Ch 7 Part 3- Aspiring and Engaging Bodhicitta Flashcards

(473 cards)

1
Q

What is the ‘perfection of wisdom’ (prajñāpāramitā) and why is it considered the ‘mother’ of all Buddhas?

A

It is the direct realization of emptiness, considered the mother because it is the essential condition for attaining Buddhahood; all enlightened beings are born from this wisdom.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

How does Tsongkhapa explain the ‘non-conceptual’ nature of ultimate wisdom?

A

Non-conceptual wisdom is a direct, unmediated apprehension of emptiness that is free from all conceptual elaborations, dualistic appearances, and the superimposition of inherent existence.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What is the significance of the bodhisattva’s ‘great aspirations’ (mahāpraṇidhāna) in their journey to Buddhahood?

A

These are immense, unwavering vows to liberate all sentient beings and to achieve Buddhahood for their sake, providing constant motivation and preventing deviation from the path.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of ‘the self’ by showing it is neither identical to nor different from the aggregates?

A

He demonstrates that if the self were identical to the aggregates, it would be multiple and impermanent; if entirely different, it would be unobservable, thus proving it is merely imputed.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What is the ‘path of meditation’ (bhāvanā-mārga) and its purpose?

A

It is the path where a bodhisattva repeatedly habituates to the direct realization of emptiness, gradually eliminating the subtle obscurations and perfecting the virtues until Buddhahood.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is the ‘extraordinary intention’ (adhiśaya) in the context of generating bodhicitta?

A

It is the unique resolve to personally take responsibility for freeing all sentient beings from suffering, beyond merely wishing for their freedom, leading directly to the aspiration for Buddhahood.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

How does the practice of ‘calm abiding’ (śamatha) contribute to the development of wisdom?

A

Calm abiding provides a stable, clear, and pliable mind, free from mental agitation and dullness, which is the necessary foundation for analytical insight into emptiness.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is the relationship between ‘compassion’ and ‘wisdom’ on the Mahayana path?

A

Compassion (method) is the boundless altruistic motivation that drives the bodhisattva, while wisdom (emptiness realization) is the means to achieve liberation; they are inseparable and like two wings of a bird.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of ‘motion’ (gati)?

A

He analyzes the three moments of motion (going, gone, yet to go) and shows that none can inherently exist, nor can motion exist independently of them, thus proving its emptiness.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is the ‘perfection of patience’ (kṣānti pāramitā) and its benefits for a bodhisattva?

A

It is the ability to endure suffering, criticism, and aggression without anger or resentment, which purifies negative karma and prevents mental disturbances, fostering inner peace.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What is the significance of the ‘non-abiding nirvāṇa’ (apratiṣṭhita nirvāṇa) in the Mahayana context?

A

It describes the state of a Buddha who, having fully realized emptiness, does not abide in a solitary peace but manifests continuously in cyclic existence out of great compassion to benefit sentient beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

How does Tsongkhapa explain the ‘union of method and wisdom’ in the Mahayana path?

A

It refers to the inseparable practice of accumulating merit (through method, e.g., compassion, perfections) and accumulating wisdom (through emptiness realization), both being equally essential for Buddhahood.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is the role of ‘non-conceptualization’ (avikalpa) in the direct realization of emptiness?

A

Non-conceptualization is the mind’s ability to directly perceive emptiness without engaging in conceptual overlays, dualistic thought, or reifying the object of meditation.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What are the ‘four factors that cause one to lose bodhicitta’ according to A Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life?

A

Deceiving one’s spiritual master, making others regret virtuous deeds, speaking disparagingly of the Mahayana, and deceiving sentient beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of ‘time’ (past

A

present, future)?, “He demonstrates that each of the three times is defined only in relation to the others, meaning none can inherently exist independently, proving their dependent nature.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What is the ultimate purpose of accumulating the ‘collection of merit’ (puṇyasaṃbhāra)?

A

The collection of merit purifies defilements, creates positive karmic conditions, and provides the necessary conducive environment for wisdom to arise and for achieving the form body of a Buddha.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of ‘the elements’ (mahābhūta) like earth

A

water, fire, and wind?, “He argues that these elements are mutually dependent and cannot exist as independent, self-sufficient entities, thereby demonstrating their emptiness.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What is the ‘path of no more training’ (aśaikṣa-mārga) and its ultimate achievement?

A

It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all obscurations are eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish, representing complete enlightenment.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What is the ethical imperative of ‘right livelihood’ (samyak-ājīva) in Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland?

A

Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, promoting a virtuous life and societal harmony.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

How does Tsongkhapa reconcile the ‘appearance of inherent existence’ with the ‘realization of emptiness’?

A

He explains that while phenomena appear to have inherent existence (due to ignorance), this appearance is merely a cognitive overlay that is refuted by the wisdom realizing their true nature of emptiness.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

What is the purpose of ‘meditating on the sufferings of others’ in the seven-point cause and effect instruction?

A

To generate immense compassion (mahākaruṇā) by contemplating the various types of suffering (pain, change, pervasive conditioning) experienced by sentient beings, leading to the resolve to liberate them.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of ‘the mind’ (citta)?

A

He examines its moments (past, present, future) and its objects, demonstrating that no inherently existing mind can be found independently of these factors, thus the mind is empty.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

What is the ‘path of accumulation’ (saṃbhāra-mārga) and its characteristics?

A

It is the initial path where one accumulates vast merit and develops a conceptual understanding of emptiness through extensive study, contemplation, and practice of the perfections.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

What is the significance of the ‘two obscurations’ (klesha-āvaraṇa and jñeya-āvaraṇa) for the Mahayana path?

