research methods Flashcards
field experiments adv
- popular with interpretivists, interested in meaning
- Easy to determine + manipulate cases and events
- repeatable for other researchers
- Enables comparison with similar research
field exp weaknesses
- Participants mislead researches
- if overt, Hawthorne effect
- small scale settings used large scale issues
open questionnaire - adv
- responds own words which improves validity
- imposition problem found in closed questionnaires is less of an issue
- more detailed and deeper answers, includes feelings and attitudes
- Open ended questions do not allow respondents to speed read or avoid reading the questionnaire
open questionnaire - weakness
- broad range of answers, hard to classify and qualify the data into graphs and charts
- difficult to compare results with similar research methods
- response rate can be lower
- time consuming.
closed questionnaire - adv
- cheap
- easy to compare with other researchers
- closed questions are customer friendly and easily quantified
closed questionnaire, weaknesses
- may get lower response rate
- inflexible, set questions
- question design isn’t easy
- interpretivists don’t like as questions and fixed responses reflect what sociologists
- closed questions don’t allow people to speak for themselves
structured interviews - Advantages
- high response rate
- people are more likely to give honest responses
- compared with semi-structured or unstructured interviews, they can be more reliable as the same interview can be repeated
structured interview, disadv
- less valid
- the interviewer has to persist with a particular line of questioning even if the interviewee has other interesting things to say
unstructured interviews - adv
- produce qualitative data that is thought to offer verstehen and be high in validity
- interviewers are able to offer their subjects support and exercise sensitivity
- method favoured by feminists conducting research on sensitive subjects, such as Dobash and Dobash’s work on domestic violence
disadvantages of unstructured interviews
- time consuming and require a skilled interviewer
- produce large amounts of feels which is difficult to analyse
- positivist sociologists would be concerned that the method lacks reliability and is unscientific and subjective
Participant observation
- covert, hides identity
- overt, reveals identity to the group
- covert participant observation doesn’t deal with Hawthorne effect, where as overt does.
Participant Observation adv.
- insight, bias
- validity, produces qualitative data which shows picture of how people really live, researcher can see for themselves
- flexibility - more flexible and allows an open mind
- practical advantages, access to more suspicious groups as can gain trust - helpful when studying gangs
- Avoid Hawthorne effect
Non participant observation - adv.
- allows researcher to see what happens with an open eye
- more open minded
- more ethical if done overtly
non participant observation - disadv.
- Hawthorne effect
- impression management
- harder to get accurate results
- time consuming
Rosenthal and Jacobson (1968)
- elementary school in California supports self fulfilling prophecy
- selected random students - 209 labelled as exceptional
- tested all students at the beginning of experiment for IQ and again after a year, found out that the randomly selected “spurter” group gained more IQ than the other 809, who were labelled as ‘average’
- Rosenthal and Jacobson speculated that teachers had passed on their higher expectations to students which had produced a self fulfilling prophecy.
quota sampling
- to interview people who fit the certain categories
- Used in market research, e.g field researches are told to stop and survey 100 women
Multistage sampling
- researcher selects a sample by using combos of different sampling methods
- i.e, stage 1, a researcher might use systematic sampling, stage 2, they might use random sampling to select a subject for final sample
Snowball sampling
- researches find a few participants, ask them to find participants themselves- useful when sample harder to obtain
- i.e, Taylor used method when investigating criminals, didn’t know many criminals but had criminals ask other criminals.
theory and methods
- modernity refers to a particular era in human history, it is an era characterised by scientific thought individualism, a focus on industrialisation and technical development and a rejection of some traditional values.
consensus and conflict theories
- consensus theory assumes society is primarily harmonious and social order is maintained by agreement (consensus) between people on goals and values
- Conflict theory - sees society as a conflict, hidden and unstable which emphasis social differences and conflict.
determinism and choice
- Determinism is the extent to which individuals have control or are they victims of social forces
- structuralism - determined
- social action or interpretivist - free will
- integrated approach - combine structure and social action approaches.
Structuralism
- macro theory surface level view, structured society, human behaviour understood in context of the social system.
- people ae not just independent actors, they are products of the social conditions in which they live
- Personality and values structured by social forces
Functionalism - strengths
- proves a good explanation of the working of society
- recognises the importance of social structure in understanding society
- provides an explanation for social order and why most people comform
functionalism - weaknesses
- action theorists see it as too deterministic
- Meta narrative, tries to explain everything from their perspective
- struggle to explain social change
- over-emphasises the benefits of institutions
- takes for granted there is value consensus in society
- tends to be conservative supporting the status quo.