Final Flashcards
The principle of cooperation with evil
Used when someone else uses our good actions for evil
Types of cooperation
- Formal Cooperation (Explicit or implicit)
2. Material Cooperation (Immediate or mediate)
Explicit Formal Cooperation
Evil intent is known
Implicit Formal Cooperation
Evil intent is not known but is implied
Immediate Material cooperation
Your action plays a big role
Mediate Material Cooperation
Your action does not play an essential role
Mediate Material cooperation can be morally permissible if
- Proportionality of your doing the action
2. How grave is the evil/What is the good you are doing?
The graveness of an action
- Proximity to the action
- Is your participation essential or nonessential
- Question of Scandal (leading others to sin….We have a moral obligation to reduce scandal)
Conscientious Objection
Have a judgment of conscience about a particular action and you refuse to do that action because your conscience has deemed it morally wrong
Medical Vitalism
Have to do everything to keep a person alive
Subjectivism
Do not have to do anything and it is up to the patient
Ordinary (Medical)
Scientifically established, statistically successful, available
Extraordinary (Medical)
More experimental, not readily available
Ordinary (Church)
Proportionate
Morally Obligatory
Treatments in which the benefits of the treatment outweigh the burdens of the treatment
Extraordinary (Church)
Disproportionate
Morally Optional
Treatments in which the burdens of the treatment outweigh the benefits of the treatment
Can you forgo extraordinary means?
Yes, as long as one does not fail some more serious duty
You need to consider your spiritual and social relationships
Who decides what is extraordinary and what is ordinary?
The patient unless it is contradictory to Catholic Moral Teaching
Can not force a treatment but can not cooperate with an evil action
Preserving Life
Life is good and we are called to preserve it but that duty is not an absolute duty (God has ownership of our lives)
Euthanasia
Intrinsic Evil
An action or an omission which of itself or by intention causes death in order that all suffering be eliminated
Ordinary Universal Teaching
NG Tube
Runs from nose down to stomach; more temporary
GJ Tube
Tube that starts in the stomach and runs down to small instenstine
more permanent
used if someone has issues digesting in stomach
TPN
Nutrition and hydration provided through veins
Used when stomach and small intestine can not digest food
Doctors do not like using long term because of risk
Possible Benefits of ANH
Survival Prolong Life Reduce risk of aspiration (Pneumonia sometimes) increase funtion Communal value of food
Possible Burdens of ANH
Irritation Infection Uncomfortable Complication Financial Burden Increase risk of Aspiration (Pneumonia) Risk of Surgery Take away pleasure of eating and taking away communal aspect sometimes requires restraint
Specific Cases Church Believes ANH is extraordinary
- Very remote places or in extreme poverty where it can not be provided
- Cases where patients can not assimilate food or liquid
- Any complications in the means (Excessively Burdensome)
- Would not be reasonably expected to prolong life
PDE: Lethal Dose of Morphine
Physical Action: Lethal dose
Moral Object: Euthanasia
Intention: Relieve pain by hastening death
Bad Effect (Death) is means to good effect (Relief of Pain)
Murder/suicide is intrinsically evil and you can not do an intrinsic evil even for good intention no matter the magnitude of the good
Personhood of the Fetus
Personhood is a philosophical question, and philosophy is the handmaiden of theology
Is the fetus an individual?
Has unique DNA, can respond to stimulation, and metabolization is occurring within its cells so it appears to be an individual
Should error on the side of caution when we are unsure
How should we treat the fetus?
With the same dignity as a human person
Didache spoke out against abortion and exposure
Church can do this since it has supremacy in the area of faith and morals
Four parts of the promises that spouses make to each other in their wedding vows which they renew during the conjugal act?
I give myself to you freely, faithfully, totally and fruitfully
This is also how God loves us
TOB 1
Human beings are made incomplete and we yearn to be in communion with other people
TOB 2
In order to find ourselves we have to give ourselves
TOB 3
Sexual intercourse in marriage is the most radical from of self giving
It is the only action where we can completely give ourselves to another person
TOB 4
“Language of the body”
With our bodies we say “I give myself to you freely, totally, faithfully, and fruitfully”
“Responsible Parenthood”
At some points in time, not not necessarily at all times, it may be permissable to refrain from having children for financial, health, and other reasons
This is a prudential judgements by the couple (Should be taken to God in prayer)
Values of NFP and Contraception
Refrain from having children (may be permissable)
Disvalues of contraception
Seperation of the procreative and unitive dimensions of the conjugal act by rendering procreation impossible
Eugenics
Movement aimed at improving the human race
Which types of cooperation are always morally impermissible
Explicit/Implicit Formal Cooperation
Immediate Material Cooperation
What distinguishes Implicit formal cooperation and immediate material cooperation?
- If there is another possible reason then it is not necessarily implied
- If there is duress
Duress
Can lessen moral culpability
Referal for contraception
Immediate material-Does it play a big role?
Mediate Material-Perhaps not a big role, other physician might not prescribe
Bads and Goods of Mediate Material referal for contraception
Goods: Ensuring the patient gets a good physician, good care of the patient
Bads: Risk of scandal and the patient actually getting contraception
Compassion means
To suffer with
Physical action of Euthanasia
An action (PAS/Euthanasia) or an ommision (Withdrawing/withholding ordinary treatment) which of itself
Euthanasia (Medical/Legal)
Someone else is responsible for the death of the patient in the name of eliminating suffering
PAS
Physician supplies the means while the patient does the action causing death
Palliative Care
- Symptom Management
- “Big Picture”
- Can happen at any point in life
- No limitation on medical procedures
Who is palliative care for
Helpful for anyone who has chronic conditions which cause complicated symptoms (Symptom management)