Test 1 Flashcards
(41 cards)
According to Davrim does Hashem want us to have a king?
Depends on how you transalte ואמרת
What is strange about the wording of this מצוה
Why do we ask to do a mitzvah, this is the only mitzvah that we have to ask, Hashem willl say yes, and then we can do. The language is strange. We dont ask to do shabbas and then hashems says yes and we do it
What are the two ways to translate ואמרת
You should say
You will say
What are examples where Valachtah means both definitions of ואמרת
ביכורם- you MUST take
אשת יפת תואר-you CAN take
For kings does ואמרת mean can ask or must ask?????
What are the prohibition on a king
Money
Horses
Wives
How many years pasted since they entered Israel and did not ask for a king
about 400 years
According to Shmuel does G-d want us to have a king
NOO
According to the Abarbenel want us the have a king
no- “you can take” but he doesnt want us to.
According to the Abarbanel which sourses is the main sourse teaches us about wherther or not to have a king?
Shmuel
According to the Abarbeanel why do Hashem and shemual beome upset Beni Yisrael when they request a king?
The Jews were doing great without a king from Yehusha-1rst 10 years of Shmuel life. But now they ask for a king and G-d is angry bc we gave into our Yetzar Hara
According to the Rambam which source is the main source which teaches us about whether or not to have a king?
Chumash
According to this approach why do Hashem and שמואל become upset at the Jews when they ask for a king
Hashem wants us to have a king, he got mad in שמואל א because the Jews only asked for a king because they didn’t want שמואל not to fulfill the Mitzvah
What does the Rambam say?
There are three Mitzvot that the Jews MUST do when they enter Israel
- King
- destroy Amelek
- build Beit HaMikdash
Which תנא does the Rambam hold like?
רבי יהודה
What does the Abarbanel say?
Hashem deos not want us to have a king but he allows it
What תנא does the Abarbanel hold like
רבי נהוראי
2 reasons why we need a king is we already have a Navi, Kohen Gadol etc….
- role model
2. establish order
What is the danger of having a king?
- bad role model
2. establish neg order
We daven for the return of מלכות בית דוד and the coming of מלך משיח everyday, does this support the Rambam or Abarbanel
Rambam
How does Abrabanel explain the everyday davening for מלך משיח
He says that מלך משיח is just like training wheels on a bike. He will help us with peace, Beit HaMikdah etc. and then once we are on our feet we will no longer need him.
Is it possible that the Abarnael and Rambam had different perspectives on having a king bc of where and when they lived?
Abarbanel- 1400-1500s–> worked for 4 different corrupt kings as a treasurer
–> no way Has he would COMMAND such corruption
Rambam- was a dr. for Arabain kings__> good kings
Was Shlomo’s international marriages allowed (Radak)
He converted her- but violated the laws about conversion of a Mitri (you have to wait until the 3rd generation convert from Mitrzriam to marry them)
Shalom thought that it did not apply for women (bc of רות) but he was wrong
Are במות allowed?
As long as the Mishkanis not in a permanent spot they are allowed
If במות are permitted why does the Pasuk say “רק”? Radak
Bc they are comparing Shlomo to David and even if במות are permitted it leads to Avodah Zara and David wouldn’t do anything that would lead to Avodah Zara.
