social strat Flashcards
(96 cards)
key concepts
- Social stratification refers to the hierarchical structure of society, where groups are ranked unequally.
- It is often visualised as a pyramid, with the most privileged at the top and the least favoured at the bottom.
- Social inequality is the uneven distribution of resources, opportunities, and life chances among individuals and groups.
social hierarchy and inequality
- Social hierarchy indicates the distribution of power, wealth, income, and status across different strata.
- Resources such as education, employment, and health are distributed unequally, leading to significant disparities.
- Factors contributing to social inequality include social class, gender, ethnicity, and age.
types of stratification
- Different societies exhibit various forms of stratification, including caste systems, apartheid, and feudalism.
- The caste system in India is linked to Hindu beliefs, where social position is ascribed at birth and affects life chances.
- Apartheid in South Africa enforced racial segregation, limiting opportunities for Black individuals.
comparison of stratification systems
- caste - ascribed status - limited soc mobility
- apartheid - racial segregation - very limited soc mobility
- social class - achieved status - possible soc mobility
Davis and Moore
- Davis and Moore (1945) argue that stratification is essential for society’s functioning.
- They believe that some roles are more important and require exceptional talent, thus justifying inequality.
- The education and training required for these roles create barriers that limit access to them.
criticisms of functionalism
- Critics argue that Davis and Moore’s theory overlooks the impact of social structures on inequality.
- The theory may justify existing inequalities rather than addressing the need for social change.
key concepts of functionalism
- Functionalism posits that some societal roles are more important than others for societal survival.
- Essential roles require exceptional talent and extensive training, which only a minority possess.
- Davis and Moore argue that social inequality is necessary to attract qualified individuals to important positions.
- Societies must have some degree of inequality, which is accepted as fair by the populace.
criticisms of davis and moore
- Many vital jobs (e.g., nurses) have low pay and status, challenging the functionalist view.
- Pay and status may be linked to power rather than functional importance.
- Critics argue that society is not meritocratic and that social mobility is limited.
- Talented individuals may not make significant sacrifices during training, contradicting functionalist claims.
key ideas of karl marx
- Marx identified two main classes in capitalist society: the bourgeoisie (owners) and the proletariat (workers).
- Class membership is determined by economic factors, particularly ownership of production means.
- The bourgeoisie exploits the proletariat, leading to class struggle and conflict.
- Marx emphasised the link between economic power and political power, with the bourgeoisie justifying their position through ruling-class ideology.
criticisms of marx
- The absence of a social revolution in capitalist societies challenges Marxist predictions.
- The emergence of a large middle class and social mobility contradicts Marxist views.
- Feminist critiques highlight the neglect of gender and ethnicity in Marxist analysis.
- Contemporary Marxists focus on the distribution of power and wealth, emphasising ongoing inequalities.
global capitalism in the 21st century
- Contemporary Marxists apply Marx’s theories to global capitalism, identifying a ruling oligarchy of capitalists and power elites.
- Graham Scambler argues that a small percentage of the population holds significant wealth and power.
- Multinational corporations (MNCs) are criticised for their influence over government policies and tax evasion.
- The dynamics of global capitalism continue to shape class relations and inequalities.
marxist approach to social strat
- Marx identified two main classes: the bourgeoisie (owners) and the proletariat (workers).
- Class membership is determined by economic factors, specifically ownership of the means of production.
- Recent Marxist theories focus on global financial capitalism and its impact on class structures.
- The Occupy Movement exemplifies resistance against the wealth concentration of the top 1%.
- Marx viewed ownership as the primary division in society, with other inequalities stemming from class divisions.
weber approach to social strat
- Max Weber argued that social classes are formed in marketplaces, particularly the labour market.
- He identified four main classes: property owners, petty bourgeoisie, professionals, and the working class.
- Weber emphasised the importance of non-economic factors such as status (prestige) and power (political influence) in determining life chances.
- He distinguished between class and status, noting that they can differ; for example, aristocrats may lack wealth but possess high status.
- Weber’s view includes the idea that life chances are influenced by access to education, health, and opportunities.
challenges in researching elites
- Researching elite groups is difficult due to their limited visibility and accessibility.
- Elites often have resources to control their image and limit exposure to researchers.
- There may be a lack of willingness from elites to participate in studies, fearing exposure or misrepresentation.
- Ethical considerations arise when studying powerful groups, as their influence can affect research outcomes.
the Registrar General’s Classification
- The Registrar General’s scale was the UK’s official class scale from 1911 to 1998, distinguishing between manual and non-manual occupations.
- It identifies five social classes: I (Professional), II (Managerial), III (Skilled Non-manual), IV (Skilled Manual), and V (Unskilled).
- Manual occupations are seen as working class, while non-manual occupations are considered middle class.
- The scale has limitations, such as not accommodating jobless individuals and not reflecting wealth or property accurately.
National Statistics Socio-economic Classification (NS-SEC)
- The NS-SEC groups occupations based on similar rewards, career prospects, and job security.
- It includes categories such as ‘Students’ and ‘Not classified’ for those not adequately described.
- Higher managerial roles include senior sales managers and solicitors, while lower roles include social workers and teachers.
- The classification helps in understanding employment status and authority levels in the workforce.
definition of life chances
- Life chances refer to the opportunities individuals have for achieving positive or negative outcomes in life.
- These outcomes include health, education, and income, which are not equally distributed among social classes.
- Higher social classes generally have better access to desirable resources like healthcare and housing.
factors affecting life chances
- Life chances are influenced by social class, gender, ethnicity, and other factors.
- Inequalities in health, education, and income are prevalent among different social classes.
- The Child Poverty Action Group highlights that low income directly reduces life chances, particularly in education.
the emboureoisiement thesis
- The embourgeoisement thesis suggests that working-class families adopt middle-class norms as their living standards improve.
- This process leads to a focus on privatised lifestyles centred around home and family.
- Traditional working-class values of community are thought to diminish as affluence increases.
the affluent worker study
- Conducted by Goldthorpe in the 1960s, this study aimed to test the embourgeoisement thesis in Luton, England.
- Researchers used structured interviews with affluent manual workers and their families to gather data on attitudes and lifestyles.
- Findings indicated that while affluent workers had home-centred lifestyles, they did not fully embody middle-class values, leading to the concept of a ‘new’ working class.
affluent workers research context
- The study was conducted in Luton, a prosperous town in southeast England.
- Researchers focused on affluent manual workers and their families.
- Structured interviews were used to gather data on attitudes, lifestyles, and political views.
findings of goldthorpe et al
- Goldthorpe and colleagues rejected the embourgeoisement thesis.
- They proposed the concept of a ‘new’ working class resembling the middle class.
- Affluent workers exhibited privatised, home-centred lifestyles and instrumental collectivism.
instrumentalism and work attitudes
- Instrumentalism refers to viewing work as a means to an end, not for job satisfaction.
- Affluent workers sought to improve personal pay rather than societal change.
- Their collective actions were driven by individual interests rather than solidarity.
comparison with devine’s findings
- Fiona Devine revisited the affluent worker study and found little change in working-class lifestyles.
- Devine noted that affluent workers were geographically mobile but still maintained ties with kin.
- Her findings suggested that working-class norms and values remained stable despite Goldthorpe’s conclusions.