Ch 7 Part 2- Aspiring and Engaging Bodhicitta Flashcards

(499 cards)

1
Q

What is the “offering” limb of the seven-limb prayer?

A

Making offerings of all kinds to the Three Jewels.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What is the “confession” limb of the seven-limb prayer?

A

Acknowledging and regretting non-virtuous actions committed.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What is the “rejoicing” limb of the seven-limb prayer?

A

Feeling joy in the virtuous actions of oneself and all others.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What is the “requesting to turn the wheel of Dharma” limb?

A

Requesting the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas to teach the Dharma to all beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What is the “requesting not to pass into nirvana” limb?

A

Requesting the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas to remain in the world to continue benefiting sentient beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is the “dedication of merit” limb of the seven-limb prayer?

A

Dedication of all accumulated merit for the enlightenment of all sentient beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

How does the practice of “mind training” (lojong) contribute to the bodhisattva path?

A

It provides practical methods for transforming adverse circumstances into the path to enlightenment and developing bodhicitta.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the Bodhisattvabhūmi in terms of the practitioner’s development?

A

To guide the practitioner to transcend all ordinary mental states and attain the pure, non-conceptual mind of a Buddha.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What are the “ten non-virtuous actions” that a bodhisattva avoids?

A

Killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, divisive speech, harsh speech, senseless chatter, covetousness, malice, and wrong views.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What are the “ten virtuous actions” that a bodhisattva cultivates?

A

Protecting life, generosity, ethical conduct, truthful speech, unifying speech, gentle speech, meaningful speech, contentment, loving-kindness, and correct views.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

How does one develop “skill in means” (upāya-kauśalya) in the context of the bodhisattva path?

A

Through extensive Dharma study, personal practice, and interacting with diverse sentient beings to understand their needs.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What is the significance of “aspirational prayers” (monlam) for a bodhisattva?

A

They are powerful expressions of one’s wish for the welfare of all beings and help to direct one’s accumulated merit towards specific beneficial outcomes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is the ultimate benefit of mastering meditative concentration for a bodhisattva?

A

It leads to the development of clairvoyance and other miraculous abilities that can be used to benefit sentient beings more effectively.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

How does a bodhisattva relate to suffering in the world?

A

They willingly take on the suffering of others and offer their own happiness and merit to them through practices like Tonglen.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is the role of a bodhisattva’s “great love” (mahāmaitrī)?

A

The unwavering wish for all sentient beings to have happiness and its causes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the “path of accumulation”?

A

To generate an unwavering bodhicitta and collect vast amounts of merit and wisdom.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the “path of preparation”?

A

To achieve stability in the realization of emptiness through conceptual understanding.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the “path of seeing”?

A

To attain direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness and become an Arya Bodhisattva.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the “path of meditation”?

A

To further purify defilements and cultivate the wisdom of emptiness through repeated meditation.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What is the ultimate aim of the “path of no more learning”?

A

To achieve full buddhahood, transcending all limitations and embodying omniscience and perfect compassion.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

How does one practice the “six recollections” (anussati) to foster virtuous qualities?

A

Recollecting the Buddha, Dharma, Sangha, generosity, ethical discipline, and deities.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

What is the importance of understanding “emptiness” (śūnyatā) in engaging in ethical conduct?

A

Understanding emptiness prevents attachment to the virtuous actions themselves, ensuring they are performed with ultimate wisdom.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

How does a bodhisattva cultivate “compassion for suffering” (duḥkha-karuṇā)?

A

By contemplating the universal nature of suffering in cyclic existence and wishing for all beings to be free from it.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

What is the distinction between “boundless wisdom” and “boundless compassion” for a Buddha?

