Witness Flashcards
(237 cards)
A witness who testifies to what he has seen, heard, or otherwise observed is referred to as a/an:
- Observer
- Expert witness
- Fact witness
- Objective witness
Fact witness
You receive a subpoena asking that you produce all appraisal reports you have prepared in the past five years for property similar to the subject property in a current litigation. You know that to honor this subpoena, you will be revealing confidential information from past assignments. What is the most likely action you would take to avoid revealing this confidential information?
- Invoke the RECORDKEEPING RULE in USPAP
- Ask the opposing attorney file a motion to quash
- Have your personal attorney file a motion to quash
- Produce the appraisals, as a subpoena is the same as a court order
Have your personal attorney file a motion to quash
“The appraiser has the benefit of knowing the issues and can focus the appraisal to address them and adequately support all the necessary analyses and conclusions to ‘bulletproof’ the appraisal.” This statement describes one of the advantages of the _________ type of appraisal assignment.
- Practitioner - Unintentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
Practitioner - Intentional
You receive a call from an attorney who is contemplating a new lawsuit regarding a landlord/tenant dispute where the lease contains an ambiguous purchase option for the subject property. You will need to determine the value to be used in the exercise of the purchase option. The tenant already has an appraisal with an abnormally low value. Which of the three types of appraisal assignments would this be?
- Practitioner - Unintentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
Practitioner - Intentional
You receive a call from an attorney involved in litigation where appraisals have already been produced by each side. The attorney wants you to review both appraisals and advise him regarding their relative merits so he can develop a trial strategy. You will be preparing a USPAP STANDARDS 3 and 4 review of each appraisal as the major part of your assignment. Which of the three types of appraisal assignments would this be?
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Practitioner - Unintentional
Non-Practitioner - Intentional
A witness whose testimony is based on scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge is called a/an:
- Opinion witness
- Expert witness
- Appraisal witness
- Fact witness
Expert witness
An appraiser is subpoenaed to testify about an appraisal he prepared in the past which now is part of pending litigation. He was not retained by the lawyers specifically to prepare the appraisal for this case because the litigation issue developed after his appraisal was completed. Which of the following best described this situation?
- The appraiser will be testifying as a fact witness and be able to collect a nominal witness fee for his time on the witness stand.
- The appraiser will be testifying as an expert witness and will be able to collect a handsome hourly fee for the time spent on the witness stand.
- The appraiser is not an expert for this case but can charge his normal expert witness hour fees for his time on the witness stand.
- The appraiser will be testifying as a fact witness and will not be able to charge for his time on the witness stand.
The appraiser will be testifying as a fact witness and be able to collect a nominal witness fee for his time on the witness stand.
The appraiser who testifies at this level usually will have significant experience in court testimony and can be perceived as a ‘hired gun.’ “ This statement describes one of the disadvantages of the _________ type of appraisal assignment.
- Practitioner - Unintentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
Non-Practitioner - Intentional
You are asked to assist an attorney in litigation related to an IRS challenge of a charitable contribution of real property on his client’s tax return. Which of the following would be a concern to you about taking on a litigation assignment related to the IRS?
- The appraisal may require a retrospective value, which requires more research than a current effective date.
- A negative IRS appraisal review could have significant negative ramifications on your future appraisal career.
- Both choices are incorrect
- The first two choices are correct.
The first two choices are correct.
According to the definition of a “Lay Witness” in Federal Rule 701, which of the following is NOT a criterion for an acceptable opinion expressed by the witness?
- Opinion not based on scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge within the scope of Rule 702
- Opinion helpful to a clear understanding of the witness’ testimony or the determination of a fact in issue
- Opinion developed through the use of a scientific instrument
- Rational opinion based on the witness’ perception
Opinion developed through the use of a scientific instrument
Two years ago, you prepared an appraisal of property owned by a husband and wife. The couple has decided to get a divorce, and the attorney representing the husband wants you to testify about your previous appraisal. Which of the three types of appraisal assignments would this be?
- Practitioner - Unintentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
Practitioner - Unintentional
You receive a call from an attorney who is contemplating a new lawsuit regarding a landlord/tenant dispute where the lease contains an ambiguous purchase option for the subject property. You will need to determine the value to be used in the exercise of the purchase option. The tenant already has an appraisal with an abnormally low value. Which of the three types of appraisal assignments would this be?
- Practitioner - Unintentional
- Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Intentional
- Non-Practitioner - Unintentional
Non-Practitioner - Intentional
If, while on the witness stand, an appraiser is asked to provide her opinion of the appraisal performed for the other side, and she makes a few statements about the merits of the other appraisal, what has just happened?
- She has delivered an oral appraisal review report.
- If she does not have a workfile on the other appraisal, she has violated USPAP.
- She has given opposing counsel an opportunity to impeach her professionalism and character, diminishing the credibility of her appraisal.