A

The Mahayana path aims to eliminate both: afflictive obscurations (mental afflictions) for liberation, and obscurations to omniscience (subtle imprints of dualistic appearance) for full Buddhahood.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
How does Candrakīrti use the analogy of a 'dream' to explain emptiness?
He explains that just as phenomena in a dream appear real but are ultimately empty of inherent existence, so too are all phenomena in waking life ultimately empty of inherent reality.
26
What is the 'perfection of ethical discipline' (*śīla pāramitā*) and its importance?
It is the practice of abstaining from all non-virtuous actions and engaging in virtuous ones, providing the stable foundation for all higher meditative states and the accumulation of merit.
27
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise against 'senseless chatter'?
It suggests avoiding speech that is not beneficial, timely, or truthful, and instead encourages speech that promotes Dharma, harmony, and meaningful communication.
28
What is the purpose of 'dedicating merit' (pariṇāmanā) in Mahayana practice?
Dedicating all accumulated merit for the benefit of all sentient beings ensures that one's positive actions lead to universal enlightenment, preventing limited individual liberation and strengthening altruism.
29
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the 'validity of conventional phenomena' when they are empty of inherent existence?
He explains that phenomena, though empty of inherent existence, are still conventionally valid and functional, allowing for the operation of karma and the existence of the path to liberation.
30
What is the significance of the 'ten stages' (*daśabhūmi*) in the bodhisattva's development?
The ten stages represent the progressive levels of realization of emptiness and perfection of the pāramitās, culminating in full Buddhahood, each marked by profound spiritual growth.
31
What is the 'path of preparation' (*prayoga-mārga*) and its main characteristic?
It is the path where a conceptual understanding of emptiness is developed through extensive study and contemplation, leading to a strong intellectual conviction prior to direct realization.
32
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the world' (loka) and 'time' (kāla)?
He argues that they are merely conceptual designations based on dependently arisen phenomena and their relations, lacking any inherent, independent reality.
33
What is the 'causality' aspect of the Four Noble Truths?
It is the truth of the origin of suffering (samudaya), which states that suffering arises from causes, primarily grasping and ignorance, illustrating dependent arising.
34
What is the relationship between 'faith' (śraddhā) and 'wisdom' (prajñā) in the Mahayana path?
Faith provides the initial trust and confidence in the teachings and the path, while wisdom, cultivated through analysis and meditation, provides the direct realization that liberates.
35
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta)?
He demonstrates that elements like earth, water, fire, and wind are mutually dependent and cannot exist as independent, self-sufficient entities, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
36
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the shortcomings of self-cherishing'?
To recognize that self-cherishing is the source of all suffering and obstacles, motivating one to reverse this ingrained habit and cultivate altruism for true happiness.
37
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'union of the two truths' (conventional and ultimate)?
He clarifies that the two truths are not separate realities but two aspects of the same phenomenon, inseparable like the two sides of a coin, with ultimate truth being the true nature of conventional truth.
38
What is the significance of the 'non-duality of saṃsāra and nirvāṇa' for Nāgārjuna?
It means that from the ultimate perspective of emptiness, cyclic existence and liberation are not inherently distinct; their difference lies in one's conceptual overlay and ignorance, not in their ultimate nature.
39
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'three bodies of a Buddha' (Trikāya)?
It describes the Dharmakāya (truth body), Sambhogakāya (enjoyment body), and Nirmāṇakāya (emanation body), representing the ultimate wisdom, enjoyment, and compassionate manifestation of a Buddha.
40
What is the role of 'non-attachment' in the practice of generosity?
Non-attachment ensures that generosity is pure, free from any clinging to the giver, gift, or recipient, thereby maximizing its merit and leading to freedom from cyclic existence.
41
What are the 'eight worldly dharmas' (or concerns) that a practitioner aims to transcend?
They are gain and loss, pleasure and pain, praise and blame, fame and disrepute. Transcending them frees one from worldly attachments.
42
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the self-cognizing consciousness' (svasaṃvedana)?
He argues that consciousness cannot inherently apprehend itself, as the act of apprehending requires a distinction between subject and object, which refutes self-cognition.
43
What is the 'supreme enlightenment' (*anuttara samyaksaṃbodhi*) that a bodhisattva seeks?
It is the full, perfect, and unsurpassed awakening of a Buddha, characterized by omniscience and boundless compassion, attained for the benefit of all sentient beings.
44
What is the significance of the 'three higher trainings' (ethics
concentration, wisdom) in the Mahayana path?, "They are the essential components that systematically purify the mind, develop mental stability, and cultivate penetrative insight, leading to liberation and omniscience.
45
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the senses' (indriyas)?
He demonstrates that senses cannot inherently exist independently of their objects or corresponding consciousnesses, proving their mutual dependence and emptiness.
46
What is the role of 'reasoning' (rigs pa) in Tsongkhapa's approach to realizing emptiness?
Reasoning is used to eliminate mistaken conceptual elaborations and to lead the mind to a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness by systematically refuting inherent existence.
47
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
It refers to the progressive elimination of both the afflictive obscurations and the obscurations to omniscience as a bodhisattva advances through the *bhūmis*, leading to perfect purity.
48
How does the practice of 'equanimity' (upekṣā) differ from indifference?
Equanimity is a balanced, unbiased mind free from attachment and aversion, accompanied by a genuine concern for all beings, whereas indifference is apathy or a lack of concern.
49
What is the ultimate benefit of understanding 'dependent arising' (*pratītyasamutpāda*) in depth?
Deep understanding of dependent arising leads directly to the realization of emptiness, which is the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the means to liberate oneself and others from suffering.
50
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise a ruler on 'just governance'?
It advises a ruler to govern ethically, prioritize the welfare of their subjects, avoid excessive taxation, and promote Dharma, demonstrating the application of Buddhist ethics in society.
51
What is the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) and its key characteristic?
It is the final path, representing full Buddhahood, where all obscurations are eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish in terms of practice or realization.
52
What is the 'yoga of emptiness' in the context of meditative practice?
It refers to the meditative absorption where one directly and non-conceptually apprehends the emptiness of all phenomena, transcending dualistic thought and mental fabrication.
53
How does the concept of 'impermanence' (anitya) serve as a stepping stone to understanding emptiness?
Recognizing the constant change and impermanence of phenomena helps to undermine the notion of their inherent, unchanging existence, leading towards the understanding of emptiness.
54
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three pure actions' (body
speech, and mind)?, "They are actions purified by bodhicitta and perfected with wisdom, leading to the accumulation of vast merit and the elimination of defilements, contributing to Buddhahood.
55
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'causes and effects'?
He argues that if causes and effects were inherently existent, they would either be identical (no production) or totally separate (no relationship), both of which are untenable, proving their dependent nature.
56
What are the 'four general pervasive features' of all conditioned phenomena?
They are impermanence, suffering, selflessness, and peace (or emptiness). These features serve as objects of contemplation to develop insight.
57
What is the role of 'non-conceptual compassion' in a Buddha's activities?
A Buddha's compassion is non-conceptual, spontaneous, and boundless, arising naturally from their realization of emptiness and their complete elimination of self-cherishing.
58
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise against 'harming others'?
It teaches that causing harm to any living being, no matter how small, leads to negative karmic results, and that compassion motivates the abandonment of all harmful actions.
59
What is the 'lineage of method' (upāya-vaṃśa) and its components?
It refers to the practices of compassion and skillful means (including generosity, ethics, patience, joyous effort, and meditative stabilization), which are essential for accumulating merit.
60
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the importance of 'identifying the object of negation' in emptiness meditation?
Correctly identifying the object of negation (inherent existence) is paramount to avoid falling into the extreme of nihilism (negating conventional existence) or eternalism (failing to negate inherent existence).
61
What is the relationship between 'aspiring bodhicitta' and 'engaging bodhicitta' in practice?
Aspiring bodhicitta is the wish for enlightenment for others, which is the basis; engaging bodhicitta is the actual undertaking of the bodhisattva deeds (perfections) to fulfill that aspiration.
62
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the doer' (kāraka) and 'the deed' (kārya)?
He shows that neither can inherently exist independently of the other; the doer is defined by the deed, and vice versa, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
63
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the pervasive suffering of conditioned existence'?
To recognize that all conditioned phenomena, even seemingly pleasant ones, are inherently tainted by suffering due to their impermanent and dependently arisen nature, fostering renunciation of saṃsāra.
64
What are the 'three types of vows' a Mahayana practitioner may take?
Pratimoksha vows (individual liberation), bodhisattva vows (to benefit all beings), and tantric vows (samayas), representing progressive levels of commitment.
65
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the world' (loka) and 'time' (kāla)?
He argues that they are merely conceptual designations based on dependently arisen phenomena and their relations, lacking any inherent, independent reality when analyzed.
66
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'uninterrupted flow of compassion'?
Even after realizing emptiness and achieving high spiritual attainments, a bodhisattva's compassion for sentient beings remains constant and active, propelling them to work tirelessly for others' liberation.
67
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'three types of omniscience'?
It differentiates between the omniscience of all aspects (Buddha's omniscience), the omniscience of paths, and the omniscience of individual knowledge (Arhat's knowledge), detailing their scope.
68
What is the ethical imperative of 'right speech' (samyak-vāc) in Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right speech involves avoiding lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and senseless chatter, and instead engaging in truthful, kind, harmonious, and meaningful communication.
69
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the 'union of method and wisdom' on the path?
He emphasizes that both method (compassion, perfections leading to merit) and wisdom (emptiness realization leading to wisdom collection) must be practiced in conjunction and be inseparable for complete Buddhahood.
70
What is the significance of 'taking refuge' in the Three Jewels (Buddha
Dharma, Sangha) for a Mahayana practitioner?, "Taking refuge is the fundamental commitment that provides direction, protection, and a spiritual foundation for all Buddhist practice, especially when motivated by bodhicitta.
71
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in general Buddhist terms?
It refers to the progressive elimination of mental defilements (afflictions and obscurations to omniscience) through ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom, leading to perfect purity.
72
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He systematically demonstrates that each of the five aggregates (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) is dependently arisen and lacks inherent existence, thus the self imputed upon them is also empty.
73
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the senses' (indriyas) and their 'objects'?
He argues that senses cannot inherently exist without their objects, nor objects without senses; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
74
What is the importance of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers' in the seven-point instruction?
This practice cultivates deep gratitude and a profound sense of connection, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness by guiding them to ultimate happiness.
75
What is the 'path of vision' (darśana-mārga) and its key characteristic?
It is the first of the five paths where a bodhisattva achieves a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, marking their irreversible entry into the true Mahayana path.
76
What is the purpose of 'meditative absorption' (dhyāna) for a bodhisattva?
To develop profound mental stability and one-pointedness, which serves as the necessary foundation for deep insight into emptiness and for manifesting skillful means to benefit others.
77
What is the role of 'analytic meditation' (*vipassanā*) in realizing emptiness?
Analytic meditation involves systematic investigation and reasoning to ascertain the lack of inherent existence of phenomena, leading to a direct, non-conceptual insight into emptiness.
78
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'sexual misconduct'?
It advises against sexual activity that causes harm, is non-consensual, or violates commitments, emphasizing respect and purity in relationships, leading to positive karmic results.
79
What is the 'ultimate wisdom' (paramārtha-jñāna) and its object?
It is the direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, and its object is the ultimate truth—the emptiness of inherent existence of all phenomena, beyond conceptual fabrication.
80
What are the 'four immeasurables' (loving-kindness
compassion, joy, equanimity) and their function?, "They are boundless mental states that cultivate impartial altruism, serving as a foundational practice to expand one's heart and prepare the mind for generating bodhicitta.
81