A

Boundless wisdom knows all phenomena as they are, and boundless compassion acts limitlessly for the benefit of all beings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
What is the function of "analytic meditation" for a bodhisattva?
To thoroughly investigate the nature of reality and develop insight into emptiness and dependent arising.
26
What is the significance of the "seven branches of awakening" (*saptabodhyanga*) in the path of practice?
Mindfulness, Dharma investigation, joyous effort, rapture, tranquility, concentration, and equanimity, which are essential factors for enlightenment.
27
How does the practice of "ethical discipline" relate to speech for a bodhisattva?
It involves abstaining from lying, divisive speech, harsh speech, and senseless chatter, and cultivating truthful, unifying, gentle, and meaningful speech.
28
What is the ultimate purpose of developing clairvoyance for a bodhisattva?
To understand the minds and needs of sentient beings precisely, enabling more effective guidance and benefit.
29
What is the definition of "right view" (*samyag-dṛṣṭi*) for a bodhisattva?
Understanding karma, dependent arising, and emptiness, free from misconceptions.
30
What is the relationship between the bodhisattva's path and the ultimate goal of freedom from cyclic existence?
The bodhisattva path leads to freedom from cyclic existence (samsara) for oneself, while simultaneously striving to liberate all others.
31
What is the role of "vows" in shaping a bodhisattva's conduct?
They provide a strong ethical commitment, guiding every action and intention towards the benefit of others and enlightenment.
32
How does a bodhisattva use "mindfulness" in daily life?
To remain aware of one's thoughts, speech, and actions, ensuring they are in alignment with bodhicitta and the vows.
33
What is the significance of the phrase "vast as space" when referring to the bodhisattva's activities?
It implies the boundless scope of their compassion and efforts to benefit all sentient beings.
34
What is the ultimate result of completing the bodhisattva path and attaining buddhahood?
The realization of the two form bodies (rupakaya) and the truth body (dharmakaya) of a Buddha.
35
What is the distinction between the "cause" and "result" of bodhicitta?
The cause is the intention to benefit others and achieve enlightenment, while the result is the actual attainment of buddhahood.
36
How does a bodhisattva cultivate "unlimited sympathetic joy"?
By rejoicing in the happiness and virtues of all sentient beings, without envy or resentment.
37
How does a bodhisattva cultivate "unlimited equanimity"?
By developing a balanced mind free from attachment to friends, aversion to enemies, and indifference to strangers.
38
What is the purpose of "meditation on impermanence" in the bodhisattva's training?
It helps to reduce attachment to cyclic existence and to develop a sense of urgency for spiritual practice and helping others.
39
What is the significance of "the four reliances" in understanding Dharma?
Rely on the meaning, not the words; rely on wisdom, not consciousness; rely on the definitive meaning, not the provisional; rely on the Dharma, not the person.
40
What is the "definitive meaning" in Dharma teachings?
Teachings that express the ultimate truth directly, such as those on emptiness.
41
What is the "provisional meaning" in Dharma teachings?
Teachings that are given for a specific purpose or to specific individuals, requiring further interpretation.
42
What is the ultimate aim of the 'equalizing and exchanging self and others' practice in generating bodhicitta?
The ultimate aim is to dismantle self-cherishing, which is the root of all suffering, and to replace it with the boundless altruism of cherishing others.
43
How does the practice of 'taking and giving' (tonglen) directly cultivate compassion and bodhicitta?
Tonglen involves mentally taking on the suffering and negative karma of others, and giving them all one's happiness, virtues, and merits, thereby profoundly strengthening altruism and empathy.
44
What is the distinction between 'conventional truth' and 'ultimate truth' in the Madhyamaka school?
Conventional truth refers to how phenomena appear to exist and function in everyday experience, while ultimate truth refers to their true mode of existence, which is emptiness of inherent nature.
45
Why is understanding the 'two truths' essential for a Mahayana practitioner?
Understanding the two truths prevents nihilism (by affirming conventional existence) and eternalism (by affirming ultimate emptiness), thus providing the correct view for practice and liberation.
46
According to Nāgārjuna
what is the consequence of clinging to 'inherent existence' (svabhāva)?,"Clinging to inherent existence leads to mental proliferation (prapañca) and binds one to cyclic existence (saṃsāra) and its sufferings.
47
How does the *Bodhisattvabhūmi* describe the 'perfection of ethical conduct' (*śīla pāramitā*)?
It is the practice of abstaining from all non-virtuous actions, engaging in virtuous actions, and benefiting sentient beings, motivated by bodhicitta.
48
What is the primary characteristic of the 'path of accumulation' (*saṃbhāra-mārga*) in the bodhisattva journey?
It is characterized by the accumulation of vast collections of merit and wisdom through extensive practice of the perfections, accompanied by a conceptual understanding of emptiness.
49
How does Tsongkhapa explain that emptiness is not a 'void' or 'nothingness'?
Tsongkhapa clarifies that emptiness is the *absence of inherent existence*, not the absence of existence altogether; phenomena still exist conventionally as dependent arisings.
50
What is the significance of the 'six perfections' (pāramitās) being 'transcendent' (pāramitā)?
They are transcendent because they are perfected with the wisdom realizing emptiness and motivated by bodhicitta, making them causes for full enlightenment, not just ordinary virtues.
51
According to Candrakīrti
