Sleep and Emotion Flashcards
(46 cards)
What is The case of Randy (Ross, 1965)
- 1964: Prolonged wakefulness of a 17-year-old boy named Randy Gardner, in an attempt to break the world record for prolonged wakefulness
- Remained awake for 11 days and was subjected to a series of tests every 6 hours
- By the 3rd day he developed mood changes and from the 4th day, he became irritable and uncooperative
- By the 9th day, he regularly did not finish his sentences, showed fragmented thoughts and suffered from blurred vision
Sleep and Emotion:
1- what is found in terms of consistency for studies involving sleep deprivation
2- what does emotion involve?
3- what varies across studies?
4- what does bad sleep affect?
5- examples
6- disrupted sleep is both a symptom and a risk factor for ____
1- A great deal of inconsistency in findings from studies involving sleep deprivation
2- Emotion involves several components
3- Also the methodological approaches vary across studies
4- Common knowledge that bad sleep affects our mood the next day – crankiness in children is very obvious, mood swings etc
5- Grumpiness, short-tempered etc
6- Disrupted sleep is both a symptom and a risk factor for various mental health conditions
Effects of Sleep Deprivation on Performance: A meta-analysis by Pilcher and Huffcutt 1996
- A substantial difference across three dependent measures: cognitive performance, motor performance and mood
- The mean level of functioning in SD-participants was comparable to that of only the 9th percentile of those non-SD
- Cognitive performance was more affected by SD than motor performance but Mood was much more affected than either cognitive or motor performance
- Mood was much worse (over 3SD) in those SD, than those non-SD
Pilcher and Huffcutt 1996
Distribution of people who are sleep deprived and nonsleep deprived. Both groups are behaving in a different way.
The average person in the deprived group is functioning at the tail end of the people who are non deprived
Sum- mood is affected by lack of sleep
Sleep and Aggression
What have correlational studies found about non-aggressive vs aggressive populations
In non-aggressive populations:
Several studies found a correlation between self-reported sleep difficulties and feelings of anger, hostile tendencies and aggressive behaviour
In aggressive populations:
a) incarcerated offenders: shorter sleep has been associated with greater hostility
b) forensic psychiatric patients: association between poor sleep quality and increased aggression
SD and Aggression in Animal Studies:
Licklider and Bunch (1946) study and findings
Investigated the physiological effects of long-term selective rapid-eye movement (REM) sleep deprivation and found quite striking effects on aggression
Rats died after 3-14 days due to fighting with each other; even the slightest physical contact led to a vicious fight, not only targeting the offender but also innocent bystanders
A bidirectional relationship between anger and sleep?
- Perhaps angry or hostile traits may predispose individuals to sleep problems
- Studies in individuals with traits of antisocial personality disorder, characterized by irritability, hostility, aggressive behaviour, impulsivity, lack of remorse and deceptive acts, find that 58-80% suffer from poor sleep quality (Kamphuis et al 2013; Semiz et al 2008)
A systematic Review and Meta-analysis of studies on Sleep Quality and Aggression (Van Veen et al 2021)
- Included subjective and objective measures of sleep quality and multiple measures of aggression: externalizing behaviour, anger, hostility and irritability
- Overall data from 74 studies were used, a total of 58,154 children, adolescents and adults
- First systematic evaluation of studies in this area
- Poor sleep was associated with higher aggression in 80.8% of studies
Overall Correlation Estimate of Sleep Quality and Aggression
Van Veen et al 2021
- A consistent association between poor sleep quality and measures of aggression in general and in clinical populations
- Both qualitative and quantitative data supported this association
- Greater vulnerability in those with psychological or medical conditions
- increased likelihood of those who are sleep deprived to show increased irritability, hostility, externalising behaviour, anger, aggression control, aggression composite, aggressive behaviour
Studies in Sleep and Mood in Adolescents
- What did the National Sleep Foundation poll (US) report?
- wakefulness and sleep disturbances in adolescence?