How does Candrakīrti reconcile the appearance of suffering with its emptiness?
He explains that while suffering appears to exist conventionally and is experienced, it is ultimately empty of inherent existence, meaning it is not a fixed, independent entity and can therefore be ceased.
82
What is the ethical imperative of 'right action' (samyak-karmānta) according to Nāgārjuna?
Right action involves abandoning killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct, and instead engaging in life protection, generosity, and pure conduct, leading to favorable rebirths and spiritual progress.
83
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three realms' of activity?
A bodhisattva works tirelessly in all three realms of existence (desire, form, formless) to liberate sentient beings from suffering, without being bound by these realms due to their wisdom and compassion.
84
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the role of 'dependent arising' in establishing emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena are empty of inherent existence precisely *because* they arise dependently; dependent arising is the reason and sign for emptiness, and they are mutually inclusive.
85
What is the primary function of 'mindfulness' (smṛti) in meditative practice?
Mindfulness is the mental faculty that keeps the mind from distraction and forgetfulness of the meditation object, thereby maintaining mental stability and clarity.
86
What is the ultimate aim of the 'bodhisattva path'?
The ultimate aim is the attainment of complete Buddhahood (omniscience and boundless compassion) for the perfect liberation of all sentient beings from cyclic existence.
87
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the perceiver and the perceived'?
He argues that the perceiver (subject) cannot exist inherently without the perceived (object), nor the perceived without the perceiver; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
88
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great compassion' being 'uncontaminated' by self-cherishing?
Uncontaminated compassion is purely altruistic, free from any subtle motivation of self-interest or a dualistic apprehension of a separate self and others, making it boundless and truly effective.
89
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'identity' and 'difference'?
He demonstrates that identity cannot inherently exist without difference, nor difference without identity, as they are mutually dependent concepts, thus proving their emptiness.
90
What is the role of 'non-conceptual compassion' in a Buddha's activities?
A Buddha's compassion is non-conceptual, spontaneous, and boundless, arising naturally from their profound realization of emptiness and their complete elimination of self-cherishing.
91
What is the ultimate purpose of 'analytic meditation' on emptiness?
To directly realize the lack of inherent existence of all phenomena, thereby eliminating the root of cyclic existence (ignorance) and developing genuine wisdom for liberation.
92
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'divisive speech'?
It advises against speech that creates discord and disunity among people, and instead encourages speech that fosters harmony, understanding, and reconciliation.
93
What are the 'six perfections' (pāramitās) in brief?
Generosity, ethical discipline, patience, joyous effort, meditative concentration, and wisdom.
94
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He systematically analyzes each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) to show that none are inherently existent individually or as a collection, demonstrating that any self imputed upon them is empty.
95
What is the significance of 'emptiness of emptiness' in Madhyamaka?
It means that even the concept of 'emptiness' itself is empty of inherent existence, preventing one from reifying emptiness into a new ultimate truth or clinging to it.
96
What is the role of 'aspirational prayer' (*praṇidhāna*) in sustaining bodhicitta?
Aspirational prayers help to reinforce and deepen the wish for enlightenment for all beings, keeping the motivation strong over time and dedicating all efforts towards this goal.
97
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'origination' (utpāda) and 'cessation' (nirodha)?
He demonstrates that if origination and cessation were inherently existent, they would be illogical and contradictory, thus proving they are empty and dependently arisen.
98
What is the 'path of accumulation' (*saṃbhāra-mārga*) and its main objective?
It is the initial path where one accumulates vast merit and develops a conceptual understanding of emptiness through extensive study, contemplation, and practice of the perfections, laying the groundwork for direct realization.
99
What is the significance of the 'four purities of the Prajñāpāramitā'?
They refer to the purity of the basis, path, practitioner, and result, all understood in terms of emptiness, signifying their non-inherent nature and complete freedom from inherent existence.
100
What is the ethical imperative of 'right intention' (samyak-saṃkalpa) in the Mahayana path?
Right intention involves intentions of renunciation, non-ill-will, and non-harming, forming the basis for virtuous thoughts and actions, and aligning with the bodhisattva's altruistic motivation.
101
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle imputation of inherent existence'?
It is the beginningless, ingrained habit of mind to spontaneously project and apprehend phenomena as truly existing from their own side, which is the precise object to be refuted by the wisdom realizing emptiness.
102
What is the purpose of 'contemplating impermanence' (anitya-bhāvanā)?
Contemplating impermanence helps to reduce attachment to worldly phenomena, overcome grasping, and foster a sense of urgency to practice Dharma, recognizing the fleeting nature of all conditioned things.
103
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the self' (ātman) through a lack of identity with the aggregates?
He argues that if the self were inherently identical to the aggregates, it would be multiple and impermanent; if entirely different, it would be unobservable, thus neither is tenable, proving its empty nature.
104
What is the 'path of cultivation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*) and its objective?
It is the path where a bodhisattva repeatedly habituates to the direct realization of emptiness, gradually eliminating the subtle obscurations and perfecting the virtues until full Buddhahood.
105
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great intention' (adhiśaya) to liberate all beings?
It is the profound resolve to personally take on the responsibility of freeing all sentient beings from suffering, which is the direct cause for generating bodhicitta and sustains the bodhisattva throughout the path.
106
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the seen' (dṛśya) and 'the seer' (draṣṭā)?
He demonstrates that neither can inherently exist without the other; the seen is defined by the seer, and vice versa, proving their mutual dependence and emptiness.
107
What is the role of 'non-conceptual wisdom' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*) in the path to Buddhahood?
Non-conceptual wisdom is the direct, unmediated apprehension of emptiness, free from all mental constructs and dualistic appearances, which is the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the direct cause for attaining omniscience.
108
What is the 'path of preparation' (*prayoga-mārga*) and its main characteristic?
It is the path where a conceptual understanding of emptiness is developed and refined through extensive study and contemplation, leading to a strong intellectual conviction prior to direct realization.
109
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'sexual misconduct'?
It advises against sexual activity that causes harm, is non-consensual, or violates commitments, emphasizing respect and purity in relationships, and promoting positive karmic results.
110
What are the 'three types of suffering' (*duḥkha*) that bodhicitta helps to overcome?
The suffering of pain (physical/mental discomfort), the suffering of change (impermanent happiness that eventually turns to suffering), and the pervasive suffering of conditioning (existence under the sway of karma and afflictions).
111
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the equality of self and others'?
To dismantle the ingrained habit of self-cherishing, recognizing that all beings equally desire happiness and freedom from suffering, thereby fostering impartiality and universal altruism.
112
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the knower' and 'the known'?
He argues that the knower (subject) cannot inherently exist without the known (object), nor the known without the knower; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
113
What is the 'conventional self' according to Madhyamaka?
The conventional self is merely a designation imputed upon the five aggregates; it exists functionally in conventional reality but lacks any inherent, independently existing nature.
114
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'non-conceptual mind' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*) on the path of seeing?
On the path of seeing, the bodhisattva achieves a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, which is the first time they truly cut the root of afflictive obscurations.
115
What is the essence of 'true cessation' (nirodha) in the context of the Four Noble Truths?
True cessation is the complete and permanent elimination of suffering and its causes, achieved through the realization of emptiness and the abandonment of ignorance and grasping.
116
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ten stages' (bhūmis) of a bodhisattva in detail?
It systematically outlines the progressive levels of spiritual development, detailing how each of the ten perfections is increasingly perfected and the realization of emptiness deepens through each stage.
117
What is the role of 'analytic wisdom' in the Mahayana path?
Analytic wisdom systematically investigates phenomena to ascertain their ultimate nature of emptiness, distinguishing it from merely intellectual understanding by directly counteracting the root of ignorance.
118
What is the ultimate purpose of 'aspirational bodhicitta' in the context of the entire Mahayana path?
Aspirational bodhicitta, the fervent wish to attain Buddhahood for others' sake, serves as the fundamental and continuous motivation that sustains a bodhisattva through countless aeons of practice.
119
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'causality' (hetu-phala) in detail?
He argues that if causes inherently produced effects, they would either exist simultaneously or be entirely separate, neither of which is tenable, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
120
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'perfection of joyous effort' (*vīrya pāramitā*) in overcoming obstacles?
Joyous effort is the enthusiastic and sustained exertion in all virtuous activities, which directly counteracts laziness, discouragement, and hindrances, ensuring continuous progress on the long path to Buddhahood.
121
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'conventional existence' of phenomena despite their ultimate emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena exist conventionally through valid nominal designation and dependently, appearing functionally to an unanalyzing mind, even though they lack inherent reality.
122
What is the role of 'non-conceptual wisdom' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*) in eradicating obscurations?
Non-conceptual wisdom directly apprehends emptiness, which is the direct antidote to the fundamental ignorance and the subtle obscurations to omniscience, eradicating them completely.
123
How does Tsongkhapa address the 'two extremes' (eternalism and nihilism) in relation to emptiness?
He clarifies that emptiness avoids eternalism (by refuting inherent existence) and nihilism (by affirming conventional existence), presenting the middle way that is free from both extremes.
124
What is the ethical implication of 'right mindfulness' (samyak-smṛti) according to Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right mindfulness involves constant awareness of one's body, speech, and mind, preventing the arising of non-virtuous actions and cultivating virtuous conduct.
125
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
It refers to the progressive elimination of both the afflictive obscurations (klesha-āvaraṇa) and the obscurations to omniscience (jñeya-āvaraṇa) as a bodhisattva advances through the bhūmis.
126
How does the practice of 'equanimity' (upekṣā) overcome partiality?
By meditating on the fact that all beings equally desire happiness and freedom from suffering, one dissolves biases and prejudice towards friends, enemies, and strangers, developing impartial love and compassion.
127
What is the significance of the 'two collections' (merit and wisdom) for attaining Buddhahood?
The collection of merit is the cause for attaining the form body of a Buddha, while the collection of wisdom is the cause for attaining the wisdom truth body, both being essential for complete enlightenment.
128
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'the self' (ātman) by analyzing its relationship to the aggregates?
He demonstrates that the self is neither inherently identical to nor inherently separate from the five aggregates, thus it is merely designated upon them and lacks inherent existence.
129
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers' in the seven-point cause and effect instruction?
To generate profound gratitude for the countless times all sentient beings have shown kindness in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness through seeking enlightenment.
130
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the objects of knowledge' (prameya)?
He argues that an object of knowledge cannot inherently exist independently of a knowing subject, nor a knowing subject without an object, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
131
What is the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) and its ultimate characteristic?
It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all defilements and obscurations are completely eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish.
132
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of all aspects' (*sarvākārajñatā*)?
It describes the Buddha's perfect and simultaneous knowledge of all phenomena, both conventional and ultimate, in all their aspects, achieved upon full enlightenment.
133
What is the ethical implication of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) in the Mahayana path?
Right livelihood means engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby supporting one's spiritual practice and benefiting society.
134
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the 'union of method and wisdom' on the Mahayana path?
He emphasizes that method (compassion, skillful means, merit accumulation) and wisdom (emptiness realization, wisdom accumulation) must be practiced inseparably, like two wings of a bird, for complete Buddhahood.
135
What is the 'perfection of meditative stabilization' (*dhyāna pāramitā*) and its primary function for a bodhisattva?
