PO MIDTERM 1 Flashcards

(68 cards)

1
Q

What are the 5 principles of politics?

A
  1. Rationality principle
  2. Institution principle
  3. Collective Action prinicple
  4. Policy Principle
  5. History Principle
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

How do analyze grpahs/stats

A
  1. Obervation (what do you see: patterns)
  2. Analytical (use prior knowledge: trend, what is the cause?)
  3. Normative (Value judgement? Is this okay?)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What is the Rationalilty Principle?

A

All Political behavior has a puropse
-Political actions are purposeful, not random; often done with forethought and is calculated
-Political actors pursue policy preferences, reelection, and power and aim to mazimize their agency budgets

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What is the Institution Principle?

A

*Institutions structure politics *
-Institutions: Rules and procedures that provide incentives for political behavior
-Have the power to discourage conflict, encourage coordination & enable barganing, thus facilitating decision making
-Institutions are not necessarily permanant–>Rules chaneg; they just don’t change easily
-Institutions act as script & core card

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

5 ways institutions provide politicians with authority?

A
  1. Jurisdiction
  2. Agenda
  3. Veto power
  4. Decisiveness
  5. Delegation
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is Jurisdiction

(Institutions)

A

Jurisdiction is the domain over which an institution or a member of it has authority
-Ex: proposed legislation regarding the military must pass through the Armed Services Committee before the entire House or Senate can consider it

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is Agenda Power?

(Institutions)

A

Agenda power describes who determines what will be taken up for consideration in an institution
-Act as “Gatekeepers” –> Having the power to make proposals and the power to block proposals from being made

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is Veto Power?

(Institutions)

A

Veto power is the ability to defeat something even if it does become apart of the agenda
-President has no gatekeeping or agenda power, but does have limited veto
-Ex: President cannot interupt Congress from passing a measure bc Congress has its own agenga, but once passed President can veto

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is Decisiveness Rules?

(Institutions)

A

Desiciveness rules specify when votes may be taken, the sequence in which votes occur, and how many individuals supporting a mortion are sufficient for it to pass
-Basically allows legislation to “move” –> need to debate to get measure to close and get of the floor

**Essentially the rules for decision manking
or
How a policy making body choses to conduct itself
**

Ex: Supermajority (60 votes) is required to close a debate

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is Delegation?

(Institutions)

A

Delegation is representing democracy. Citizens, through voting, delegate authority to make desicions on their behalf to representitives, rather than exercising political authority directly
-Essentially, think of political representatives as our agents who act on our behalf
-Transmission of authority to some other official or body
-Principles (ppl with pwr) can load off “delegate” to specialists taks that they themselves arent capable of doing (transfering authority/pwr to another)

Keep in mind: principle-agent relationship

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Principal-Agent relationship

A

Principle: The political actors w/ power and authority
Agent: The political actor who recieves delegated pwr from the principal

Problems: Incompatability, Transaction costs and monitoring

EX: Micahel Scott delegate pwr to Creed to take care of things
Problems: Creed has different goals a Michael, creed doesn’t do his job

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What is the Collective Action Principle?

A

*All Politics is Collective Action *
-Political action requires biilding, combining, mixing, & uniting peoples individual goals
-Collective Action= the pooling of resources and teh coordination of effort and activity by a group of ppll to achieve a common goal (making arrangements)

-Collective action is difficult, it becomes more difficult as teh number of ppl and interest involved grow

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Formal vs Informal Barganing

(Collective Action Principle)

A

Informal Bargening= Highly formal or entirely informal, not a legally binding agreement

Formal Bargening= Associated w/ events in offical institutions

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What is Free Riding?

(Collective Action Principle)

A

Benefiting from the efforts of few without contributing themselves

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is Public Good?

(Collective Action Principle)

A

A benefit that other cannot be denied from enjoying once it has been provided

-Nobody can achieve a piblic good by themselves

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What is Tragedy of the Commons?