why is it necessary to refute even the inherent existence of 'mind' or 'consciousness'?, "If mind or consciousness were inherently existent, it would be impossible for them to be transformed or for suffering to cease, thus refuting their inherent existence is crucial for liberation.
52
What are the ethical implications of understanding karma in light of emptiness?
Understanding that karma and its results are dependently arisen and empty of inherent existence reinforces the importance of ethical cause and effect, without reifying them.
53
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* present the 'omniscience of a Buddha'?
It describes the omniscience of a Buddha as the simultaneous and direct apprehension of all phenomena, both conventionally and ultimately, without any obstruction.
54
What is the 'lineage of method' (upāya-vaṃśa) in the context of the bodhisattva path?
It refers to the practices of compassion and skillful means, which are essential for accumulating merit and benefiting sentient beings.
55
What is the 'lineage of wisdom' (prajñā-vaṃśa)?
It refers to the practices of wisdom, particularly the realization of emptiness, which is essential for accumulating wisdom and cutting the root of ignorance.
56
How does Nāgārjuna refute inherent 'substance' and 'attribute'?
He argues that substance cannot inherently exist without attributes, nor attributes without a substance, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
57
What is the significance of 'analytical meditation' (dpyad sgom) in realizing emptiness?
Analytical meditation involves using reasoning to dismantle mistaken conceptions of inherent existence, leading the mind to the non-conceptual realization of emptiness.
58
Why is 'impermanence' considered the 'gateway to emptiness' in some Buddhist traditions?
Recognizing impermanence leads to a deeper understanding of the constantly changing nature of phenomena, which in turn helps to undermine the notion of their inherent, unchanging existence.
59
How does bodhicitta act as an 'inner fire' that burns away obstacles?
The immense power of bodhicitta, fueled by compassion and wisdom, purifies mental defilements and karmic obscurations, accelerating spiritual progress.
60
What is the importance of 'the four ways of gathering disciples' for a bodhisattva?
They are generosity, kind speech, teaching according to capacity, and acting in accordance with the teaching, enabling a bodhisattva to effectively lead beings to liberation.
61
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'production from other'?
He argues that if things were produced from something inherently separate or unrelated, there would be no causal connection, leading to the absurd conclusion that anything could produce anything.
62
What is the role of 'non-attachment' in the practice of generosity according to Nāgārjuna?
Non-attachment ensures that generosity is pure, free from ulterior motives or clinging to the giver, gift, or recipient, maximizing its merit.
63
How does the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* demonstrate the emptiness of 'the self' by analyzing its relationship to the aggregates?
Nāgārjuna shows that the self is neither identical to nor separate from the five aggregates, thus it is merely designated in dependence on them and lacks inherent existence.
64
What is the significance of 'accumulating merit' (puṇya-saṃbhāra) for the realization of emptiness?
Accumulating merit purifies the mind, creates positive karmic conditions, and provides the necessary conducive environment for wisdom to arise and realize emptiness.
65
What is the 'path of preparation' (*prayoga-mārga*) in the bodhisattva journey?
It is the path where conceptual understanding of emptiness is developed and refined through extensive study and contemplation, prior to direct realization.
66
How does Tsongkhapa refute the inherent existence of 'mind' by analyzing its moments?
He demonstrates that a past mind has ceased, a future mind has not yet arisen, and a present mind is indivisible or cannot inherently exist without past/future, thus mind is empty of inherent nature.
67
What is the ultimate benefit of developing 'perfect concentration' (*dhyāna pāramitā*)?
Perfect concentration leads to profound mental stability and clarity, which enables the sustained, penetrating insight needed for realizing emptiness and manifesting enlightened activities.
68
Why is 'compassion' considered the 'root' of the Mahayana path by Candrakīrti?
Compassion for all sentient beings, perceiving their suffering, is the indispensable motivation that drives a bodhisattva to embark on the arduous path to full enlightenment for their sake.
69
How does Nāgārjuna apply emptiness to 'producer' and 'produced'?
He argues that neither the producer nor the produced can inherently exist independently, as they are mutually dependent. A producer is defined by what it produces, and vice-versa.
70
What is the 'yoga of emptiness' in the context of meditative practice?
It is the meditative absorption where one directly and non-conceptually apprehends the emptiness of all phenomena, transcending dualistic thought.
71
What are the 'eight worldly dharmas' that a bodhisattva aims to transcend?
They are gain and loss, pleasure and pain, praise and blame, fame and disrepute.
72
How does the understanding of 'interdependence' (dependent arising) lead to wisdom of emptiness?
Interdependence means nothing exists independently; everything relies on causes, conditions, and other phenomena, revealing their lack of inherent nature, which is emptiness.
73
What is the significance of the 'bodhisattva vow' in transforming one's actions?
Taking the bodhisattva vow dedicates all actions, thoughts, and words to the ultimate goal of benefiting all sentient beings, infusing them with altruistic power.
74
How does the *Bodhisattvabhūmi* describe the 'perfection of joyous effort' (*vīrya pāramitā*)?
It is the sustained, unflagging enthusiasm and energy applied to all virtuous activities on the path, preventing discouragement and ensuring continuous progress.
75
What is the importance of distinguishing between 'mere existence' and 'inherent existence' in Madhyamaka?
