WEEK 8 - BUILDING ARGUMENTS Flashcards
(33 cards)
This course teaches two skills, what are they:
- Writing
- Soft or life skills
What is needed to write persuasively?
- Identify the possible objections and address them
- Make it clear what you are asking for and what decision you want them to make
- Do not lie
- Remember to consider any cultural issues and appeal to common goals and values
In identifying the possible objections and addressing them, what should you do?
Cite experts who support you and offer convincing evidence and statistics.
What do you need to do to get your point across?
- Speak well
- Have a well thought out argument
What is the difference between a quarrel and argumentation?
Quarrel = anger
Argument = debate/discussion
An argument must include what four things?
- Summary / Assertion
- Context / Reason
- Details / Evidence
- Conclusion / Impact
When are the three times you will use this skill?
- When you explain why you made a particular choice/decision.
- When you are presenting your point of view
- Writing persuasively (reports, emails and presentations)
Structure for an argument
Introduction, body and conclusion
What does the introduction include?
A universal statement to grab attention, general statement to elaborate, linking statement – intro thesis and finally, the thesis/hypothesis.
What does the body include?
Topic Introduction, paragraph thesis point, arguments (proof), linking (to next argument or to the conclusion)
What does the conclusion include?
Re-state thesis, exiting general statement, exiting universal statement
What does the essential point need?
The essential point requires one to (1) begin with a Clear statement of what you want your audience to do
and (2) end with a clear statement of the action or change you expect.
Classical argumentation has four main components, what are they?
A.R.E.
Assertion - the claim
Reason - prove the assertion and strong reasoning
Evidence - data to support the reason
Impact - the importance
Classical rhetoric is composed of three things, what are they?
Logos, Ethos and Pathos.
What is Logos?
Appeals to logic
- Using statistics, data and/or scientific method
What is Ethos?
Appeals to authority
- Use an author / expert to help prove the claim
What is Pathos?
Appeals to emotion
- Uses emotion to prove the claim / convince people
What is the Toulmin method?
Takes Classical argument to a new level of detail with 6 components within.
the Argument Grounds
1. Assertion
2. Reason
3. Evidence
4. Backing – additional info (like common knowledge)
5. Qualifier – where the assertion could be false (boundary)
6. Rebuttal – address the opposing view
What is the Rogerian method?
- Makes classical argument more open ended
- Usually has 3 elements
1. Opposing position & it’s grounds (positioned as the readers position)
2. Your position & argument grounds
3. Compromising grounds between the arguments
What should the introduction content include?
Clear statement of your premise and a high level list of the arguments
What should the conclusion include?
Re-iterate your premise and a summarized list of the arguments
What should the argument include? (AREI)
A clear statement of your argument
What should the reason include? (AREI)
How / why your argument is true
What should the evidence include? (AREI)
Clear evidence supporting your reason