(Collective Action Principle)

A

Depletion of a common resource due to individuals’ overuse of it

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What is the Policy Principle?

A

Political outcomes are the products of individual preferences, institutional procedures, and collective action
-Policy principle is the results of the political process - A collection of decisions

Personal interests +
Electoral ambitions+
Institutional ambtitions
=Polocies–> the procduct of insititional procedures & individual aspirations (series fo shutes and ladders)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What is the History Principle?

A

How we got her matters
-Path dependency- Suggest that some possiblities are more or less likely b/c of earlier events & choices

3 factors help explain why history matters in poltical life:
1. Rule and procedures
2. Loyalties & Alliances
3. Hostorically conditioned points of view

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What is Politics?

A

-Conflicts over the character, membership, and policies of a group of people
-Resolving conflict: voting, dictator, bargening

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What is Government?

A

-An institution in society that was a monoply on the ligitimate use of force
-Governments can be simple or complex (councils or state) (can be informal too like “family politics”
-Rules by which a land of ppl are governed

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

First Founding:

What were the Conflicting Interests?

A

-13 colonies w/ their own economic interests
-Loyalists vs Revolutionaries
-Large vs Small states
-North vs South (disagreed over land use/tarrifs, economic conflict)
-Federalists vs Anti-federalists
(Federalists=large gov)
(Anti-federalists=small gov)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

First Founding:

Coloniel Elite vs Radical Groups

A

Conloniel Elite: Conlonial taxation divides these groups
-New England Merchants
-Southern Plantation Owners
-Royalists

Radical Groups:
-Shopkeepers, artisans, laborers
-Small farmers

Both groups agreed over idea that they don’t want to be taxed

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

First Founding:

Continental Congress & The Revolution

A

Continental Congress:
-First continental Congress (1774) : boycott British goods, begin considering independence
-Second Continenal Congress (1776): Declaration of Independence (breakup letter LOL) –> justification for resisting Monarchy, define unalienable rights, result of collective action, not legal document
Declaration does NOT create a new government

Revolutionary war: (1775-1783)
-Asymmetric conflict: colonies did not need to defeat the British; just needed to make them leave

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

First Founding:

