Quiz 3 Flashcards
(310 cards)
What is clinical depression often confused with that may lead to an increase in diagnoses in recent times?
Intense sadness
Why does intense sadness often get incorrectly diagnosed as a depressive disorder?
Because diagnosticians fail to take into account context i.e. if the person has just experienced something very sad
What may account for the 36% increase in depression from Baxter (2014) systematic review?
- Increase in population over time - Some depression checklists may be measuring psych distress rather than clinical depression - greater public awareness of depression -> more frequent use of the term
What might explain the stagnant rate of depression despite advances in treatments?
- equal increase in prescriptions and reporting of depression cancelling each other out (not yet suported) - treatment received by ppl who did not meet requirements for clinical depression ie. not targeted to those with the greatest need - survey methodologies and diagnostic criteria changed substantially between 1990-2015, limiting the extent to which comparisons can be made.
What is the Better Access scheme?
- Designed to expand availability of psych treatment under Medicare - Patients could be referred to a clinical psych by a medical practitioner as part of a GP Mental Health Treatment Plan or referred by a psychiatrist or paediatrician - New billing items to subsidise costs
How much did the Better Access scheme exceed budgeting expectations?
By 2011, the scheme was costing ‘more than three times its initial 4 year estimate of $538 million, or more than $10 million each week
What were some concerns regarding Better Access?
Apart from the cost, there were concerns about: - Inequities in the distribution of services - the model of care - the quality of the treatment provided - the adequacy of the evaluation commissioned by the government
Why was it impossible to carry out a controlled trial on the effectiveness of Better Access scheme?
Because the Better Access scheme was rolled out nationally in advance of any evaluation
According to Jorm (2018), how have mental health services, psych distress levels, suicide rates changed since Better Access?
Mental health sevices - drastically increased and then started to plateau Psych distress levels - relatively unchanged Suicide rates - increased
How likely is it that other gradual changes in Australia, such as increased risk factor exposure or willingness to report symptoms, are masking any improvements in mental health?
Unlikely - because the increase in services under Better Access was so rapid
What explanations does Jorm (2018) provide for lack of impact of Better Access on mental health levels?
- Dose not sufficient - most patients getting minimal treatment - Services not going to ppl with highest need - quality of treatment is low - underlying determinants of mental health problems in community - Better Access maybe partly a shift in funding source for services that were already being provided
What is the conclusion of Jorm (2018) review on Better Access?
- No detectable benefit to the mental health of Australians - Need for development of more effective treatments and improved implementation of existing treatments in practice
Mulder (2017): why are clinically proven treatments that benefit individual patients not working at a community level?
Maybe: - not being directed at those who will benefit - non-illnesses being overdiagnosed - more severe illnesses, where arguably treatment is more effective, left untreated - treatment of poor quality - treatments being applied too late - Would things be even worse without the increase in mental health treatments
What suggestions does Mulder offer for improved mental health outcomes?
May need to do less, not more. eg. widespread use of long-term medications not convincingly associated with better long-term outcomes for mental disorders. Factors such as income inequality, discrimination, prejudice, unemployment and strongly materialistic and competitive values may contribute to increased mental distress
Mulder (2017): What factors may be needed in addition to psych treatments?
Potential for prevention through risk factor modification particularly: - parenting behaviours, - school and workplace environments, - diet and lifestyle (Jorm et al., 2017)
What is “selling sickness” or “disease mongering”?
Depression epidemic debate linked to executives in the pharmaceutical industry, who are said to benefit financially from increases in the number of people taking antidepressants
What are the 3 main factors that influence the ‘depression epidemic’?
- Multinational drug companies - Medical practitioners - The public
In what parts of the world can psychologists prescribe medication?
- 7 states of the US - Alberta, Canada - Guam - South Africa
What does the AMA say about prescription rights laws?
- Prescription of med by other professionals = risky because do not meet accreditation standards set out on the National Prescribing Service (NPS) Competencies Required to Prescribe Medicines - no high-level evidence that independent non-medical prescribing is safe for patients or cost‑effective for the health system
Why do psychologists feel concerned about prescription rights?
Lack of perceived knowledge, politics, ethics, and law.
How is sadness from grief and depression delineated in the DSM-5?
Early editions: someone could NOT be diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder if the symptoms occurred following bereavement, particularly within the first two months. However, critics argue that although low mood and sadness could be expected following a loss, possible that bereavement could be the trigger for clinical depression. As such, the DSM-5 (the current DSM) removed this criterion.
What is thanatology?
The study of death, dying, grief and loss Thanatologists study, teach, research, and care for the psychological health of those responding to both death and non-death losses NOT palliative care (caring for terminally ill)
What is disenfranchised grief?
Grief experienced after losses that cannot be openly acknowledged, publicly mourned, or socially supported eg. death from AIDS, loss of pet, death of extramarital partner, losing personality due to brain injury (non-death)
What is complicated grief? (sometimes called prolonged grief)
When the experience of grief becomes debilitating and results in impairment in daily functioning