE-1 cause asymmetric division?

A
  • These are both maternal transcripts, already present in the maternal egg
  • The proteins become polarised before the asymmetric division occurs causing preferential inheritance. Once the division happens, they are segregated into AB and P1
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What are PAR proteins?

A

PAR proteins are a mix of membrane binding proteins, kinases and components of the ubiquitin degradation pathway.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Outline the PAR distribution in the unfertilised c.elegans zygote

A
  • In the unfertilised egg, PAR proteins are mostly associated with either the cell membrane or the cytoplasm. The PARs associated with the membrane stop the other PARs from binding there.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is the key driver of polarity in the C.elegan zygote?

A
  • The key driver of polarity here is sperm entry.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

How does sperm entry drive polarity in the C.elegans zygote?

A
  • The sperm entry point becomes the posterior pole of the egg and causes changes in the membrane, resulting in some PAR proteins shifting to the anterior and the others then moving onto the posterior membrane.
  • Interactions between the PARs stabilise this localisation. This localisation is crucial because these posterior PAR proteins act on MEX-5 and this results in MEX-5 being localised to the anterior pole.
  • It is MEX5 that drives polarisation of PIE-1 as MEX5 inhibits PIE-1.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Give evidence for the intrinsic control of c elegant zygote asymmetric division

A

Laufer et al

  • The lab specifically burst cells within the egg to look at the effect of the remaining cells.
  • They burst the AB cell, leaving the P1 cell. The cell continues to divide and they followed the division. They saw that the lineage is the same as that in the Wt
  • This tells us that intrinsic factors driving the division because otherwise the removal of the AB cell would affect the linage of P1
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

How was the role of PIE-1 in the c.elegan zygote?

A

Mello et al, 1992

  • Carried out a mutagenesis screen and found a maternal mutant PIE1. In these mutants, the complete germ line lineage is deleted but the gut and muscles still form.
  • The maternal gene is present in the unfertilised egg and inhibits transcriptional elongation by preventing phosphorylation of the RNA pol II C-terminal domain by CDK9 and inhibits genes associated with somatic cell fate. This causes cells to be maintained as germline cells.
  • Pes-1 is a marker of somatic cell fate and when stain in embryo can see it is not found where PIE-1 is found showing that PIE-1 drives germline fate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Give evidence for when PIE-1 localisation occurs in the embryo

A

Reese et al, 2000

  • An embryo expressing PIE1-GFP was live imaged to show PIE-1 localisation in the posterior pole occurs before the asymmetric division
  • PIE1 inhibits the regulation of somatic genes and its protein becomes polarised before asymmetric division
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What kind of proteins are PIE-1 and MEX5?

A

Group of maternally inherited mRNAs encoding zinc finger RNA binding proteins

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What is the phenotype of a MEX5 mutant?

A
  • Disruption of mex-5 causes embryonic death with a terminal phenotype that includes proliferation of muscle (MEX = muscle excess)
  • This is likely explained by cells being blocked in AB lineage fate and hence acquire P1 fate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Give evidence for the role of MEX-5 in fate determination

A

Schubert et al, 2000

  • Can see before asymmetric division, MEX5 is polarised anteriorly as shown by the immunostaining.
  • Investigated the localisation of PIE-1 in the Wt and MEX5 mutant embryo. In the WT that these proteins are confined to the germline P2 cell but, in a MEX-5 mutant, their expression is now found throughout the embryo
  • MEX5 inhibits the expression of the germ line promotors in somatic cells – negatively regulating PIE1
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

How do we know that MEX5 does not TRANSCRIPTIONALLY regulate PIE1?

A
  • We’ve seen that PIE-1 can inhibit the transcription of some genes. However, PIE-1 are maternal transcripts so the transcripts are already in the embryo.
  • Therefore, MEX5 does not transcriptionally regulate PIE1 as it is the protein that is localised posteriorly not the RNA.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

How does MEX5 regulate PIE1?

A

DeRenzo et al, 2003

  • A yeast-2-hybrid screen for interacting partners of MEX-5 and PIE-1 identified ZIF-1. Further interaction studies found that ZIF-1 is part of an E3 ubiquitin ligase complex that targets proteins for breakdown ZIF1 is an E3 ubiquitin ligase and targets proteins for degradation
  • In RNAi of Zif1, PIE1 is found in all the cells but in Wt it is localised.
  • MEX5 recruits ZIF1 to target PIE1 and to cause its degradation anteriorly.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

When is polarity determined in the c elegant zygote?

A

Polarity is beginning to be determined very early before polarisation of MEX5 and PIE1

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

When are PAR proteins localised in the c elegant zygote?