Articles of Confederation

A

-First Constitution (1777-1789)
-States had most of the pwr (decentrilization)
-Congress only national institution (states enforeced national laws)
-Each state had one vote in Congressm members chosen and paid by state legislatures (citizens had no direct role in national government)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
# First Founding Fall of Articles of Confederation
-Congress can't levy taxes or regulate commerce -Each stae has independent foreign policy -No executive or judiciary -Gov could not act decisively (thus Shays rebellion was so sucessful)---> farmer w/ limited artillary, rebellion was wake up call to changes in confederation | Summary--> National gov could not solve collective action problems
26
# Second Founding Constitutional Convention (1787)
-initially convened to advise AofC -AofC failures convinced delegates they needed a different approach Delegates' interests and Ideas: -Philosophical: individual liberty, popular sovereignty: citizens delegate power to government -Economic: Founders benefited economically from new constitution, protected trade, prperty rights and commerce
27
# Second Founding Slavery
-Divided Southern (slave) and Northern (non-slave) states -Southern states demanded that slaves be counted as part of population for House seats -Three-Fifths Compromise: 5 slave states counted as 3 citizens for House appointment -Slavery eventually devided by Civil War, compromise could not hold
28
# Second Founding Great Compromise
Virginia Plan: -Strong national government -Proportional representation in both chambers of a bicameral Congress -National government can veto state laws New Jersey Plan: -Weak national government -Equal representation of states **=Conneticut Compromise: ** -Bicameral legislature -Proportional representationn in the House (lower chamber) -Equal representation in Senate (upper chamber) | Compromise was preferable in the status quo
29
What is the Constitution?
-Foundational document -Focal point in American Politics today Historical Context: -Few sources of guidance -Lots of conflict -But, terrible status quo Articles: Article 1- Legislative Branch Article 2- Executive Branch Article 3- Judicial Branch Article 4- The States Article 5-Amendment Process Article 6-The States Cont. Articel 7- Ratification
30
# Constitution: Article 1 | Legislative Branch
-Constitution begins with Congress -Bicameral (2 chambers) --> House & Senate -Specifies qualifications & terms of members -Ennumerates Congress's powers (necessary and proper clause) *House:* -Seats appointed by population -Every member elected every 2 years -Members elected *House Powers:* -Elects a speaker and other officies -Brings articles of impeachment -Sole power to prupose revenue *Senate:* -Every state gets 2 -6 year term. 1/3 elected every 2 years -30+ years old -Citizen for 9+ years *Senate Power:* -Vice President is President of Senate; Acts as tiebreaker -Court of imeachment (2/3 vote); chief Justi epresides -Sole power to reatify treaties and approve presidential appointments
31
# Constitution: Article 2 | Executive Branch
* The Electoral College * Accept ambassadors * Negotiat treaties * Commander in chief of the armed forces * Grant repriece and pardons (check on judiciary) * Power of appointment (judges and ecexutive branch individuals) * Convene Congress in special session (force Congress to come to DC for large problems) * Power to Veto legislation **Checks on Presidential Power:** * Treaties require Senate approval * Veotes can be overridden by 2/3 vote in each chamber of Congress * Appointments are subject to "advice and consent" of the Senate (hearing for pres appintees ie. Judge)
32
# Constitution The Electoral College | (Article 2)
Incentivises candidates to win states (hopefully with high amount of electoral votes) instead of individual votes * Mechanism for indirect election * Each state sends electors to the electoral college: # of representatives=2, state legislture decides how to allocate (can divide electors proportional like Maine/Nabraska or do winner takes all) **In most states all electors are allocated to state popular vote winner** * If no majority- top 3 candidates are voted on in the House. Each state gets 1 vote * Pipular vote (election day in Nov.) doesn't matter of electoral college votes Ex: Clinton vs. Trump 2016)
33
# Consitution Article 3 | Judicial Branch
-Arbitrates disputed btw states and Fed Gov -Courts is supreme: rulings are superior to laws adopted by states -Jurisdiction over controversies between citizens of different states (diversity Jurisdiction) -Justices given lifetime appointments with “good behavior” -President appoints judges; Senate confirms (The only court the Constitution creates is the Supreme Court)
34
Article 4 & 6
-Article IV provide reciprocity among the states through “full faith and credit” and “privileges and immunities” (ex: recognizing status in one state means status in another state) (each states recognizes the legality of the other states) -Article VI promotes national power through the national supremacy clause- a clause stating that laws made by the federal government are supreme and superior to state or local laws.
