L2 - Behavioral therapy Flashcards
(67 cards)
What is behaviour in behavioral therapy?
- Behaviour is not just behaviour - motor behaviours but also physiological responses, emotions and cognitions (conscious thoughts, deliberate thinking, unconscious schemas, information processing)
- Not behaving is also behaviour (or not talking is also behaviour) = it’s impossible not to behave
- Any kind of therapy is behavioural therapy - the therapist is part of the client’s enviornment that is influencing him
- behavioural therapy has behaviour as the target of therapy but thoughts and feelings are also considered important
How can we define behavior therapy?
From the book
- The definitions vary and not one feels perfect (according to the lecturer)
- In clinical practice, behavior therapy takes different forms
- Book: Behavior therapy aims to change factors in the environment that influence an individual’s behavior as well as the ways in which individuals respond to their environment
How does the European Association of Behavior Cognitive Therapies define BT?
- Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapies are psychological approaches which are based on scientific principles and which research has shown to be effective for a wide range of problems. Clients and therapists work together to identify and understand problems in terms of the relationship between thoughts, feelings and behaviour. The approach usually focuses on difficulties in the here and now and relies on the therapist and client developing a shared view of the individual’s problem. This then leads to the identification of personalised, time-limited therapy goals and strategies which are continually monitored and evaluated. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapists work with individuals, families and groups. The approaches can be used to help anyone irrespective of ability, culture, race, gender or sexual preference.
How can we define behavioural therapy as an empirical cycle?
- Each session is concieved as a scientific experiment with a single participant, the patient in which the therapist and the patient go through at least one empirical cycle (or more if the problem persists or other problems emerge that deserve attention)
- It’s a definition of a process and the process is the application of the experimental, scientific, empirical cycle to the patient’s problem
- You develop a hypothesis on how a problem of the patient has come about and how it’s maintained in the here and now and how it can be resolved
- The hypothesis of the causes of the maintaining factors is tested by the therapeutic procedures
- If the procedures lead to symptom reduction or improvement of the patient’s problem then this confirms that the hypothesis about the maintaining factors was correct
- Picture 1 - left: experimental terms; right: clinical terms
- The treatment plan can be anything (so not just learning theory) as long as it logically follows from the hypothesis that is individual to the patient
- Behaviour therapy in this view is a way of cyclic thinking rather a closed collection of specific techniques
How is BT linked with scientific research?
- Linked very closely - lots of studies into BT: mechanisms/explanation, outcomes/evaluation, predictors…
- Important characteristic of BT: experimental method and attitude of the therapist
- Both on individual patient level as well as group level: loads of scientific research
How do manuals for BT relate to the individual approach?
- In practice, not every individual treatment is different: symptoms, cause, what works to treat, they are not all different for every new patient - they show similarities, co-vary and there are patterns
- If you build up the evidence of what works for specific cases and there are patterns, they can develop into strandardized treatments and manuals
- Misunderstanding of protocols and manuals is that they are one-size-fits-all - that is not true, they allow for lot of specific variation for each patient, characteristic, symptom, problem
- E.g. you tailor exposure to the specific object of fear
- If the manualised form doesn’t work, you can follow-up with a more individualised approach
What is the discussion around manualized treatment about?
- There is lot of discussion on the pros and cons of manuals
- Pro: good way to learn how to deliver therapy (especially for therapists in early stage of their career)
- Completely non-manualised treatment doesn’t exist - wouldn’t be treatment because then we can’t talk about it and teach about it
- The discussion should be rather a distinction of the level of detail of the manulatization, rather then a dichotomous distinction
What are manuals based on in practice?
- In practice, these manuals are offered in response to DSM classification
- Also basis for reimbursement policies from insurance companies
- Usually these combination works well, if not then indiviudalised approach is offered
Go to flashcard 65!!!!
Shared characteristics of BT
- Focus on behavioral change/expanding behavioral repertoire and response options - not telling people how to behave but rather providing wider range of choice of how to respond in certain situations
↪ important to determine early in the treatment whether the person’s problem is due to lack of range in repertoir or because they might be scared to show such behaviour due to the consequences - these have different clinical implications - Focus on empiricism, (individual) hypothesis-testing, (continuous) evaluation
- Relatedly: supported by scientific research (efficacy, mechanisms, etc.)