A

Kemphues et al, 1988

  • PAR mutants found in maternal screen looking for mutants that effect polarity determination
  • PAR1 and 2 are localised posterior cortex before division while PAR3,4 and PKC-3 are present in the anterior cortex.
  • PAR proteins show polarity
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
How do PAR proteins become polarised?
Goldtsein and Hird, 1996 - The sperm entry point defines the posterior pole - Manipulated sperm entry so it occurs anteriorly. This reverses the polarity of the zygote - Experiments were also done examining what happens if the sperm enters at a lateral position and in these instances, the sperm pronucleus quickly migrated to the nearest pole and this became the posterior. Cytochalasin D treatment inhibited this movement indicating that intact actin microfilaments are needed for this process. - Sperm donates a centrosome to the entry point (contains actin) affecting actin within the oocyte
26
What is meant by the fountain head streaming affect?
- The mesh of actin is contracting and relaxing and sperm entry results in relaxation at the posterior pole meaning actin only contracts at the anterior. This forces cytoplasm to move to the other end. This is known as a fountain head streaming affect. - This is critical for the localisation of PAR proteins
27
Outline the PAR distribution in the unfertilised c.elegan zygote
Before fertilisation, PAR3, PAR6 and PKC-3 are present around the entire cortex. These proteins inhibit PAR1 and PAR2 from the cortex
28
Outline the PAR distribution in the fertilised c.elegan zygote
- After fertilisation, and fountain head streaming occurs, PAR3 and 6 are driven into the anterior pole allowing PAR1 and PAR2 from the cytoplasm to bind to the membrane in the posterior pole. - This results in PAR3 and 6 localised at the anterior cortex and PAR1 and 2 and the posterior cortex. The PAR proteins are mutually exclusive.
29
How are PAR proteins mutually exclusive?
PKC-3 phosphorylation inhibits their ability to bind the anterior region by phosphorylating PAR-1 and PAR-2. In turn, PAR-1 inhibits PAR-6/6/PKC-3 from binding the posterior region by phosphorylating PAR-3, whilst PAR-2 can inhibit PKC-3.
30
How does PAR distribution affect MEX5 polarisation?
- PAR1 acts on MEX5 causing its dissociation from proteins and RNA. Usually it is associated with protein and RNA making it slow moving. - Once PAR1 causes its dissociation, it produced two pools of MEX5 – one bound to proteins which is slow moving and another which is free from proteins and fast moving. - MEX5 is unable to bind proteins in the posterior due to the presence of PAR1 and its subsequent phosphorylation meaning MEX5 moves anteriorly where it can bind proteins and become slow moving again. - This results in MEX5 to gradually localise anteriorly
31
What are stomata?
- A stomata is formed of two specialised guard cells that flank the stomatal pore. - CO2 exchange and fixing via the Calvin Cycle into glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate. The cuticle of most plants is reasonably impermeable to gas exchange, so these pores allow CO2 to enter the plant. - It is required to balance CO2 and H20 levels
32
What cell types are in the stomatal lineage
The stomatal lineage consists of a series of defined cell divisions that ultimately result in the stomatal complex, consisting of two guard cells flanking the pore.
33
Outline the stages in stomatal development
- A protodermal cell takes a meristemoid mother cell fate (MMC). - The MMC is a cell that is competent to enter the stomatal lineage. Asymmetric division occurs and gives rise to a smaller meristemoid (M) cell and a larger stomatal lineage ground cell (SLGC). - Eventually the M differentiates to form a guard mother cell (GMC), which is the immediate precursor of a stomata. The transition from GMC to guard cells involves a symmetrical division, which sees the production of two guard cells and the formation of the pore.
34
What is the cell fate determinant involves in the MMC cell asymmetric division?
The cell fate determinant is a basic helix-loop-helix (bhLh) transcription factor called speechless and is found in the meristermoid cell
35
Outline how speechless is localised in the different cell fates of the MCC's daughter cells
- It is present in the MMC before the asymmetric division and is present in both daughter cells immediately after division – equal segregation. - There is then a mechanism that activates the degradation of speechless in the SLGC. This is different to what occurs in the C. elegans zygote asymmetric division
36
Outline how speechless drives the different cell fates of the MCC's daughter cells
- A mechanism activates the degradation of speechless in the SLGC. - This mechanism involved MAPK and BASL, a polarity determining factor which acts as a scaffold for the MAPK module. This scaffold makes sure that this MAPK is only found in the SLGC by sequestering it away to the membrane (polarity) before division and allowing it to degrade speechless in the SLGC after division
37
What gene did Bergmann et al, 2004 discover to be involved in stomata development?
Yoda
38
What is the mutant phenotype of Yoda?
This mutant is characterised by a massive overproliferation of stomata, which are severely clustered together. This clustering is rarely seen in WT plants as they always have at least one cell between stomata.
39
What is the role of Yoda?
Yoda is therefore a negative regulator of stomatal cell fate and their spacing.
40
What did cloning Yoda by Bergmann et al, 2004 reveal about it?
- It is a MAPKKK (top of the MAPK cascade). It has a regulatory N terminal domain and deletion of this results in constitutively active yoda (turns on the pathway always). This results in an epidermis that has no stomata. - This agrees with Yoda being a negative regulator of stomatal development. - This also implies the involvement of MAPK and MAPKK.
41
Why is MAPK signalling difficult to analyse and how did Wang et al, 2007 overcome this?
MAPK signalling is difficult to analyse due to large numbers of MAPK in Arabidopsis and its wide use. This lab therefore focused on MAPKs that had been shown to have a role in environmental stress signalling.
42
What did Wang et al, 2007 discover about the MAPKs involved in stromal development
- Determined this using double mutant analysis. If knockout MKK4 and MKK5, similar phenotype to yoda knockout. If knockout MPK3 and MPK6 then there is a phenotype of stomata everywhere (yoda knockout). - This shows that these kinases act downstream of yoda
43
How did the Bergmann lab look for key regulators of the asymmetric division of MCC?
Used microarrays to look for sets of genes whose activity was altered in constitutively active yoda and mutant yoda.
44
What gene did the Bergmann lab identify?
Identified a basic helix loop helix (bHLH) transcription factor FAMA which is expressed in guard cells. FAMA mutants have defects in specification of guard cells (final step)
45
How did the identification of FAMA lead to the discovery of speechless?
A phylogenetic analysis of the bHLH family in Arabidopsis revealed that FAMA is closely related to two other bHLH Transcription factors. One of these was speechless and the other was mute.
46
What is the phenotype of a speechless mutant?
There are no asymmetric divisions in a speechless mutant and produces no stomata – lethal mutation
47
What is the phenotype caused by the over expression of speechless?
Over expression of speechless leads to ectopic asymmetric divisions
48
Why was speechless thought to be the cell fate determinant involved in MCC asymmetric division?
- Can see using SPCH-GFP that speechless is localised to meristermoid cells. - Its overexpression leads to ectopic asymmetric divisions and its loss leads to no asymmetric divisions. - This is evidence that speechless is the cell fate determinant
49
How did the Bergmann lab show that speechless and Yoda operated in the same pathway?
- Created a double mutant. - The double mutant resembles a speechless mutant despite yoda usually causing lots of stomata. - This is evidence for epistasis and that yoda acts on speechless.
50
Give evidence that speechless is a direct target of the MAPK pathway?
Lampard et al (2008) - Speechless has a domain that is not conserved in mute and fama. - This region has a number of residues that conforms with a MAPK target sequence. MAPK usually acts on serine or threonine that are surrounded by proline - Mutated these known residues to alanine to prevent their phosphorylation – created a phospho-mutant. - The result is speechless variants with increased stability, such that they persist and induce ectopic asymmetric divisions. If mutate more serine residues (more representative of what you see if you overexpress MUTE and FAMA)
51
What is the phenotype of a BASL mutant?
Breaking of Asymmetry in the Stomatal Lineage. These mutants have lost their ability to orient their divisions and results in asymmetric divisions occurring next to each other so that meristemoids are touching
52
Outline the expression of BASL after the asymmetric divison of MMCs
- In meristemoid, BASL was always in the nucleus. - In the larger SLGC – immediately after an ACD, BASL is expressed both in the nucleus AND the cell periphery. - The BASL in the periphery is opposite the division plane.
53
How did Dong et al, 2009 show that BASL interacts with Yoda?
- Analysed the sequence of BASL. There are three kinase interrupting motifs. There is also a series of serine’s that conform to MAPK targeting. This suggests that BASL has the capability to bind MAPK and is phosphorylated by them - In a kinase assay, BASL was shown to be phosphorylated by MPK6. - In a pull down assay, they were investigating with BASL interacts with yoda. They found that it does and the kinase domains are required for this interaction and deletion of these domains results in failure to interact with yoda.
54
What conclusion did Dong et al, 2009 come to about the role of BASL?
- BASL is acting as a MAPK scaffold protein – a protein that interacts with MAPK signalling modules and brings them together to enable them to signal in response to specific stimuli – that cycles between different places within the cell. - In the nucleus, it is inactive. It then becomes phosphorylated by MPK6 which causes BASL to move out to the membrane and act as a scaffold to bring together the MAPK components (yoda) together at the periphery of the cell.
55
Give evidence that speechless is segregated after the asymmetric division?
Zhang et al, 2016 - In the meristermoid speechless is in the nucleus but in the SGLC it is in the periphery and nucleus - After division, there is an equal amount of speechless in both daughter cells meaning that there is no polarisation before the asymmetric division. - |t is the BASL that has the integral role in degradation of speechless - BASL is only found in the SLGC meaning that is where the MAPK module is localised resulting in speechless degradation in that daughter cell.
56
Is the MCC asymmetric division intrinsic or extrinsically controlled?
- This occurs in a sheet of cells (the epidermis) so there are many cell interactions. - Stomatal lineage cells secrete an extracellular peptide called Epidermal patterning factor 2 (EPF2). EPF2 is the ligand for the erecta receptor like kinases. Binding of EPF2 leads to activation of the Yoda-MAPK cascade. - Both intrinsic and extrinsic signals are involved but due to this happening in a field of cells it is almost impossible to completely dissociate the two components to answer unequivocally the role of intrinsic v extrinsic factors.
57
What transcription factors are involved in the Endodermal and cortical patterning in the root meristem?
short-root (SHR) and scarecrow (SCR).
58
How were SHR and SCR discovered?
Levesque et al (2006) - Isolated two mutants called Scr and Shr which only had a single ground meristem layer and this was due to their being no asymmetric division of the CEI (Cortex-Endodermis Initial).
59
How was it shown that SHR is required for SCR expression?
- Transcriptional constructs were generated in which either the SHR or SCR promoters was linked to GFP. - Using confocal microscopy it was then clear that SHR mRNA is found in the stele (the vascular tissue) whilst SCR expression occurs in the meristem and CEI as well as the endodermis. - SCR expression is significantly reduced in a Shr mutant suggesting the Shr is required for SCR expression. - SHR is having an impact on CEI asymmetric division and SCR expression
60
SHR moves from the stele into the endodermis but not to the cortex. Why does SHR only move one cell layer?
- SHR interacts with SCR and together, this results in a feedforward loop resulting in more SCR expression. - This ensures all the SHR is bound by SCR and remains in the nucleus, where the SHR-SCR complex induce expression of CYCD6 and you get asymmetrical division of the CEI.
61
How did Cui et al, 2007 show that SHR and SCR proteins interact?
Carried out ß-galactosidase assay and yeast-2-hybrid assays
62
What did Cui et al, 2007 show about the role of SCR?
- In the CEI, SHR is expressed in the nucleus but is cytoplasmic in the stele but in a SCR mutant, SHR is cytoplasmic in the CEI, endodermis and stele meaning that SCR is required for the nuclear localisation of SHR in the endodermis and CEI. - In SCR-RNAi roots, SHR has moved more than one cell layer causing ectopic divisions meaning that SCR is required to limit SHR movement.
63
How did Cui et al, 2007 show that SCR regulates its own expression?
- In the SCR mutant, there is reduced SCRproGFP meaning SCR upregulates its own expression
64
Why are ectopic divisions seen in SCR RNAi but not in the SCR mutual in Cui et al, 2007?
- This is not seen in the SCR mutant because SCR is vital for these cell divisions – you need a little bit of SCR in order to promote the division. No SCR results in no division, a little bit means that some SHR protein escapes the endodermis and moves another cell layer, where it interacts again with SCR and promotes division.
65
What does the SHR-SCR complex activate in the nucleus?
Cyclin-D6 | - By inducing this in the CEI, an asymmetrical division is promoted.
66
Give an overview of asymmetric division in the root meristem
- SHR is expressed in the stele - It’s protein moves into the next cell layer, this includes the CEI. - It interacts with SCR and together, this results in a feedforward loop resulting in more SCR expression. - This ensures all the SHR is bound by SCR and remains in the nucleus, where the SHR-SCR complex induce expression of CYCD6 and you get asymmetrical division of the CEI. - There is now an endodermis and cortex. SCR is found in both cell types but it is its presence in the endodermis that prevents SHR moving into the cortex and causing further cell divisions
67
When does wing development occur in the drosophila?
Wing development is something that is initiated late in development and progresses as the larva pupates and undergoes metamorphosis.
68
What are imaginal discs?
- Imaginal discs are groups of cells that form later in development and divide and exit through the body wall and form the external organs of the body e.g. head, wings, legs. - There are 19 in the late stage pupae each consisting of as few as 10-15 cells. After proliferation, the wings consist of 50000 cells – lots of proliferation
69
When do the imaginal discs from the external organs of the drosophila body?
During metamorphosis, these cells have a very high rate of proliferation and they move from inside the larva, through the larval wall and into the space under the pupal case. There, they unfold and elongate and complete the final differentiation steps to form the structures of the adult fly – they also fuse together to form a continuous epithelium.
70
What does the drosophila wing consist of?
The wing consists of: - the notum – forms part of the dorsal thorax to which the wing attaches - the hinge – allows wing movement - the wing – this is the set of cells that the wing as you envisage it, is derived.
71
Outline the mechanism of Hh signalling in drosophila segment polarity
- Segment polarity is defined by the transcription factor engrailed which regulates the transcription of Hh. Hh is secreted from the cells that produce it and diffuses away. - This then activates Hh signalling in adjacent cells and activates target genes including wingless. - This system is not relevant in the formation of the drosophila wing.
72
Outline the Hh signalling pathway
- Hedgehog binds to its receptor patched and inhibits its action. - Patched usually inhibits these actions of the signal transducing component smoothened. The relieving of this inhibition allows the transcription factor Ci to stabilise and regulate the transcription of target genes. - In the absence of Ci acts as transcriptional repressor - When there is Hh, Ci is not cleaved and it activates gene expression - The balance of these forms of Ci defines the target gene expression
73
What is meant by the wing disc being compartmentalised?
- The cells in the anterior and the posterior of the wing come from different linages - This results in a defined boundary between the two lineages (between AP)
74