35
# Constitution Article 5 | How to amend the Consitution
How to Amend the Constitution (Built in steps to agree to changes to Constitution) 4 ways: -2 propose -2 ratify -->Proposing an Amendment * By Congress (⅔ vote of House and Senate) OR * By States: (petition by ⅔ of the states) --->Ratifying an Amendment **(CONGRESS CANNOT RATIFY--they can only propose and amendment)** * ¾ of State legislatures OR * ¾ of State Constitutional Conventions Amending the Constitution: -27 Amendments -All initiated by Congress -Six proposed amendments failed state ratification -Bill of Rights : * First 10 Amendments adopted in 1791 * Describes certain rights and liberties
36
# Constitution Article 7 | Ratifying the Constitution
-Nine States must approve -Each state organized a state convention, elected delegates to debate ratification -Federalists vs. Anti-Federalists (Defining moment for republic) *Publius v. Brutus & Centinel
37
# Federalism Federalists
-Alexander H, John J, James Madison -Property owners, merchants, creditors -Believe elites should govern; “excessive democracy” is dangerous * Insulate government from popular control -Strong National Government -Advantages: * Everyone was dissatisfied with AoC * Well-known supporters * Pressure on holdout states (Bullied states in doing ratifying conventions and ratifying)
38
# Federalism Anti-Federalists
-Small farmers, shopkeepers, frontiersman, debtors -Call for another constitutional convention -Main complaints: * Patrick Henry, Sam Adams, George Mason * Creates aristocracy * Federal government too powerful * Too little distinction between branches * No bill of rights
39
What is Federalism?
Federalism is an Institution- about dividing power across multiple sovereigns Federalist 51: -Main thing that is going to keep gov in check is people and voting, but its not enough, need for auxiliary precautions -Madisons auxi Federalism, separation of powers, and bi-cameralism -->Meant to slow government down, and stop abuse of powers Federalsim: -System where power is divided between central and regional governments (national and state) -Two sovereigns whos competition provides limitations on both -Constitutional source: * Provides “expressed” and “implied” powers to the federal government * 10th Amendment reserves remainder of powers to the states ***National government has grown more powerful since Constitution has been ratified, has to do with demands of government and specific policy areas***
40
# Federalism What is Constitutional Source?
=States obligations to each other Full faith and credit: -States must recognize the actions and decisions taken in other states as legal and proper Ex : driver license, Not law license bc states have different laws Privileges and immunities: -A state cannot discriminate against someone from another state or give special privileges to its own residents
41
# Federalism What are Rober Dahl's main arguments about the democratic nature of the elites?
-Critiques undemocratic elements of the Constitution How does he define undemocratic? * Slavery * Suffrage * Election of the President * Choosing Senators * Equal representation * Judicial Power * Congressional Power
42
# Federalism What are the 4 Stages of Federalism
1. Dual Federalism (1789-1937) 2. Cooperative Federalism (1937-1960s) 3. Regulated Federalism (1960s-1990s) 4. New Federalism (1990s-Present)
43
# 4 stages of Fedealism Dual Federalism
(Layer Cake Federalism - two tiers → National gov and State gov) -States exercise the most important powers -Duties and operations of the different levels of government were strictly separated (Does Not blend in substance; strictly separated) * Exception Case: McCulloch v. Maryland: Established the power of the federal government to exercise powers implied by the commerce clause Article I, Section 8, of the Constitution -->The Commerce Clause delegates to Congress the power to “regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes” --->Maryland wants to tax Federal Bank, Fed says no, Maryland says Fed doesn't have power to establish the Fed bank and → Decision, under elastic clause, court says State cannot tax National Bank (supremacy clause into practice [federal and state conflict, federal law wins]) ------>Exception case bc its weird for National gov to assert itself over States
44
# 4 stages of Federalism Cooperative Federalism
(Marble Cake → National gov and State gov) -Marked by supportive relations and partnerships between the federal government and state/local governments * Regulation of things in the Private sector; things that have not been previously regulated * Roosevelt Admin– New Deal * The power shifted into the National government during these times (Great Depression) never goes back --->Gov still have all those powers even after the hard times are over -Rise in “grants-in-aid” –Funds given by Congress to state and local agencies * States have lots of say in how they spend this money * States dealing with how to spend Federal money
45