It is the ability to maintain one-pointed concentration on any virtuous object, free from mental dullness or agitation, which provides the stable mind necessary for penetrating insight and manifesting skillful means.
136
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta) like earth
water, fire, and wind?, "He demonstrates that each element is defined in relation to others and cannot exist independently, showing their mutual dependence and thus emptiness of inherent nature.
137
What is the purpose of 'contemplating the shortcomings of self-cherishing'?
To recognize that self-cherishing is the root cause of all suffering and the primary obstacle to developing genuine altruism, thereby motivating one to abandon it and cultivate cherishing others.
138
What is the 'path of accumulation' (*saṃbhāra-mārga*) and its main characteristic?
It is the initial path where one accumulates vast merit and develops a conceptual understanding of emptiness through extensive study, contemplation, and practice of the perfections.
139
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great compassion' being 'uncontaminated' by self-cherishing?
Uncontaminated compassion is purely altruistic, free from any subtle motivation of self-interest or a dualistic apprehension of a separate self and others, making it boundless and truly effective in leading others to enlightenment.
140
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of paths' (*mārga-jñatā*)?
It describes the Buddha's perfect knowledge of all the different paths and stages that lead to liberation and enlightenment for all sentient beings, enabling them to guide others effectively.
141
What is the role of 'renunciation' (nekkhamma) in the Mahayana path?
Renunciation is the sincere wish to be free from cyclic existence and its causes, motivating one to abandon the causes of suffering and pursue liberation for oneself and others.
142
What is the ultimate benefit of 'dedicating merit' (pariṇāmanā) in Mahayana practice?
Dedicating all accumulated merit for the benefit of all sentient beings ensures that one's positive actions contribute to universal enlightenment, preventing limited individual liberation and strengthening altruism.
143
What is the significance of the 'two types of selflessness' (person and phenomena) for understanding emptiness?
The selflessness of persons (pudgala-nairātmya) refutes an inherent self, leading to arhatship; the selflessness of phenomena (dharma-nairātmya) refutes inherent existence of all phenomena, leading to Buddhahood.
144
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* emphasize the importance of 'compassion' in a ruler's governance?
It states that a ruler should govern with great compassion, seeing all subjects as their own children, ensuring their welfare and protecting them from harm, reflecting the bodhisattva ideal.
145
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
It refers to the progressive elimination of both the afflictive obscurations and the obscurations to omniscience as a bodhisattva advances through the bhūmis, leading to perfect purity.
146
What is the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) and why is it paramount?
It is the direct realization of emptiness, paramount because it is the only antidote to ignorance, the root of all suffering, leading directly to liberation and omniscience.
147
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He systematically demonstrates that each of the five aggregates is dependently arisen and lacks inherent existence, and thus no inherent self can be found within them, proving their emptiness.
148
What is the ethical imperative of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) in Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby promoting a virtuous life and societal harmony.
149
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the sufferings of others' in the seven-point instruction?
To generate immense compassion (mahākaruṇā) by contemplating the various types of suffering experienced by sentient beings, leading to the resolve to liberate them.
150
What is the ethical imperative of 'non-harming' in Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
It states that causing harm to any living being, no matter how small, leads to negative karmic results, and that compassion motivates the abandonment of all harmful actions.
151
What is the significance of the 'eight worldly dharmas' (or concerns) for a practitioner?
They are the pairs of opposites (gain/loss, pleasure/pain, praise/blame, fame/disrepute) that bind one to cyclic existence when clung to; transcending them leads to liberation and inner peace.
152
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' by showing it is neither identical to nor different from the aggregates?
He demonstrates that if the self were identical to the aggregates, it would be multiple and impermanent; if entirely different, it would be unobservable, thus neither holds true, proving it is merely imputed.
153
What is the ultimate aim of 'analytic meditation' (*vipassanā*) on emptiness?
To directly realize the lack of inherent existence of all phenomena, thereby eliminating the root of cyclic existence (ignorance) and developing genuine wisdom for liberation.
154
What is the role of 'right mindfulness' (samyak-smṛti) in meditative practice?
Right mindfulness is the faculty that keeps the mind from distraction, preventing forgetfulness of the meditation object, thereby maintaining mental stability and clarity.
155
How does the practice of 'calm abiding' (śamatha) prepare the mind for realizing emptiness?
Calm abiding develops one-pointed concentration and mental stability, providing a clear and pliable mind that is free from agitation and dullness, which is the necessary foundation for penetrating insight into emptiness.
156
What is the significance of 'impermanence' (anitya) in the context of meditative practice?
Contemplating impermanence helps to loosen attachment to worldly phenomena, reduces grasping, and fosters a sense of urgency to practice Dharma, recognizing the fleeting nature of all conditioned things.
157
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the 'meaning of non-conceptual' in relation to realizing emptiness?
Non-conceptual means free from dualistic apprehension, from the conceptual overlay of subject and object, and from the reification of inherent existence; it is a direct, unmediated apprehension.
158
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'causes and effects'?
He demonstrates that if causes inherently existed before effects, they would cease to be causes when effects arise, and if they existed simultaneously, they would not be cause and effect; thus they are empty and dependently arisen.
159
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'path of meditation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*)?
It describes the continuous cultivation of wisdom (realizing emptiness) and method (perfections) across the bodhisattva grounds, gradually eliminating subtle obscurations until Buddhahood is attained.
160
What is the role of 'analogy' in explaining emptiness?
Analogies (like dreams, illusions, reflections) help to illustrate how phenomena appear vividly yet lack inherent existence, making the abstract concept of emptiness more accessible and understandable.
161
What is the 'supreme enlightenment' (*anuttara samyaksaṃbodhi*) that a bodhisattva seeks?
It is the full, perfect, and unsurpassed awakening of a Buddha, which entails omniscience and the spontaneous ability to benefit all sentient beings, attained for their ultimate liberation.
162
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'motion' (gati)?
He analyzes its three phases (going, gone, yet to go) and shows that none can inherently exist, as they are mutually dependent, proving movement's emptiness.
163
What is the significance of 'rejoicing in others' virtues' (muditā) in the Mahayana path?
Rejoicing in the virtuous deeds and happiness of others generates immense merit for oneself, counters envy, and expands one's altruistic heart, fostering a joyful and expansive mind.
164
What is the ultimate purpose of 'meditative concentration' (*dhyāna*) for a bodhisattva?
To provide a stable, clear, and pliable mind that is capable of realizing emptiness and manifesting enlightened activities, thereby serving the ultimate goal of benefiting all sentient beings effectively.
165
What is the ethical imperative of 'non-sexual misconduct' in Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
It advises against sexual activity that causes harm, is non-consensual, or violates commitments, emphasizing respect and purity in relationships, leading to positive karmic results.
166
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle selflessness of phenomena'?
It is the absence of inherent existence in all phenomena, meaning they are merely designated upon their basis and are not truly existent from their own side, which is the object of negation for wisdom.
167
What is the ultimate 'emptiness' that Nāgārjuna describes?
It is not a void or nothingness, but the absence of inherent existence, the true mode of being of all phenomena, allowing for their conventional functionality.
168
What is the role of 'mindfulness' (smṛti) in meditative practice?
Mindfulness is the mental faculty that keeps the mind from distraction, preventing forgetfulness of the meditation object, thereby maintaining mental stability and clarity.
169
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise on 'avoiding harsh speech'?
It advises against speech that causes discord, resentment, and negativity, and instead encourages speech that is kind, pleasing, and promotes harmony.
170
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'non-abiding nirvāṇa'?
It signifies that a Buddha, having fully realized emptiness, does not remain in a solitary peace but manifests continuously in cyclic existence out of great compassion to benefit sentient beings.
171
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'two truths' (conventional and ultimate) as being 'mutually inclusive'?
He clarifies that the two truths are not separate realities but are two aspects of the same phenomenon, existing simultaneously; a phenomenon's conventional appearance is inseparable from its ultimate emptiness.
172
What is the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) in the context of the ten perfections?
It is the direct realization of emptiness, which is the most crucial perfection as it serves as the guide for all other perfections and is the direct antidote to ignorance.
173
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He systematically analyzes each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) to show that none can inherently exist individually or as a collection, demonstrating that any self imputed upon them is empty.
174
What is the role of 'vows and commitments' in maintaining ethical discipline on the bodhisattva path?
Vows and commitments provide a clear framework for ethical conduct, motivate practice, and serve as protective factors to ensure consistent progress towards enlightenment, preventing deviations.
175
What is the ultimate purpose of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers'?
To generate profound gratitude for the countless times all sentient beings have shown kindness in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness through seeking enlightenment for their ultimate happiness.
176
What is the ultimate purpose of 'engaging bodhicitta' in terms of personal transformation?
Engaging bodhicitta, through the practice of the six perfections, transforms one's mindstream by gradually purifying all defilements and obscurations, leading to the full realization of Buddhahood.
177
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) by analyzing their relationship to the self?
He demonstrates that the self cannot be found as inherently existing either as identical to or separate from any or all of the five aggregates, thus concluding the self is merely designated on them.
178
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'perfection of generosity' (*dāna pāramitā*) in fulfilling their aspirations?
Generosity, practiced with bodhicitta and wisdom, is crucial for accumulating vast merit, overcoming attachment, and developing a boundless mind that is capable of truly benefiting all sentient beings.
179
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'illusion-like' nature of phenomena in relation to emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena, like illusions, appear vividly and function conventionally, but they are ultimately empty of inherent existence; they are not non-existent but are devoid of intrinsic reality.
180
What are the 'four factors of irreversibility' on the bodhisattva path
ensuring non-regression?, "They are: not abandoning any sentient being, not abandoning the practice of the six perfections, not abandoning the direct realization of emptiness, and not abandoning the great aspiration to Buddhahood.
181
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the importance of 'correct reasoning' in understanding emptiness?
Correct reasoning, especially the use of *prasanga* arguments, is essential to dismantle mistaken conceptualizations of inherent existence and to arrive at a precise, accurate understanding of emptiness.
182
What is the 'path of meditation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*) and its key objective?
It is the path where the bodhisattva repeatedly habituates to the direct realization of emptiness, gradually eliminating the subtle obscurations (both afflictive and to omniscience) and perfecting the virtues.
183
What is the ethical imperative of 'right intention' (samyak-saṃkalpa) in the context of the noble eightfold path?
Right intention involves cultivating intentions of renunciation (from cyclic existence), non-ill-will (towards others), and non-harming, forming the basis for virtuous actions and thoughts.
184
How does the practice of 'equanimity' (upekṣā) transform one's relationships with others?
By meditating on the fact that all beings equally desire happiness and freedom from suffering, equanimity dissolves biases and prejudice (attachment to friends, aversion to enemies), fostering impartial compassion.
185
What is the significance of 'taking refuge' in the Three Jewels (Buddha
Dharma, Sangha) for a Mahayana practitioner?, "Taking refuge is the foundational commitment that provides ultimate direction, protection, and support on the path to liberation and full enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings.
186
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' (ātman) by showing it is not a distinct entity apart from the aggregates?
He demonstrates that if the self were separate from the aggregates, it would be unobservable and non-functional, thus it is merely designated in dependence on them.
187
What is the role of 'non-conceptual compassion' in a Buddha's activities?
A Buddha's compassion is non-conceptual, spontaneous, and boundless, arising naturally from their profound realization of emptiness and their complete elimination of self-cherishing, enabling effortless benefit for all beings.
188
What are the 'six perfections' (pāramitās) that bodhisattvas cultivate?
Generosity, ethical discipline, patience, joyous effort, meditative concentration, and wisdom.
189
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) by showing they are not inherently one or many?
He analyzes each aggregate and shows that they are neither inherently one nor inherently many, thus demonstrating their empty nature.
