role of communication Flashcards
(20 cards)
gottman positive affects
interest validation affection humour joy
Negative affect
disgust contempt belligerence, domineering, anger, fear, defensiveness, whining, sadness, stonewalling
aim of gottman
To test the role of positive functions on a relationship. He wanted to test the active listening model, in other words the validation model.
participants gottman
Couples recruit from newspaper
Married for the 1 time within 6 months of participation and no kids
Marital adjustment test; to test for satisfaction
124 couples
gottman procedure
- Every year for 6 years they were tested with the MAT
- At the end there were 17 divorces
- MAT decide on a topic of disagreement for the session
- topic was discussed for 15 mins and
- heart rate
- pulse
- skin conductivity
measured - they were asked to sit for 2 mins to establish a baseline
- both were recorded, and the specific affect coding system was used to measure expressions, then other observers watch it
- active listening was qualified as when one produced a negative affect, and the other validates it
- they then had to review their video and they were asked to continually rate how they felt throughout on a scale of 1-10
results gottman
- high intensity neg affect predicted divorce for men and woman (bewilderment, defensiveness and contempt)
- low intensity affect predicts divorce women(wining sadness disgust)
-active listening was rarely demonstrated and there isn’t enough evidence to support it
strengths gottman
- Using data triangulation as both physical aspects plus observations were used
- Inter coder reliability established increasing internal validity
- SPAFF (specfic inter coder affect ting)is standardized
weaknesses gottman
-Self selected samples - sampling bias
-Reductionist as it could be a number of factors, not just one
-Internal validity of such longitudinal studies is problematic
what questions is bradbury and fincham useful for?
- communication
- why relationships fall apart
- ethics
- research method
participants bradbury and fincham
- 47 married couples through local media
- Had not been in counseling
- Average length of 8.5 years
procedure bradbury and fincham
- All participants complete a survey on marital satisfaction
- questionnaire: determine the greatest problems in their marriage
- They chose a similarity issue for both parties and asked them who was responsible
- They then questioned them on one issue that wasn’t apparent by both people
- After they were brought together to discuss a solution
- Was in a lab
- 15 minutes
- Recorded
research method and aim of bradbury and fincham
- observational study
- To see wether attribution factors are related to marital satisfaction
what were bradburys two theories of communication
relationship enhancing pattern
- distress maintaining pattern
relationship enhancing patterns
relationshipis that dont place blame on one anouther or claim thinsg were done on purpose
distress maintaining pattern
blaming partners for action and dont give credit for potive events
results bradbury and fincham
- Three researchers independently coded the tape for Relationship enhancing patterns and Distress-maintaining pattern
- lower marital satisfaction: harmful patterns, and more likely to blame marital problems on their partner and tend to see their partner behave intentionally with selfishness
- seemed more hostile and rejective of their partners approaches
conclusion bradbury and fincham
The way people attribute (blame/explain) marital problems are related to the behaviours that spouses exhibit during problem solving
weaknesses bradbury and fincham
- results are correlational = bidirectional ambiguity. We don’t know if distress-maintaining communications cause or is a result of marriage dysfunctions
- Reductionist to just communication styles, other factors = mental health
- There was not consistency to the seriousness of the problems that were being discussed
- The pre-questionnaire may have influenced behaviour. Order effect was not applies
- Sampling bias- all western
- Cross sectional design so change over time can not be observed
strengths bradbury and fincham
- Research triangulation, strengthening the data