# 4 stages of Federalism Regulated Federalism
-The federal government dictates national standards states must meet or rules states must follow Ex: National Speed limit. National gov threatened to take withdraw Highway funds if states don't set a 55mph speed limit -A rise in unfunded mandates: national standards or programs imposed on state and local governments without providing funding Ex: American Disability Act; states aren't given funds to comply with ADA standards << Recipe: Regulate Federalism >> National Standards → National Gov mandates the recipe Conditional Grants → State governments are mandated to provide the ingredients Unfunded Mandates Preemption →National gov determines policies; state governments pay for and administer them
46
# 4 stages of Federalism New Federalism
-National policies return more discretion to the states -Rise in block grants -Unfunded Mandates Reform Act -Loosing of federal restrictions on grants-in-aid -Courts interpret the interstate commerce cause more narrowly -Important Case: US v Lopez * Lopez was arrested under the Guns to Free Schools Act because he had a firearm within a certain distance to a school. Argued Congress doesn't have Constitutional authority in commerce for this. Congress cant go that far. << Recipe: New Federalism >> Policies → State governments provide the recipe Laws → National gov provides the ingredients Revenue sharing + Devolution of power + Block Grants = State Governments have more flexibility to make policy and administer programs
47
# Federalsim Issues in Federalism
Healthcare (Individual Mandate): * NFIB V. SEBELIUS (2012) Immigration: * Issue when states believe Fed is not doing enough for regulation of immigration; states are being left to deal with the consequences of immigration * Arizona v. United States (2012) Drugs: * Medical Marijuana, Recreational Cannabis, Safe Injection Sites * Environmental Goals * Right to Die * Voting Regulations
48
Local Gov and the Constitution
-Local government (counties, cities, towns, etc) are not granted any power in the Constitution, as they are creations of the state -Most states have given larger cities in their states home rule: a guarantee of noninterference in local affairs
49
Seperation of Powers | & Madisons Motications
(Division of power horizontally; separation across executive, judicial, legislative branches) Madison’s Motications: -Pessimistic view of human nature (prevent tyranny but putting tyrants against each other) -Designed government around mistrust (create institutions that compete for power) -Believes way to prevent abuse of power is to have branches compete Separation of Powers: -Seeks to limit the power of the federal government by dividing it against itself -A system of mutual vetoes -Each branch is able to participate in and influence the activities of the other branches -Created so no one branch and have complete control over the other branches
50
# Seperation of Powers What is Executive Privilege?
-Executive Privilege+ Presidents can withhold information from Congress Ex: Nixon withholding info abt Watergate -Executive over Judicial Presidential pardons
51
Checks and Balances
Key Terms: Check and Balances Legislative supremacy: * Congress is preeminent and strongest branch * Congress has the most power to check the other branches * House is closest to the people Congress has sole power of appropriations (spending money): * Sets budgets for executive branch and agencies * Sets begets for courts Judicial Review– SCOTUS can declare a law unconstitutional (power not declared in the constitution) : * Established in Marbury v Madison (1803)
52
Divided Government
Divided government: when one party controls the presidency and the other party controls at least one chamber of Congress -Creates further check on executive and legislative power: institutions AND parties must agree on actions -Creates gridlock in politics→ nothing gets done
53
Sate Constitutions
-Generally much longer and more detailed than the US Constitution * U.S. : 8,500 words * Alabama: 345,000 -Easier to amend or replace * Citizens may vote to ratify * Legislatures can put amendments on the ballot * In some states citizens can propose amendments * Amendments are commonly used to make laws
54
Institutional Differences Across State Legislatures
Size: * Lower House: 40 (AK)-400 (NH), Mean= 110 * Upper House 20 (AK)-67 (MN), Mean = 39 Term Length: * Lower House: 2 years * Upper House: 2 or 4 years Term Limits: * Creates more representative body-kicks old ppl out lol Professionalism: session length, salary, staff, resources: * Session length- does this session meet full time, all year? * Salary-what do they pay; on par with other mid level jobs? Adjusted for inflation? * Resources- Do they provide research firms?
55
# State Politics Governors
-Executive power varies across states -Governors elected 2 to 4 years time -Term limits vary by state Other executive officers: -Lieutenant Governor -Attorney General -Secretary of State -Treasurer/ Comptroller -Commissioners: Land, Agriculture, Insurance, Railroad, etc.
56
# State Politics State Courts
-Every state has its own judicial system -Operates in parallel to federal courts -Generally more complex than federal system; more specific types of courts -Significant variation in court structure and judicial selection
57
Congress