190
What is the ultimate purpose of 'meditative concentration' (*dhyāna pāramitā*) on the bodhisattva path?
It is to develop profound mental stability and one-pointedness, which provides the necessary foundation for achieving penetrating insight into emptiness and manifesting limitless enlightened activities.
191
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'conventional validity' of phenomena despite their ultimate emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena, though empty of inherent existence, are still conventionally valid and functional, allowing for the operation of karma, ethical choices, and the existence of the path.
192
What are the 'three types of vows' a Mahayana practitioner may take?
Pratimoksha vows (individual liberation), bodhisattva vows (to benefit all beings), and tantric vows (samayas).
193
What is the ethical imperative of 'right speech' (samyak-vāc) according to Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right speech involves avoiding lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and senseless chatter, and instead engaging in truthful, kind, harmonious, and meaningful communication.
194
How does the practice of 'great compassion' (mahākaruṇā) purify negative karma?
Its immense power, arising from the boundless wish for all beings to be free from suffering, acts as a powerful antidote to accumulated negative karma and prevents future unwholesome actions.
195
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in general Buddhist terms?
It refers to the progressive elimination of mental defilements (afflictions and obscurations to omniscience) through ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom, leading to perfect purity and freedom.
196
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* describe the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*)?
It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all defilements and obscurations are completely eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish in terms of practice or realization.
197
What is the 'causality' aspect of the Four Noble Truths?
It is the truth of the origin of suffering (samudaya), which states that suffering arises from causes, primarily grasping and ignorance, illustrating the principle of dependent arising.
198
What is the purpose of 'dedicating merit' (pariṇāmanā) in Mahayana practice?
Dedicating all accumulated merit for the benefit of all sentient beings ensures that one's positive actions contribute to universal enlightenment, preventing limited individual liberation and strengthening altruism.
199
What is the ethical implication of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) according to Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby supporting one's spiritual practice and benefiting society.
200
What is the role of 'non-conceptual wisdom' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*) in the realization of emptiness?
Non-conceptual wisdom is the direct, unmediated apprehension of emptiness, free from all mental constructs and dualistic appearances, which is the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the direct cause for attaining omniscience.
201
What is the ethical principle of 'contentment' (santuṣṭi) and its benefit?
Contentment is being satisfied with what one has, which reduces desire, attachment, and the suffering that comes from constant striving, fostering inner peace and a virtuous mind.
202
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'conventional existence' of phenomena despite their ultimate emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena, though empty of inherent existence, are still conventionally valid and functional, allowing for the operation of karma and the existence of the path to liberation.
203
What is the 'path of no more training' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) and its ultimate achievement?
It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all defilements and obscurations are completely eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish in terms of practice or realization.
204
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three realms' (triloka) of activity?
A bodhisattva works tirelessly in all three realms of existence (desire, form, formless) to liberate sentient beings from suffering, without being bound by these realms due to their wisdom and compassion.
205
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the doer' (kāraka) and 'the deed' (kārya)?
He shows that neither action nor actor can inherently exist independently, as they are mutually defined and dependently arisen, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
206
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'illusory' nature of phenomena in relation to their emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena, like illusions, appear vividly and function conventionally, but they are ultimately empty of inherent existence; they are not non-existent but are devoid of intrinsic reality.
207
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers' in the seven-point instruction?
To generate profound gratitude for the countless times all sentient beings have shown kindness in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness through seeking enlightenment.
208
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'lying'?
It explains that lying creates negative karma and harms others, undermining trust and causing suffering, hence it should be abandoned and truthful speech cultivated.
209
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'union of the two truths' (conventional and ultimate) as being 'mutually inclusive'?
He clarifies that the two truths are not separate realities but are two aspects of the same phenomenon, existing simultaneously; a phenomenon's conventional appearance is inseparable from its ultimate emptiness.
210
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) using the 'sevenfold analysis of the chariot'?
He applies the sevenfold analysis (whether it is one, many, etc.) to the aggregates, demonstrating that no inherently existing self or aggregates can be found, thus they are empty.
211
What is the primary subject matter of the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras?
The Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras primarily elucidate the profound wisdom of emptiness and the path of the bodhisattva.
212
What is the *Abhisamayālaṁkāra* (Ornament of Clear Realization)?
It is a root text by Maitreya (or Asaṅga, depending on tradition) that provides a systematic outline and commentary on the vast Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras.
213
What is the purpose of studying the *Abhisamayālaṁkāra*?
Its purpose is to provide a comprehensive framework for understanding the hidden meanings and progressive stages of realization within the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras.
214
What are the "eight topics of realization" (*abhisamaya*) structured by the *Abhisamayālaṁkāra*?
The eight topics are: the all-aspect knowledge, the knowledge of paths, the knowledge of bases, the complete training in all aspects, the peak training, the gradual training, the training in a single instant, and the resultant dharmakāya.
215
What is the "all-aspect knowledge" (*sarvākārajñatā*)?
It is the omniscient wisdom of a Buddha, which is the ultimate goal of the Mahāyāna path, characterized by knowing all phenomena in all their aspects.
216
What is the "knowledge of paths" (*mārga-jñatā*)?
It is the wisdom of a bodhisattva that knows the paths of all three vehicles (Śrāvaka, Pratyekabuddha, and Bodhisattva) and how they lead to their respective goals.
217
What is the "knowledge of bases" (*vastu-jñatā*)?
It is the wisdom that knows the foundations or bases of everything, including phenomena of cyclic existence and nirvāṇa.
218
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁkāra* relate to the *Ten Bhūmis* (Bodhisattva Stages)?
The *Abhisamayālaṁkāra* explains the various stages of the bodhisattva's path, from generating bodhicitta up to the attainment of Buddhahood, which are correlated with the Ten Bhūmis.
219
What is the significance of "emptiness" (*śūnyatā*) in the context of the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras?
Emptiness is the ultimate nature of all phenomena, meaning they lack inherent existence, and its realization is the core of wisdom.
220
What is the meaning of "groundless paths" in the title of Brunnhölzl's book?
It refers to the understanding that the paths and realizations are themselves empty of inherent existence, yet they function effectively.
221
What are the two main types of "knowledges" that a bodhisattva cultivates?
The knowledge of the two truths (conventional and ultimate) and the knowledge of the paths that lead to liberation.
222
What is the role of *compassion* in the *Prajñāpāramitā* tradition?
Compassion (karuṇā) serves as the primary motivation for engaging in the bodhisattva path and for realizing emptiness, ensuring wisdom is not merely intellectual.
223
What is the "union of wisdom and compassion" in this context?
It means that the realization of emptiness (wisdom) is always imbued with the motivation to benefit all sentient beings (compassion).
224
What is the "peak training" (*mūrdhābhisamaya*)?
It refers to the peak of the path of preparation, where the bodhisattva's understanding of emptiness is at its highest conceptual level, just before direct realization.
225
What is the "gradual training" (*anupūrva-yogacarya*)?
It refers to the gradual purification of defilements and the enhancement of realizations that occur throughout the bodhisattva stages after gaining direct insight into emptiness.
226
What is the "training in a single instant" (*ekakṣaṇābhisamaya*)?
It refers to the final training where all remaining subtle obscurations are removed in a single moment, leading to the attainment of full Buddhahood.
227
What is the "resultant dharmakāya" (*phala-dharmakāya*)?
It is the ultimate result of the path, the Buddha's Truth Body, which encompasses perfect wisdom and infinite compassion.
228
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁkāra* categorize practitioners on the path?
It categorizes them according to their level of realization, from ordinary individuals to those on the various bodhisattva paths and finally Buddhas.
229
What is the "path of accumulation" (*sambhāra-mārga*) according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The stage where practitioners initially generate bodhicitta and accumulate merit and wisdom through practices like the Six Perfections.
230
What is the "path of preparation" (*prayoga-mārga*) according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The stage where practitioners enhance their conceptual understanding of emptiness through analytical meditation, preparing for direct realization.
231
What is the "path of seeing" (*darśana-mārga*) according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The stage where practitioners directly and non-conceptually perceive emptiness for the first time, becoming an Ārya (noble being) and entering the first bodhisattva bhūmi.
232
What is the "path of meditation" (*bhāvanā-mārga*) according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The stage where practitioners repeatedly meditate on the emptiness they have seen, gradually purifying defilements and enhancing their realizations across the remaining bhūmis.
233
What is the "path of no more learning" (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The final stage where practitioners attain full enlightenment, having completely eliminated all defilements and developed all good qualities.
234
What is the significance of the "seven types of training" mentioned in the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
These trainings encompass the entire progressive development of a bodhisattva's qualities and realizations.
235
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* emphasize the non-conceptual nature of wisdom?
It describes the ultimate wisdom as a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, transcending all intellectual constructs.
236
What are the "three jewels" (*triratna*) that a bodhisattva takes refuge in?
The Buddha, Dharma, and Saṅgha.
237
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* clarify the relationship between the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras and their commentaries?
The Sūtras are the direct words of the Buddha, while the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* serves as a systematic commentary that reveals their hidden meanings.
238
What is the meaning of "perfect wisdom" (*prajñāpāramitā*) in its ultimate sense?
It is the wisdom that perfectly realizes the emptiness of all phenomena, free from any conceptual or dualistic grasping.
239
What are the "two obscurations" that a bodhisattva seeks to overcome?
The obscurations of afflictions (kleśāvaraṇa) and the obscurations to omniscience (jñeyāvaraṇa).
240
What are the *four types of yogic practitioners* described in relation to the path?
Those who analyze by way of aspects, by way of meaning, by way of both, and by way of neither.
241
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* describe the qualities of a Buddha's body (rupakaya)?
It explains the two form bodies: the enjoyment body (sambhogakāya) and the emanation body (nirmāṇakāya), which arise from the accumulation of merit.
242
What is the "training in complete aspects" (*sarvākārābhisaṃbodha*)?
It refers to the training of a bodhisattva who aims to realize all aspects of the path, including the knowledge of all phenomena and the knowledge of the paths.
243
What is the primary function of the "Prajñāpāramitā" for a bodhisattva?
It is the mother of all Buddhas, giving birth to enlightened beings and their qualities.
244
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* present the stages of gaining insight into emptiness?
Through a gradual process of conceptual understanding, analytical meditation, and eventually direct, non-conceptual realization.
245
What is the significance of the "non-abiding nirvāṇa" (*apratiṣṭhita-nirvāṇa*) for a bodhisattva?
It is the state of a Buddha who has overcome both cyclic existence and the extreme of quiescent nirvāṇa, abiding in neither for the benefit of all beings.
246
What is the role of *merit* (puṇya) in achieving the form bodies of a Buddha?
The accumulation of vast merit through virtuous actions serves as the cause for the manifestation of a Buddha's form bodies.
247
What is the role of *wisdom* (prajñā) in achieving the truth body of a Buddha?
The accumulation of deep awareness (wisdom) through realizing emptiness serves as the cause for the manifestation of a Buddha's truth body (dharmakāya).
248
What is the nature of the "Buddha's activity" (buddha-kārya) as explained in the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
A Buddha's activity is spontaneous, constant, and unceasing, arising effortlessly for the benefit of all sentient beings.
249
What is the "meditation on the universal nature" (dharmatā-dhyāna)?
A form of meditation that focuses on the ultimate nature of all phenomena, which is emptiness.
250
What is the purpose of *pratītyasamutpāda* (dependent arising) within the Prajñāpāramitā teachings?
It serves as the logical basis for understanding emptiness, as phenomena that arise dependently cannot have inherent existence.
251