What morphogens are involved in the AP patterning of the wing disc?
- Hh | - Dpp
75
Give evidence for Hh only being expressed in posterior wing disc cells
In situ hybridisation of wing disc - In situ for engrailed protein. En is only found in posterior cells. En is the transcription factor which is limited to the cells in which it is expressed and activates Hh - Can also see Hh in the posterior cells of the wing disc showing that En is regulating Hh in the posterior cells
76
Why do the posterior wing disc cells not respond to Hh?
- Although Hh is expressed in these cells, they are incapable of responding to it (refractory to Hh). - It is En that prevents these cells from responding to Hh. En regulates Hh and inhibits its action in the same cells by inhibiting the expression pf patched
77
Which cells respond to Hh in the wing disc?
Anterior - En is limited to the posterior cells and prevents them repsonding to Hh. - Hh can diffuse extracellularly and move away to the anterior compartment to cells with no En and competent to respond
78
Where is Ci expressed in the wing disc?
Ci is expressed in the anterior but not the posterior due to the presence of En inhibiting the expression of patched and Ci these cells. Once this inhibition is removed, these genes can be expressed and receive Hh signalling and initiate the signalling cascade
79
Why is there a Hh diffusion gradient across the anterior compartment of the wing disc?
Hh is being expressed at the posterior side so the highest concentration of Hh will be at the AP boundary and reduce as it moves across the anterior domain.
80
Give an overview of what occurs in the posterior compartment of the wing disc at a molecular level
- En regulates Hh expression in the posterior cells but Engrailed also blocks the expression of Patched (Hh receptor) and Ci (transcriptional regulator) in these posterior cells. - Even though HH is there, these posterior cells cannot perceive it and hence do not respond (are refractory)
81
Give an overview of what occurs in the anterior compartment of the wing disc at a molecular level
- These anterior cells do express Patched and Ci – so they do respond to this HH gradient - You get active Ci when Hh is present and repressive Ci when Hh is absent. - Across the Hh gradient you get a similar gradient of Ci(active):Ci(repressor) with the active Ci being at the AP boundary and the Ci repressor being at the other side of the anterior compartment
82
Why is the distinct venation pattern in the adult win useful?
Can be used to determine whether factors impact on wing development e.g. how these factors interact to regulate fate.
83
Outline the venation pattern in the adult wing
The anterior compartment, it has veins I, II and III. The posterior has veins IV and V. So, consider each vein as a marker of particular cell fate.
84
Give evidence that Hh is acting as a morphogen in wing patterning?
Tabata and Takei, 2004 - Cells in the anterior region of the wing were made to express Hh- ectopic expression. These cells are competent to respond to Hh and Hh will diffuse out - Result in a mirror image duplication event centred around at vein 3. This vein is found just into the anterior compartment in the Wt wing - The concentration of Hh is influencing cell fate and where Hh is at its highest concentration (highest Ci activation to repressor), vein 3 forms. - Veins 4 and 5 are not affected as they are in the posterior compartment and these cells are not competent to respond to Hh.
85
What is Dpp?
Homologue of BMP and is a secreted peptide
86
What regulates Dpp in the wing disc?
It is regulated by Hh and can diffuse into both the anterior and the posterior compartments
87
Are both anterior and posterior cells competent to respond to Dpp?
Ectopically expressed Dpp anteriorly - This resulted in mirror image duplication centred around vein 2. Highest concentration of Dpp defines vein 2 identity Ectopically expressed Dpp posteriorly - Resulted in mirror image duplication centred around vein 4 showing that posterior cells are competent to respond to Dpp and highest concentrations result in vein 4 identity - Different to rctopic Hh expression in posterior as cells are not competent to respond to Hh
88
Outline Dpp signal transduction
- Receptor pair at the cell surface Tkv and Punt. The ligand binds to the extracellular domain and this in results in the cytoplasmic serine/threonine kinase domain of the receptors being activated - This then phosphorylates MAD forming p-MAD. - This activated p-MAD translocates into the nucleus where, together with two other factors called Medea and Schnurri, it regulates the transcriptional repressor Brinker. - Brinker negatively regulates the expression of DPP target genes (vein 4 cell fate)
89
What are the two major targets of the transcription repressor Brinker?
optomotor-blind (omb) and salm (sal)
90
Outline the localisation of Brinkeer and Dpp
- DPP is expressed in a strip at the A-P boundary and is regulated by Hh. As a morphogen, it can diffuse in both directions – so into both the Anterior and Posterior compartments. - As DPP represses Brinker transcription via p-MAD, Brinker expression is seen most strongly at the extreme Anterior and posterior poles. - The localisation of p-MAD and Brinker, they are relatively exclusive
91
Outline the expression of Brinker target genes (for repression) Sal and Omb?
- Sal requires higher concentrations of DPP (p-MAD) signalling than omb, hence the broader expression pattern of OMB. The expression of both Sal and Omb is repressed by Brinker
92
What is formed at the boundary between Brinker and Omb expression?
Vein 5
93
Give evidence for vein 5 forming at the boundary between Brinker and Omb expression?
- This can be experimentally proven by knocking out Brinker expression in the Brinker expressing cells (most anterior or posterior cells) therefore allowing Omb expression (as Dpp diffuses in) and creating a secondary Omb:Brinker boundary. - This distinct boundary results in the formation of a secondary vein 5 showing that this boundary is what drives vein 5 cell fate.
94
What is a choice assay?
- Genetically alter the expression of one of your key genes, using a DNA recombination based system to excise the relevant gene from the genomic DNA in a random cell, so that the cell becomes mutant for that gene. - You then allow development to occur and that cell will divide and you then look at where the clone of cells derived from this original cell is now found.
95
How was it shown that En and Ci are involved in the formation of the AP boundary in the wing disc?
- A wing disc expressing GFP in both anterior and posterior compartments was engineered so that the expression of EN, Ci or both could be switched off in cells using a heat shock recombination based system (also removed GFP). - Researchers then focused on cells where the knockout event was close to the AP boundary. - Cells were then allowed to divide - In some cells, the excision event occurred in a cell in the anterior compartment (knocked out Ci, Eg or Hh). - After it was allowed to divide, we see that the clone of cells derived from this have now expanded into the posterior compartment. - Anterior-posterior cells are derived from different lineages and would not normally be able to do this.
96
Outline a Flp-out cassette
- FLP recombinase expressed from a heat shock promoter. - Construct with FRT sites flanking the region you want to excise and once FLP expression is induced by a heat shock, you will get excision of that WT gene.
97
What did Dahmann and Basler, 2000 show about the role of Engrailed in the formation of the AP border?
- In an anterior cell near the A-P boundary, a cell was manipulated to mutate Ci and to turn on En. - The clone of cells expanded into the posterior compartment and took on posterior fate. So, this is suggesting that En alone is sufficient for cells to have posterior cell identity and it can do this in a HH independent manner
98
What did Dahmann and Basler, 2000 show about the role of Ci in the formation of the AP border?
- A cell in the posterior compartment has been mutated so it can’t express En. The cells are still able to express Ci. - The cells divide and move into the anterior compartment, indicating that Ci is sufficient to specify Anterior cell segregation. - As Hh is required for active Ci, this would suggest that this is Hh-dependent as Hh can diffuse so even though it is expressed in the posterior compartment it can diffuse into the anterior one
99
What did Dahmann and Basler, 2000 experiments show about the requirement of Hh in AP boundary formation?
HH-independent mechanism operating to sort Posterior cells and HH-dependent mechanism to sort Anterior cells. - When a posterior cell expressed both Ci and EN it sorts into the anterior compartment. - This suggests that the HH-dependent pathway is dominant to the HH-independent pathway.
100
What did Cook et al, 2004 do to investigate the role of Omb in the formation of the AP boundary in the wing disc?
- FLP-FRT recombinase system has been used to generate clones of cells mutant in either Omb or Brinker.
101
What did Cook et al, 2004 show about the role of Omb in the formation of the AP boundary in the wing disc?
- Produced two Omb mutant clones. The top one, is not in contact with the vein area and has no impact. However, the second Omb mutant clone overlaps where vein V is and results in loss of vein development in that mutant clone. - This means Omb is required for the positioning of vein V. To make vein V, cells must express Omb.
102
What did Cook et al, 2004 show about the role of Brinker in the formation of the AP boundary in the wing disc?
- A clone of cells posterior to the normal vein V have had brinker expression knocked out causing an ectopic vein now forms along the boundary of this clone. - Where Brinker has been lost, Omb expression now occurs and the vein forms at the boundary between the two –Brinker repression of Omb sets a tight boundary in which vein V forms.
103
What is the neural tube?
An embryonic structure and the precursor to the central nervous system
104
How does the dorsal ventral patterning of the neural tube define the types of neurones formed?
- The dorsal plane results in sensory neurones while the ventral plane results in motor neurones. There are interneurons that connect the two - Formation of the neural tube
105
Outline the formation of the neural tube?
Neurulation - The ectoderm differentiates either into the epidermis or the neuroepithelium - BMP drives epidermal fate and the organiser (mesoderm derived) secretes BMP antagonists such as chords and noggin which block BMP and induce neuroepithelium - The neuroepithelium grows and undergo columnisation to form the neural plate which is found at the bottom of the neural tube - Then elongates along the AP axis and rolls into the neural tube - Simple cell movements that underlie these morphological changes
106
What is the notochord?
- Found in all chordates | - Found below the ventral surface of the neural tube
107
How is the notochord formed?
- As soon as the organiser induces the neural plate, the organiser self-differentiates into the axial mesoderm. The axial mesoderm then involutes and undergoes convergent extension - The axial mesoderm consists of the prechordal mesoderm and the anterior endoderm which mark the head of the organism (anterior) and the notochord which marks the body of the organism (posterior)
108
What are the roles of the notochord?
Acts as a structural support and plays a crucial role in dorsoventral patterning of the neural tube.
109
Give evidence for the role of the notochord in formation of the neural tube
Beddington et al, 1994 - The node/organiser gives rise to the notochord and they knew that the notochord was involved in neural tube patterning - They excised the node/organiser from one embryo and transplanted onto the lateral surface of another embryo. - A control was also done using anterior endoderm transplantation - Developed a secondary neural tube at the graft site showing that the node itself induced and developed into the neural tube
110
What did Yamada et al, 1994 investigate about the notochord?
Examined the ability of the notochord to regulate motor neuron development
111
How did Yamada et al, 1994 show that the notochord was capable of driving motor neurone cell fate?
- Used Islet-1 as a marker for motor neuron fate and stained a chick spinal cord cross section - Excised neural plate from embryo and incubated in collagen gel (control) and stain for islet-1. There were no motor neurons formed showing that the formation of motor neurons in not inherent to that tissue – not autonomous - Repeated with cells incubated on an isolated notochord – resulted in motor neurones. - Notochord is capable of inducing motor neuron cell fate from neural plate cells
112
How did Yamada et al, 1994 show that the notochord produced a diffusible signal that controlled neural tube patterning?
- They took notochord and incubated in buffer over night and removed all the cells from the buffer. - They then repeated the experiment with the neural plate cells incubates in the buffer. This too resulted in the formation of motor neurones. - This shows that the notochord must be producing a diffusible signal that is capable of inducing this developmental change in the neural plate cells.
113
Why was it thought that it was Shh that was expressed from the notochord?
Echerlard et al, 1998 - Isolated Shh in zebrafish and mice – homologue of Hh in drosophila - In situ hybridisation of Shh in chick notochord. Can see that Shh is present in the notochord and in the neural plate cells in late development - This shows that Shh is expressed in the right place at the right time to be the diffusible molecule expressed by the notochord. - Only circumstantial evidence
114
How did Roelink et al, 1995 test the inductive role of Shh?
- Shh is a peptide and produced as a pro-protein and undergoes autoproteolysis to cleave to itself into the mature form - They looked to see which part of the Shh is involved in regulating these processes and is there a concentration dependant manor to this control and used full length Shh, mutated Shh which cannot undergo autoproteolysis, C terminal Shh and N terminal Shh. - They expressed these proteins in Cos cells and incubated with neural plate explants
115
What did Roelink et al, 1995 find about what part of Shh has inductive ability in the neural plate?
- Incubation with full length Shh, both islet1 and HNF3b (floor plate identity marker) is expressed. - This is also seen in N terminus but not the C terminal protein showing that the c terminus is not biological active. - If Shh cannot be cleaved (not N and C terminus) there is also no markers. - This shows that it is the N terminus that is biologically active.
116
Did Roelink et al, 1995 determine how Shh was acting to drive fate in the neural tube?
As a morphogen - Then repeated the experiments but took dilutions of Cos cells to have different concentrations of Shh. - The different concentrations resulted in different outcomes. - High concentration results in floor plate cells but lower concentrations result in motor neuron formation. - This shows that Shh has concentration specific effects on cell identity
117
What does Shh concentration gradient lead to in the ventral neural tube?
- Different precursor cells develop at specific points in the ventral neural tube due to the gradient of Shh, starting with the floor plate cells and progressing to the p0 pool. - pMN is the progenitor pool for motor neurons whereas the other progenitors give rise to a distinct type of interneuron – which enable communication between sensory and motor neurons.
118
How does Shh concentration gradient lead to differing cell fates in the ventral neural tube?
- Balance between active and repressive forms of Ci (Gli in mammals) determines the cell fate of targets. This results in two classes of genes: dorsal and ventral expressing genes.
119
Give examples of how Shh drives the differential expression of transcription factors in the ventral neural tube
- Pax7 is highly expressed when there is no Shh. When Shh increases, the expression is repressed - Pax6 is more widely expressed then pax7 but is primarily expressed in the mid and dorsal domain - still expressed when Shh is present but high Shh represses it. - Nkx2.2 is expressed in the ventral domain - high Shh is required for its expression - The concentration of Shh therefore regulates these transcription factors
120
What occurs the pax6 expression when Shh is depleted?
- Incubated floor plate cells with anti-Shh to bind Shh and look what happens in a Shh mutant. - This results in an increase in Pax6 expression in these cells and a reduction of Nkx2.2 and causes a change from motor neuron formation to interneurons V1 and V2. - Pax6 expression is defines by Shh which in turn defines cell identity - Shh therefore represses (pax6) and induces (nkx2.2) various transcription factors
121
What does double immunohistochemical labelling of dorsal and ventral transcription factor reveal about what drives progenitor cell fate in the neural tube?
