Key Battles/Conflicts 7101-7103 Flashcards
(81 cards)
Leuctra *
(7101-1)
“Start point for military history” Dr. Rudd
“By all means Epaminondas should have got his ass kicked, the key is a leader who can make an executable plan with an inferior force and win.”
“Tactics is about seeking/creating a difference then exploiting that difference”
Thebes (Epaminondas) vs. Sparta
Context: Spartans had seized Thebes. Athens liberated with displaced Thebans
Spartans had numerical advantage and used phalanx – cavalry was used to scout. ~11k
Epaminondas used cavalry as fighting force
Epaminondas drew up Thebans in oblique order to deny the Spartans the ability to simultaneously smash into the Theban lines. It also allowed the Thebans to focus on the Spartan right
Epamonindas made his left (direct across from Spartan strenght) was made deeper]
Epamonindas cavalrhy charged against Spartan cavalry – chased off field
Theban sacred band led Thebes’ deep left
Envelopment
“In essence Epaminondas resorted to a formation known today as the oblique order, which, while not a maneuver in itself, paved the way for a further advance in the art of war, such as deliberate maneuver against a flank…No finer illustration of the successful application of the principles of Mass and Economy of Force is to be found in ancient military history.
Leuthen *
(7101-1)
“Leuthen not about Leuthen”
Austrians (70k) vs. Frederick (36k)
Key Point - Value of knowledge of terrain. “Should make you obsessed with recon” Dr. Rudd
Approaches the French (Charles & Daun) right flank (feint) – French focus on defending there. Frederick moves to the south (French left flank) unseen behind hills. Charles thought they may not want to fight.
Attacked the Austrian “Elbow” at Sagshcutz (FLANK ATTACK)
Uses “Oblique order”
“For a short time, the issue at that key point was in doubt. But superior fires soon told on the stunned defenders and their shocked commanders… Charles’left wing collapsed and rolled back across the hill.” 124
“The battle is in itself a complete lesson in tactics – deception, maneuver, inspiration, and reslove – gathered together inot a volume on generalship, with no one chapter missing.”
Frederick, “Those who cannot survive disaster do not deserve success.”
Note: Feints have to be believable
Chaeronea *
(7101-1)
Phillip leads Macedonians against Greeks (including Thebans)
PENETRATION - Philip creates a gap, Alexander exploits
Alexander leads from the front - his person is C2 (where do we C2 from at operational level?)
Greeks were weaker – used the tactical defense – strong position to deny Macedonian CG “Hammer-and-anvil” - denied flanks by tying into high ground on left flank and river on right flank
Philip has part of his line – the phalanx withdraw, creates an oblique with an opening at the Greek Center – Alexander leads his cavalry into the newly created / exposed flank and achieves decisive victory
“Both sides had numbered about 30k, but the combined arms of Philip had created a weak spot – an enemy flank – where none had been.
Cannae
(7101-1)
Hannibal provokes Romans on a day when Varro is in charge (knows his enemy) - Hannibal feints toward Roman small camp to draw out the Romans.
Hannibal masses Gallic cavalry (8k) on his left. He economizes with 2k Numidian cavalry on right
Can Numidians hold on long enough for the cavalry on the left to crush their opposing Romans?
Similar to Marathon – Wings were strengthened & the center was weak
“As the light troops moved forward to open the battle, Hannibal advanced his weakened center until it formed a salient toward the enemy, while the wings, well back, stood fast. The Romans charged forward and struck the Carthaginian center. As Varro had hoped, the weight of the maniples was too great for the Gauls, who were pressed back steadily. If this center had broken, the day would have been lost; but Hannibal earlier had rehearsed his subordinates in the battle tactics to be employed, and consequently, even though hard pressed, they did not panic. Additionally, Hannibal had posted both himself and his younger brother Mago at the center to command personally that portion of the line where leadership and example were most required.”58 REHEARSALS & PERSONAL LEADERSHIP
Varro keeps pushing more mass into the center losing his mobility.
The Cavalry on the flank beat the Romans and attack the Legions in the rear – the Romans, cheering for victory now are trapped & slaughtered.
DOUBLE ENVELOPMENT
Issus
(7101-1)
Darius vs Alexander
Armies pass each other accidentally – Alexander’s withdraw cut off
Persians 5 to 1 advantage – used narrow terrain to have significant depth
Darius ME = cavalry, Darius thinks Alexander’s ME = phalanx, but that was wrong
Alexander places some troops at right angles to his right wing (refused his flank). Parmenion on left flank tied into the sea. Alexander orders center and left to advance slowly – to delay serious engagement until Alexander could crush the Persian left
“Alexander, seeing that Darius intended to keep his infantry on the far side of the river, perceived that the persian had made a mistake in keeping his center on one side of the river while crossing the cavalry over it. If this Persian center were to be disabled, no efforts made by the persian right could save it. Alexander’s problem then was how to break this center. He felt this could best be done by striking the Persian left and then taking the center in flank. 33
The outcome of the battle was in doubt until Alexander was able to clear the Persian left and wheel his cavalry to strike the Greek mercenaries in flank and rout them. Darius, seeing his left wing collapsing, turned and fled in panic.