-Congress is more independent and powerful than legislatures in other industrialized democracies -Congress has the bulk of government power -Primacy of Congress in the Constitution and level of detail are no coincidence -Article 1 Section 8 * Tax & Spend * Raise an army or navy, declare war * Regulate commerce * Coin money * Make all laws “necessary and proper”
58
# Congress Representation
-A MC(member of Congress)’s primary responsibility is to their constituency * Constituency = citizens who reside in the dirstiric from which an official is elected * Fenno subdivides this idea into overlapping constituencies -Representation encompasses a wide variety of activities -Two views of legislative representation * Delegates- vote according to constituent preferences * Trustees- vote according to what they think is best -Agency representation * Principal agent relationship -Descriptive representation * Racial/Sexuality/Class (HAHAHAHAHA THAT ACE GUY) -Substantive representation * Same motivations and policy preferences (HAHAHA i don't share beliefs of that ACE GUY)
59
# Congress Feno Home Style
-Geographic constituency (largest) -Reelection constituency -Primary constituency -Personal constituency (smallest)
60
# Congress The Electoral Connection
-Mayhew: politician are ambitious -They want to get reelected, or run for higher office -This means they need to: * Discover preferences fo constituents * Attempt to represent constituents and district effectively -Key activities: advertising, credit-claiming, position-taking * Credit-claiming: Taking credit for having accomplished something
61
# The electoral System Incumbancy
-Incumbency= holding a political office for which one is running -Prodived advantages in elections * Committee assignments * Patronage -->Gov workers giving their constituents gov positions * Pork-barrel legislation -->Directing federal money towards a project in a specific geological area * Fund raising networks * Name recognition
62
# Congress Congressional Districts
-435 total seats (since 1929) -Every 10 years, House districts must be reappointed to reflect population changes -The way district boundaries are drawn can advantage on part over another, this is gerrymandering
63
# Legistlative Organization House & Senate differences
-Congress is bicameral: two chambers -House is larger * More centeralized (power concentrated in party leadership) * More organized process (for lawmaking) * Stronger leaders * Policy specialists * Smaller, more homogenous districts -Senate is smaller * More deliberative * Members have individual power (deventrilized power) * Policy generalists * Districts are states -Chamber rules are set by the members themselves as they pursue individual and collective interests
64
# Legislative Organization Problems with Legislative Organization
-Division of Labor -Gather and process information -Agenda setting * What are we gonna talk about and what order -Rules and procedures * Like when passing bills -Place limits on discussion * How long are they going to talk about things -Cooperation, coalitions, compromise
65
# Legislative Organization Structures to help problems of Legislative Organization
**Party leadership** -Party organization is not in the Constitution -Parties meet at the beginning of new Congress * Democrats: part caucus * Republicans: party conference * Normally closed meeting of a political or legislative..? **The Speaker of the House** -Cheif presiding officer of the House -Elected at the beginning of each Congress on a straight party vote -Second in presidential line of sucession (after VP) -Current speaker of house; Nancy Pelosi **Senate** -Senate leadership: Vice president (Calama Harris) * Patrick Layhe President implore (not a lot of power) -Most powerful person in Senate is the senate majority leader **What do party leaders do?** -Control committee assignments -Public face of the party -Fund-raising: leadership PAC’s -Set agenda -->When bills will be voted on and what order -House Speaker/Senate Majority - assign bills to committee
66
Committee System
-Division of labor and specialization of labor -Standing committees * Permanent committees with specific jurisdiction * Members (mostly) keep their committee seats over time * Committee chairs are powerful; preside over committees; determined (mostly) by seniority
67
Committee Powers
-Gatekeeping authority-->the power to decide if a policy change will be considered -Proposal power--> the power to bring a proposal before the chambe * Most bills die in committee -After-The-fact Authority: the power to influence a proposal after it has been passed by the chamber * Conference committee--> resolve difference between House and Senate versions of a bill -Oversight: Committees oversee executive branch implementation of policies
68
Congressional Staff
-Formulate/draft proposals -Organize hearings * How they learn about things -Work with administrative agencies -Negotiate with lobbyists -Approx. 11,0000 personal staff; 2,000 committee staff -Staff Agnecies: (serves both chambers) * Congressional Research Service -->Think tank * Congression Budget Office --> How much a bill is going to cost * Government Accountability Office -->Reports on legal activity, advises congress about efficiency