Natural law is right to base morals on telos

Question 1

natural law is WRONG to base morals on telos

Answer 1

Aquinas may be making the mistake of assuming that all human beings have the same purposes; it may be possible that each of us has different purposes. Aquinas himself seems to allow this in his recognition that priests who are called to celibacy are exempt from the primary precept of reproduction.

Question 2

natural law is WRONG to base morals on telos

Answer 2

As shown above, existentialists dispute whether humans have any purpose except the ones they freely choose for themselves. If God does not exist, then it seems difficult to argue for objective human purpose.

Question 3

natural law is WRONG to base morals on telos

Answer 3

Similarly, the scientific theory of evolution seems to suggest that purpose is not a feature of the world, but is rather something that human beings project on to the natural world.

Question 4

natural law is WRONG to base morals on telos

Answer 4

The idea of telos entails that some things are natural to human beings and other things are unnatural.