Lesson 4 of Estate Planning: Advanced Estate Planning Flashcards
(102 cards)
The Unlimited Marital Deduction!
- The Single Economic Unit
Under current law, an individual is generally permitted to leave an unlimited amount of property to his
spouse at his death without incurring any estate tax.
Advantages of the Unlimited Marital Deduction include:
- Defers estate taxes until the death of the surviving spouse.
- May fund the applicable estate tax credit of the surviving spouse.
- Ensures the surviving spouse has sufficient assets to support his
lifestyle.
The Unlimited Marital Deduction!
- Requirements of the Unlimited Marital Deduction
In order to claim a Unlimited marital deduction,
- the decedent must have been married as of the date of his death
- and the surviving spouse must receive property through the estate.
- Surviving Spouse must be a US Citizen
Exam Question - Requirements of the Unlimited Marital Deduction
Which of the following is not a requirement of the unlimited marital deduction?
a) In order to claim a marital deduction, the decedent must have been married as of the date of his death.
b) The surviving spouse must receive property through the estate.
c) The surviving spouse must be a US citizen.
d) The gross value of qualifying property left to the surviving spouse is included in the
marital deduction.
Answer: D
Answers A, B, and C are all requirements of the unlimited marital deduction,
Answer D is incorrect because only the net value, not the gross value, of qualifying property left to the surviving spouse is included in the marital deduction.
The term “net value” for marital deduction purposes equals the gross value of the qualifying property left to the surviving spouse less any taxes, debts, or estate administration expenses payable out of the spousal interest.
The Unlimited Marital Deduction!
- Limitations of the Unlimited Marital Deduction
**To prevent abuse, the unlimited marital deduction is limited in two ways: **
- (1) the property passing to the spouse must qualify for the marital deduction, and
- (2) only the net value of qualifying property that is left to a surviving spouse can be included as the marital deduction.
The term “net value” for marital deduction purposes
- equals the gross value of the qualifying
property left to the surviving spouse - less any taxes,
- debts, or
- estate administration expenses payable
out of the spousal interest.
If property is not transferred to the surviving spouse outright,
- special qualification rules must be met for
such property to qualify for the marital deduction- There are generally three ways to leave property to a spouse and qualify for the marital deduction.
- These are summarized in the following chart:
Qualification for the Marital Deduction
For a transfer to qualify for the estate tax marital deduction, the property interest must meet three requirements.
- First, the property must be included in the decedent’s gross estate.
- Second, the property must be transferred to the surviving spouse.
- Third, the interest must not be a terminable interest unless it meets one of the exceptions.
If the surviving spouse is not a US citizen,
- additional requirements must be met in order to qualify for the unlimited marital deduction.
If property is not included in the gross estate of the decedent,
- the decedent will NOT be permitted to deduct the value of that property from the gross estate as a marital deduction.
In order to qualify for the unlimited marital deduction, the property must pass from the decedent to, and for the benefit of, the surviving spouse.
- If the property passes from someone other than the decedent to the surviving spouse, or if the property passed by the decedent goes to someone who is not his surviving spouse, the marital deduction will not be available.
- If the decedent leaves property to his surviving spouse as trustee for some other individual, the surviving spouse does not have a beneficial interest in the property and the transfer will not qualify for the marital deduction.
- Generally, property that is included in the decedent’s gross estate and is transferred to the surviving spouse by any means will meet the “transferred to” requirement for the marital deduction, even if he decedent is not the person transferring the property.
Qualification for the Marital Deduction
- Terminable Interest
A teminable interet is
- any interest in property passing from a decedent to his surviving spouse where he surviving spouse’s interest in that property will terminate at some point in the future
The terminable interest rule is based on the premise that
- a marital deduction should only be permitted when property passing from the decedent spouse
- to a surviving spouse will be included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate.
There are situations, however, where property left to the surviving spouse will not be included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate.
- For example, if the decedent leaves property in trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse, and the trust gives the spouse the right to receive all income, the right to receive distributions for health, education, maintenance, and support, and the right to demand the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust corpus each year, the spouse will not have a sufficient ownership interest in the property to require an inclusion in her estate.
- The terminable interest rule is designed to prevent the use of the unlimited marital deduction in circumstances where the surviving spouse will not have to include in his gross estate the value of property passing from the deceased spouse.
Qualification for the Marital Deduction
- A Terminble Interest Alone
- Terminable Interest Rule Additional Caveat
A terminable interest, alone, will not prevent the use of the unlimited marital deduction for the transfer.
The marital deduction will not be available if:
- a terminable interest is transferred to a surviving spouse, and
- another interest in the same property passes from the decedent to someone other than the surviving spouse (a third party) for less than full and adequate consideration in money or money’s worth, and
- the third party may possess or use any part of the property after the interest of the surviving spouse terminates.