- Shows that there are distinct boundaries between their expression domains - The location of the progenitor cells within in the neural tube relates to the boundaries formed between these transcription factors and tells us which transcription factors define which progenitor cells. - It is the boundaries that defines where the progenitor cells form - If the boundaries move, then that results in the reprogramming of the dorsoventral axis.
122
Is Shh sufficient alone to form distinct expression domains of transcription factors?
- A morphogen can rarely define these tight boundaries alone. Interactions refine these boundaries - Negative interactions between the transcription factors are required for the formation of the tight boundaries
123
Give evidence for negative interactions between the transcription factors driving these distinct expression boundaries in the neural tube?
Nkx6.1 usually negatively regulates Dbx2. Mutant Nkx6.1 therefore has an expanded Dbx2 expression domain due to the removal of the negative repression
124
What is the role of Pou and Sox in the formation of expression boundaries?
- The homeodomain transcription factors in the neural tube are primarily transcriptional repressors – so they switch target genes off, meaning transcriptional activators are required, usually the widely expressed transcription factors Pou and Sox
125
Why is it difficult to study Shh's role in a specific system?
Shh has many uses in development so studying its role in a specific system is difficult because mutant Shh will have large effects
126
What did Jeong and McMahon, 2005 investigate?
What role does Patched regulation have in Shh patterning?
127
How did Jeong and McMahon, 2005 investigate how patched regulation is involved in Shh patterning?
- Shh is required for patch expression so they uncoupled this relationship - They did this by generating patched knockout mice but introduced a construct whereby Patched was expressed at low level from a widely expressed metallothionein promoter (MtPtch1) which doesn’t respond to Shh. - This means that the cells in the neural tube can respond to Shh but they cannot induce Patched - In the wild type mice, Shh is in a concentration gradient which induced patched expression in the same gradient. In these mutant mice, the patched expression is the same across the neural tube
128
What did Jeong and McMahon, 2005 find about the role of patched in Shh expression?
They looked at the expression of some ventrally expressed genes and found that in the mutant mice their expression domain had expanded showing that Shh regulation of patched usually acts to limit Shh signalling and its own action
129
Outline how patched is used to steepen the Shh gradient
- Shh binds to its receptor patched which in turn upregulates patched receptors in that cell meaning more Shh can bind. - This binding and signal activation causes the degradation of Shh molecules meaning they cannot diffuse further away. - As there is more Shh towards its origin, it will activate more patched receptors on adjacent cells and therefore initiate more degradation. - This creates a steep gradient for Shh as the cells further away will only be exposed to the Shh molecules that have not already been degraded by the adjacent cells expressing high patched receptors.
130
How is it though that Gli is responsible for refining the expression of target genes in response to Shh?
- The expression of the transcription factors is dependent on both the number and affinity of Gli binding sites within the promoter of a target gene. - So, Gene A (see diagram) has only 1 weak affinity site and so needs a high concentration of Shh to drive its expression. - Gene c however, has 3 high affinity sites so doesn’t require as high of Shh and so is expressed broadly.
131
What other interactions, as well as Gli binding sites, are thought to be involved in boundary formation in the neural tube?
- Broadly expressed regulatory transcription factors that either positively or negatively regulate targets. - There are also interactions between the target genes themselves to refine the boundaries - Meaning there are three mechanisms involved in the expression pattern domains: It is the combination of Gli binding sites, the binding sites of broadly expressed positive or negative regulators and target gene interactions that refines pattern.
132
What are meristems?
- Meristems are found in most plants organs and are stem cell niches. For example, in the leaf, meristematic tissue is associated with the vascular tissue in the stems and contribute to radial growth - E.g. root and shoot meristems
133
Give examples of meristems
- Shoot apical meristem (SAM) – formed during embryogenesis and responsible for all above ground tissue (so ultimately, other meristems will be derived from this meristem). - Root apical meristem – root cells are all derived from this, though lateral roots then derive from lateral root meristems, which are associated with vascular tissue. - Floral meristem – gives rise to the reproductive organs of the plant - Procambium – gives the xylem and phloem -
134
How do meristems result in organ formation?
- They are a collection of stem cells and are held in an undifferentiated state but when a stem cell divides and leaves the meristem they divide into a specific cell type. - The meristem cells will persist only if the cells lost to organ recruitment are in turn replaced – maintain the stem cell pool. If not then left with the resulting organ and a terminal fate
135
When does flowering of a plant occur?
- Normal plant growth is known as the vegetative phase. In this phase, the apical meristem forms organs such as leaves from flanking cells - Depending on the type of plant, there becomes a stage, usually triggered by environmental signals, where a developmental phase transition is induced and results in reproductive growth. This forms flowers instead of leaves. This is the same as puberty in humans
136
What happens to the shoot apical meristem (SAM) when the developmental phase transition occurs?
- The SAM could either convert to inflorescence meristem which is a meristem that forms floral meristems rather than leaves and the floral meristems on its flanks then develop into flowers. This produces lots of flowers while maintaining the inflorescence meristem population - Or the SAM convert straight to the floral meristem – a terminal differentiation and the stem cell pool is lost
137
What is the difference between inflorescent meristem and floral meristem?
- SAM converts to inflorescence meristem (pool of stem cells maintained and therefore indeterminate) which converts to floral meristems (stem cells used up and therefore determinant)
138
What is meant by meristem determinacy?
- Determinant includes when each branch point ends in a terminal flower - Indeterminists also flower but the meristem is not being consumes in the process. It continues until senescence occurs. During normal growth, the meristem is not consuming and it continues to form floral meristems. If it branches, they will also remain indeterminate.
139
What mutants involved in determinant were identified?
- Terminal flower - Leafy - Apetala 1
140
What is the phenotype of a terminal flower mutant?
In these mutants, the inflorescence meristem is converted to a floral meristem and forms terminal flowers at the end of the branches - determinant
141
What is the phenotype of a leafy mutant?
Produce more vegetative like organs instead of flowers - indeterminate
142
What is the phenotype of apetala 1 mutant?
same as leafy - floral meristem converts to a vegetative meristem
143
What is the phenotype of a leafy and petals 1 double mutant?
When both knocked out, there are no floral organs forming at all and the meristems are vegetative
144
What is the phenotype of over expression of terminal flower?
- Results in the same phenotype as the leafy Apetala 1 double mutant - This suggests that there is an interaction between these genes and that terminal flower (TFL) is inhibiting the action of leafy and Apetala 1 – overexpression turns them off and therefore resembles the double mutant
145
What is the phenotype of over expression of leafy?
- Same phenotype as the terminal flower mutant so therefore leafy switches off TFL - This tells us that the interactions are going in both directions
146
Outline the interactions between Leafy, AP1 and TFL1
- TFL1 and leafy/Apetala 1 mutually repress each other - Leafy and Apetala 1 promote vegetative to floral transition and terminal flower inhibits this transition and therefore promotes indeterminacy
147
What did Blazquez et al, 2006 show about the expression of TFL1, leafy and Apetala 1 in negative meristem?
Expression in vegetative meristem before flowering - Where there is TFL there isn’t the other two genes – negative interactions - Inflorescence meristem (middle) has strong TFL. In the floral meristems (on the flank), leafy and Apetala 1 is highly expressed on the meristems - TNF and leafy/Apetala 1 are mutually exclusive
148
How does the expression pattern change in a TFL1 mutant?
Leafy and AP1 moves into the domain where TfL would be expressed and converts it to a determinant floral meristem
149
How does the expression pattern change in a Leafy/Ap1 double mutant?
TFL1 expression expands into the organs forming on the flank and maintains in vegetative fate – indeterminate
150
What did Antonio Serrano-Mislata et al do ti investigate TFL expression?
- Used comparative genomics and looked at the terminal flower locus. They asked what regulates its expression and what impacts the expression has on determinacy - Sequenced the entire locus including regulatory regions in Arabidopsis and compared with four plant species
151
What did Antonio Serrano-Mislata et al find about the TFL1 locus between species?
- The TFL1 exons are highly conserved between all four species - There are regulatory regions that are shared in some species but not others.
152
How did Antonio Serrano-Mislata et al determine the importance of conserved regions of the TFL1 gene?
- Producing transgenic plants that had deletions of these regions e.g. reporter gene instead of TFL gene and removed a regulatory region
153
What was the phenotypes of the transgenic plants produced by Antonio Serrano-Mislata et al?
- Wt - TFL had strong expression in the middle of the meristem and rib meristem - Delete box B conserved regulatory region – drop in TFL expression. Then expressed TFL in the TFL mutant to ask if they can rescue the mutant phenotype – still get a terminal flower mutant showing that the regulatory region is important in how much TFL is expressed - If removed E and F regulatory regions, you lose expression of TFL in the middle of the meristem resulting in a terminal flower
154
What genes were found to bind to the regulatory regions of the TFL locus?
- Leafy binds to box f - Apetala 1 binds to box E - These genes can regulate each other and determines when where and how much is expressed - One of the genes involved needs to be altered expression and the whole system is changed
155
What is the identity of AP1?
MADS domain transcription factor
156
What is the identity of leafy?
plant specific transcription factor
157
What is the identity of TFL1
phosphatidylethanolamine-binding (PPB) protein
158
What other PPB protein has been shown to be involved in determinacy?
- Flowering locus T (56% amino acid identity) but have exact opposite phenotypes - If overexpress FT then it resembles a terminal flower mutant
159
What is the relationship TLF1 and FT?
Appear to have negative interactions between them
160
What is the phenotype of Ft over expression?
- TFL1 expression is excluded from the centre of the meristem but is still found in the axillary meristems - AP1 and leafy is increased compared to Wt – excludes TFL1
161
How did Hanano & Goto, 2011 investigate how FT interact with each other?
- Suppressor screens – mutagenize a mutant to see if the phenotype is reverted - Yeast -2- hybrid – proteins interact
162
What did Hanano & Goto, 2011 find about FT and TFL1 interaction?
- Found a transcription factor FD which interacts with both TFL1 and FT - FT has a positive impact on leafy and AP1. - Used RT-PCR to look at the outcome of a FD and FT interaction. Overexpression of FD, AP1 is expressed. - FD and FT expression drives AP1 and leafy but TFL1 and FD blocks leady and AP1 expression
163
How do we know that FT is required for FD and AP1 interaction?
This ability is dependent on FT because if overexpress FD in a FT mutant, there is no AP1 expression
164
Outline how determinacy identity is decided in a plant meristem?
- In inflorescent meristem FD interacts with TFL1 and inhibits leafy and AP1 – indeterminate. FT is directed to the flank and becomes floral meristem - In floral meristem, FD interacts with FT and drives leafy and AP1 – determinant – TFL1 and FD are directed to the flank are drive branching
165
Why is the expression pattern of the genes involved in determinacy important?
If any part of this system changes its expression (quantitative or temporal – anything to change the equilibrium), then the interactions change and so does the determinacy phenotype
166
Give a brief overview of limb development
SHH is vital to hind limb development and is found in the zone of polarising activity (ZPA). There is a reciprocal signalling between the ZPA and apical ectodermal ridge (AER) which produces FGF and reinforces patter. FGF and SHH maintain each other’s expression
167
Do any snakes have limb buds?
Advanced snakes have no limbs but pythons and boas have hind limb buds but development stops
168
Why do snakes not have limbs?
- After egg laying (oviposition), there is no SHH in python but SHH expression could be induced in relevant python cells transplanted into a chick wing bud - This suggests that the cells can make SHH but is prevented by regulation
169
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 do to investigate limb development in snakes?
In situ hybridisations of SHH and other components SHH signalling in a python (no legs) and in anole hind limb (forms hind leg) and compared samples at similar times of development
170
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 find through SHH in situ hybridisation in the limb bud?
- Previously, SHH has not been detected in the developing limb buds of snakes. - They looked earlier in development and saw that SHH is expressed at low levels and then is lost as development continues. - This is compared to the stages in Anole which expresses SHH at higher levels and persists through development.
171
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 find through SHH transcriptional readouts in situ hybridisation in the limb bud?
- They also examined transcriptional readouts of SHH signalling including PTCH1 and GLI1. - These are markers of SHH activity. In the python, their expression drops trough development and is maintained in the Anole. - This consolidates the idea that SHH is expressed in early development in the python and decreases during development
172
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 find through GLI3 in situ hybridisation in the limb bud?
GLI3 is a repressor of SHH and is found to increase its expression domain in the python hind limb during development. This increase is not seen in the anole hind limb
173
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 find through FGF8 in situ hybridisation in the limb bud?
- They looked at the expression of FGF8 and found that in early python development, FGF8 is expressed at the AER. As SHH is repressed in development, so does the presence of FGF in the AER – breakdown of the AER. In the anole hind limb, the FGF8 expression in the AER is maintained through development - This evidence shows that the limb formation signalling is present in early development in snake but breaks down during development
174
What are HAND2, HOXD13, HOXA13?
regulatory genes of SHH
175
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 show about HAND2, HOXD13, HOXA13 expression in the limb bud?
The expression patterns of HAND2, HOXD13, HOXA13 are similar between python and Anole hind limbs – species specific differences showing that SHH and its regulatory genes are still present in pythons
176
What is the ZRS?
The ZRS is an enhancer region found in the intron of another gene and is essential for SHH expression in hind limbs. Regulatory sequences bind to the ZRS
177
What did Leal and Cohn, 2016 show about the role of ZRS in SHH expression in the hind limb?
- They expanded out this 2kb region and compared this region across species capable of forming limb buds. - There are high conservation sequences in the ZRS locus but there is a missing conservation sequence apparent in snakes that is present in other limb forming organisms. - The region is partially deleted in pythons and boas and is almost completely deleted in advanced snakes that cannot produce hind limbs - This suggests that the change in SHH expression is due to regulatory changes
178
Why do snakes not develop limbs?
The regulatory genes are still present and expressed (HAND2, HOXD13, HOXA13) at sufficient levels but key regions in the SHH enhancer, ZRS, that are missing which results in its loss of expression in snakes. The binding sites of the SHH regulatory regions are lost
179
