Chapter 11 Flashcards
(16 cards)
Constitutional Tension
Balancing the First Amendment and the Sixth Amendment. Prejudicial publicity can undermine the fairness of criminal trials
Prejudicial Publicity
News that might bias jurors agaisnt a defendant
Voir Dire
Questioning Jurors to uncover bias
Change of Venue
Moving trial location to find impartial jurors
Change of Veniremen
Importing jurors from another area
Continuance
Delaying trial to let media influence subside
Admonition
Instructing jurors to ignore outside info
Sequestration
Isolating jurors from media during trial
Restrictive Orders (Gag orders)
Court order limiting speech by trial participants or media
- Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart (1976)
Gag orders on the press are unconstitutional unless
- Publicity is intense and pervasive
- No alternative remedies exist
- The order will effectively prevent prejudice
- Smith v. Daily Mail (1979)
Lawfully obtained truthful info can be published
Gag orders on ________ are more likely to be upheld
Trial participants
- Skilling Test
Used to determine if pretrial publicity biases the jury pool.
1. Media tone and reach
2. Time between crime and trial
3. Community size and impact
4. Publicity surrounding confessions or smoking gun evidence
United States v. Burr (1807)
Jurors can have prior knowledge but must remain impartial
Skilling v. United States (2010)
Created the multi-factor test to assess juror bias
Prior Restraint
Government action that prohibits speech before it occurs