The terminable interest rule has one additional caveat.
- If the deceased spouse’s will directs his executor to use property included in the gross estate to purchase terminable interest property for the surviving spouse,
- the unlimited marital deduction is not available for that property.
Qualification for the Marital Deduction
- The Exceptions to the Terminable Interest Rule Include:
- Contingency Clauses
Exam Tip: Know these exceptions.
- A six-month survival contingency.
- A terminable interest, either outright or in trust, over which the surviving spouse has a general power of appointment.
- A Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) Trust.
- A Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT) where a spouse is the only noncharitable beneficiary.
In planning large estates, contingency clauses are often used
- to ensure that the combined estates of a married couple make full use of their available applicable estate tax credits and
- to provide for the orderly disposition of the client’s wealth.
Exam Question - Terminable Interests
Which of the following is NOT a terminable interest?
a) An ownership interest in a life insurance policy
b) A life estate in a home.
c) A interest in a patent.
d) An interest in property for a term equal to an individual’s life
Answer: A
The ownership interest of a life insurance policy is not a terminable interest. The ownership interest does not terminate.
All of the other interests listed are terminable interests.
- A life estate is a terminable interest because the interest in the property terminates at the individual’s death.
- An interest in a patent is a terminable interest because a patent right terminates after a certain
period of time. - Answer D describes a life estate, so it is also a terminable interest.
Exam Question - Property Qualifying for the Unlimited Marital Deduction
Anne recently died. Anne is survived by her husband, Edward, and daughter, Catherine. Which of the following would be a qualifying property transfer for the purposes of the unlimited marital deduction?
a) Anne leaves ownership of certain copyrights to Edward.
b) Property transferred to a credit shelter trust for the benefit of Catherine, with Edward as the trustee.
c) Anne leaves her beach house to Edward, subject to the condition that if Edward does not survive Anne’s sister, Anne’s sister will get the property.
d) The $1,000,000 life insurance policy on Anne’s life owned by Edward.
Answer: A
Although copyrights are terminable interests, no person other than Edward has any interest in the property, since all rights were given to Edward. Therefore, the transfer of the copyrights to
Edward will qualify for the marital deduction.
Answer B does not qualify for the unlimited marital deduction because even though Edward is trustee, and has legal title to the property inside the trust, he does not have beneficial title to the property.
Answer C does not qualify for the unlimited marital deduction because the transfer to Edward is a terminable interest.
Answer D does not qualify for the unlimited marital deduction because the proceeds of a life insurance policy owned by Edward on Anne’s life will not be included in Anne’s gross estate.
Outright Bequests to the Spouse
The simplest way to qualify the transfer of property for the unlimited marital deduction is to transfer property directly to the surviving spouse.
- Many individuals prefer this method, since the surviving spouse has complete control over the property during his lifetime.
While an outright transfer to the surviving spouse is simple and gives the surviving spouse complete control over the property,
- it may be more appropriate to limit the surviving spouse’s control over the property through the use
of a trust.
In situations where the surviving spouse is not capable of managing assets or may need protection from current and future creditors,
- a transfer in trust should be considered.
- Once a transfer to the surviving spouse is accomplished through the use of a trust, a terminable interest results, potentially disqualifying the transfer for the marital deduction.
There are two types of trusts,
- General Power of Appointment Trusts and
- QTIP Trusts,
- which can be created to protect property for a decedent’s heirs and still qualify for the unlimited marital deduction. These trusts are addressed below
General Power of Appointment (GPOA) Trusts
A General Power of Appointment (GPA) Trust, also known as an “A Trust,”
- creates a terminable interest for a surviving spouse
- that will nevertheless require the unconsumed assets to be included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate and
- thus qualify the transfer of the property to the trust or the unlimited marital deduction.
To qualify for the marital deduction, the trust must grant to the surviving spouse a power to appoint the trust
- property to himself,
- his estate,
- his creditors, or
- the creditors of his estate.
A general power of appointment trust that only grants the surviving spouse the power to appoint the property to his estate is referred to as an estate trust.
- Unlike a normal power of appointment trust, an estate trust does not require the annual distribution of income to the surviving spouse.
- Note, however, that if income is accumulated in an estate trust, such accumulated income is included in the surviving spouse’s gross estate in addition to the original principal of the trust.
- For the trust to qualify, no one other than the surviving spouse can have a beneficial interest in the trust.
- Upon the surviving spouse’s death, the trusts assets must pass to the spouse’s estate.
- Estate trusts are useful for passing nonincome producing property since there is no statutory requirement for the trust to produce income. The trustee controls the trust assets during the spouse’s lifetime.
Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) Trusts
Use of a Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) Trust, also known as a “C Trust,”
- allows a decedent to qualify a transfer for the marital deduction at his death yet still control the ultimate disposition of the property.