What is the "knowledge of non-production" (*anutpāda-jñāna*)?
The wisdom that realizes that phenomena do not arise inherently, nor do they cease inherently.
252
What is the meaning of "perfect equanimity" in the context of the bodhisattva's path?
It is a mind free from attachment to friends, aversion to enemies, and indifference to strangers, rooted in the understanding of their ultimate emptiness.
253
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* explain the "signs" (nimitta) that a bodhisattva cultivates?
These are the various characteristics and qualities that manifest as a bodhisattva progresses through the stages, reflecting their increasing wisdom and compassion.
254
What is the "mirror-like wisdom" (*ādarśajñāna*) of a Buddha?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which perfectly reflects all phenomena as they are, without distortion.
255
What is the "wisdom of equanimity" (*samatā-jñāna*) of a Buddha?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which perceives the equality of all phenomena in emptiness and the equality of all sentient beings.
256
What is the "discriminating wisdom" (*pratyavekṣaṇā-jñāna*) of a Buddha?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which precisely distinguishes all phenomena and their characteristics.
257
What is the "accomplishing wisdom" (*kṛtyānuṣṭhāna-jñāna*) of a Buddha?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which spontaneously accomplishes all activities for the benefit of sentient beings.
258
What is the "Dharma-realm wisdom" (*dharma-dhātu-jñāna*) of a Buddha?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which directly realizes the ultimate nature of reality, the dharmadhātu.
259
What is the importance of *meditative absorption* (samādhi) in the Prajñāpāramitā path?
It provides the stability and clarity of mind necessary for deeply engaging with and realizing the wisdom of emptiness.
260
What is the "great compassion that is unsubduable" (*asaṃhārya-karuṇā*)?
The profound compassion of a Buddha or high-level bodhisattva that cannot be discouraged or overwhelmed by the suffering of sentient beings.
261
What is the "path of great light" for a bodhisattva?
It refers to the radiant wisdom that dispels the darkness of ignorance as a bodhisattva progresses on the path.
262
What is the role of *aspirational prayers* (*praṇidhāna*) in the context of the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
They are powerful intentions that guide a bodhisattva's practice and help to actualize their vows to benefit all beings.
263
What is the meaning of "non-referential compassion" in the Prajñāpāramitā tradition?
Compassion that arises from the understanding of emptiness, free from any inherent dualistic grasping at an inherently existing "sufferer" or "savior".
264
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* relate to the *mind-only* (cittamātra) school?
While it discusses the mind, its ultimate view transcends the inherent existence posited by some Mind-Only interpretations, moving towards the Mādhyamaka view of emptiness.
265
What are the "four applications of mindfulness" (*smṛtyupasthāna*) as a practice for wisdom?
Mindfulness of body, feelings, mind, and phenomena.
266
What are the "four correct abandonments" (*samyak-prahāṇa*) as a practice for wisdom?
Exertion to prevent non-virtue from arising, abandon arisen non-virtue, produce unarisen virtue, and develop arisen virtue.
267
What are the "four limbs of miracle" (*ṛddhipāda*) as a practice for wisdom?
Concentration based on aspiration, effort, thinking, and analysis.
268
What are the "five faculties" (*indriya*) as a practice for wisdom?
Faith, effort, mindfulness, meditative concentration, and wisdom.
269
What are the "five powers" (*bala*) as a practice for wisdom?
The matured forms of the five faculties: power of faith, effort, mindfulness, meditative concentration, and wisdom.
270
What are the "seven branches of awakening" (*bodhyaṅga*) as a practice for wisdom?
Mindfulness, Dharma investigation, joyous effort, rapture, tranquility, concentration, and equanimity.
271
What is the "eightfold noble path" (*āryāṣṭāṅgika-mārga*) as a practice for wisdom?
Right view, right thought, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration.
272
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* describe the "purification of defilements" on the path?
It is a gradual process of eliminating obscurations through increasing realization of emptiness and cultivation of the perfections.
273
What is the meaning of "perfected engagement" in the context of the bodhisattva's actions?
Actions performed with the motivation of bodhicitta and sealed by the wisdom of emptiness, making them truly transformative.
274
What is the importance of *analytical wisdom* in the initial stages of the path?
It helps to conceptually understand emptiness and refute wrong views, paving the way for direct realization.
275
What is the "non-conceptual wisdom" in the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The direct and immediate realization of emptiness, free from all mental constructs and dualities, attained on the path of seeing.
276
What is the "union of appearances and emptiness" in the context of a Buddha's mind?
A Buddha simultaneously perceives conventional appearances and their ultimate emptiness, without contradiction.
277
What is the *paramārtha-satya* (ultimate truth) as explained by the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The emptiness of inherent existence of all phenomena, beyond conceptual fabrication.
278
What is the *saṃvṛti-satya* (conventional truth) as explained by the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The valid, functional appearances of phenomena, which are nonetheless empty of inherent existence.
279
What is the primary "obscuration to omniscience" (*jñeyāvaraṇa*)?
The subtle imprints left by the grasping at inherent existence, preventing full, omniscient knowledge of all phenomena.
280
What is the primary "obscuration of afflictions" (*kleśāvaraṇa*)?
The mental afflictions (attachment, anger, ignorance, etc.) that prevent liberation from cyclic existence.
281
How does a bodhisattva purify the two obscurations?
The obscurations of afflictions are mainly purified on the path of seeing and meditation, while the obscurations to omniscience are fully purified on the path of no more learning.
282
What are the "four trainings" (yoga) that a bodhisattva engages in to realize emptiness?
The training in the understanding of the nature of phenomena, the training in non-conceptual wisdom, the training in the two truths, and the training in the union of wisdom and compassion.
283
What is the meaning of "unfabricated" (*anābhoga*) in relation to a Buddha's activity?
A Buddha's enlightened activities arise spontaneously and effortlessly, without any need for conscious effort or fabrication.
284
What is the "omniscience of a Buddha" in the context of the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The complete and perfect knowledge of all phenomena, both conventionally and ultimately, without any limitations.
285
How is the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* structured to teach the Prajñāpāramitā?
It presents the entire content of the Perfection of Wisdom sutras in a condensed, systematic outline based on the bodhisattva's journey.
286
What is the "meaning of *pāramitā*" in the context of the perfections?
It means "gone to the other shore," signifying that these practices lead one beyond cyclic existence to enlightenment.
287
What is the "path of insight" (vipashyana) in the context of the Prajñāpāramitā?
It is the analytical meditation that leads to the direct realization of emptiness.
288
What is the "path of calm abiding" (shamatha) in the context of the Prajñāpāramitā?
It is the development of single-pointed concentration that provides the stable foundation for insightful meditation.
289
What is the relationship between shamatha and vipashyana in the Prajñāpāramitā path?
They are practiced in union; shamatha provides the mental stability, and vipashyana provides the wisdom that penetrates reality.
290
What is the "wisdom of discerning phenomena" (*pratyavekṣaṇā-jñāna*)?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which perfectly discerns all phenomena and their specific characteristics.
291
What is the "wisdom of fulfilling all wishes" (*kṛtyānuṣṭhāna-jñāna*)?
One of the five wisdoms of a Buddha, which effortlessly accomplishes all actions for the benefit of sentient beings.
292
What is the role of *conceptual thought* in the early stages of realizing emptiness?
Conceptual thought is initially used in analytical meditation to understand emptiness, but is eventually transcended for direct, non-conceptual realization.
293
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* present the *nature of the mind*?
The mind is described as fundamentally pure (empty of inherent existence) but temporarily obscured by adventitious defilements.
294
What is the "resultant state" of the bodhisattva path?
The attainment of the two kāyas (bodies) of a Buddha: the form bodies (rūpakāya) for the benefit of others and the truth body (dharmakāya) for one's own realization.
295
What is the meaning of "non-dual wisdom" in the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The wisdom that directly perceives emptiness without the duality of subject and object, or any inherent distinctions.
296
What is the significance of the *heart sutra* in the Prajñāpāramitā tradition?
It succinctly encapsulates the essence of the Prajñāpāramitā teachings, stating that form is emptiness, and emptiness is form.
297
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* guide a bodhisattva to relinquish attachment to phenomena?
By systematically analyzing their lack of inherent existence, demonstrating their illusory nature.
298
What is the meaning of "appearance-only" in the context of the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
While similar to the Mind-Only school, here it refers to phenomena appearing to the mind but ultimately being empty of inherent existence.
299
What are the "three aspects of the knower of bases"?
The knowledge of the bases of cyclic existence, the bases of nirvāṇa, and the bases that are neither.
300
What is the function of the "knowledge of paths" for a bodhisattva's compassion?
It allows the bodhisattva to skillfully guide beings of all three vehicles to their respective liberations, understanding their diverse needs.
301
What is the "ultimate wisdom" according to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The wisdom that directly perceives the ultimate truth of emptiness, which is beyond all conceptual elaborations.
302
What is the "relative truth" from the perspective of the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The world of appearances, which functions conventionally but is ultimately empty of inherent existence.
303
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* provide a framework for meditation on emptiness?
It systematically lays out the steps and types of knowledge needed to progressively realize emptiness through both conceptual and non-conceptual means.
304
What is the significance of "Buddha activity" flowing spontaneously from emptiness?
From the realization of emptiness, a Buddha's boundless compassion and skillful means manifest naturally and effortlessly to benefit beings.
305
What is the "all-pervading wisdom" of a Buddha?
The complete knowledge of all phenomena in their every aspect, which is the result of fully purifying both obscurations.
306
What is the "training in the characteristics of objects"?
A part of the training that involves discerning the specific characteristics of various phenomena to understand their true nature.
307
What is the "training in the non-characteristics of objects"?
A part of the training that involves realizing the emptiness of inherent characteristics in all phenomena.
308
What is the role of *faith* (*śraddhā*) in the Prajñāpāramitā path?
Faith in the teachings of emptiness and the path of the bodhisattva provides the initial impetus for practice.
309
What is the significance of "irreversibility" (avaivartika) for a bodhisattva who has reached the first bhūmi?
They are irreversible from the path to full enlightenment, having gained direct insight into emptiness.
310
What is the relationship between the *Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras* and the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra*?
The *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* is a structured commentary that extracts and clarifies the profound, often diffuse, meaning of the Perfection of Wisdom Sūtras.
311
What is the primary obstacle to realizing emptiness?
The deeply ingrained habit of grasping at inherent existence.
312
How does *analytical investigation* lead to certainty in emptiness?
By systematically searching for inherent existence in all phenomena and failing to find it, one develops unwavering conviction.
313
What is the "wisdom of dependent arising" in the context of emptiness?
The understanding that because phenomena arise dependently, they must necessarily be empty of inherent existence.
314
What is the "Buddha's two bodies" that a bodhisattva aims to achieve?
The Form Body (Rūpakāya) for the benefit of others and the Truth Body (Dharmakāya) for one's own perfect realization.
315
What is the purpose of distinguishing between "definitive" and "interpretive" meanings in the Sūtras?
To guide practitioners to understand the ultimate truth of emptiness (definitive) and to apply provisional teachings (interpretive) appropriately.
316
What is the *ultimate fruit* of the Prajñāpāramitā path?
The attainment of unsurpassed, perfect, complete Buddhahood.
317
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* present the path of a bodhisattva as a progression?
As a systematic, logical, and increasingly profound journey through various stages of understanding and realization.
318
What is the *essence of all phenomena* according to the Prajñāpāramitā?
Emptiness, the absence of inherent existence.
319
What is the "single taste" of all phenomena in the context of emptiness?
All phenomena, regardless of their conventional appearances, share the single taste of emptiness.
320
What is the significance of the "ten perfections" as described in some Prajñāpāramitā texts?
These are the six perfections plus four additional ones (skillful means, aspiration, power, wisdom), all practiced with the realization of emptiness.
321
What is the role of *accumulating wisdom* for a bodhisattva on the path?
Accumulating wisdom (through understanding emptiness) is the primary cause for attaining the Truth Body (Dharmakāya) of a Buddha.
322
What is the ultimate aim of the "Path of No More Learning" in relation to obscurations?
The complete and irreversible elimination of all obscurations to omniscience.
323
What is the "Great Compassion" in the context of the Prajñāpāramitā that is born from emptiness?
It is a compassion that sees sentient beings as suffering in an illusory way, motivating tireless effort for their liberation.
324
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* structure the teachings on the *Prajñāpāramitā*?
It presents them in a highly organized and detailed manner, revealing the inner connections and logical progression of the path.
325
What is the significance of the *commentaries* to the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* (like those in Brunnhölzl's book)?