“Alexander’s victory on the Pinarus underscored the ‘training, dash and high morale which make the Companions the finest cavalry in history’”
Granicus
(7101-1)
Alexander crosses Hellespont, invades Persia
Persians – mostly cavalry, 40k + 5k Greek hoplite mercenary
Alexander: 40k – 30k infantry, 5k cavalry, +others
Persians line up behind Granicus river with Cavalry in front – tactical error b/c limited mobility of cavalry, but they may have just wanted to kill Alexander and didn’t actually think they would win
Aexander immediately attacks with oblique formation
Offensive wing on right commanded by Alexander, Defensive wing on left commanded by Parmenion
1) Pierce the enemy;s left flank by a daring attack of the Macedonain cavalry
2) Turn the cavalry to the left andd rol up the enemy line
3) Simultaneously bring the phalanx covered by cavalry on the left forward in echelon to engage the enemy
Alexander doesn’t go straight against EN Left – b/c that is where they strenghtened their line anticipating Alexander to attack. (AVOIDS SURFACE, LOOKS FOR GAP)
Marathon
(7101-1)
Darius wanted to punish Athens, “Master, don’t forget Athens”
Miltiades leads Greeks ~10000 - Strong defensive position anchored by hills
Spartans celebrating Carneian Festival of Appolo
Armies facing each other for as much as 8 days
Persians leave 30k at Marathon and send 20k on ship to go to Athens (including cavalry)
Miltiades decides to take advantage
**Griess does not state the cavalry embarked – maybe they did. THe battle took place on Miltiades’ day to command (10 generals took turns)
Envelopment
Athenians and Plateans make their Right and Left flanks strong / deep to prevent the Persians from flanking. Lengthened line to prevent numerically superior Persians from flanking them. Caused Greek center to be thin
“The risk was apparent. Could the flank forces succeed before the weak center was entirely overcome?”
Miltiades has Athenians sprint last 100m to limit effectiveness of Persian archers
Greek center is about to break. Greeek flanks are winning. Greeks hold on in center long enough for flanks to win and begin to attack Persian flank / rear
6400 Persians die, 192 Greeks die
Rossbach *
(7101-1)
Frederick (22k) vs. French (54k)
At end of campaigning season, Frederick needs to strike blow against the German/French forces under Soubise & Hildburghausen. French/Germans put up defenses, Frederick pulls back slightly thinking he missed an opportunity. French / German think this is a withdraw / rearward move at the end of the campaigning season. They decide to “pursue” Frederick, but Frederick was not withdrawing. The next day Frederick ambushes.
“French infantry and cvalry followed, interspersed with artillery and German infantry. The movement was ponderous and confused…There was no attempt to push an adequate screen up to the higher ground beyond Rossbach to survey Prussian moves and prevent Frederick from seeing theirs…Frederick watched this amateur generalship with disbelief.
Tasks young cavalry commader Seydlitz. “No violence done by man can ever surpass the brutality of the Rossbach death ride…It was a masterful combined performance. The iron bracelet of guns around the slopes of Janus…
“It was a contest between an agile army with brains and a clumsy army without any.”121
French have to admit they were whipped by a force half their size - prompts French mil reform for next 20 years
Zorndorf
(7101-1)
1758 (Part of Seven Years’ War) - Russians (Count Fermor) vs. Prussians (Frederick the Great)
After Rossbach & Leuthen (Prussian victories)
Tactically inconclusive
Zorndorf has been described as the most terrible of the battles of the Seven Years War. Keith’s warning to Frederick on the fighting qualities of the Russian soldiers was fully born out. Frederick considered the hero of the battle to be Seydlitz for his devastating attack from the left wing.
During the battle, Frederick famously took a regimental standard and led an attack himself, rallying his troops.
Prague
(7101-1)
“The indecisive victory”
Charles (Bavaria) had to decide to 1) Attack before Frederick’s forces joined up 2) Defend outside the city of Prague on favorable terrain, 3) Retreating into the city or 4) Abandoning Prague altogether
Frederick joins his forces, reconnoiters
Incorrectly assesses the ground in front of Charles as “green meadows” - it was actually muck/swamp
“Shot and grape tore at the desperate Prussians as Browne (Bavarian) at last found his chance to strike. The Austrians swarmed from their cannon-covered hill and met the dripping Prussians rising from the muck. In these straits, only valor could retrieve what error had all but thrown away”…Schwerin rallies with a flag – shot down…
A gap opened in Austrian lines – Frederick’s subordinate (Manstein) initially exploits it - Frederick sees the opportunity (like Alexander) and takes advantage.
Note: sometimes this is mission command sometimes this is “rogue subordinate”
“Orders should create parameters for initiative” - Dr. Rudd
Browne (competent Bavarian had been wounded – resulting in a loss of coordination) Charles (Bavarian incompetent leader) had a seizure at the critical moment.
