final 2.0 Flashcards
(62 cards)
Beneficence
is a moral right duty
-benefit
-your morally obligation is to do what benefits the patient
-not the same thing as benevolence
Active vs. Passive approaches to beneficence
Active: going above and beyond, thinking of the patient in terms of their needs, wants, benefits
Passive: sits and observes, waiting for the patient to come to you
Broad vs. Narrow approaches to healthcare
Broad: benefit the patient by doing other things besides their care plan, improve their care plan with patient input
E.g. Can the patient afford the medications? And do they know the about resources to help pay
Narrow: what’s in their care plan and nothing else
E.g. these are the medications that the patient must get
Disease vs. Illness
Disease: more science, tests, assessments, scans etc.
Illness: the lived experience of the certain condition; pain and how pain is managed
HARM (non-maleficence)
It is impossible to deliver health care with 100% no harm?
-Doctrine of double effect: says that it is okay to do some harm as long as the harm is outweighed by benefit
- Comes from utilitarianism
- Remember that the harm doesn’t just happen to the patient Including sometimes the RPN
Difficulties Balancing harm and benefit in mental health care
- Psychiatric diagnosis
benefit: you get properly diagnosed and treated
Harm: misdiagnosis, lack of resources, stigma (identity)
- Nature of treatment
benefit: it may improve conditions
harm: overuse, side affects
- Involuntary treatment
- Use of restraints
- harm reduction strategies
(Save needle programs)
- Risk of suicide/ medical assistance in dying
- Over and under diagnosis of mental health conditions
- Medical research
(Too many involuntary patients are used in research)
- Lack of resources and other social problems
Autonomy
greater self determination
Paternalism
doctor knows best.
-doctor is able to make decisions for the patients medical treatment even if the patient is able to do so alone
De-institutionalization
movement to save money disguised as a movement for self determination
-source of homeless problem: patients were let out into the community without the support they needed
Why is Autonomy important in our health care system?
- Legal reasons: doing things to people without their permission is a illegal offence
- Respect for persons
- Shift to patient-centered medicine
How to know that a patient has autonomy: Freedom
to act on their choices; independent, cannot be pressure
How to know that a patient has autonomy: Rationality
the patient must have the ability to understand different possible outcomes and decide on a plan
-Competency is not the same thing as autonomy: Just because a person is deemed incompetent is doesn’t mean that they aren’t involved at all in their care (Include them to some extent if possible [e.g. what they wear, what they eat etc.])
- Everyone has the right to make a bad choice: when a person makes a choice that you don’t agree with– don’t automatically question their rationality as long as it makes sense to the patient (E.g. patients have the right to decline treatment even if that treatment would safe their life but in cases in mental health)
How to know that a patient has autonomy: Goals and desires
the person must be able to identify their goals and desires and make choices to help fulfil them
-work through them with your patient (ask them)
Patient Autonomy Questions
-If the patient does not show the appropriate levels of freedom, rationality, and goal orientedness, then it may be necessary to seek alternatives or decisions about their care
-Going in we assume that all patients have autonomy
-if the patient is a child we do not treat them as if they have autonomy (there is no minimal age consent for autonomy; it is the doctors judgement of whether they are sufficiently cognitive maturity)
-if a patient isn’t able to make decisions for themselves, the health care team will look towards, DNR’S, living wills (other medical desires)
Psychiatric Advanced Directive
lets the person decide while they are well what kind of treatment they want when they aren’t well
If there is no documentation..
talk to a social worker
–don’t talk to the family until you need to – family members don’t always have the patients best interest at heart
- if they are unable to make decisions, no documentation, no neutral third party (SW), family doesn’t seem like they have the patients best interest in mind, then doctor decides if they have the best interest in mind – this is weak/limited paternalism
Negatives of autonomy
-Autonomy expects us to be independent at a time where we are not very independent
-cultural differences around autonomy
-is the concept of autonomy sexist?
-patients often don’t know that they have autonomy
-patient non-compliance
-problem of reduced capacity
Societal views
Society views autonomy as a status that a patient either has or lacks
but…. you should view it as:
-a goal you are trying to restore a patient to
-a feature of certain kinds of relationships
informed consent (choice)
choice is a ongoing process not a one time thing
Justice
-legal sense
-phil sense
-ethical sense
social justice:how we organize society to keep it fair
distributive justice: how we distribute our sources or social goods to help keep society fair
Canada Health Act
is supposed to govern distributive justice in this country unless your indigenous
-5 fundamental principles of justice:
1, Comprehensiveness (what’s covered)
- Universality (who’s covered)
- Accessibility (can you get what your entitled to)
- Portability (your care travels with you)
- Public administration (the level of government that is responsible for providing health care is provincial/territorial and not federal)
Health Care Spending: societal level
-taxes: either increase taxes it cut services
other opinions:
-pay politicians less
-stop/reduce tax breaks –> corporations/ wealthy ind’s
- less military funding
POLITICIANS
ARE BIG FAT DIRTY LYING RAT BAGS
Health Care Spending: personal level
where you work
-nurses should be aware that they sometimes
undermine the values of their own profession
-ask candidates for public office about health care
Funding
-be a educator and a advocate for the public as well
-the values you defend in your practice should be
rpn values not corporate values