They provide extensive explanations, clarify difficult points, and elaborate on the subtle meanings, making the root text accessible to students.
326
What is the meaning of "perfect knowledge of everything" for a Buddha?
The ability to know all phenomena, their causes, conditions, and results, simultaneously and without effort.
327
What is the *Great Voidness* (*mahāśūnyatā*)?
A term used to describe the emptiness of all phenomena, emphasizing its all-encompassing nature.
328
What is the *unimpeded wisdom* (*asaṅga-jñāna*) of a Buddha?
The Buddha's wisdom that perceives all phenomena without any obstruction or hindrance.
329
How does the *Abhisamayālaṁlāra* distinguish between *conceptual* and *non-conceptual* wisdom?
Conceptual wisdom involves mental constructs and dualities, while non-conceptual wisdom directly perceives emptiness without such limitations.
330
What is the "wisdom of knowing the mindstreams of others" (*paracitta-jñāna*)?
A realization that develops as a bodhisattva progresses, allowing them to understand the thoughts and intentions of other beings.
331
What is the "great wisdom" (*mahāprajñā*) of a Buddha?
The ultimate wisdom that fully realizes the emptiness of all phenomena, transcending all intellectual constructs.
332
What is the full title of Nāgārjuna's foundational text on the Middle Way?
The *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* (Root Verses on the Middle Way).
333
What is the primary aim of Nāgārjuna's *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* (MMK)?
To demonstrate the emptiness (śūnyatā) of all phenomena by refuting any inherent existence or self-nature (svabhāva).
334
What are the "two truths" as understood in Nāgārjuna's Mādhyamaka?
Conventional truth (saṃvṛti-satya) and ultimate truth (paramārtha-satya).
335
How does Nāgārjuna define "emptiness" (śūnyatā) in the MMK?
Emptiness is the absence of inherent existence in all phenomena, meaning nothing exists independently or by its own nature.
336
What is the relationship between "emptiness" and "dependent arising" (pratītyasamutpāda) for Nāgārjuna?
They are synonymous: because phenomena are dependently arisen, they are empty of inherent existence; and because they are empty, they can arise dependently.
337
What are the "four alternatives" (catuṣkoṭi) often used by Nāgārjuna in his arguments?
Existence, non-existence, both existence and non-existence, and neither existence nor non-existence.
338
How does Nāgārjuna use the four alternatives to refute inherent production?
He argues that nothing can arise inherently from itself, from other, from both, or from neither, thereby demonstrating that all production is dependently originated and thus empty.
339
What is the "object of negation" (pratiṣedhya) in Mādhyamaka analysis?
The inherent existence (svabhāva) of phenomena.
340
Why does Nāgārjuna refute inherent existence?
Because grasping at inherent existence is the root cause of all suffering and mental afflictions.
341
What is the primary method of argumentation employed by Nāgārjuna in the MMK?
The *prasanga* (reductio ad absurdum) method, showing the absurd consequences of assuming inherent existence.
342
What is the meaning of "cessation" (nirodha) according to Nāgārjuna?
Cessation is also empty of inherent existence; it is the cessation of suffering and its causes, which is itself dependently arisen.
343
How does Nāgārjuna argue against the inherent existence of "motion" (gati)?
He shows that motion cannot inherently exist in the mover, the path, or the motion itself, demonstrating its dependent nature.
344
What is the purpose of analyzing the *self* (ātman) in the MMK?
To demonstrate the selflessness of persons (pudgala-nairātmya) by showing that no inherently existing self can be found.
345
How does Nāgārjuna argue against the inherent existence of *time*?
He shows that past, present, and future are dependently related and cannot exist inherently in isolation.
346
What is the *nature of suffering* (duḥkha) from Nāgārjuna's Mādhyamaka perspective?
Suffering, like all phenomena, is empty of inherent existence, meaning it is not a fixed, independent entity but arises dependently and can be ceased.
347
How does Nāgārjuna address the concept of *nirvāṇa*?
Nirvāṇa is also empty of inherent existence; it is not a positive entity but the mere cessation of grasping and defilements.
348
What is the famous statement by Nāgārjuna about samsara and nirvana?
There is not the slightest distinction between samsara and nirvana.
349
What does it mean that "samsara and nirvana are not different" in Nāgārjuna's view?
Both samsara and nirvana are empty of inherent existence; their distinction is merely conventional.
350
Why is the understanding of emptiness crucial for liberation?
Because it eradicates the fundamental ignorance that grasps at inherent existence, which is the root of cyclic existence.
351
What is the role of *compassion* in Nāgārjuna's philosophy?
Compassion motivates one to realize emptiness for the benefit of all suffering beings, who are deluded by grasping at inherent existence.
352
What is Nāgārjuna's view on the inherent existence of *causes and conditions*?
Causes and conditions are themselves empty of inherent existence; they function dependently but are not ultimately real in themselves.
353
How does Nāgārjuna critique the idea of *inherent identity* between cause and effect?
If cause and effect were inherently identical, there would be no production; if inherently different, they could not relate as cause and effect.
354
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that explicitly discusses "Examination of Motion"?
Chapter 2.
355
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that explicitly discusses "Examination of Self"?
Chapter 27.
356
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Nirvana"?
Chapter 25.
357
What is the core argument in MMK Chapter 1
Examination of Conditions"?,It refutes inherent production from any of the four conditions (cause, object-support, immediate, predominant).
358
What is the meaning of "conventional truth" (saṃvṛti-satya) in Nāgārjuna's context?
It refers to phenomena that appear to exist and are valid for ordinary interaction, but only in dependence and without inherent reality.
359
What is the meaning of "ultimate truth" (paramārtha-satya) in Nāgārjuna's context?
It refers to the absence of inherent existence, the true mode of being of phenomena, which is realized non-conceptually.
360
How does Nāgārjuna's emptiness avoid *nihilism*?
By asserting that emptiness is not absolute non-existence but the lack of inherent existence, allowing for conventional functionality.
361
How does Nāgārjuna's emptiness avoid *eternalism*?
By refuting any inherently existing, permanent self or phenomena.
362
What is the meaning of "empty of self-nature" (*svabhāva-śūnya*)?
It means that phenomena do not possess an unchanging, independent essence or identity from their own side.
363
What is the significance of the phrase "whatever is dependently originated is emptiness" in the MMK?
It directly links dependent arising with emptiness, making them two sides of the same coin.
364
How does Nāgārjuna's analysis of "nirvana" relate to mental purification?
Nirvana is the cessation of concepts and proliferation (prapañca), which are rooted in grasping at inherent existence.
365
What is the "king of reasonings" in Mādhyamaka
as attributed to dependent arising?,Dependent arising is considered the supreme reasoning for establishing emptiness.
366
What is the *functionality* of phenomena in Nāgārjuna's view
despite their emptiness?,Phenomena, though empty, can still perform functions and engage in cause-and-effect relationships.
367
What is the *conventional validity* of ordinary perception for Nāgārjuna?
Ordinary perception is conventionally valid for practical purposes, even if it apprehends phenomena as inherently existent.
368
What is the *root of all suffering* according to Nāgārjuna?
The fundamental ignorance that grasps at inherent existence.
369
How does Nāgārjuna argue against the inherent existence of *fire and fuel*?
He shows they are mutually dependent and cannot inherently exist independently of each other.
370
What is the *goal of the Mādhyamaka path* for a practitioner?
To realize emptiness directly and thereby cut off the root of cyclic existence.
371
What is the *role of wisdom* (prajñā) in Nāgārjuna's teaching?
Wisdom, the realization of emptiness, is the direct antidote to ignorance and the means to liberation.
372
What is the *conventional truth of a person* according to Nāgārjuna?
A person is a mere designation on the aggregates (body, mind, etc.) and does not inherently exist.
373
What is the *ultimate truth of a person* according to Nāgārjuna?
The emptiness of inherent existence of the person.
374
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of *suffering* (duḥkha) itself?
Suffering arises dependently and lacks inherent nature; it is not a fixed, independent entity.
375
What is the significance of the *emptiness of ultimate truth* itself?
Even ultimate truth (emptiness) is empty of inherent existence; it is not a reified absolute.
376
How does Nāgārjuna's Mādhyamaka contribute to the *bodhisattva's compassion*?
By understanding that sentient beings suffer due to grasping at what is ultimately non-existent, a bodhisattva's compassion deepens.
377
What is the *true nature of reality* according to Nāgārjuna?
Emptiness, free from all conceptual elaborations and extremes.
378
What is the meaning of "origination from other" (para-bhāva) in MMK analysis?
The idea that something inherently arises from something else, which Nāgārjuna refutes.
379
What is the meaning of "origination from self" (svataḥ-utpāda) in MMK analysis?
The idea that something inherently arises from itself, which Nāgārjuna refutes.
380
What is the *analogy of a dream* or *illusion* in Nāgārjuna's work?
Phenomena appear to exist but are ultimately empty of inherent reality, similar to a dream or an illusion.
381
What is the *significance of silence* for Nāgārjuna regarding ultimate reality?
Ultimate reality, emptiness, is beyond words and concepts, thus sometimes represented by silence.
382
What is the *conventional existence* of things for Nāgārjuna?
It is their dependent existence, which is sufficient for them to function in the world.
383
How does Nāgārjuna address the concept of *nirvana* being a state to be achieved?
Nirvana is not something to be *acquired* but the *cessation* of ignorance and defilements, which are already non-inherently existent.
384
What is the *relationship between conventional and ultimate truths* for Nāgārjuna?
They are not separate entities; ultimate truth is the true nature of conventional phenomena.
385
What is the *ultimate fruit* of realizing emptiness for a practitioner?
Complete liberation from cyclic existence and the attainment of Buddhahood.
386
What is the *primary philosophical school* that Nāgārjuna founded?
The Mādhyamaka (Middle Way) school.
387
How does Nāgārjuna argue that the *Buddha* himself is empty of inherent existence?
The Buddha, like all phenomena, exists dependently and lacks inherent nature.
388
What is the significance of the *twenty-seven chapters* of the MMK?
Each chapter systematically refutes the inherent existence of a particular phenomenon or concept.
389
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of the Aggregates"?
Chapter 3.
390
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of the Sense Organs and Objects"?
Chapter 4.
391
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of the Elements"?
Chapter 5.
392
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Attachment and the Attacher"?
Chapter 6.
393
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Agent and Action"?
Chapter 8.
394
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Previous Existence"?
Chapter 9.
395
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Fire and Fuel"?
Chapter 10.
396
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Past and Future"?
Chapter 11.
397
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Suffering"?
Chapter 12.
398
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of Mental Afflictions"?
Chapter 23.
399
What is the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* chapter that discusses "Examination of the Twelve Links"?
Chapter 26.
400
What does Nāgārjuna say about the cessation of *prapañca* (conceptual proliferation) in relation to nirvana?
Nirvana is the peaceful cessation of all conceptual proliferations.
401
How does Nāgārjuna's argument for emptiness avoid making emptiness itself an inherent entity?
Emptiness itself is also empty of inherent existence; it is not a reified absolute or a 'thing'.
402
What is the significance of the MMK in Buddhist philosophy?
It systematically established the Mādhyamaka view of emptiness, becoming a cornerstone for later philosophical developments in India and Tibet.
403
What is the *analogy of space* in the context of emptiness?
Just as space is not a substance but allows for the existence of all phenomena, emptiness (absence of inherent existence) allows for dependent arising.
404
What is the *ethical implication* of realizing emptiness according to Mādhyamaka?
Realizing emptiness reduces grasping and egoism, fostering greater compassion and altruistic action.
405
What is the *relationship between suffering and its causes* in Nāgārjuna's view?
Suffering arises dependently on its causes, which are themselves empty of inherent existence.
406
How does Nāgārjuna address the idea of *inherent identity* between the individual and the aggregates?
He shows that the individual is neither inherently identical with the aggregates nor inherently separate from them.
407
What is the ultimate benefit of understanding the *interdependence* of all phenomena?
It leads to the realization of emptiness and reduces grasping at fixed entities.
408
What is the *Buddha's teaching on the Middle Way* in the MMK?
The Buddha taught that existence is not permanent (eternalism) nor does it cease completely (nihilism), but exists as dependent arising, thus empty.
409
What is the *importance of logic and reasoning* in Nāgārjuna's work?
Logic and reasoning are used as tools to dismantle misconceptions about inherent existence, leading to the direct experience of emptiness.
410
What is the nature of *reality* as understood by the wise according to Nāgārjuna?
Reality is beyond all dualistic conceptualizations and inherent existence.
411
How does Nāgārjuna's Mādhyamaka influence the *meditative practice*?
It guides the practitioner to analyze phenomena and ultimately rest in the non-conceptual realization of their emptiness.
412
What is the *ultimate aim* of realizing emptiness for others' benefit?
To attain omniscience and be able to spontaneously and effectively benefit all sentient beings.
413
What is the *significance of the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras* as a source for Nāgārjuna's work?
The Prajñāpāramitā Sūtras are the primary scriptural source for Nāgārjuna's philosophical arguments on emptiness.
414
How does Nāgārjuna's analysis of *production* relate to the *emptiness of phenomena*?
By refuting inherent production, he shows that phenomena are necessarily empty of inherent existence.
415
What is the meaning of "unfabricated" in the context of emptiness?
Emptiness is not something created or constructed; it is the ultimate nature of reality as it is.
416
What is the relationship between *ignorance* and *attachment* in Mādhyamaka?
Ignorance (grasping at inherent existence) leads to attachment, which in turn leads to suffering.
