Chapter 12 Flashcards
(54 cards)
Origins of Scientific or Western Medicine
- While medicine is the dominant health profession in contemporary society, scientific or Western modern medicine only dates back to the late 19th century
- However, efforts to care for the sick & explain disease have been common for thousands of years
Hippocrates
*Considered the Father of Medicine because he connected disease to natural causes, rather than spirits or magic
Humoral theory of disease
Illness due to humor imbalance
17th Century
Disease was still viewed in spiritual terms during early Christian times & until early 17th century
- during this time, medical practice was based in monasteries & controlled by religious organizations, but secular healers also existed
Renaissance Period
Brought scientific approach to medical knowledge & practice
- Experimentation, observation & dissection of the human body, emergence of medical schools
- Mostly benefitted wealthy; rural residents relied on traditional methods
Scientific Revolution
Of 17th century changed thinking about much of world
Age of Enlightenment
Scientific method became prevalent approach to study of many aspects of life
-medical discoveries included: the circulation of blood by the heart, early vaccination for small pox & anatomical model of disease
19th Century
Discovery of stethoscope, improvements in X-ray & microscope, discovery of the cell & the germ theory of disease
- concern for social medicine, as links were made between poor living & working conditions & infectious diseases
- Hospital became site of treatment for disease
- surgery became safer & less painful because of anesthesia & antiseptics
Germ theory of disease
Bacteria as the cause of diseases among the most important discoveries
20th Century
Scientific medicine & the biomedical approach to illness had established legitimacy
- Many important developments in last century
Allopathic medicine
Conventional medicine that relies on the scientific approach by treating disease & illness, based on the biomedical model
Allopathic medicine (Underlying Principles)
- The determinants of illness are primary biological
- Based on engineering model of the body
- Health care is focused on curing illness or disability
- Medicine is scientific
- The Doctor is the authority & expert
Consequences of the determinants of health being viewed as biological
Focus on diagnostic tests & prescriptions, therefore Drs. do not need to ask about social factors
*If no observable evidence, complaint may be dismissed by Dr.
Based on Engineering model of the body
- Medical specialization
- Body as machine= focus on certain body parts
- Fee-for-service payment
Health care is focused on curing illness or disability
- Acute care
* Focus is impersonal, rather than patient specific
Acute Care
Aimed at treatment rather than prevention/addressing social determinants
Medicine is Scientific
- Presumption that all treatments are based in scientific research (randomized control trials) projects air of superiority
- Assumes neutrality of medicine
- Proposes universal presentation of disease & response to treatment
The Doctor is the authority & expert
- Have jurisdiction to define & label some as ill= ability to determine what is illness & what is not
- Drs as always right; patients’ views typically dismissed
- Neglects social & political processes related to medicalization, pursuit of profit etc.
Medical Dominance
The power that medical profession has to control their own work & work of others as well as influence health policy & organization of health care
- Medicine was & mostly continues to be, the most powerful profession in the health care system
- Reinforced by scientific advances- as more discoveries were made, more authority was accumulated
- Drs. restricted activities of other health care occupations
- Connections to elite members of society & the state allowed this dominance to occur
% of Medical Professionals (2011)
10.3%- Doctors
42.7%- Nurses
47%- Others
Freidson (1970)
Professional dominance & medical power enforced by Drs.’ clinical role in diagnosis & treatment, in which they possess control over knowledge & supervision of other health professions
*Drs. control diagnosis & treatment which determines work of other health professionals, such as pharmacists, as many therapies require referral from a doctor
Wolpe (1985)
Medical dominance lies in social capital
- Institutionalized in Drs. control over licensing, education & self-regulation, which is not subject to formal direction or evaluation by others
Marxist analysis (Conflict Theory)
- In US, medical dominance serves interests of dominant (Capitalist) class
- Drs can establish & maintain power because of other forms of power that enable control over production of knowledge, practice & institutions of medicine
Confederation (1867)
- Few Dr.s at time of confederation & no med schools or associations (but soon after)
- most people did not consult Drs. when sick, but natural or spiritual healers
- Drs. often served wealthy only, & did have same level of respect because of post-operative infection