Media - Paper 2 Flashcards
Paper 2
What are some examples of traditional media?
- Terrestrial
- Newspapers
- Books
- Radio (if accessed through is internet is new media)
- CD
- DVD
- MP3
What are some examples of new media?
- Cable and satellite TV
- The internet
- Smartphones
- Computer games
- Online magazines
- Advertising
Why do sociologists study the media?
The media plays a huge role in our lives because we live in a ‘media saturated society’ (postmodernists). The media is an important source of information and influences our identity and what we buy
How does the media impact our behaviour?
- Influences our views on social groups e.g., hate groups
- Norms and values
- Likes and dislikes
- Stereotypes
- Can impact mental health - self esteem, body image
- Work ethic
- Voting behaviour - politicians use media for campaigns
- Deviant behaviour - normalising violence
- Trends - buying behaviour
- Pester power
What does Marcuse say about the media?
Transmits mass culture which is injected into the hearts of the population through ruling class propaganda. Eat out to help out exploited us because the economy was suffering. Put people at risk - fake caring face of capitalism, benefits ruling class
What does Norris say about the media and voting behaviour?
Media can influence voting behaviour/ During Brexit, the media was used highly to campaign for leave or remain. Politicians can use strategies that they know will have a big influence on people’s views. Alan Sugar said Brexit would be a disaster for the UK
What is the hypodermic syringe model?
Suggests the media acts like a hypodermic syringe, injecting media tests into the veins of audiences. They are passive and unthinking receivers of media texts who are unable to resist messages. Media can fill audiences with dominant ideology, audience then immediately acts on these messages
Who says the hypodermic syringe model does exist?
Marxists and Feminists
How would Postmodernists criticise the hypodermic syringe model?
Outdated because the media is so large that they can form their own views. We have an active audience in society so people have free will.
People on benefits = scroungers –> Benefit Britain and other programmes –> Stereotypical views and prejudice, cultural devision and marginalisation
What do feminists say about the hypodermic syringe model?
There is a casual link between porn and sexual violence. Morgan and Dworkin
What does Morgan say? (HSM)
Porn is theory and rape is practice
What does Dworkin say? (HSM)
Porn trivialises rape and encourages men to abuse and inflict pain on women - can affect marriage as men and women are less supportive of marriage
What does Malmuth say? (HSM)
Porn only worsens the behaviour of those who are already aggressive and for the majority has no negative effects
What are the criticisms of the hypodermic syringe model?
- Model assumes that entire audiences are passive and will react in the same way. A person’s own experience may play a part e.g., some people may laugh at violent scenes as they feel uncomfortable. People of different ages and social class will have different reactions to the media
- It assumes audiences are passive, gullible and easily manipulated. People do not believe everything seen on the media. People are more aware of things being false on the media and were often critical of what we see. Active audience - opinions - postmodernists
- It assumes the media have enormous power and influence over-riding all other socialisation. Social classes can have a large impact on attitudes and behaviour. We are all brought up in different ways. Home life - family set up, peers in education
- Little evidence that media content has the immediate effects on the audience. It is hard to study the effects and impact of media because different age and social groups consume different media so it is impossible to measure effects. Postmodernists - free will. Just because you consume it it doesn’t mean that you will copy the behaviour
What does Buckingham say?
Children are much more media literate as they have grown up with many forms of media so know the difference between what is real and fiction
What are some examples of copycat crime?
Violent media causes copycat crime - HSM
James Bulger and Columbine
How does Bandura support the idea of media causing violence
- Showed 3 groups a film containing a Bobo doll. In some, the adult was being aggressive towards the doll and some were friendly.
- He found that those who watched the aggressive role models in the film also showed the same behaviour
- He concluded that media content leads to copycat behaviour
What do McCabe and Martin say about media violence?
The Disinhibition Effect - they argue that the media has this effect - it convinces children that in some situations the normal rules of society can be abandoned and instead we can resolve conflict in violence
What does Newson say about media violence?
Desensitisation
Noted that children and teenagers are subjected to thousands of killings and acts of violence as they grow up through watching television and films. She suggested that such prolonged exposure to media violence may have a ‘drip-drip’ effect on young people over the course of their childhood and result in their becoming desensitised to violence. They become socialised into accepting violent behaviour as normal
How have people tried to tackle the issue of media violence?
Age restrictions but people still find access e.g., no verification
Who criticises media violence?
Buckingham, Fesbach and Sanger, Jock Young, Gauntlett
How does Buckingham criticise media violence?
children are more media literate and know the difference between real and fictional violence
How do Fesbach and Sanger criticise media violence? (Catharsis)
They found that screen violence is a safe outlet for people with aggressive tendencies - Catharsis. They looked at violent TV and the impact on teens and found that those that saw aggressive behaviour on TV were less aggressive
Someone with aggressive tendencies will be able to use video games with a violent aspect e.g., shooting or fighting, to take out the anger. Instead of doing it in real life, they’re doing it fictionally
How does Jock Young criticise media violence?
Sensitisation seeing the effects of violence - pain and suffering makes us more aware of the consequences for committing offence so puts people off violence