What would happen if a transgenic snake was produced where the deleted ZRS regions were added back into the genome?
Limbs would form
180
What is meant by genomic equivalence?
- Every somatic cell nucleus contains identical DNA - Unused genes in differentiated cells are maintained and retain the potential for being expressed - Only a small proportion of the genome is expressed in each cell type and a proportion of RNA expression is cell type specific
181
How are stem cells classified based on their pluripotency?
- Totipotent: all cell types of the human body including trophoblasts (zygote) - Pluripotent: derivatives from the three germ layers (embryonic stem cells) - Multipotent: different cell types from a tissue or organ - Progenitor cells: Can divide a limited number of times before differentiation
182
How are embryonic stem cells isolated?
from the inner cell mass of the blastocyst
183
How are embryonic stem cells maintained in culture?
- A feeder layer is a carpet of fibroblasts that are put in a tissue culture dish and treated in a way to stop the fibroblasts from dividing. - They produce LIF and BMP which condition the media and produce an environment so the embryonic stem cells can maintain pluripotency indefinitely
184
What are the pluripotency factors?
Oct4, Nanog, Sox2 | - They are homeodomain transcription factors and are master regulators of cell fate
185
How were the pluripotency factors discovered?
Takahashi and Yamanaka, 2006 | - Reprogrammed somatic cells using these factors to produce IPS cells
186
What are pioneer transcription factors?
Transcription factors that can directly bind to condensed chromatin and activate gene expression
187
How do the pluripotency factors maintain pluripotency of ESCs?
They maintain ESCs in pluripotent state by autoregulation of their own expression, co-binding and co-ordinated regulation of target genes and collectively target lineage determining transcription factors. They work within an open chromatin state
188
Give evidence for the pluriopotency factors regulating their own and each others expression
- Induction of Sox2 in mouse ES cells where Sox2 is knocked out, Sox2 and other pluripotency factors are upregulated - Co-immunoprecipitation of these factors, shows the other factors showing that they interact and regulate each other’s expression
189
What are the functions of pluripotency genes?
They carry out two opposing functions: they work to promote activation of genes required for pluripotency and silence genes required for differentiation
190
How do the pluripotency factors promote activation of target genes?
The transcription factors occupy pluripotency target genes promotors and recruit RNA polymerase II and activate their transcription
191
How do the pluripotency factors repress of target genes?
ChiP sequencing showed that the repressed genes are bound by Polycomb complexes which modify the histones of lineage specific genes
192
What are heterochromatin and euchromatin?
Closed chromatin or heterochromatin represses transcription while open chromatin or euchromatic activates transcription. The dark regions of heterochromatin are usually at the periphery of the cell while euchromatic is at the centre
193
How do pluripotency factors aim to change chromatin states?
They aim for an open chromatin stateand as differentiation occurs, cells become more tightly packed. The open chromatin state allows the rapid swapping to different cell fates. This allows him to respond to signals quickly along differentiation pathways
194
Outline the chromatin remodelling factors
SWI/SNF - E.g. BAF - Ejection – removes a nucleosome and opens chromatin CHD - NuRD - Ejection – removes a nucleosome and opens chromatin ISWI - NuFR - Sliding – moves nucleosomes over to access sequence INO80 - TIP60 - Dimer exchange - Changes the histone modification
195
How do chromatin remodelling proteins effect gene transcription?
- Chromatin remodelling proteins use energy released form ATP hydrolysis to disrupt the interactions between histones and DNA. E.g. INO80, SWI/SNF. - Expression of these chromatin remodellers is elevated in stem cells
196
How does DNA methylation affect gene expression?
DNA methylation is a repressive epigenetic modification that occurs on Cytosine residues of CpG nucleotides
197
How does DNA methylation occur?
DNA methyltransferases, DNMT3A and DNMT3B are responsible for this de novo methylation
198
Why is DNA methylation considered a true epigenetic mechanism?
DNA modifications are considered true epigenetic mechanisms because they can be inherited by cells This maintenance methylation is carried out by the enzyme DNMT1 which recognises hemi-methylated DNA (only one strand is methylated from the parent cell).
199
Outline DNA methylation in pluripotent cells
DNA methylation of CpG islands are high at promotors of inactive genes in pluripotent ES cells
200
Outline DNA methylation in totipotent cells
Totipotent zygotes are essentially devoid of DNA methylation - As preimplantation embryo is created and develops, methylation is decreasing. Once is becomes the epiblast (post implantation), remethylation occurs. This demethylation wave in the preimplantation embryo is erasing the epigenetic imprints that the sperm and egg has - 30% of genes in ES cells are methylated at promotors
201
How does histone acetylation affect gene transcription?
Lysine acetylation on the NH3+ side chain is associated with active chromatin
202
How is histone acetylation carried out?
Carried out by histone acetyltransferases HATs and removed by HDACs
203
How does histone methylation affect gene transcription?
- Usually repressive – if the methylation occurs on H3K9 or H3K27 - H3K4 methylation is active
204
How is histone methylation carried out?
Carried out by histone methyltransferases (HMTs) and removed by histone demethylases
205
What is meant by bivalent modifications?
- Most developmental genes that are silenced by Oct4, Sox2 and Nanog in pluripotent stem cells are co-occupied by Polycomb group proteins. They add the repressive mark H3K27me3 and the activating mark H3K4me3 on lineage specific gene - This is known as bivalent modifications and allow the quick removal of one of these marks once the cell receives a signal to promote differentiation
206
What occurs to the pluripotency genes when lineage commitment occurs?
- Oct4 is rapidly silenced and repressive H3K27 and H3K9me3 are added and activating modifications are removed. - H3K9me3 is catalysed by the HMT G9a and this then promotes DNA methylation at OCT4s promotor also occurs
207
What did Takahashi K and Yamanaka S (2006) aim to find?
Asked how many genes controlled pluripotency, are there a few genes required or just one?
208
What system did Takahashi K and Yamanaka S (2006) use?
- Created a new system where he could screen for pluripotency. - He knew that Fbx-15 gene is highly expressed in ES cells but it is not important in pluripotency meaning it could be manipulated without damaging pluripotency. - He knocked in Bgeo or G418 (neomycin selection gene) instead of Fbx-15. If this gene is active then neomycin resistance gene will therefore be active. - Somatic cells can be killed with low levels of neomycin and if turn on this gene (only turned on in pluripotent ES cells) then they become resistant to this and the cells will survive
209
How did Takahashi K and Yamanaka S (2006) use their system to find factors needed to reprogram somatic cells?
- Used fibroblasts and with the G418/Fbx-15 system - Used viral infection to add 24 genes (hypothesised to be involved in pluripotency) one by one. No cells survived meaning they hadn’t acquired ES cell properties. - He then added them all together and this resulted in 22 clones and 5 of them looked very like ES cells. - He then purified this further and found that they expressed pluripotent factors
210
What pluripotency factors did Takahashi K and Yamanaka S (2006) find were required to reporgamme somatic cells?
Oct4, Sox2, C-Myc and Klf4 | - Nanog was dispensable
211
What are enhancer elements?
- They are genetic elements consisting of 100-1000bp of non-coding DNA and positively active transcript - They act independent to location, orientation and distance and are crucial determinates of lineage specific gene expression
212
Where are enhancers located?
- cis-regulatory (located on the same chromosome) and reside away from the promotors they act upon
213
How does the structure of enhancers allow their function?
They contain clusters of different transcription factor binding motifs which allows them to integrate information from multiple different signalling events into one regulatory locus to drive gene expression
214
What is the ZRS enhancer?
Controls shh expression
215
What happens when the ZRS enhancer is mutated?
- Located away from the shh promotor site and when mutations occur, there is ectopic expression of the shh gene - Can result in polydactyly (extra digit formation)
216
How can an enhancer be located on the genome through genetic analysis?
Look if there are clusters of transcription binding
217
What are the epigenetic marks of an active enhancer?
- H3K4me1 - H3K27ac - Higher levels of DNAse1 hypersensitivity - CpG low enrichment
218
Why is there H3K4me1 at active enhancers?
- H3K4me3 is found at promotors but only mono-methylation at enhancers. The more methylation is a mark of transcriptional activity which is higher at promotors than enhancers
219
Why is there H3K27ac at active enhancers?
- Enhancers are highly dependent on transitional coactivators that bind and modify the chromatin at that region: CBP and p300. - These are histone acetyltransferases which give the activating mark. This recruitment results in increased histone acetylation of H3K27 and increased transcription
220
Why is there higher levels of DNAse1 hypersensitivity at active enhancers?
The chromatin are more open and available for incoming transcriptional activators
221
Why is there low CpG enrichment at active enhancers?
Prevents DNA methylation which reduces DNA transcription
222
How does transcription levels compare between enhancers and promotors?
Overall levels of transcription are lower in enhancers than promotor but can see small transcription.
223
Give evidence for enhancers working in a cell type specific manor?
TAL1 is a lineage determining transcription factor - In cell lineages where TAL1 is active, there is elevated H3K4me2 and acetylated H3K27 at the enhancer regions of TAL1. - In cells where the gene is turned off, there are none of these modifications at the enhancer sites showing that the enhancers work in a cell type specific manor
224
What is meant by pioneer activity?
The transcription factors can bind to DNA sequences even in closed chromatin - can bind to DNA and nucleosomes and loosen the tightly packed chromatin and makes some of the other TF binding sites more accessible for binding by chromatin remodellers and other TFs
225
How do enhancers become primed in specific cell types?
- Lineage determining transcription factors have pioneer activity and bind to the enhancer - This makes the enhancer site more open and active – recruits coactivators and results in modifications at the chromatin creates a primed enhancer
226
How does enhancer activation occur in a primed enhancer?
- After pioneer activity has opened chromatin at the enhancer element, the signal dependant transcription factors can then bind allowing integration of the genetic response with signalling factors received by the cell - This is highly cell type specific because the ability to respond to these signals is due to the pioneer activity of the lineage specific transcription factors
227
What two models explain how transcription factors bind and activate enhancers?
- Enhanceosome model | - Billboard model
228
Outline the Enhanceosome model
- The position and order of the sequences in the enhancers that’s important in defining TF binding - Multiple transcription factors bind to the enhancer and forms a highly structured complex called the Enhanceosome. The targets genes would only be activated by the enhancer upon precise assembly of this complex
229
Outline the billboard model
- More flexible than enhanceosome model - The identity of the TFs that bind to the enhancer is important for the function of the enhancer site - Multiple transcription factors of different purposes bind to the enhancer and discrete regions of the enhancer containing a few of these binding sites is sampled by the basal machinery and determines the overall output - A rigid complex is not required
230
Give examples of co-activators recruited at enhancer elements
- Histone methyltransferases (MLL) - Histone acetyltransferases (CBP) - Chromatin remodellers (BAF) - Mediator complex
231
How are co-activators recruited to enhancer elements?
Recruited to loci in the genome by sequence dependant transcription factors (lineage specific) binding to enhancers which in turn recruit the co-activators. The co-activators act independently to the underlying DNA sequences
232
What is the function of the co-ativators of enhancer elements?
After pioneer transcription factors bind to enhancers, co-activators are recruited which modify histones and allow the enhance to enter an open state - primed - These coactivators are required for the function of DNA binding activators
233
How do the co-activators of enhancers vary between cell types?
The same co-activators are used - Lineage specific transcription factors bind to the enhancer regions and open chromatin in different cell lineages. - The same coactivators are then recruited to the newly opened enhance regions by these lineage specific transcription factors
234
How does an enhancer go from a primed to a poised state using multiple co-activators?
- After linage determining factor binding, transcription factors binds to UTX, a histone demethylase, which removes repressive histone modifications H3K27me3 made by EzH2. This is then replaced with H3K4me by the MLL/COMPASS complex - p300 is recruited which with adds H3K27ac to open the chromatin making the enhancer poised for activation - When in the poised state and the enhancer is off, there is high level of H3K27me3 and low/no H3K4me and H3K27ac. When activated, the repressive marks are removed and p300 binds to add H3K27ac. The differences are on the level of chromatin modifications
235
What state are enhancers in in embryonic stem cells?
Embryonic stem cells are enriched in the poised enhancers and upon differentiation these enhancers transfer to an active state - poised enhancers are later in activation stage and characterised by epigenetic marks (primed only TF binding)
236
What are eRNAs?
RNA pol II transcribes when the enhancer is active to produce eRNAs which promote the activity of the enhancer to drive gene expression
237
What is the role of eRNAs?
- They can promote looping between the promotor and the enhancer using cohesin and the mediator. - They can release Poll II from the gene promotor to the gene body and stabilise TF binding to enhancers. - They can also stimulate the CBP activity to increase H3K27ac
238
What are topologically associated domains (TADs)?
Higher order organisational units of chromatin folding and function within the nucleus - TADs identify the extent of a chromatin domain containing transcriptionally co-regulated gene
239
How far do enhancers act upon?
Enhancers interact with genes within the same topologically associated domains due to the presence of TAD boundaries which are defined by the insulator protein CTCF.
240
How are TAD boundaries formed?
Hand-cuff model - Two ends of a TAD are brought together in 3D space by CTCF proteins which bind to each boundary via the DNA motifs ad recruit cohesin. - This is supported as the cohesin complex generally co-localises with CTCF throughout the mammalian genome
241
What is the problem with the handcuff model?
A problem is that the number of CTCF binding sites are much more abundant than the number of TAD boundaries. Therefore, why are TADs not more abundant?
242
How can the 3D structure of the genome be investigated?
Hi-C | - Based upon chromatin capture e.g 3C
243
Outline Hi-C
- Close chromatin are cross linked using formaldehyde - DNA is digested - Before DNA ligation, the newly made restriction ends are filled in with biotin-labelled nucleotides which tag the DNA at different positions - Then ligated to produce a circular DNA and then sequenced - A Biotin pull-down is the performed to ensure that only ligation junctions are selected. - Reads are then mapped back to the genome and when a pair of tags are found on two different restriction fragments then these two fragments are known to interact in the 3D nucleus.
244
How can HI-C produce crosslinks between chromatin in the nucleus?
When chromatin are interacting, they are near each other. This process works by crosslinking chromatin in the nucleus and joins together regions of the chromatin that are in proximity to each other by treating the chromatin with formaldehyde
245
How can Hi-C resulted be used to show the 3D structure of the nucleus?
- You can use the results of Hi-C interactions to map the genome and investigate contact frequency between different loci - Can then find domains within in the chromosome that are in contact with each other in 3D
246