- what is sleep disturbance a precursor for?
- what do sleep issues seem to affect?
- National Sleep Foundation poll (US) reported that more than 87% of US high school students get less than the recommended hours of sleep (Krueger & Friedman, 2009)
- Adolescents spent more wakefulness in bed (take longer to fall asleep) and more wakefulness during the night, and reported more sleep disturbances
- Data suggest that sleep disturbance is a precursor for the development of depression
- sleep issues seem (eg sleep quality) to predispose people and set the grounds for mental health conditions eg depression
Sleep Duration and Mood in Adolescents Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (Short et al 2020)
study and findings
- 74 studies, including 361,505 adolescents were used
- Results indicated that less sleep was associated with a 55% increase in the likelihood of mood deficits
- Positive mood showed the largest relationship with sleep duration followed by anger, depression, negative affect and anxiety
- This effect was true across all geographical regions although the effect size was different (greater for North America compared to Europe, Australia, New Zealand and Asia
What did findings from Short et al 2020 find the strongest impact on?
Positive affect
Short et al 2020 results and implications
Short sleep duration:
- doubled the odds of adolescents experiencing reduced positive affect
- Increased the odds of anger by 83%
- Increased the odds of depressed mood by 62%
- Increased the odds for negative affect by 60%
- Increased the odds for anxiety by 41%
- Consistent with Shen et al (2018) who examined association between sleep duration and mood in 4,582 adolescents and found that sleep loss and mood association was stronger for happiness and positive affect than for negative affect
- Anhedonia is a core symptom of Major Depressive Disorder (the other being depressed mood)
Things that were pleasurable before are not pleasurable anymore
Sleep Loss in Medical Residents: Zohar et al 2005
Method
- Investigated the relationship between sleep loss and emotional reactivity in medical residents. Hypothesized that this will be influenced by sleep loss effects on cognitive-energy resources in light of goal-disruptive ( interfering with something they wanted to do at the time/ interfere with ability to do work) and goal-enhancing events
- 78 medical residents, 26-39 years old, with shifts that varied (up to 32h each time)
- Measured sleep-wake cycles with actigraphy for 5-7days, every 6 months for the first 2y of residency
- Received 3 phone calls that reminded them to complete a questionnaire
- Sleep loss intensified negative emotions and fatigue following daytime goal-disruptive events whereas positive emotion was blunted following goal-enhancing events
Sleep Loss in Medical Residents: Zohar et al 2005
Results
Affect:
a) NA: when something disruptive was happening, those that are sleep deprived are experiencing greater NA compared to the well slept people
b) PA: with enhancing events, people are helping out and getting good equipment, those who had good sleep were benefiting/ demonstrating greater positive affect when having help but low sleep didn’t show much improvement.
PA based on this study is taken away if they don’t sleep properly because they don’t have enhancement - PA was blunted because of their lack of sleep
Fatigue:
a) started off the same but looking at the levels of fatigue after a disruptive event, those who didn’t sleep well showed a much greater fatigue response (fatigue levels higher)
b) even with enhancing events, those who have low sleep continue to exhibit greater levels of fatigue
Major Depression
1- sleep disturbances in ____ were noted since ancient times
2- what did Emil Kraeplin (1909) note?
3- what is depression characterised by?
1- Sleep disturbances in melancholia were noted since ancient times, by Plato and Hippocrates
2- Emil Kraeplin (1909) noted that various disorders are associated with sleep disturbances
3- Depression is characterized by changes in sleep and arousal most likely a predisposing factor
Sleep in Psychiatric Conditions Baglioni et al 2016
Background
- Meta-analysis with studies from 1992-2015 (English, Italian, Spanish, French, German).
