Task 1 Flashcards
(7 cards)
Hegel
history proceeds in a line and that is directional or going somewhere - criticism: civilizations can advance and regress
Fukuyama
History has to come to an end with liberal democracy - coherent development of human societies from trivial to modern liberal society and driven by capitalism
Can history be objective?
No, there is no neutral position from which to do history, because each seems to understand the past within a framework - selected facts interpreted and given from their particular perspective
Causality in relation to History
Necessary cause - condition fro x to be y is on of potentially many conditions that have to be ratified before we can say x is y (Horse example)
Suficiente cause - one that is enough to conclude immediately that we have something.
What are the philosophical approaches to history
Historical realism - concepts and theories employed in history to get at what really happened - the past exists independently of what we think of it
Historians anti-representionalism - theory of truth within historians has to be given up and the constructs of historians understood as fictions and closer approximations of the past as it happened
Different approaches towards the finding of the truth
- Correspondence theory - those who think it is still worth it aiming for the truth, bring to match up the past and our accounts of it
- Coherence theory - the only way to test historians accounts is by comparison with others
- Pragmatic theory - historians shits down interpretations that do not accord with war is useful for a society and supper or undermine dominant marginalized histories.
What is history according to Fukuyama
Humans naturally have desire for recognition - satisfied in a liberal democracy (participation and equal recognitions) and basic economic needs (capitalist democracy and free markets)