Drugs, Addiction and Crime Flashcards
(77 cards)
What are the key readings?
Moyle et al (2019)
Goldstein (1985)
What are the key points from Goldstein?
There are three models of the drugs-violence relationship: psychopharmacological, economic-compulsive + systematic
The models are not mutually exclusive such as cocaine users
What is psychopharmacological violence?
Some individuals, as a result of short or long term ingestion of specific substances, may become excitable, irrational, and may exhibit violent behaviour.
Who looked at heroin as an example for psychopharmacological violence?
Lindesmith 1941
What did Lindesmith find?
Rather than increasing aggression its pharmacological properties, as with marijuana, it in fact ‘suppresses hostility and aggression
Who looked at the supporting evidence for psychopharmacological?
Parker & Auerhahn
What did Parker & Auerhahn find?
Alcohol has been widely studied for its role in lowering inhibitions and increasing aggression, as seen in Parker and Auerhahn’s (1998) review of alcohol-related violence
What is a critique of Parker & Auerhahn?
Not all drug users exhibit violent behaviour, suggesting that the individual’s predisposition and social context play a mediating role
What is economic-compulsive violence?
Driven by the need to fund drug habits, but nuanced factors such as poverty and social disadvantage also play a role
Who looked at the supporting evidence for economic-compulsive?
Johnson et al 2000
What did Johnson et al find?
Studies on heroin and crack cocaine users in urban environments confirm a correlation between economic need and property crimes involving violence
Who critiqued Johnson et al?
Maher & Daly (1996)
What did Maher & Daly find?
Research suggests that not all drug users resort to violence for economic reasons; alternative coping strategies (e.g., informal borrowing, sex work) are also common
Who objected to economic-compulsive violence?
Bennett & Holloway 2007
Moyle & Coomber 2015
What did Bennett and Holloway say?
Ignores the influence of poverty and social disadvantage
What did Moyle & Coomber say?
Make nuanced decisions about ways to fund ‘habit’ - ‘most heroin users avoid violent acquisitive crime if viable non-violent alternatives exist’
What is systemic violence?
Violence within drug markets, influenced by the market’s structure and participants
Who looked at the supporting evidence for systematic?
Jacobs 2000
What did Jacobs find?
Research on urban drug markets confirms a high prevalence of violence in contexts where law enforcement is absent or ineffective
Who critiqued Jacobs?
Coomber 2006
What did Coomber 2006 find?
Systemic violence may not be universal; some drug markets operate with minimal violence due to strong internal governance structures
What are the policy implications from Goldstein?
Harm reduction
Treatment over punishment
Community interventions
Who spoke about harm reduction?
Reuter 2009
What did Reuter 2009 say?
Advocated for policies that target the systemic drivers of violence, such as decriminalisation or regulation of drug markets