Pleading Flashcards
(19 cards)
Complaint
sets out the plaintiff’s allegations against the defendant
- must state facts, theory of law supporting claim, and remedy
- Defense can say there are missing facts or no legal theory
Responsive pleading is and includes
Is the document that responds to the complaint and
Includes answer and counterclaims
Cause of action is
allegations where if you can prove the relevant facts P is going to recover
Three Requirements for Federal Complaints
- Jurisdictional allegations (subject matter)
- There must be a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief
- Demand for judgement
Conley Standard for Complaint
Complaint should not be dismissed for failure to state a claim unless it appears beyond doubt that the plaintiff can prove no set of facts in support of his claim which would entitle him to relief
Can you put two allegations that can’t both be true in a complaint
Yes
- Rule 8d2-3
When alleging fraud or mistake must
Provide the details of the allegation
- Rule 9b
Twombly Standard for Complaint
Facts must be sufficient to create a reasonable expectation of illegality (plausibility)
- Identify the legal theory/elements of the claim
- Accept all nonconclusory allegations as true
- Based on what is left, is the claim plausible
Responding to the complaint three options
- Ignore the complaint
- Answer the complaint
- Motion to dismiss under rule 12
If the complaint is ignored
default judgement
- rule 55
- P must file asking for default judgement and asking for what they want
- Default can be set aside for good cause
Must make all plausible Rule
12 defenses because if not stated they are waived
Rule 12b Motions
1) No subject matter jurisdiction
2) No personal jurisdiction
3) Improper venue
4 &5) Improper Notice and Service Process
6) Failure to state a claim
Exception fo Omnibus rule (join all 12 motions)
If the action was not available when the first action was filed
Affirmative Defenses
Regardless of whether or not i did it I’m still not liable
Procedural Objection
Regardless of whether I did it or not, something about the way the case was brought was flawed so it must be dismissed
Rule 11b Reasonable Inquiry
Requires a reasonable inquiry under the circumstances and not for improper purpose, frivolous legal contentions, factual allegations that lack support and are not likely to have support, or denying facts without justification
- must be written
Amendment at a matter of right
Can always amend 21 days after filing or 21 days after the answer to amend the original pleading if statute of limitations has not expired
- only once
Preparation prejudice
won’t have time to prepare an answer/defense to the amendment
For statute of limitations to relate back
- Must have opposing party’s written consent or court’s leave which should be given freely if justice requires
- If there is a common nucleus of operative facts then the statute of limitations can relate back
- If new facts or claims that require new investigation not allowed to relate back