What could be detected on a 5kb Hi-C?
Interactions that are no further than 5kb a part. Can see gene and enhancer loops, Polycomb mediated
247
What could be detected on a 10kb Hi-C?
Can see TADs. Dark triangles show the TADs regions that interact with each other in 3D space. In the nucleus, each domain is more closely interacting with each other in 3 dimensions
248
What could be detected on a 50kb Hi-C?
Can see that individual TAD domains start to group together to form multi TAD domains and form chromatin compartments and can be defined more by histone modifications
249
What could be detected on a interchromsomal Hi-C?
The hi-C map indicates individual chromosomes. Can see that there are very few interactions in trans between different chromosomes
250
Do TADs vary between cell types?
In vertebrates, there is a high level of conservation of the location of the TADs between cell differences. The differences seen between cell types are at the level of structure within a TAD, such as enhancers active
251
What DNA sequences are found at TAD boundaries?
- TADs form between the binding sites of the insulator protein CTCF. - Housekeeping genes are also found at the boundaries of TADs as they do not require enhancer for their activity - Repetitive parts of the genome
252
How can TADs cause disease?
TADs are crucial for development and disease. If disrupt the TAD boundaries, enhancers will begin to act in parts of the genome that it should not and cause ectopic gene expression
253
Outline the loop extrusion model for TAD formation
- Driven by the cohesin complex - Forms ring around two strands of DNA and uses ATP hydrolysis to push DNA through the ring structure forming a loop region - Two CTCF binding sites sit at the neck of the loop that are in the same direction. - When the cohesin complex meets these sites during loop formation, the looping stops at his point and the CTCF binds to its two opposite binding sites and dorms a TAD domain
254
What is the function of TADs?
TAD structure is important for enhancer activity as it limits the range of genes that an enhancer can act upon
255
What happens if CTCF binding sites are disrupted?
CTCF sites are crucial for maintaining TAD structure. Disruption of CTCF binding allows enhances to regulate gene expression in a different manor deviating from it’s normal regulation.
256
Can TADs be cell type specific?
Cohesin complex and CTCF can also interact with cell type specific factors which can give TADs a cell type specific function
257
Give evidence for the importance of TADs?
- Experimental deletion of CTCF domains - Resulted in the formation of larger TADs by the joining of smaller TAD regions where the CTCF binding site had been lost - This changes the activity of enhancers
258
What are chromatin compartments?
Compartments are regions of chromatin formed of multiple TADs over large distances
259
What are the two two types of chromatin compartments?
A active and B inactive
260
How are chromatin compartments defined?
- TADs within these regions preferentially interact with each other and is defined by chromatin modifications - e.g. An A compartments TAD has more activing histone modifications and chromatin within B compartments have more repressive modifications
261
Does TAD structure change during differentiation?
The overall TAD structure does not significantly change during differentiation but they can shift from an active to an inactive compartment depending if they are going to be expressed in that cell lineage.
262
What drives the change from TAD boundaries being in a active or inactive compartment?
This is driven by chromatin regulatory complexes. This shown by artificially recruiting dCas9 to an artificial region which resulting in shifting the TAD domain between compartments
263
What is the histone code?
Post translational modifications of histone tails which change the chromatin state
264
What is the most common histone modification?
Lysine acetylation or methylation
265
What classes of enzymes are involved in histone modifications?
- Writers: introduces the post-translational modification - Erasers: removes the modification - Readers: binds the modification and acts upon this modification
266
What is the function of the Polycomb complexes?
These complexes are involved in the establishment of transcriptionally repressed chromatin. When these complexes can’t work (due to one gene mutation) then the system falls apart and it results in derepression of the Hox gene cluster
267
Describe the structure of the PRC1 core?
The core contains histone ubiquitinates: RING1A and RING1B which are mutually exclusive. They require a stable association with one of the polycomb group ring finger (PCGF) proteins. There are 6 different PCGF proteins. - There are at least 100 different forms of PRC1 could functionally exist in each cell at a given developmental stage. The specific functional properties and regulation of these complexes are poorly understood
268
Describe the structure of the PRC2 core
- EZH1 and EZH2 are mutually exclusive (PCR2 only has one type) - They methylate H3K27 and require stable associative with Eed and Suz12 and recruit RBBP4 or RBBP7.
269
How does PRC2 work?
- The enhancer of zeste is the catalytic core of the complex to create the trimethylation and Esc recognises the mark. This pair of activity allows chromatin to be progressively methylated. - Enhancer of zeste methylates histone, the Esc then binds to this methylation mark and positions enhancer of zeste in the correct location to methylate the next histone H3 in the next nucleosome - The enhancer of zeste protein is inactive without ESC showing the need for the whole PRC2 complex
270
How does PRC1 work?
- Recognises the trimethyl mark through the chromodomain - Methylation on lysine 27 from PRC2, the Polycomb protein in PCR1 then sits in between these methylations and creates condensed chromatin
271
What is the relationship between trithorax and polycomb proteins?
Functionally antagonistic
272
What do trithorax proteins do?
methylates lysine 4 - activating mark
273
What recognise H3K4 methylation by trithorax?
PHD fingers
274
How does the epigenome of differentiated and ES cells differ?
- ES have a bivalent pattern of modification. Contains both methylated lysine 4 and lysine 27 which have distinct functional characteristics. Lysine 4 is activating and lysine 27 is repressive - In differentiated cells some retain the lysine 4 or the lysine 27 methylation. They make the decision to remove one of the methylation marks allowing either transcription or repression. It loses bivalency. - Genes required for a specific lineage maintain their lysine 4 mark and remove their lysine 27 mark.
275
What is meant by ES cells being in a poised state?
- The vast majority of promoters are enriched in H3K27 and H3K4 methylation. They are bivalent and are all inactive genes but have an association with RNA polymerase II so are ready to differentiate (poised)
276
Give evidence for H3K4 methylation requiring trithorax function
H3K4 methylation requires the activity of the Trithorax protein Mll2 - In Wt ES cells there is a strong peak of H3K4 methylation in various genes - Knockout of Mll2 then the level of methylation has been completely abolished - However, H3K27 methylation is unaffected by Mll2 knockouts
277
Give evidence for H3K27 methylation requiring polycomb function
H3K37 require polycomb function - Knockout components of the Polycomb complexes - Knockout of EED (binds to EzH2), or EzH2 then lose tri and di methylation of H3K27 - Expression of pioneer transcription factors (nanog ect) in knockouts is gone. Polycomb function is required for pluripotency - Loss of PRC2 function causes spontaneous differentiation of ESCs into meso-endodermal tissue and lose pluripotency
278
How do ES cells have the bivalent pattern of histone modification?
Polycomb and Trithorax Group proteins are functionally antagonistic - Come together on bivalent genes to create the state of poised transcriptional inactivity - Induction of differentiation disturbs this balance and breaks the transcriptional silence to allow for the removal of H3K27 marks and differentiation into a specific lineage.
279
What is meant by genomic equivalence?
Every somatic cell nucleus contains identical DNA. Unused genes in differentiated cells are maintained and retain the potential for being expressed. Only a small proportion of the genome is expressed in each cell type and a proportion of RNA expression is cell type specific
280
What did Soufi et al, 2012 investigate?
- How do reprogramming transcription factors initially interact with the genome during reprogramming? - How different transcriptional networks are regulated during reprogramming? - How do OSKM factors work together to drive re-programming?
281
What are OSKM factors?
Oct4 Sox2 Klf4 C-Myc
282
What model system did Soufi et al, 2012 use to investigate OSKM factors during reprogramming?
- Induced expression of OSKM in human fibroblasts using Dox inducible expression. OSKM are maximally expressed at 48 hours. If then remove the exogenous expression of the OSKM by removing dox, the cells continue to grow and express pluripotency markers – induced pluripotent cells - After 48 hours, ChIP-Seq for OSKM following 48 hours of Dox to look across the genome to see where the OSKM factors are binding.
283
How did Soufi et al, 2012 show that the OSKM factors co-bind in the genome?
- Oct4 Chip-Seq also showed enrichment of the other factors at the same point. - This shows that the factors all bind together and the same sites in the genome suggesting in early stages of reprogramming the factors act in the same transcriptional network
284
What did Soufi et al, 2012 find about where the OSKM factors bind in the genome?
- OSKM factors bind and regulate genes required in reprogramming - turn off fibroblast specific and turn on pluripotent. - Many of these bindings occur at enhancer regions rather than promotors
285
What did Soufi et al, 2012 find about the different between OSK and C-myc binding?
- C-Myc binds open chromatin while OSK factors bind closed chromatin. - OSK factors therefore have pioneer factor ability. 70% of all OSK factors bind at closed chromatin regions using this pioneer factor activity- they bind to genes involved in pluripotency which are closed in differentiated cells - This pioneer ability is due to the varying crystal structure of the factors
286
What did Soufi et al, 2012 find about what is required for c-myc binding?
C- myc binding at enhancers and promotors in DNAse resistant areas requires the presence of the other factors – requires the pioneer activity of oct4 and sox2
287
What did Soufi et al, 2012 define as differentially bound regions (DBRs)?
Whole genome sequence found large domains where OSKM factors did not bound
288
What did Soufi et al, 2012 find about why OSKM factors can't bind to DBRs?
DBRs have large enrichened regions of repressive H3K9me3 | - Once reprogrammed these regions lost methylation and OSKM could bind
289
How did Soufi et al, 2012 evidence the fact that H3K9me3 was responsible for DBRs?
They depleted the methyltransferase responsible for this repressive mark (Suv39H1/2) by siRNAs. This resulted in a recovery of Oct4 and sox2 binding in the DBRs showing that it is the H3K9me3 that is blocking OSKM binding. This recovery is not seen in regions that aren’t affected by methylation
290
What is the vulva?
The vulva is the egg laying organ in the hermaphrodite worm
291
Draw diagram of vuvlal development in worms
See notes
292
What are worms without a vulva?
Worms that have developed without a vulva exhibit egg laying defect phenotype
293
Why are C. elegans used as a model organism?
They are good model organism because they are small, rapid life-cycle, free living, few cell types, compact genome, transparent cuticle (look in a live worm) and there are hermaphrodites and males, every cell linage is mapped
294
What are hermaphrodite and male C. elegans?
Hermaphrodites start their life as a male and produce sperm and then later in development produce eggs which can be self-fertilised
295
Why is the C. elegant vuvlal development important?
The C. Elegans hermaphrodite vulva is one of the best studied models for signal transduction and cell fate determination during organogenesis
296
How were the pathways in vulval development discovered?
These pathways were discovered by forward genetic screens and laser ablation. Laser ablation is when they kill one of the cells in the worm and then see how this effects development of the worm
297
What are VPCs?
Vulval precursor cells
298
When does C. elegans vulval development occur?
Begins with 6 vulval precursor cells (VPC) which overlay an anchor cell in the L2 stage of larval development
299
What is meant by vulval development being an example of invariant pattern of cell fates?
The process is always the same | - One exception: P3.p sometimes becomes a VPC and sometimes fuses with Hys7
300
What pathways define the VPCs?
EGFR, NOTCH and Wnt
301
What are the types of VPCs and how are they defined?
The combined actin of the three pathways result in a single primary VPC (P6P) that Is always flanked by two secondary VPCs (P5p and P7p). If there is no signal at all from the signalling then they become tertiary VPC
302
What type of signalling is Wnt, EGFR and notch?
Wnt and EGFR are an example of paracrine signalling while NOTCH is Juxtacrine signalling
303
Where do Wnt, EGFR and notch signalling occur in vulval development?
- NOTCH signalling occurs between secondary and primary VPCs. Wnt and EGFR occurs between anchor cells and VPCs - These pathways cooperate acting with partial redundancy to specify cell fate.
304
What occurs in the canonical Wnt signalling pathway when Wnt is not present?
- Beta catenin is bound to a destruction complex in the cell cytoplasm, formed by the kinases CK1 and GSK3 and proteins APC, Axin and Slimb - CK1 and GSK3 phosphorylate beta catenin causing the slimb protein to ubiquinate it. These targets the beta catenin for degradation by the proteasome - Without the presence of beta catenin in the nucleus, repressor proteins such as Groucho block activation of the target genes
305
How does Groucho repress transcription in the canonical wnt signalling pathway?
- Groucho represses transcription by recruiting histone deacetylases which causes acetyl groups to be removed from histones so that they are packed tighter. - Therefore, transcription cannot occur because the genes are not accessible
306
What occurs in the canonical Wnt signalling pathway when Wnt is present?
- Wnt binds to the transmembrane receptor frizzled and co-receptor arrow/LRP - Destruction complex proteins CK1 and GSK3 phosphorylate the cytoplasmic tail of the activated arrow/LRP and this leads to the phosphorylation of Dsh. This stops the formation of the destruction complex and the loss of slimb protein - Beta catenin is still phosphorylated but it cannot be degraded causing the release of beta catenin which enters the nucleus and removes the repression protein Groucho and activate transcription of the selected target genes
307
How does beta canteen remove the repression of beta catenin in the canonical Wnt signalling pathway?
- Beta catenin removes repression by binding to the promotor region and activating histone acetyl transferases and BRC1 (a chromatin remodelling factor). - This causes the histones to be less densely packed so transcription can occur.
308
Draw a diagram of the canonical Wnt signalling pathway
See notes
309
Outline EGFR signalling
- EGF activates a receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) pathway - Binding of the ligand LIN-3 triggers dimerization of the receptor causing transphosphorylation and triggers a kinase cascade Eventually the activated ERK kinases alters gene expression by phosphorylating transcriptional factors
310
Draw a diagram of EGFR signalling
See notes
311
Outline canonical NOTCH signalling
- Notch (transmembrane receptor) binds to Delta (transmembrane receptor on adjacent cell). - This occurs at two receptors at the cell surface which then interact and causes proteolysis of the Notch receptor. - The intracellular domain of NOTCH to enter the nucleus and activates target genes by binding to CSL which displaces transcriptional repressors and recruits transactional activators e.g. histone acetyl transferase p300 This is how the primary and the secondary VPCs communicate
312
Draw a diagram of canonical NOTCH signalling
See notes
313
What is hys7 in C.elegans?
The syncytium
314
Which of the 6 VPCs form which type of cell?
- The primary cell fate is the primary VPC (P6.p) and forms the central vulval cells - The secondary cell fate (P5.p and P7.p) and forms lateral vulval cells - The tertiary cell fate (p3.p p3.p and p8.p) fuse with hyp7 and forms the hypodermal cells
315
How are the vulval competence group of cells formed at the start of vulval development?
- In L1 stage of development P cells divide into Pn.a and pn.p. (where n is any number of cells) - The pn.p goes onto form the epidermis but wnt signalling selects six of the Pn.p cells to become the vulval precursor cells. - It does this by inducing the Hox gene Lin-39. - The other Pn.p cells lose this potential and become the hypodermis