- All of the above.
All of the above.
You are reviewing an appraisal in litigation. The report date is two years ago, with an effective date a few weeks earlier. In your review activity, you discover three very comparable sales near the subject not mentioned in the report. One closed two months before the report date; one closed one month after the report date; and the other closed nine months after the report date. Which of these sales could you use to claim a deficiency in the appraisal under review?
- All three can and should be used.
- Only the first, as it was public knowledge as of the report date.
- The first and second, because they both reflect the current market.
- None of the above; the appraisal had sufficient support without these sales.
Only the first, as it was public knowledge as of the report date.
An attorney requests your assistance in developing a trial strategy for a case involving five different commercial properties in four different states. There has been contamination on all of the properties by a tenant, and the landlord is suing for damages. You will not prepare an appraisal, but will rely on appraisals prepared by seven other appraisers. You will assist the attorney in understanding the appraisals for both sides and help design a trial strategy. You will then assist in preparing questions for both direct and cross examinations. This scenario requires you to be a:
- Testifying Fact Witness
- Testifying Expert Appraiser
- Consulting Expert Appraiser
- None of the above
Consulting Expert Appraiser
You are on the witness stand testifying about an appraisal you performed for this litigation. On cross examination, opposing counsel asks, “Do you think that the comparables you selected are superior to the comparables selected by my appraiser?” You answer, “Yes.”
- This is an appropriate answer, as you can defend your appraisal report so you are not advocating for retaining counsel’s client.
- This in an insufficient answer, as you will need to explain why your comparables are superior.
- You have just performed an oral appraisal review report on the other appraisal and must have previously prepared a separate workfile for that “assignment,” must state the additional information required under STANDARD 3, and must place a signed certification in your workfile.
- You are not permitted to criticize another appraiser while on the witness stand.
You have just performed an oral appraisal review report on the other appraisal and must have previously prepared a separate workfile for that “assignment,” must state the additional information required under STANDARD 3, and must place a signed certification in your workfile.
Which of the following benefits can performing a USPAP STANDARDS 3 and 4 appraisal review on an appraisal used in litigation provide to the attorney who retains you?
- Help the attorney understand the weaknesses of the opposing counsel’s appraisal
- Help the attorney see where his own appraiser’s report needs further support
- Provide “peer review” of the attorney’s appraisal to help withstand a challenge
- All of the above
All of the above
You have been asked to review an appraisal being used in litigation. The date of the appraisal is two years ago. You will be testifying in court about the reliability of the appraisal. In your review, you will reference compliance with USPAP. Which edition of USPAP will you need to use to determine compliance?
- The current edition of USPAP.
- The edition of USPAP in effect as of the date of the appraisal report.
- The edition of USPAP in effect as of the date of value.
- The current edition for the review requirements and the edition in effect on the date of the appraisal report for the appraisal requirements.
The current edition for the review requirements and the edition in effect on the date of the appraisal report for the appraisal requirements.
You are serving as a consulting appraiser, helping an attorney with a case which involves defective construction on an apartment building. The attorney asks you to prepare an appraisal review of the opposition’s appraisal report so she can find flaws to pursue. Can you fulfill this request?
- No. As an advocate you cannot also perform an appraisal service such as an appraisal review.
- Yes. An appraisal review does not fall under the appraisal services which would conflict with an advocacy assignment.
- Yes. There is no conflict with an advocate preparing an appraisal review report, oral or written, in the same assignment.
- That question is still unresolved, and you should consult your personal attorney.
That question is still unresolved, and you should consult your personal attorney.
You are retained by an attorney to prepare an appraisal and explain your appraisal report and conclusions to the court on the witness stand. Which of the three types of witness discussed in the course materials does this require?
- Testifying Fact Witness
- Testifying Expert Appraiser
- Consulting Expert Appraiser
- None of the above
Testifying Expert Appraiser
Which of the following statements reflects the basic rules for testifying and consulting experts?
- If the expert is testifying, all communications are discoverable which are not otherwise privileged, such as “work product of the attorney.”
- If the expert is only consulting, the work done for the attorney is part of the attorney’s work product and is not discoverable.
- If a testifying expert uses a part of the consulting expert’s work, then the work of the consulting expert is discoverable.
- All of the above
All of the above
Which of the following questions of the appraiser expert witness during testimony may be most valuable for the case?
- Questions from the other appraiser
- Questions from the judge
- Cross examination
- Direct examination
Questions from the judge
Which of the following terms best describes the written questions prepared for opposing sides in litigation that must be answered in writing and under oath?
- Deposition
- Discovery
- Interrogatories
- Disposition
Interrogatories
Opposing counsel made a request to the judge before trial to exclude certain evidence, which may prohibit an appraisal from being admitted into evidence. This request is called a:
- Petition of Exclusion
- Request for Variance
- Motion to Exclude
- Motion in Limine
Motion in Limine