- In most mental health conditions, the balance between arousal and de-arousal is disturbed
- Insomnia, the most prevalent sleep continuity disorder is highly comorbid with mental and somatic conditions and needs to be better understood
- Comorbidity is the rule and not the exception in mental health conditions and this complicates the process
Sleep in Psychiatric Conditions Baglioni et al 2016
Method
Grouped 11 sleep variables in three main domains:
1) Sleep continuity (when we go to sleep are we able to maintain sleep): defined by higher sleep efficiency (time in bed vs time asleep), shorter sleep onset latency (time to get to sleep), and reduced number of awakenings
2) Sleep depth: defined by shorter duration of NREM 1 sleep, and longer duration of NREM 2 and SWS
3) REM pressure: defined by shorter REM latency, increased REM density (how much eyes blink in REM), and longer duration of REM sleep.
Sleep in Psychiatric Conditions Baglioni et al 2016
Findings
- Depression was associated with the most severe changes in sleep continuity, sleep depth and increased REM pressure
– Longer REM duration
– Shortened REM latency
– Prolonged 1st REM episode - Other studies find increased REM density in depression (indicating a high number of rapid eye movements)
- Benca et al 1992 – Meta-analysis which included first night PSG, found differences in those with depression:
– Shortened REM latency (observed more frequently than in any other disorder)
– Increased REM density (found exclusively in affective disorders)
– Reduced time in SWS
- sleep continuity was affected the most- high significance for MDD
- decrease in sleep depth for major depression and an increase in REM pressure
- for anxiety disorders there was a significant impact of sleep continuity (arousals ect.) but this was mostly due to ptsd. So sleep continuity is affected for anxiety disorders more than sleep depth and REM pressure.
- Schizophrenia was also highly significant- sever impact on sleep continuity and a little bit on sleep depth.
Subgroup Analyses in Baglioni et al 2016: Gender and Age in Depression
- Men: sleep continuity, depth and REM pressure were altered compared to controls, they spent less time asleep and more time awake
- Women: only sleep continuity was disrupted (important because usually women complain more about their sleep compared to men)
- In younger age groups only marginally worse continuity in sleep
– studies seem to suggest that depressive symptoms may be less severe in younger groups, so it may be the best time to intervene and prevent deterioration
Conceptual Model
For the relationship between depression and poor sleep, suggested by Lovato & Gradisar, 2014
Puberty:
- decreased SWS
- decreased total sleep time
- circadian delay
- evening arousal
|
Poor sleep:
- increased SOL (arousal)
- increased WASO (arousal)
- decreased self-reported sleep quality
|
Ruminating
|
Depression >(=) 5 symptoms
- increased irritable mood
- decreased motivation
- increased fatigue/ decreased energy
- decreased concentration
- insomnia
Anxiety:
1- what is anxiety characterised by?
2- What is worry often accompanied by?
3- rumination?
4- what are people with insomnia more likely to do?
5- what are high levels of worry associated with?
1- Anxiety is characterised by worry about perceived threats
2- Worry is often accompanied by maladaptive thoughts, that are often repetitive and intrusive
3- Rumination (repetitive thoughts that are not productive) intensifies negative affect and is associated with longer sleep onset latency
4- People with insomnia are 10 times more likely to attribute their insomnia to cognitive factors such as worrying, planning, difficulty of controlling thoughts etc
5- High levels of worry are associated with elevated sympathetic system activation during wakefulness and sleep
Worry and Sleep
1- what do college students with high levels of worry report?
2- what are adults with work-related worry more likely to have?
3- what is worrying about sleepiness related to?
1- College students with high levels of worry report shorter sleep durations
2- Adults with work-related worry are more likely to have poor sleep quality
3- Worrying about sleeplessness is related to self-reported sleep disturbances including shorter sleep, longer sleep onset latency and more time awake after sleep onset
Findings for Anxiety Disorders: Baglioni et al 2016
- Majority of the studies included on anxiety focused on PTSD (13/21 studies)
- Anxiety disorders were found to have reduced SWS duration (not reported in the previous meta-analysis by Benca et al 1992)
- PTSD was found to be linked with all measures of sleep continuity, sleep depth and sleep pressure