316
How is Wnt signalling involved in the formation of vulval competence cells?
- The Wnt signalling comes from the anchor cell and without it, no pn.p cells are driven to vulval competence and the vulva does not form - Activates Hox gene Lin-39
317
Give evidence for EGFR signalling being involved in the formation of vulval competence cells?
- P3.p can either become a VPC or fuse with hyp7 - Animals over expressing Lin-3 (EGF like ligand), the fusion of P3.p is not observed. - This showed that the vulval equivalence is decided by Wnt and EGFR signalling. If it was only decided by Wnt, the amount of Lin-3 would not affect the outcome of p3.p
318
What specifies the primary cell fate of VPCs?
The anchor cell
319
Outline how the primary VPC is specified?
- LIN-3 is secreted from the anchor cell in a gradient and activates LET-23 (EGFR) in all VPCs - P7.p receives the most of LIN-3 and becomes the primary VPC – EGFR tyrosine kinase pathway is activated. This pathway ends with phosphorylation of the transcription factors LIN-1 and LIN-31. - The phosphorylated version of these factors cannot repress transcription and activate genes associated with a primary cell fate. - One targets of these genes is the lin-39 hox gene which promotes the primary cell fate - Wnt also activates Lin-39, showing that both Wnt and EGFR contribute to the primary cell fate
320
What signalling is involved in secondary cell fate specification?
NOTCH signalling - the primary VPC expresses transmembrane receptor ligands LAG-2, DSL-1 and APX - other VPCs express NOTCH receptor Lin-12
321
Outline how the secondary VPCs are specified?
- The secondary cells already had less of the lin-3 signal from the anchor cell - Notch signalling inhibits EGFR signalling in the flanking cell by lateral inhibition. - It triggers the endocytosis of the EGFR to prevent further activation of EGFR signalling and it also triggers activation of MAPK phosphatases which is undoing the kinase cascade activated by EGFR signalling already
322
Give evidence for the role of NOTCH signalling in the specification of secondary VPCs?
- This was evidenced in a constitutive LIN-12 mutant as all the 6 VPCs adopt a secondary cell fate. - This shows that NOTCH must have an inductive role even if LIN-3 signalling is absent. - NOTCH signalling is sufficient to drive secondary VPC fate
323
Outline how the tertiary VPCs are specified?
The distal VPCs that receive neither lin-3 nor lateral Lin-12 signal adopt the tertiary non-vulval cell fate
324
Which paper identified the model for vulval development?
Sternberg et al, 1986
325
What is meant by pluripotent factors being mutually repressive?
- The pluripotency factors all drive expression of different tissues so the balance of them results in no differentiation and the cells remaining in a self-renewing state - This is achieved by the factors mutually repressing each other. Oct4 drives mesoderm differentiation but represses trophoectoderm formation. Sox2 drives ectoderm but repressed trophoectoderm and mesoderm
326
How can DNA methylation be reversed?
DNA methylation can also be removed by TET enzymes in a multi-step process - Forms hydroxyl methylcytosine (sign of active demethylation) - Leads to full removal of the nucleotide to create a gap in the DNA - Repaired by the base excision repair mechanism - Is then repaired to unmethylated cytosine
327
Where are poised enhancers found?
Poised enhancers are commonly found in ES cells
328
What is the difference between poised and primed enhancers?
- Poised are characterised by the presence of epigenetic modifications and require longer to activate then primed - Primed state is characterised by transcription factor binding but no epigenetic modification
329
What did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 investigate?
Pattern formation during vulval development in C. elegans
330
What methods did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 use?
- They looked at the pattern of cell division to identify each cell type using Normatski optics - Ablated individual cells with a laser
331
What were Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 main conclusions?
- Determination occurs in the Pn.p (P(3-8).p cells and not their progeny (pn.px). After cell division, the cells are committed to their fate - The unindicted ground state of the Pn.p cells is to adopt a tertiary fate – fuses with the syncytium - A graded signal from the anchor cell specifies which of the three fates are adapted
332
How did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 show that cell replacement can occur in pn.p cells that have not divided?
- They ablated different of the VPCs in 9 different C. elegans before the first cell division - When no cells are ablated, P6.p is primary, P5 and P7 are secondary and the others are tertiary - When ablated P5.p cells, everything to the right stayed the same: the primary secondary and tertiary but to the left the p4.p moved and adopted the secondary cell fate on the left and the P3.p remained tertiary - If ablate a cell before division, cells can be replaced. If occurs after cell division, replacement cannot occur
333
How did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 show that cell replacement cannot occur in pn.p cells after division?
- Used Ion-1 mutant which are 50% longer than wild type. - Because of this, the anchor cell is not always in the correct place giving a shifted vulvae phenotype. - This could therefore change the fate of Pn.ps and the anchor cell would be between the P5.p and the P6.p and expect to see a half shit in cell identity. - However, this never occurred suggesting that the cell identity cannot be changed after division
334
Is the anchor cell required at all times in vulval formation?
The anchor cell is not required after the first division. If ablate, development is normal
335
What two hypotheses did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 suggest to explain how the fates of the VPCs occur?
- The anchor cell could stimulate P(5-7) to adopt a primary or tertiary cell. This would mean that the ground state of the pn.p cell is to adopt a 3’ fat. - Pn.p cells could inhibit each other from adapting primary or secondary fates and that the anchor cell could release P(5-7) from inhibition by their neighbours
336
How did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 find which hypothesis was correct?
- If remove the gonad (row B), this removes the anchor cell, everything becomes tertiary - Ablated P5-7 (row C) and kept the gonad (and therefore anchor cell), this resulted in cells moving in o replace the lost primary and secondary cells - Ablated the gonad and P5-P7, all cells adopt a tertiary cell fate - Therefore, the ground state is tertiary and the anchor cell induces the primary and secondary cell fate
337
Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 suggested that the anchor cell induces primary cell which in turn induces secondary cells, how was this proved wrong?
- This model suggests that an isolated Pn.p cell could not adopt a secondary cell fate. - They therefore used an unc-84 mutant where cells cannot move to generate isolated pn.p cells. - The isolated pn.p cells could adopt any fate depending on its distance from the anchor cell – it doesn’t need to talk to other pn.p cells, proving model B wrong
338
What did Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986 show about what dictates pn.p fate?
Distance from the anchor cell dictates pn.p cell - When a p8.p is under the anchor cell it forms the primary VPC. - When p8.p is further away it becomes a secondary cell and when it is at its furthest away it adopts a tertiary cell fate.
339
What model of pn.p induction was identified as a result of Sternberg and Horvitz, 1986?
- The anchor cell releases EGF ligand Lin-3 where most is received by primary and least by tertiary - The primary (P6.p) and secondary cells (p5.p, p7.p) which becomes the vulva. While the tertiary cells become the hypodermis syncytium - There is also notch signalling between the primary and secondary cells - After specification, the cells divide - For morphogenesis to occur, interaction between primary and secondary cells is required (notch signalling)
340
Give an example of notch signalling in vertebrate development?
Notch signalling in bone development (Yamada et al, 2003)
341
Outline some major findings from (Yamada et al, 2003)
- Early in vitro studies have found the Notch signaling pathway functions as down-regulator in osteoclastogenesis and osteoblastogenesis - Constitutively active Notch1-transfected stromal cells showed increased expression osteoclast repressive genes, resulting in reduction of their ability to support osteoclast development - Overexpression of Notch signaling inhibits BMP2-induced osteoblast differentiation.
342
What is the role of Notch signalling in bone development?
Overall, Notch signaling has a major role in the commitment of mesenchymal cells to the osteoblastic lineage and provides a possible therapeutic approach to bone regeneration
343
Define Vernalization
Flowering decision in response to cold weather
344
Give two examples of the environmental impact on development
Vernalisation in plants Metabolic disease risk or behavioural traits in mammals
345
What gene is responsible for vernalisation
Flowering Locus C (FLC)
346
What does FLC gene do?
- FLC is floral repressor - If on, there is late or no flowering - If off, early flowering
347
Why is the studying of vernalisation important?
- Because this is so well characterised, it is an experimentally robust way to study gene regulation. Refers to other organisms
348
How can vernalisation be measured by a quantitative output?
The length of time and when flowering occurs
349
Does FLC repression propagate?
The prolonged exposure to cold leads to a mitotically stable state that survives vegetative propagation – gene stays off even when reprogrammed to a stem cell
350
What makes the repression of the FLC locus unusual in epigenetic terms?
- The repression is limited to one locus and the genes adjacent to FLC are not affected by cold temperature. - This is quite rare in epigenetics – usually whole regions affected
351
Why is it easy to measure FLC gene state?
- There is a clear temporal separation of the establishment (cold winter) and the maintenance (spring) - The silencing is quantitative – the degree of stable FLC silencing after vernalisation reflects the length of cold exposure – this occur is a cell autonomous way
352
How is it ensured that vernalisation requirement is inherited in the offspring?
The epigenetic state is re-set at every generation to ensure that the vernalisation requirement is inherited in the offspring
353
Outline the life cycle of the Arabidopsis
- 6 weeks- seed to seed - Germination, seeding establishment, vegetative growth (continues until cold), floral transition, senescence - Embryo development occurs after the flower had been fertilised - There is a transition from vegetative meristem to reproductive meristem when the FCL gene is involved
354
How does FLC expression control flowering?
- If grow a plant at 20 degrees, it won’t flower because high expression of FLC. If put plant in fridge with light, FCL expression deceases. When return the flower to 20 degrees, the plant flowers - A longer exposure to the cold results in a quicker flowering when removed from the cold
355
How is vernalisation an advantage in temperate climates?
It temperate climates, vernalisation is advantageous to keep plants in a vegetative state in winter
356
Why is it difficult for plants to detect differences between autumn and spring?
- Light quality, light time and temperature is about the same - Doesn't know when to flower
357
How do plants detect differences between autumn and spring?
- It does this by measuring the prolonged period of cold – has it been winter before
358
How does vernalisation vary between Arabidopsis in different countries?
- The repression of FCL is quantitative and increases with accumulating exposure to cold. This leads to the progressively earlier flowering - Can see this affects the evolution in the genomes of plants in different countries – require different amounts of cold to flower
359
How is FLC silenced in vernalisation?
Vernalisation involved the down regulation and epigenetic silencing of a key floral repressor gene called FLC
360
How does silencing of FLC occur in cold weather?
- During the cold, silencing occurs at small patches of the gene called nucleation sites which then spreads across the while locus when returned to the warm – known this because can separate the exposure and memory sections in the genome
361
Outline the mechanism of FLC silencing in response to cold in vernalisation?
- PRC2 is already at the FLC gene in the cold. - Cold activates anti-sense transcript to FLC called COOLAIR (a ncRNA) which transcriptionally shuts down FLC - After longer exposure to cold, VIN3 upregulates which recruits a PHD protein to the PRC at the FLC locus. - The PHD protein adds repressive marks to the locus – e.g. H3K27me3 - VIN3 also nucleates the PRC to small nucleation regions in the FLC - Nucleation increases with time in the cold
362
Outline the mechanism of FLC silencing in the warm after cold in vernalisation?
- In the warm, VIN3 turns off and the silencing marks in the small nucleation regions of the FLC locus spread across the whole locus and FLC is turned off
363
What happens to the FLC gene after vernalisation?
After fertilisation, resetting occurs and ELF6 removes the H3K27me3 marks from the FLC locus. LEC1 is also involved in this process
364
How does COOLAIR act upon FLC in the warm?
- When warm and FLC is transcribed, there is expression of distally polyadeylated COOLAIR – long anti-sense - FRI-C is associated to the FLC locus and adds activating histone modification such as H3K36me3
365
How does COOLAIR act upon FLC in the cold?
- When cold and transcription of FLC decreases, COOLAIR is polyadenylated proximally forming a small transcript which binds to flowering genes such as FCA and FY. - They then recruit FVE and FLD to the FLC locus. - These acts independently. FLD removes the active histone marks (it’s a H3K4 demethylase) meaning that site is available for a repressive mark. - FVE is histone deacetylates 6 and adds a different repressive mark
366
Give examples of how vernalisation has lead to adapted Arabidopsis?
- Rapid cyclers are from hot places such as Columbia and have no vernalisation requirement - Rapid vernalisers e.g. UK – low vernalisation requirement but requires small cold for flowering - Slow vernalisers e.g. Sweden – requires a long winter for FLC to be repressed. If taken to England, the plant will never flower as FLC is not repressed for long enough to shut it off
367
What is the normal 'wild type Arabidopsis used in labs?
The wild type Arabidopsis, Columbia, is a rapid cycler and has lost FRIGIDA gene
368
What is FRIGIDA?
- A strong up regulator of the FLC | - Absolutely required for active FLC transcription and delay flowering
369
How does FRIGIDA promote FLC transcription?
- Directly binds to the nuclear cap-binding complex - Recruits a WD40-domain protein that promotes H3Kt6 trimethylation - Forms transcriptional activator complex
370
What happens to FLC expression in the progeny of vernalised plants?
- FLC is silenced after winter and the silencing is maintained through mitosis. However, this gene needs to be turned back on before it is passed on to the next generation - Plants DO NOT have a germ line
371
What is LEC1?
LEC encodes a subunit of NF-Y and is master regulator of embryogenesis
372
Outline FLC expression in the life of vernalised plants?
- A plant grows in the warm in the seedling stage, FLC is on and LEC1 is off. - Vernalisation occurs and FLC is turned off. - Return plant to the warm and the plant flowers and undergoes meiosis and gametogenesis – FLC is still off. - In early embryo development, LEC1 turns on and exchanges the silencing marks to the active marks on the FLC locus – FLC is turned on. - The cycle repeats
373
What are pioneer transcription factors?
- Pioneer transcription factors are special types of transcription factors that can access their target sequences in condensed chromatin - They are often associated with changes in cell fate and developmental switching.
374
What is LEC1?
- The seed-specific transcription factor LEAFY COTYLEDON1 (LEC1) acts as a pioneer transcription factor.
375
What is the role of LEC1?
- Is necessary for FLC resetting during embryo formation | - LEC1 is necessary for the increase in activating histone marks at the FLC locus
376
What did Tao et al 2017 investigate?
The role of LEC1 in the reprogramming of embryonic FLC expression
377
How did Tao et al, 2017 show that FLC expression is turned back on the progeny of parents vernalised plants?
- Vernalised and non-vernalised plants 1-5 days after pollination and the expression of FLC with the reporter gene GUS - Difference in expression disappears by day 3 and FLC is turned back on in the embryo as there is no visual difference between FLC expression in vernalised and non-vernalised parental plants
378
How did Tao et al, 2017 show that LEC1 reactivates FLC expression?