- Behavior is (largely) ‘functional’ in/function of environment (reinforcement/punishment) and not a patient’s ‘fault’
- Focus on maintaining factors/current determinants of problem behavior
- Focus on ‘homework’ in patient’s real environment (treatment takes 168 h/w)
- Active, structured, directive, creative - no secrets, you share the process of therapy with the client
- Transparant and collaborative (shared decision making)
BT and other psychotherapies
- BT is closely aligned with other psychotherapies, especially those that are directive and biref - cognitive therapy & REBT
- Often, practictioners of all 3 just refer to their practice as CBT & borrow +mix approaches and techniques
- Many current behaviour therapists believe thoughts and beliefs to be fundamental to how we respond to their enviornment
Gestalt and Alderian therapy
- BT shares features with both
- Alderian psychotherapy: important to change beliefs, especially those that minimize self-worth + abnormal behaviour is bets encompased in terms of ‘problems of living’ rather than evidence of ilness
- Gestalt therapy: uses beh. strategies: role-plays
- Interpersonal and family therapies may also partially overlap (BT can be done in a family context)
BT vs other approaches
BT vs REBT (rational emotive behaviour therpy)
- Time limited, directive, transparent, evidence-based, active, and focused on maintaining factors
BT vs psychoanalysis &psychodynamic approaches
- The most different from BT, which mostly takes behaviours at face value, doesn’t assume them to be manifestations of unconscious conflicts (despite still recognizing the role of processes outside our awarness)
- These approaches are non-directive, less transparent, less evidence-based, more reliant on therapist’s interpretation and more focused on factors that might have triggered/developed the problems
- Much longer, often yeals (BT can also be relatively short)
- Cannot explain results of BT, which often contradicts psychoanalytic principles
What can’t PA explain about BT?
- PA considers that treatments focusing on changing symptoms (exposure for phobia) will be ineffective because they target the surface problems rather than the root of the problem (=symptom substitution)
- However, results of BT actually show generalization of improvement to multiple areas of functioning (PA cannot explain this)
BT vs CCT
- also different - nondirective and no homework
- Many elements of the therapeutic relationship are common to all therapies including behavioural ones
Misunderstandings of BT
- Denial of (‘deeper’) thoughts and feelings - BT can be very thorough and can go back a long way, it’s not just focused on the hear and now
- Superficial and (only) addressing symptoms instead of (real) causes - it just does it in different terms
- Exclusive focus on present
- Simplistic and manualized - if anything that’s a limitation of the current healthcare system rather than inherent in BT
- Ignores therapeutic relationship
What are the three (four) ‘waves’ of BT?
- Behavioral
- Behavioral + cognitive
- Behavioral + cognitive + acceptance
- Behavioral + cognitive + acceptance + technological/neurocognitive/neurobiological? (not yet clearly manifested in practice so not fully accepted as a fourth wave)
How did the names of professional associations of BT developed over the years, reflecting the progress of the waves?
- Association for Behavior Therapy
- Association for Behavioral Therapy and Cognitive Therapy
- Association for Behavioral and Cognitive Therapies
BT and research
- BT is well established in research like no other therapy
- The number of meta-analysis of BT has been increasing exponentially since the 2000s
- BT is the first-line treatment in many treatment guidelines for many disorders
- Also many international journels
What are some critiques of research of BT?
- Research should be about quality and not quantity and the quality is not good
- it uses lot of strictly selected groups with strict exclusion/inclusion criteria
- not studying the real patients and what is actually important in therapy
- He disagrees with most of these and thinks they are quite weak
- Although it’s important to be open to improvement but just because research is difficult should not be a reason for not doing research
Is learning theory the basis of BT?
- Learning theory is not inherently the theoretical basis for BT but very often in practice it actually is, because it has been very fruitful theory
- It has lot of applications, it explains lot of observations and it works very well as a theory
- Forms of learning: classical conditioning, operant conditioning, vicarious/observational learning, rule-governed/instructional learning (e.g. learning how to drive a car starts with instructional learning from an instructor but it doesn’t take you very far, because the actual driving behaviour is fine-tuned through operant conditioning)
- According to the learning theory, there is not a difference between how we acquire problematic and adaptive behaviours - it’s a distinction we make or it’s determined by our enviornment (e.g. detaching emotionally from others can be adaptive in a context of childhood abuse but problematic at a later stage in life)
Key concepts
Classical conditioning, extinction and reinstatement
- Classical conditioning = a form of learning in which a previously neutral stimulus (conditioned stimulus; CS) comes to predict the occurrence of a second stimulus (unconditioned stimulus; US), thereby eliciting a conditioned response (CR)
- Extinction (in classical conditioning) = presentation of the CS in the absence of the US so that the CR eventually stops occurring
- However, through reinstatement fear typically returns quickly
- Reinstatement = a repairing of the US and CS after extinction, leading to a return of fear
Key concepts
Operant conditioning and the four cells
= a form of learning in the frequency or strength of behavior is influenced by its consequences
- Positive Reinforcement: rewarding consequence added, behavior increases
- Negative Reinforcement: aversive consequence removed, behavior increases
- (Positive) Punishment: aversive consequence added, behavior decreases
- Negative Punishment: rewarding consequence removed, behavior decreases
Reinforcement is more effective than punishment - in punishment they learn what not to do but not what to do instead
Key concepts
Extinction (OC), discrimination learning and generalization
- Extinction (in operant conditioning) = when behavior stops occurring because it is no longer reinforced
- Discrimination learning = when a response is reinforced or punished in some situations but not in others, which leads to the response becoming context dependent
- Generalization = the occurrence of a learned behavior in situations other than where it was acquired