module six Flashcards
(26 cards)
intersectionality
- mainstream feminism wasnt for all women, but for a specific subgroup of women, the white middle-class
- at the micro and macro level, intersectionality is at play and needs to be recognized in feminist work
- believes privilege and oppression can only exist in relation each other
intersectionality - micro and macro levels
- micro: we occupy multiple status positions in the larger social structure that all intersect at the micro level in the way we understand ourselves/identities/subjectivities
- macro: larger social structures and processes; intersectionality draws our attention to the ‘matrix of domination’
intersectionality - privilege and oppression
- our experiences of privilege and oppression are rooted in those same status positions that we occupy
- within the ‘matrix of domination,’ each one of us might be privileged in certain ways and be oppressed in others
- this is why we see resistance to social changes that lead in the direction of greater equality between groups b/c no one wants to lose their privilege
- e.g. you can only experience privilege if another group is experiencing oppression
- e.g. patriarchal society; a certain man might experience privilege of being a man in a patriarchal society while also experiencing oppression being black, poor, or queer
Canadian ethnic patterns
- Canadians have >200 different ethnic origins
- Canadians speak >450 “mother tongues” or “primary languages spoken at home”
- approx. 5% of people are Indigenous
- 23% of people were born abroad
- 32% of youth ages 15 and under have a parent who was born abroad
top 3 countries for immigration
- china
- india
- philippines
future immigration trends
- 24-30% will be born abroad and come to Canada as immigrants or refugees
- 44-50% will be born abroad or have parents who were born abroad
- 26-31% will have a mother tongue other than English or French
- 35-40% will belong to a visible minority group
- the top cities current for immigration are believed to remain the same; being toronto, vancouver and montreal
bicultural/hybrid adaptation patterns
- bicultural/hybrid identity: young people that straddle the boundary between 2 different cultures, their heritage culture and the dominant national culture in the country they currently live in
- adaptation patterns are not solely individual choice; larger structural and systemic issues can reflect how bicultural young people adapt and navigate this experience
four core patterns of adaptations
- integration pattern
- ethnic pattern
- national pattern
- diffuse pattern
implications of adaptation
- implications for psychological adjustment = overall mental health and wellbeing
- implications for sociocultural adjustment = extent to which young people felt accepted and like they belonged in their community, at school, etc
integration pattern
- reflected young people whose ethnic identities combined both their heritage culture and the dominant national culture
- combining/blending elements of both cultures
- best overall adjustment outcome, meaning they demonstrated high self-esteem, absence of anxiety or depression, positive self-concepts and felt as though they fit in
ethnic pattern
- reflected in young people who said their ethnic identities were built primarily or exclusively on their heritage culture
- positive psychological adjustment but more negative socio-cultural adjustment
national pattern
- reflected in young people who said their ethnic identities were built primarily or exclusively on the dominant national culture where they currently live/immigrated too
- negative psychological adjustment but positive socio-cultural adjustment
diffuse pattern
- reflected in young people who did not report any ethnic identity and don’t identify with either their heritage or national culture
- felt they didn’t fit in anywhere or were a part of either culture
- worst overall adjustment outcome b/c they exhibited low self-esteem and higher anxiety and depression, and felt as though they didn’t fit in anywhere
ethnic identity - creese (2019)
- Interviewed young adults of African descent living in Vancouver about their daily lives and ethnic backgrounds
- regardless of how they self-identify or where they were born, the reality was that being Black marks them as “outsiders” and impacted their understanding of themselves and Canadian society
- often asked, “where are you from?” and found that the people posing those questions only took certain answers as being legitimate
- ethnic identities are fluid
ethnic identities as fluid
- fluid nature of identity and how their understandings of their ethnicity are shaped by those they interact with and the social contexts they are in
- e.g. visiting their home country, they identify as Canadian but when interacting with white Canadians they identified as black, and when interacting with other black canadians they identify with their heritage culture
reconciliation and Indigenous youth
- Indigenous youth have a specific range of experiences in society because of colonization
- this aspect is what makes Indigenous experiences unique from those of immigrants b/c, for immigrants, there is a sense of voluntary assimilation
- several generations of Indigenous children grew up in residential schools rather than with their families
- the exploitation of Indigenous peoples and involuntary coercive assimilation into the dominant culture of the colonizers is still impactful on the culture and experiences of Indigenous youth today
proportions of Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations 14 yrs and under
- 26.7% Indigenous population
- 16% non-indigenous
proportions of Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations 15-24
- 16% indigenous population
- 12% non-indigenous
average age of the indigenous population in Canada
- the average age of the Indigenous population in Canada is 33.6
- they tend to have higher birth rates and shorter life spans, which contributes to the younger average ages
- over 40% of the Indigenous population is under 24
two themes are reflected in the research participants’ views of culture
- perception of cultural differences
- elusive concepts of Chinese and Canadian cultures
perception of cultural differences
- illustrated in multiple examples such as:
- teaching styles adopted by Canadian versus Chinese school teachers
- parenting styles
- school, workplace and family contexts
teaching styles as perceptions of cultural differences
- Chinese education system tends to enforce strict discipline on students, prescribe a rigid academic path, impose heavy academic pressure and emphasize the merits of good grades
- the Canadian education system is characterized by smaller class sizes, laid-back teaching style, play-oriented classes, emphasis on extracurricular activities and interactive, vibrant school atmospheres
parenting styles as perceptions of cultural differences
- Chinese parents are more likely to adopt authoritarian parenting in raising their children and hope their children become academically successful, hardworking and overall perfect at everything
- Chinese parents also deem physical punishment acceptable and necessary to achieve those goals.
- it is perceived that Canadian parents often follow an egalitarian parenting style that involves open expression of their love and affection toward their children.
contexts as perceptions of cultural differences
- Across contexts, it was noted by participants that power hierarchy, relationship harmony, and unconditional respect for the elderly are endorsed in Chinese culture
- In Western culture, “respect should be something that needs to be earned.”
- In the workplace, participants noted that the influence of Chinese cultural values on work ethic, independence, emotional stability, hard work, and achieving goals through moral means