A QTIP Trust holds property
- for the benefit of a surviving spouse and
- makes income distributions to the surviving spouse at least annually.
- At the surviving spouse’s death, the trust property will transfer to the remainder beneficiary as determined by the grantor of the QTIP Trust, the first-to-die spouse.
In order to qualify as a QTIP Trust, the following requirements must be met:
- The property transferred to the trust must qualify for the unlimited marital deduction.
- Consequently, it must be in the gross estate of the first-to-die spouse and must be transferred to the surviving spouse (in this case, in trust).
- The surviving spouse is entitled to all of the trust income for her life and that income must be paid at
least annually.- If the trust earns income during the surviving spouse’s lifetime that is not distributed as of the date of the surviving spouse’s death, the trust must distribute this income to the surviving spouse’s estate (this is referred to as “stub income”).
- The surviving spouse must have the authority to compel the trustee to sell nonincome-producing investments and reinvest those proceeds in income-producing investments.
- During the surviving spouse’s lifetime, no one can have the right to appoint the property to anyone other
than the surviving spouse. - The transferor or his executor must file an election to treat the trust as a QTIP Trust on the
- transferor’s gift tax return (Form 709) or
- the decedent’s federal estate tax retum (Form 706).
Planning for the Non-Citizen Spouse
- Unlimited Estate Tax Marital Deduction
The unlimited estate tax marital deduction is not available for an outright bequest to a surviving spouse if the
- surviving spouse is not a US citizen.
For non-citizen spouses, there is a special annual exclusion amount of
- $175,000 (2023) available for lifetime transfers by a citizen spouse to a non-citizen spouse.
Exam Question - Transfers to Non-US Citizen Spouses
Amanda has been married to Javier for 25 years. Javier is a Honduran citizen. Amanda would like to make an inter vivos transfer to Javier. What is the maximum amount that Amanda can transfer to Javier without incurring transfer taxes or utilizing her applicable credit during 2023?
a) $0
b) $17,000
c) $175,000
d) $250,000
Answer: C
There is a special annual exclusion for non-citizen spouses of $175,000. A spouse can transfer up to $175,000 to her non-citizen spouse without incurring gift taxes.
Exam Question - Transfers to Non-US Citizen Spouses
Miguel and Jane have been married for 45 years. Miguel is a citizen of Mexico, where the couple has lived for the past 25 years. Given the following list of separate property owned by Jane, and considering Jane’s will leaves everything to Miguel outright, what amount would qualify for the unlimited marital deduction?
- A California home valued at $1,000,000.
- Mexican property valued at $450,000.
- The contents of the California home valued at $100,000
- An investment account held at a New York City bank valued at $500,000
a) $0
b) $175,000
c) $5,113,800
d) $5,490,000.
Answer: A
Because the property is transferred outright to a non citizen spouse, it does not qualify for the unlimited marital deduction
Planning for the Non-Citizen Spouse
- Remedy to this Problem
- Individuals Who Do Not Wish to Obtain US Citizenship
One remedy to this problem is having the non-US citizen surviving spouse become a US citizen
- before the due date of estate tax return and
- maintain residency in the United States following the death of the decedent-spouse.
If both of these conditions are met,
- the transfer to the surviving spouse will qualify for the unlimited estate tax marital deduction.
- Upon the death of the surviving spouse, the US will be able to collect an estate tax on the value of the remaining assets.
For individuals who do not wish to obtain US citizenship, the citizen-spouse, or the executor of the citizen-spouse’s estate, can create a
- Qualified Domestic Trust (QDOT) A QDOT will allow the US government to subject remaining assets to estate taxation upon the death of the non-citizen surviving spouse.
- In order to qualify the DOT for the unlimited marital deduction, the following requirements must be met:
- at least one of the ODOT trustees must be a US citizen or a US domestic corporation;
- the trust must prohibit a distribution of principal unless the US citizen trustee has the right to withhold estate tax on the distribution;
- the trustee must keep a sufficient amount of the trust assets in the United States to ensure the payment of federal estate taxes,
- or the trustee must have a minimum net worth sufficient to assure the payment of estate taxes upon the death of the non-citizen surviving spouse; and
- the executor of the citizen-spouse’s estate must elect to have the marital deduction apply to the trust.
Exam Question QDOT’s
In which of the following situations would the use of a QDOT be appropriate?
a) Tom dies and is survived by his wife, Tina, who is not a US citizen.
b) Regina dies and is survived by her husband, Raul, who becomes a US citizen two months after Regina’s death.
c) Harold dies and does not have a surviving spouse
d) Franz, who is not a US citizen, dies and is survived by his wife, Francine, who is a US
citizen.
Answer: A
Answer B does not describe a situation in which the use of a QDOT would be appropriate because Raul became a US citizen prior to the due date of the estate tax return and therefore, any property transfers to Raul would qualify for the unlimited marital deduction.
