Gender And Education Flashcards
(19 cards)
What is the gender gap in achievement in education?
girls do better than boys
What is mitsos and brownes idea of deindustrialisation for the gender gap in achievement?
- industrialisation have disengaged w/c boys which then widens the education gap further
- working class boys see less of a point in education if it does not prepare them for the careers that have been allocated by society
What is mitsos and brownes idea of feminism for the gender gap in achievement?
Feminist activism in the 20th century challenged traditional gender norms advocating for women rights in employment, education and personal autonomy and has played a key role in women’s success in education
Critique of mitsos and brownes idea of deindustrialisation
It assumes that all working class boys react the same way to industrial changes, ignoring those who still value education and want to succeed
Critique of mitsos and brownes idea of feminism
Their view overlooks how shifts in the job market and other broader social and economic changes encourage girls to succeed
What does biggart believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
Attainability of job opportunities is seen as limited especially to w/c girls
Mother hood and family life them seem more attainable goals
Critique of biggarts idea for the gender gap in achievement
Assumes all working class girls see limited job chances the same way, ignoring those who aim for careers or higher education
What does sommerville believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
Sommerville believes that slow principled pragmatism has led to girls having more freedom and more to look forward to in the future
Critique of Somervilles idea for the gender gap in achievement
Her view is too optimistic as it overlooks the ongoing inequalities many girls still face like the gender pay gap and unequal domestic roles
What does sharpe believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
Sharpe argues that girls aspirations have changed from being a housewife and doing domestic work in the 1970s to wanting a good education and a future career in the 1990s
Critique of sharpes idea for the gender gap in achievement
This view doesnt account for ongoing pressures that can limit girls aspirations such as social expectations and economic barriers
Critique of wards idea for the gender gap in achievement
This view doesnt fully consider how schools or class inequalities influence the boys behaviour
What does ward believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
The ‘boiz’ study
Young working class men who refer to themselves as the boiz
- ward explores how they use language, humor and behaviour to build a strong group identity centered on masculinity
What does Norman believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
- the socialisation of gender roles impacts education
E.g. behaviour- boys are disobedient while girls are more obedient
Critique of Norman’s idea for the gender gap in achievement
Assumes all boys and girls behave the same way, ignoring individual differences and the influence of school environment
What does mcrobbie believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
- since girls spend more time in structured, communicative environments, this has helped them become better at school tasks that required communication, organisation and literacy skills
Critique of mcrobbie idea for the gender gap in achievement
This doesn’t consider how some girls do not spend time in these environments and are more interested in other things
What does reeves believe is the reason for the gender gap in achievement?
- boys are not flourishing in school as a result of lack of representation of male jobs
- girls are leaving boys behind in today’s world
- girls are a grade levels above boys, inequalities from 50 tears ago have switched around
- he believes that boys should start school a year later for development
How does ringrose critique reeves idea for the gender gap in achievement?
- it is oversimplified moral panic
- it ignores intersectionality
- ignores wider societal issues that effect women and girls (women still dont get the higher paid jobs)