Media Influence On Pro-social Behaviour Flashcards
What did Cumberbatch argue about the difference between measuring anti social acts and pro social acts?(1)
- Cumberbatch argued that anti-social acts are easier to measure and count compared to pro-social acts as pro social acts are more subtle
What are the two theories explaining how media influences pro-social behaviour?(2)
- Social Learning Theory
2. Parental Mediation
How does social learning theory explain how media influences pro-social behaviour?(2)
- We observe and imitate models we admire, so if a model is behaving pro-socially then we are likely to imitate the pro-social acts
- Replication of these pro-social acts will depend on whether the individual is positively reinforced for behaving pro-socially
What’s study supports Social Learning Theories explanation of how media influences pro-social behaviour?(1)
- Poulos Lassie study
What was the procedure of Poulos Lassie study and what was found?(2+1)
- Children split into independent groups to watch an episode of Lassie
- Either watched an episode of Lassie where the dog was helped or they watched an episode where the dog was only played with
- Found that those who watched the episode where the dog was helped were more likely to help distressed puppies compared to the other group
Evaluation of Paulos Lassie study(4)
- Demand characteristics
- Children- not completely representative
- Lacks mundane realism
- Individual differences
What have studies found between the age and social learning and what is the reason for what they have found?(2)
- Studies have found that children are only likely to imitate a pro-social act they have socially learned when they can copy that act exactly (concrete learning).
- This is because children do not acquire abstract thoughts until their older.
Overall evaluation of how social learning theory explains media’s affect in pro-social behaviour(2)
- Media has less of an affect compared to real life models, so studies luck external validity
- Research fails to focus on the affects media has in different age groups. Studies tend to focus on children and as adults have better developed brains and have had more life experience, these results cannot be generalised to these adults, thus lowering the external validity of these studies.
What is parental mediation and how does it explain how media influences pro-social behaviour?(2)
- Parental mediation is where a parent discusses disturbing and ambiguous acts, shown in the media, to their child viewer.
- This theory suggests that pro-social acts in the media are more likely to be imitated when a parent discusses with their child why these behaviours and messages are important.
What is the name of the studies that supports Parental Mediation?(2)
- Johnson and Ettema- Free Styles study
2. Sesame Street studies
What did Johnson and Ettema do and find in their Freestyles study?(4+1)
- Large scale study
- 9-12 year olds
- Shown the TV show ‘Freestyles’, a show aimed to reduce sex-role stereotypes, over a 13 week period
- Half of the participants also participated in teacher led discussions post viewing
- Found that all of the participants acted less stereotypically, especially those who took part in the teacher led discussions
Evaluation of Johnson and Ettema’s Freestyles study(2+3)
Positive:
- Large scale study- external validity increased
- Over a decent amount of time (13 weeks)- increases reliability
Negative:
- Demand characteristics- lowers internal validity
- 9-12 year olds- lowers external validity
- Individual differences- lowers internal validity
Name the study that contradicts Parental Mediation(1)
- Rubenstein- Psychotic adolescents
What did Rubenstein et al do and find in their psychotic adolescents study?(1+2)
- Used adolescents who had been hospitalised for psychiatric problems
- Found that after post viewing discussions they were less likely to act altruistically
- Thought to be because they wanted to act independently so opposed to the adults opinions
Evaluation of Rubenstein’s Psychotic Adolescents study (3)
- Psychotic adolescents- lowers external validity
- Demand characteristics
- Unethical- not right frame of mind