Gaugamela
(7101-1)
Persians – a ton of forces, but 40k trained cavalry and only 4k trained infantry
Alexander – 40k infantry, 7k cavalry
Persians choose flat, open plains of Gaugamela to take advantage of mobility
Darius thinks there may be a night attack, so he keeps his force up all night
Length of Persian front was double Alexander’s
Alexander assumes defensive posture and oblique order to draw Persians in then when the fighting opened a gap, he planned to exploit / penetrate the gap with companion cavalry
Alexander drove a wedge “Penetration of opportunity”
Blenheim
(7101-1)
Marlborough & Eugene
Blenheim not about Blenheim
Marlborough & Eugene attack flanks, French weaken center - Marlborough exploits
Blenheim important because Marlborough out-thought his adversary
What counts is can we make it work? - Dr. Rudd
4 ways to kill an army “Not doctrinal, FMFM Morris”
7101-2
1) With a siege (Yorktown, Petersburg – Civil War)
2) In a battle of annihilation
3) With pursuit
4) Erosion over time (Western front last 3 months of War)
Can combine multiple
2 Ways to end a siege
7101-3
1) Starve/bomb them out
2) Direct Assault
American Invasion of Canada 1775-1776
Disaster for Schuyler & Arnold
“Amazing that it came so close to success”
Delay by Schuyler lacked appreciation for weather
Route selection by Arnold lacked appreciation of terrain
Both expeditions lost about 1/3 of force before contact with enemy
Battle of Quebec
Schuyler and Arnold Get to Quebec too late.
Brit Guy Carleton had time to prepare defense and stock up to outlast a siege.
Winter has set in, Quebec is besieged (3ish months), but ineffective.
Montgomery & Arnold come up with complicated plan to create diversion, breach city, and storm through. Montgomery is killed, Arnold is wounded, Daniel Morgan takes over, but it is unsuccessful. >500 US casualties to ~20 Brit casualties.
Lexington & Concord
Successful preparation for rapid mobilization on the part of the colonials
Key considerations - force and space - redcoats marched significant distance & were harried on the entire return trip.
Siege of Boston
- Boston is roughly 1 mile square. Full of buildings, etc and up to 11k troops
- Brits decide to roll back part of defenses at bunker / breed hill
- Brits had Naval power (mobile firepower) that the Americans could not match
NGF given does not make a huge difference in the battle
Washington assumes command 2 July 1775. Henry Knox gathers artillery from Ticonderoga. In March 1776, Washington occupies Dorchester Heights - making Boston untenable.
An agreement is reached to allow Brits to evacuate in exchange for not burning the city down.
Saratoga Campaign
Germain as British common commander doesn’t force Burgoyne & Howe to act in concert
Colonists end up “yarding” Burgoyne
Saratoga is an example of
Breed’s Hill / Bunker Hill
Colonists take advantage of terrain.
British are able to use water as maneuver. It seems like they should be able to effectively employ naval guns to blast colonists out, but impatience / pride lead to an aggressive frontal COA that is costly.
Battle for New York in US Revolutionary War
Washington makes a number of mistakes and gives the British a number of opportunities to cut off and capture his army.
Howe outmaneuvers Washinton and nearly captures the American army on multiple occasions.
Washington appears indecisive though he eventually escapes with his army after Lee arrives and tells him the position is not tenable.
Losses on Long Island, Fort Lee/Fort Washington (should have been abandoned but indecision led to loss of garrison), Harlem Heights, & White Plains
Trenton
Bold move by Washington
British are spread out in picket-type encampments over the winter - Washington crosses Delaware & surprises forces at Trenton
Washington crosses Delaware to attack Hessian post at dawn. Bad weather and another minor raid (uncoordinated) helped lead to Hessian surprise. “Sensational victory”
Result: 150 Hessians killed, 900 captured
Princeton
“Princeton is not about Princeton” - it is about threatening a LOC.
Washington had 3 options after Trenton – Retreat across the river to safety. Link up with Cadwalader, or defend (bunker hill style) at Trenton. Cornwallis leaves from Princeton with a force - Washington defends successfully on Jan 2 – nightfall ends Brit attacks. Rather than just withdraw from Trenton, he decides to move and attack small garrison left at Princeton. Meeting engagement outside Princeton
Result: Brits lose 50% - about 450 at Princeton. Washington crosses back to winter quarters at Morristown.
Brandywine
Quick narrative: Howe lands at Head of Elk MD on Aug 25 – moving to Philadelphia. Washington gave up war of posts strategy (likely political pressure to try to defend Philly)
▪ “Washington defending – didn’t know about Jeffries Ford - “Howe divided his army – a sign that he held Washington’s battlefield acumen in low esteem – and ordered General Knyphausen, with about 6800 British and Germans to assault the rebels’ enter at Chadd’s Ford. That was a diversion. Howe was to march with 8500 to Jeffries Ford where he would cross. If all went well Sullivan would be taken by surprise and the British would turn Washington’s right flank…247
▪ Howe waiting until sunlight resulted in only 3 hrs of sunlight for flank attack before sunset ended the battle
Howe outmaneuvered Washington after the battle and had a clear way to Philly