417
How does Nāgārjuna's *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* serve as a guide to higher wisdom?
It systematically dismantles all conceptual fabrications, leading the mind towards the direct experience of ultimate reality.
418
What is the meaning of "relational existence" in Mādhyamaka?
Phenomena exist in dependence on other factors, not in isolation.
419
What is the *result* of understanding that all mental afflictions are empty of inherent existence?
It leads to the possibility of their complete cessation.
420
How does Nāgārjuna's work pave the way for the *Mahayana path*?
By providing the profound philosophical basis for the Perfection of Wisdom, which is essential for a bodhisattva's journey.
421
What is the *ultimate purpose* of analyzing all phenomena as empty?
To free the mind from clinging and dualistic perceptions, leading to liberation.
422
What is the meaning of "beyond extremes" in the Middle Way?
It means avoiding the extremes of eternalism (inherent existence) and nihilism (absolute non-existence).
423
How does Nāgārjuna address the concept of *cause and effect* from an ultimate perspective?
Cause and effect are interdependent and empty of inherent existence, yet they function conventionally.
424
What is the relationship between *emptiness and compassion* in the Buddhist path?
Wisdom (realizing emptiness) enables one to see the root of suffering, which then fuels boundless compassion to liberate others.
425
What is the significance of *reasoning* in the Mādhyamaka practice?
It is a crucial tool to dispel misconceptions and prepare the mind for the direct insight into emptiness.
426
What does it mean for *dharmas* (phenomena) to be "non-arising" in an ultimate sense?
They do not arise inherently from a fixed, independent source.
427
How does Nāgārjuna argue against the inherent existence of *qualities and their substrata*?
Qualities cannot exist inherently separate from their substrata, nor can substrata exist inherently without qualities.
428
What is the *fundamental insight* gained from studying the MMK?
The realization that nothing has inherent existence, and everything is dependently arisen.
429
How does Nāgārjuna's Mādhyamaka provide the *basis for meditative realization*?
It provides the correct view (wisdom) that is necessary to guide effective meditation on emptiness.
430
What is the *meaning of "truth" (satya) in the context of the two truths*?
It refers to the valid mode of existence, either conventionally or ultimately.
431
What is the *ultimate nature of consciousness* for Nāgārjuna?
Consciousness, like other phenomena, is dependently arisen and empty of inherent existence.
432
How does the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* contribute to understanding the *four noble truths* from a Mahayana perspective?
It provides the ultimate understanding of suffering, its cause, cessation, and path, by showing their emptiness of inherent existence.
433
What is the ultimate benefit of cultivating 'equanimity' (upekṣā) in generating bodhicitta?
Equanimity establishes an impartial mind, free from attachment and aversion towards any sentient being, thereby ensuring that one's loving-kindness and compassion extend equally to all, without bias.
434
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) by analyzing their relationship to 'form'?
He demonstrates that 'form' cannot inherently exist as distinct from the other aggregates, nor can the other aggregates exist inherently without form, proving their mutual dependence and emptiness.
435
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'perfection of ethical discipline' (*śīla pāramitā*) in relation to higher meditative states?
Ethical discipline purifies the mind of gross defilements, creating the inner peace, absence of remorse, and mental stability necessary for sustained meditative concentration and deeper insights.
436
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'illusion-like' nature of phenomena in relation to their appearance and reality?
He clarifies that phenomena appear vividly and function conventionally, but this appearance is like an illusion, which is empty of inherent existence; they are not non-existent but are devoid of intrinsic reality.
437
What is the ultimate purpose of 'wisdom' (*prajñā*) as the 'mother' of all Buddhas?
Wisdom (the direct realization of emptiness) is paramount because it is the essential condition for attaining Buddhahood, directly cutting the root of ignorance and leading to omniscience and complete liberation.
438
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the 'union of method and wisdom' in the Mahayana path?
He emphasizes that method (compassion, skillful means, merit accumulation) and wisdom (emptiness realization, wisdom accumulation) must be practiced inseparably and simultaneously, like two wings of a bird, for complete Buddhahood.
439
What is the ethical imperative of 'right intention' (samyak-saṃkalpa) in the Mahayana path?
Right intention involves cultivating intentions of renunciation (from cyclic existence), non-ill-will (towards others), and non-harming, forming the basis for virtuous thoughts and actions, and aligning with altruism.
440
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
It refers to the progressive elimination of both the afflictive obscurations (klesha-āvaraṇa) and the obscurations to omniscience (jñeya-āvaraṇa) as a bodhisattva advances through the bhūmis, leading to perfect purity.
441
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of individual knowledge' (*sarvākārajñatā-jñāna*)?
It refers to the Buddha's perfect knowledge of all aspects of all phenomena, allowing them to comprehend the unique dispositions and needs of every sentient being and guide them effectively.
442
What is the ultimate benefit of 'aspiring bodhicitta' in generating spiritual transformation?
Aspirational bodhicitta, the fervent wish to attain Buddhahood for others' sake, acts as the fundamental, continuous motivation that transforms all of one's actions into causes for enlightenment.
443
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta) by analyzing their attributes?
He demonstrates that elements like earth, water, fire, and wind cannot inherently exist with their attributes (e.g., hardness for earth) as they are mutually dependent, proving their emptiness.
444
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'perfection of patience' (*kṣānti pāramitā*) in dealing with adversity?
Patience enables a bodhisattva to endure suffering, criticism, and aggression without anger or resentment, which purifies negative karma and prevents mental disturbances, fostering inner peace.
445
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the knower' (pramātṛ) and 'the known' (prameya) in detail?
He argues that the knower cannot inherently exist independently of the known, nor the known without the knower; they are mutually dependent, like the two sides of a balance, thus empty.
446
What are the 'four factors that cause one to fall back' from bodhicitta
leading to its weakening or loss?, "They include deceiving one's spiritual master, making others regret virtuous deeds, speaking disparagingly of the Mahayana, and deceiving sentient beings.
447
How does Tsongkhapa explain that emptiness is not a 'void' or 'nothingness'?
Tsongkhapa clarifies that emptiness is the *absence of inherent existence*, not the absence of existence altogether; phenomena still exist conventionally as dependent arisings, thus avoiding nihilism.
448
What are the 'three types of wisdom' a practitioner cultivates and their progression?
Wisdom arising from hearing (scriptural study), wisdom arising from contemplation (intellectual analysis), and wisdom arising from meditation (direct, non-conceptual realization), progressing from conceptual to experiential.
449
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of the path' (*mārga-jñatā*)?
It describes the Buddha's perfect knowledge of all the different paths and stages that lead to liberation and enlightenment for all sentient beings, enabling them to guide others effectively and appropriately.
450
What is the ultimate aim of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers' in the seven-point instruction?
To generate profound gratitude for the countless times all sentient beings have shown kindness in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness through seeking enlightenment for their ultimate happiness.
451
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' (ātman) by showing it is neither identical to nor different from the aggregates?
He demonstrates that if the self were identical to the aggregates, it would be multiple and impermanent; if entirely different, it would be unobservable, thus neither holds true, proving it is merely imputed.
452
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'causality' (hetu-phala) in detail?
He argues that if causes inherently produced effects, they would either exist simultaneously or be entirely separate, neither of which is tenable, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
453
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'conventional validity' of phenomena despite their ultimate emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena, though empty of inherent existence, are still conventionally valid and functional, allowing for the operation of karma and the existence of the path to liberation.
454
What is the ethical imperative of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) in Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby supporting one's spiritual practice and benefiting society.
455
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta) like earth
water, fire, and wind by analyzing their attributes?, "He demonstrates that elements cannot inherently exist with their attributes (e.g., hardness for earth) as they are mutually dependent and cannot be defined independently, proving their emptiness.
456
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of paths' (*mārga-jñatā*)?
It describes the Buddha's perfect knowledge of all the different paths and stages that lead to liberation and enlightenment for all sentient beings, enabling them to guide others effectively and appropriately.
457
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the mind' (citta) by analyzing its moments?
He examines its moments (past, present, future) and its objects, demonstrating that no inherently existing mind can be found independently of these factors, thus the mind is empty.
458
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great aspiration' (mahāpraṇidhāna) in their journey to Buddhahood?
These are immense, unwavering vows to liberate all sentient beings and to achieve Buddhahood for their sake, providing constant motivation and preventing deviation from the path.
459
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) by analyzing their relationship to 'the self'?
He applies the sevenfold analysis (whether it is one, many, etc.) to the aggregates, demonstrating that no inherently existing self can be found within them, nor are they inherently the self, proving their emptiness.
460
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) by analyzing their relationship to 'form'?
He demonstrates that 'form' cannot inherently exist as distinct from the other aggregates, nor can the other aggregates exist inherently without form, proving their mutual dependence and emptiness.
461
What is the ultimate purpose of 'aspirational prayer' (*praṇidhāna*) in sustaining bodhicitta?
Aspirational prayers reinforce and deepen the wish for enlightenment for all beings, keeping the motivation strong over time and dedicating all efforts towards this ultimate altruistic goal.
462
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'causality' (hetu-phala) by showing its implications for non-origination?
He argues that if causes inherently produced effects, then either something would arise from nothing (absurd), or from something already existent (no production needed), demonstrating dependent arising and emptiness of production.
463
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'perfection of joyous effort' (*vīrya pāramitā*) in maintaining perseverance?
Joyous effort is the enthusiastic and sustained exertion in all virtuous activities without discouragement or fatigue, enabling the bodhisattva to persevere through countless difficulties for the sake of sentient beings.
464
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'conventional existence' of phenomena despite their ultimate emptiness?
He clarifies that phenomena exist conventionally through valid nominal designation and dependently, appearing functionally to an unanalyzing mind, even though they lack inherent reality. This allows for karma and the path to function.
465
What is the ultimate aim of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings as mothers' in the seven-point cause and effect instruction?
To generate profound gratitude for the countless times all sentient beings have shown kindness in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness through seeking enlightenment for their ultimate happiness.
466
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the importance of 'correctly identifying the object of negation' in emptiness meditation?
Correctly identifying the object of negation (inherent existence) is paramount to avoid falling into the extreme of nihilism (negating even conventional existence) or eternalism (failing to negate inherent existence).
467
What is the ethical imperative of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) for a practitioner?
Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby supporting one's spiritual practice and benefiting society.
468
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta) by analyzing their attributes?
He demonstrates that elements cannot inherently exist with their attributes (e.g., hardness for earth) as they are mutually dependent and cannot be defined independently, proving their emptiness.
469
What is the ultimate benefit of 'analytic meditation' (*vipassanā*) on emptiness?
To directly realize the lack of inherent existence of all phenomena, thereby eliminating the root of cyclic existence (ignorance) and developing genuine wisdom for liberation.
470
What is the purpose of 'meditative concentration' (*dhyāna pāramitā*) for a bodhisattva?
To develop profound mental stability and one-pointedness, which serves as the necessary foundation for deep insight into emptiness and for manifesting skillful means to benefit others.
471
How does Candrakīrti explain the 'illusion-like' nature of phenomena in relation to their appearance and reality?
He clarifies that phenomena, like illusions, appear vividly and function conventionally, but they are ultimately empty of inherent existence; they are not non-existent but are devoid of intrinsic reality.
472
What is the ethical implication of 'right intention' (samyak-saṃkalpa) in the Mahayana path?
Right intention involves cultivating intentions of renunciation (from cyclic existence), non-ill-will (towards others), and non-harming, forming the basis for virtuous thoughts and actions, and aligning with altruism.
473
What is the ultimate benefit of 'engaging bodhicitta' in terms of personal transformation?
Engaging bodhicitta, through the practice of the six perfections, transforms one's mindstream by gradually purifying all defilements and obscurations, leading to the full realization of Buddhahood.