- Wild type Columbia flowers early (17-18 leaves) - Columbia with FRIDGIDA (FRI) put in (70 leaves) flowers late - Knockout of Lec1 in FRI background results in intermediate flowering time (partly turns FLC back on)
379
What did Tao et al, 2017 show about how LEC1 changes FLC expression?
- Hypothesised that LEC1 would bind to the cis element CCAT in the FLC promotor - There are 4 of these sites in the FLC promotor - Used antibody against LEC1 and pulled DNA down and then PCR to see what the binding sequence is - LEC1 binds partly to the first site, mostly at position 2, partly at 3 and none at 4 - LEC1 directly binds to the promotor of FLC
380
What system did Tao et al, 2017 use to again show that LEC1 activates FLC expression in seedlings?
DEX inducible system for turning on LEC1 quickly. - Express transgene with glucocorticoid receptor bound to LEC1. - This binds to HSP90 and restricted to the cytoplasm. - Then treat with DEX which binds to GR, dissociates HSP90 and allow translocation of LEC1 to the nucleus where it can activate target genes
381
What did Tao et al, 2017 show about the changing chromatin state of FLC in developing seeds?
- Active marks are reduced in lec1 mutants (H3K36me3) and an increase in repressive H3K27me3. This suggests that LEC1 is needed to recruit active marks on FLC - EFS complex is recruited to the FLC locus by LEC1
382
Does LEC1 affect FLC expression only in seedlings?
- LEC1 acts in 15-day-old plants as well as embryos - Wt Columbia, FRI and FRI lec1 - Similar results seen in older plants as embryos
383
What is the function of LEC1?
LEC1 activity is required to re-activate FLC expression during embryogenesis
384
Methylation of CpG sites at a promotor is associated with what?
Gene silencing
385
How does CpG methylation at promotors block gene expression?
It does this by blocking the binding of transcription factors or by binding MECP2 (methyl CpG binding protein 2) which recruits histone modifying complexes which promote silent chromatin formation
386
How is DNA methylation maintained through mitosis?
Detection of hemi methylated DNA by DNMT1
387
How are DNA methyl transferases produced?
The one carbon cycle - The product of this is DNMT (DNA methyltransferase) which is the source of methylation (SAM is an important methyl donor)
388
How is DNA methylation affected by diet?
The one carbon cycle - Many components are supplied by the diet including Folate, vitamins B6 and B12 and methionine - Diets high in this methyl donating nutrients can rapidly alter gene expression at the whole genome level. Isn’t gene expression - This has the largest impact during early development when the epigenome is first being established
389
Give evidence that DNA methylation is affected by diet
Dominguez-Salas et al, 2013 - In some countries, diet changes throughout the year depending on the seasonal food availability - Can see in Gambia, there are monthly and seasonal changes in protein intake which are correlated with folate, B2 and DMG (components of one carbon metabolism pathway)
390
Why can agouti mice be used to study maternal environment impact?
- Agouti gene encodes paracrine-signalling molecule ASIP (Agouti signalling peptide) - When its promoter is un-methylated, the gene is on, ASIP protein is abundant, and mice show the typical yellow coat and tendency to be obese. - ASIP inhibits hypothalamic signalling making mice hyperphagic (eat a lot) - Maternal diet therefore dictates the activity of this gene and the offspring phenotype
391
Give an example of when agouti mice have been used to understand the maternal role of diet
Morgan et al, 1999 - Mice were supplemented with vitamin B12, folic acid, choline and betaine during pregnancy results in thin, brown pups. - Without supplementation, the pups were yellow and hyperphagic
392
What is Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (TEI)?
Transmission of epigenetic information through the germ line that affects phenotypic traits in more than one generation without changes in DNA sequence
393
What is the difference between TEI and intrauterine exposure?
Intrauterine exposure does not require the passage of an environmental memory through the germ line
394
For a phenotype to be TEI what must be shown?
- To rule out the possibility of genetic change (difficult in large genomes such as humans) - Rule out direct exposure (the developing foetus wasn’t exposed to the environment)
395
When can be TEI be confirmed in females (direct exposure stopped)?
- The foetus (F1) is exposed to the environment that the mother (F0) is - The foetus will also have developed their oocytes (F3) and therefore exposed to the environment too by the grandmother. This is intrauterine exposure - For TEI to be correct, would have to look at the effect of the third generation (F3)
396
When can be TEI be confirmed in males (direct exposure stopped)?
- The males (F0) experience cells and his reproductive cells (F1) also experience the stress - The grandson however will not have experienced the stress so TEI could be shown at the F2 generation
397
What is the role of the MTRR protein?
The MTRR protein is responsible for the activation of methionine synthase through the reductive methylation of its vitamin B12 cofactor and is essential for folate metabolism
398
What did Padmanabhan et al, 2013 do?
Made a knockdown transgenic line of MTRR (mtrrgt). This resulted in increased plasma levels of homocysteine. The knockdown was successful and resulted in fewer methyl groups and a build-up of one of the cycle components
399
What did Padmanabhan et al, 2013 show about the grand progeny of the MTRR knockdown mice?
The grand progeny of these mice showed a variety of developmental defects including neural tube defects, developmental delay and heart defects
400
What did Padmanabhan et al, 2013 show was responsible for the defects in the grand progeny?
The genotype of the grandmother effects the phenotype of the grand progeny - When the grandmother was heterozygous for knockdown gene resulted in developmental issues - Healthy grandmother resulted in healthy mice grand progeny. - Normal genotypes of offspring still had developmental defects if the grandmother was heterozygote
401
How is Padmanabhan et al, 2013 an example of TEI?
These congenital malformations independent of maternal environment persisted for five generations – TEI
402
How does the agouti gene effect fur colour?
- The agouti gene encodes a signalling molecule (hormone) that blocks melanin production in hair follicles. - The tip of the fur is dark due to the presence of melanin and the base of the hair is yellow due to agouti blocking melanin. - These mice appear light brown and give the agouti colour. This is wild type
403
What are the three main alleles of agouti gene?
- A – melanin is always blocked so mouse is yellow - a – hormone is not produced so black - A vy () – Brown to yellow transient expression
404
How can methylation profiles off a A viable yellow mouse affect the phenotype?
- There is a IAP retro transposon upstream to the transcription start site of the agouti gene. - o When this transposon is heavily methylated, the agouti gene is silenced and they are pseudo agouti but when demethylated, the gene is active and they look yellow. - This methylation is not just in the coat but in many tissues: the brain testis and lung ect
405
How did Waterland and Jirtle 2003 use agouti to investigate maternal diet?
- Gave vitamin B12 supplementation to mother and looked at the colour of the offspring - Supplemented diet gives the pseudo-agouti phenotype (agouti is off) due to IAP being more methylated
406
How did the agouti viable yellow methylation profile change in Waterland and Jirtle 2003?
- Counted the number of sites methylated - In unsupplemented, the methylation is usually less than 30% - Supplemented mice had increased methylation - They then mapped the percentage methylation to the phenotype seen e.g. 80% methylation – pseudo-agouti - Dietary supplements can therefore change the methylation level of the transposable element in mice
407
What is bisphenol A (BPA)?
Synthetic hormone | - BPA is widely used in plastic production and leaches out of plastics over time
408
What affect does BPA have on mice?
- BPA exposure to rodents results in increased body weight, breast/prostate cancer and meiotic defects - BPA increases the frequency of yellow phenotype in Agouti vy mice
409
What did Dolinoy et al, 2007 do to investigate how BPA changes methylation?
- BPA was added to the diet of virgin wild type female mouse and they were mated with A vy/a males - The A vy/a offspring were scored for coat colour and methylation status CpG sites downstream of the transposon insertion
410
How did the methylation of IAP transposon change in Dolinoy et al, 2007?
BPA supplement reduced the DNA methylation frequency increasing the expression of the A vy gene and the mice became fatter and yellower.
411
Could dietary supplements rescue BPA exposure in Dolinoy et al, 2007?
- Fed pregnant mice with methyl donors and tried to increase the silencing of the agouti gene - The control diet was similar to the methyl donor supplemented BPA diet showing that that methyl donor supplementation can rescue BPA exposure
412
Give evidence for BPA affected methylation of agouti in multiple tissues
Genome wide study (Kim et al, 2014) in the liver - Progeny of pregnant mice that had even been fed control, small amounts of bisphenol A or large amounts of bisphenol A - Some genes are unaffected, some show modest differences to the control. Others show heavy unmethylation and some acquire methylation - Can see that the function of many of the genes that have affected methylation are involved in metabolism
413
What did Radford et al, 2004 investigate?
That prenatal environments can affect adult metabolic health and that of subsequent generations using male mice as an example
414
What method did Radford et al, 2004 use to investigate epigenetic inheritance in male mice?
F1 generation - Control group: F0 were fed during pregnancy week 1, 2 and 3 - UN group which had a reduction in food in week 3. These pups are born with low weight (F1) F2 - Take control females and mate with one of the undernourished males (F1) and feed normally - The F2 mice are either CC (control, control) or (control undernourished) - The control undernourished had many developmental disorders despite them not being undernourished them selves
415
What did Radford et al, 2004 find about the DNA methylation profile of the F2 generation?
- Immunoprecipitation experiments in F1 male sperm showed difference in DNA methylation profiles at the genome level between CC (control) and UC - Some genes in the sperm were hypomethylated and some were hypermethylated compared to the control
416
Did the DMR persist from the sperm into the F2 generation in Radford et al, 2004?
- The F2 had dysregulation of metabolism in the over and by 8 months they had glucose intolerance and high white adipose tissue. - However, the differential methylation pattern seen in sperm had been lost but the dysregulation of genes neighbouring the DMRs is observed in F2 offspring - The mechanism of this is unknown
417
Give evidence for offspring being affected by sperm small RNAs?
Chen at al, 2016 - Offspring were affected by sperm small tRNAs paternal dietary conditions in mammals and influence the metabolic phenotypes of offspring - They injected the 5’ fraction of sperm tRNA from males who had not been fed a high-fat diet into normal fertilised oocytes (not the parents). - The progeny has various metabolic disorders – not inherited as parents weren’t fed differently – must be because of the tRNA - Altered gene expression in metabolic pathway and obesity
418
What did Sharma et al, 2016 do?
Also investigated how offspring were affected by sperm small RNAs - Observed a reduction in abundant tRNA-derived small RNAs in sperm from mice on a low protein diet
419
Give a study that investigates epigenetic reprogramming by maternal behaviour?
Weaver et al, 2004
420
What did Weaver et al, 2004 find?
- High nurturing mothers raise nurturing offspring and low nurturing mothers raise low nurturing offspring - Whether the pup grows up to the anxious or relaxed depends on the mother that raises it not maternal mother
421
How did Weaver et al, 2004 measure maternal care?
- Pup licking and grooming | - Arched back nursing
422
What gene did Weaver et al, 2004 focus the experiment on?
Glucocorticoid receptor - Encoded by GR gene - Glucocorticoids are primary stress hormones that regulate physiological processes - Ligand occupied GR induces or represses the transcription of thousands of genes
423
How effect on the GR gene did maternal behaviour have in Weaver et al, 2004
- The 5’ of the GR promotor has a big difference in methylation (high grooming has less methylation) - Low grooming mothers were associated with H3K9 acetylation and NGF1-A binding to the promotor of the GR gene in the hippocampus - Long term stress was quantified by looking at HPA responses and behaviour in grown up pups
424
How did Weaver et al, 2004 show that histone acetylation in response to low grooming was affecting GR expression?
- They tested the rats with a TSA (HDAC inhibitor) and observed changes in GR expression and stress responses. However, this isn’t specific to the GR gene, it will target all genes acetylated by HDACs - GR expression did change in response to this
425
Why is transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in humans difficult to prove in humans?
- Difficult to study due to variation in genetic, ecological and cultural inheritance - Difficult to prove just through observation studies
426
What effect has parental nutrition shown to have on human offspring?
- Parental nutrition and smoking behaviour are linked to cardiovascular, metabolic diseases, schizophrenia and antisocial personality disorders in the offspring
427
What did Joubert et al, 2012 investigate in relation to TEI?
- Investigated a link between plasma folate level (methyl donor) and asthma at age 3 - 1062 participants and chose 18 Caucasians in each category
428
What did Joubert et al, 2012 find in relation to TEI?
- Global analysis if CpG sites and found three DMRs • AHRR • CYP1A1 • GFI1 - AHRR and CYPA1 play a key role in the aryl hydrocarbon receptor signalling pathway which mediated the detoxification of tobacco smoke - Epigenetic may play a role in the observed poor health outcomes of children born to smoking woman – only an association
429
What did Francis et al, 2003 show about the causes of behaviour?
Show that genotype and environment can also change behaviour - Used two strains of mice which differ in colour and behaviour: B6 and BALB
430
How did Francis et al, 2003 test the behaviour of the two strains of mice?
Then tested their behaviour using open field test. Rodents naturally have an aversion to open areas due to predators but also like to explore new areas. This conflict allows us to explore their anxiety levels. The amount of time spent on the outer edge or in the middle can determine their anxiety levels.
431
How did Francis et al, 2003 show that the mice behavioural pattern was decided by genotype and environment?
- The white (BALB) mice are generally more anxious then the black (B6) mice which are more exploratory. If BALB mice were prenatally transferred into B6 mice or if B6 mice were prenatally transferred into BALB mice but then spent with B6 mice then they have B6 behaviour - Despite genotype, both pre and post-natal periods affected their behaviour. The B6 mice who spent time with white mice were much more anxious then would naturally be
432
What did Richmond et al, 2015 investigate?
Investigated associations between prenatal exposure to maternal smoking and offspring DNA methylation
433
What did Richmond et al, 2015 find?
- Methylation at 15 CpG sites in seven gene regions including AHRR and CYP1A1 was associated with maternal smoking - Shown to be dose-dependent in relation to smoking duration and intensity - Compared paternal and maternal smoking and found stronger maternal associations
434
Is Richmond et al, 2015 an example of TEI?
- More likely an example of direct exposure rather than TEI | - Maternal environment is still important
435
What is PAR?
Predictive Adaptive Response
436
How does PAR give an organism a survival advantage if the response matches the predicted environment?
- Fetal malnutrition (e.g. low protein condition) sets the metabolism to be prepared for an environment where food is scarce and use every calorie and downregulate essential organs to increase chance of reproduction - Until recently, such predictions were mostly true enabling the individual to survive to reproductive age while staying small and thin due to nutrition in later life matching the nutrition of the mothers
437
Why is PAR now more of a problem then an advantage?
With increasingly available food supplies within a single generation, the prediction often become false, and the individual is more likely to be obese and diabetic and to have high risk of heart disease due to their lower set metabolism
438
What allows for the long term effects on metabolism?
Changes in gene expression | - DNA methylation is an epigenetic modification which enables such changes