Answer C is not correct because there is no reason to use a QDOT if Harold does not have a surviving spouse.
Answer D is not correct because a QDOT is used when the surviving spouse is not a US citizen
Alternative to Qualifcation
At first glance, the unlimited marital deduction appears to be a planning panacea once you qualify for the marital deduction, there is no estate tax on the value of the property at the death of the first spouse.
- Remember, however, that the marital deduction is only a deferral device; it is available in the first spouse’s estate only if the assets transferred will be available to be taxed in the surviving spouse’s gross estate.
In estate planning, it is important to avoid qualifying too many assets for the marital deduction.
- In 2023, an individual can pass up to $12,920,000 of assets to a nonspouse during their lifetime or at death without triggering federal transfer tax.
- Prior to 2011, when an individual left his entire estate to the surviving spouse, the applicable estate tax credit equivalency was lost and could not be retrieved.
- The Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance, Reauthorization and Job Creation Act of 2010 implemented the applicable estate tax credit portability feature.
- The exclusion amount is portable between spouses. This means that if one spouse dies and leaves all of their assets to the other spouse, the exclusion is not lost as was the case before. Now the surviving spouse is able to use any remaining exclusion not utilized by their last spouse to die.
- When too many assets pass to a surviving spouse, resulting in an increase in overall estate taxes for the Family when the surviving spouse dies, the unlimited marital deduction is said to be overqualified.
- The portability feature is only applicable if both spouses die after December 31, 2010.
- The law of the estate exclusion states that the unused exclusion amount is that amount not utilized by the last spouse” to die. Therefore, in the event that a surviving spouse remarries and is predeceased again, the unused exclusion amount from the first decedent spouse is wasted.
Exam Question
Yana and Bill are married and in the process of establishing their estate plan. Currently they only have simple mutual wills in place. Yana’s gross estate is worth $4 million and Bill’s is $3 million. Bill has made a cumulative taxable gift to his children from his first marriage of $2 million in the current year. If Bill dies this year before completing their new estate plan, how much of Bill’s unused applicable exclusion amount is available for Yana?
a) None
b) $2,000,000
c) $10,920,000
d) $12,920,000
Answer: C
Bill made taxable gifts of $2 million, which he paid no gift tax on due to the applicable exemption amount. Therefore, he has reduced his exemption amount from $12,920,000 to $10,920,000. His entire estate is then transferred to his wife so none of the remaining $3 million in his gross estate is taxable. So the total unused exclusion is $10,920,000
Exam Question
Joe and Holly are married and have a combined net worth of $8 million. Holly unexpectedly dies due to congestive heart failure leaving Joe $3 million of her $4 million gross estate. The other $1 million is split evenly between their two children. Five years pass and Joe is remarried to Chartreuse who inherited $2 million dollars from her father. Chartreuse has established her will leaving all of her assets to her children from a first marriage and excluding Joe, since she believes he has enough of his own assets. Chartreuse predeceases Joe due to a car accident. How much unused exclusion amount is available for Joe’s estate to utilize if all the proper electons were made at Holly and Chartreuse’s deaths?
a) $10,920,000
b) $11,920,000
c) $12,920,000
d) $13,920,000
Answer: A
The unused exclusion amount is based on the “last deceased spouse.” Holly’s unused exclusion does not matter. It was effectively wasted. Chartreuse has $2 million, which is left to her children, meaning $2 million of her $12,920,000 exclusion is being utilized. Therefore, Joe’s estate may utilize her $10,920,000 unused exclusion.
Assume in this example that Joe wanted to be able to utilize Holly’s exclusion. He could accomplish this by transferring assets to the children before Chartreuse’s death. Ifhe transfers $3 million to the children at any time before Chartreuse’s death then he will first apply the unused exclusion that was ported over from Holly. He will retain his own exclusion. Then when Chartreuse dies he can also port over her unused exclusion.
Alternative to Qualifcation
- Example of Unsued Exclusion Amount
Alternative to Qualifcation
- Unlimited Maritial Deduction Can Be Underqualified
In contrast, the unlimited marital deduction can also be underqualified.
- Underqualification means that too much of the decedent’s property was subject to estate tax at the death of the first spouse due to a failure to make adequate use of the unlimited marital deduction.
Alternative to Qualifcation
- A Bypass Trust
A bypass trust (sometimes referred to as a credit shelter trust, or “B Trust”) is used to ensure that an individual can make full use of his applicable estate tax credit amount.
- Instead of overqualifying the marital deduction by leaving all property to the surviving spouse,
- a bypass trust is created to receive property with a FMV equal to the decedent’s remaining applicable estate tax exemption ($12,920,000 in 2023) from the decedent’s gross estate,
- while the remainder of the property passes to the surviving spouse (either outright, or through the use of a GPOA Trust or QTIP Trust).