quiz 2 Flashcards
(38 cards)
purpose of research designs
- provides plan to aid in problem solving, answering qts, testing hypothesis
- allows researcher to apply different levels of control so it can be suggested that it was the independent variable that influenced the dependent variable
research design includes
plans, structure, and strategy
control
measures that hold the conditions steady and avoid possible influence of bias on dependent variable or outcome
extraneous (mediating) variables
interferes with operation of the phenomena being studied (age & gender)
keeping control
- use of homogenous sample
- use of consistent data-collection procedures
- manipulation of independent variable
- randomization
internal validity
- asks if it is the independent variable that caused or resulted in the change in the dependent variable
threats to internal validity
- history
- maturation
- testing effects
- instrumentation effects
- mortality
- selection bias
external validity
qts conditions under which the findings can be generalized; deals with the ability to generalize the findings outside the study
threats to external validity
- selection effects (who)
- reactive effects (where-how)
- measurement effects (how-when-what)
experimental and quasiexperimental designs differ from nonexperimental one since…
research actively seeks to bring about the desired effect and does not passively observe behaviours and actions
need to consider what with experimental and quasiexperimental
feasibility of conducting the study
(experimental/quasi) use a design that
- is appropriate to research question
- maximizes control
- holds conditions of study constant
- establishes specific sampling criteria
- maximizes level of evidence
examples of experiemental/ quasi
- what is hte effect dancing have on an indvidiuals mood
- how does educating nurses about substance use effect their attitufes towards substance users
maximizing control
- rule out extraneous variables…
- homogeneous sampling
- constancy in data collection
- manipulation of the independent variable
- randomization
experimental design types - level 2 evidence
true experimental design (statistical approach to establishing a cause-and-effect relationship between different variables)
after-only design
solomon four-group design
experimental design features
- randomization of participants to control or treatment groups
- control: independent variable -> dependent variable
- mainpulation of independent variable
Experimental Design Advantages and Disadvantages
- Most appropriate for testing cause-and-effect
relationships - Provides highest level of evidence for single studies
- Not all research
questions are amenable
to experimental manipulation or
randomization - Participant mortality
(especially control
group participants) - Difficult logistics in
field settings
quasi design types level 3 evidence
- nonequivalent control group design
- after only nonequivalent control group design
- one group (pretest-posttest) design
- time series design
typical quasi design
- select 2 groups based on pre-existing characteristics
- divide each group in half
- compare performance with and with variable
- disadvantage (pre-existing differences can confound results)
quasi design advantages and disadvantages
- practical and more feasible (clincial settings)
- some genrealizability
- difficult to make clear cause-and-effect statements
- not randomized
- may not have control group to compare
nonexperimental design rationale
-used in studies to:
- construct picture of phenomenon at one point or over a period of time
- explore ppl, places, events or situations as they naturally occur
- test relationships and differences among variables
nonexperimental research designs
- survey studies
- relationship or difference studies
survey studies
- exploratory
- descriptive
- comparative
relationship or difference studies
- correlational studies
- developmental studies