STUDY UNIT 4 Flashcards
(13 cards)
MANY FEMINISTS:
Many feminists argue that pornography should be censored because it harms women.
TWO SCHOOL THOUGHT:
- Liberals
- Pro-censorship
- LIBERAL SHOULD NOT:
Liberals should not adopt a stance of principled opposition to censoring pornography.
This liberal stance is made up of 3 main ingredients:
- liberals argue that the state is entitled to intervene coercively in the individuals’ lives on the basis of a narrow harm principle which permits governments so to act only in order to protect the physical integrity of individuals.
- Liberals argue that the consumption of pornography is a matter of private, as opposed to public, morality.
- Liberals are committed to a right of complete freedom of expression, which makes them hostile in any censorship.
LIBERAL SUPPOSE THAT:
Liberals suppose that pornography generally satisfies harmless male preferences.
LIBERALS ARE COMMITTED:
Liberals are committed to protecting the private because they want to respect the right of individual autonomy.
- FOR PRO-CENSORSHIP FEMINISTS:
for pro-censorship feminist, the liberal refusal to censor pornography shows the proverty of liberalism.
It exposes:
it exposes the inability of liberalism to deal with one of the chief defects of contemporary society, the subordination of women to men.
FOR THEM PORNOGRAPHY:
for them pornography is portrayal of women as the perpetual objects for male sexual desires.
Pornography is no pornography:
pornography is not pornography because of its sexual character but because of the context of inequality which it eroticizes.
PORNOGRAPHY MAKES:
pornography makes inequality to seem sexy.
THE SUBJECTION OF WOMEN:
Mill’s stated aim is to argue against the legal subordination of women and for what he calls “perfect equality”
FOR MILL:
For Mill, the subjection of women comes about because of status quo of inequality.