Mere existence refers to phenomena's conventional, dependently arisen existence, which is affirmed, while inherent existence, an imagined intrinsic reality, is refuted.
76
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'causes and effects'?
He argues that if causes and effects were inherently existent, they would be either simultaneous or totally separate, neither of which is tenable, demonstrating their dependent nature.
77
What is the 'supreme enlightenment' (anuttara samyaksaṃbodhi) that a bodhisattva aspires to?
It is the full, perfect, and unsurpassed awakening of a Buddha, characterized by omniscience and boundless compassion, attained for the benefit of all sentient beings.
78
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise against engaging in 'senseless chatter'?
It suggests avoiding speech that is not beneficial, timely, or truthful, and instead using speech to promote Dharma and harmony.
79
What are the 'four reliances' in the context of studying Buddhist philosophy?
Rely on the Dharma, not the person; rely on the meaning, not the words; rely on the definitive meaning, not the interpretable meaning; rely on wisdom, not consciousness.
80
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*)?
It is the final path, achieved upon attaining Buddhahood, where all defilements and obscurations are fully eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn or abandon.
81
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three pure actions'?
They are pure actions of body, speech, and mind, motivated by bodhicitta and perfected with wisdom, leading to the accumulation of merit.
82
How does Nāgārjuna address the inherent existence of 'aggregates' (skandhas)?
He analyzes each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) to show that none inherently exist independently or as a unified whole, demonstrating their emptiness.
83
What is the role of 'analytic meditation' (*vipassanā*) in realizing emptiness?
Analytic meditation involves systematic investigation and reasoning to ascertain the lack of inherent existence of phenomena, leading to direct insight into emptiness.
84
Why is 'patience' so highly valued in the Mahayana tradition?
Patience is considered the supreme austerity that eliminates anger, purifies negative karma, and enables the bodhisattva to endure the immense difficulties of the path for others' sake.
85
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'identity' and 'difference'?
He argues that identity cannot inherently exist without difference, nor difference without identity, showing their mutual dependence and emptiness.
86
What is the 'great intention' (*mahāsaṃkalpa*) in the context of aspiring bodhicitta?
It is the firm resolve to attain unsurpassed Buddhahood for the benefit of all sentient beings, arising from profound compassion and wisdom.
87
What are the two types of 'obstacles' to liberation that are overcome by the Mahayana path?
The obstacles of afflictions (klesha-āvaraṇa) and the obstacles to omniscience (jñeya-āvaraṇa).
88
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* connect individual ethical conduct with societal welfare?
It emphasizes that the ethical actions of individuals, particularly leaders, create a harmonious and prosperous society, demonstrating the interconnectedness of individual and collective well-being.
89
What is the significance of the 'vajra-like concentration' achieved by advanced bodhisattvas?
It is a supreme concentration that allows for the non-conceptual, direct realization of emptiness with immense power, leading to the final elimination of subtle obscurations.
90
How does Tsongkhapa refute the inherent existence of 'self-cognizing consciousness' (svasaṃvedana)?
He argues that consciousness cannot inherently apprehend itself, as the act of apprehending requires a distinction between subject and object, which refutes self-cognition.
91
What is the essence of 'true cessation' (nirodha) in the context of the Four Noble Truths?
True cessation is the complete and permanent elimination of suffering and its causes, achieved through the realization of emptiness.
92
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ten perfections' in detail?
It systematically outlines how each perfection is cultivated and perfected through the various stages of the bodhisattva's path, from accumulation to full Buddhahood.
93
What is the role of 'skilful means' (upāya) in helping sentient beings attain liberation?
Skilful means refers to the bodhisattva's ability to present the Dharma in ways appropriate to the diverse dispositions, capacities, and needs of sentient beings, leading them to liberation.
94
How does Candrakīrti clarify the difference between 'mental image' and 'external object' in his refutation of external reality?
He argues that if external objects were truly separate from the mind, they could not be perceived, and thus their inherent existence is refuted.
95
What is the ultimate benefit of understanding 'dependent arising' in depth?
Deep understanding of dependent arising leads directly to the realization of emptiness, which is the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the means to liberate oneself and others.
96
How does 'meditation on emptiness' (śūnyatā-bhāvanā) function as the direct antidote to the root of cyclic existence?
It directly contradicts and dismantles the fundamental ignorance that apprehends phenomena as inherently existent, thereby cutting the root of all suffering.
97
What are the 'four factors of irreversibility' on the bodhisattva path?
These factors ensure that once bodhicitta is genuinely generated, the bodhisattva will not fall back to the Śrāvaka or Pratyekabuddha paths, but will surely reach full enlightenment.
98
How does Nāgārjuna address the inherent existence of 'suffering' itself?
He argues that suffering is not inherently existent but arises dependently on causes and conditions, meaning it is not a fixed reality and can be ceased.
99
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'aspirational prayer' to achieve Buddhahood?
It is a powerful mental resolve that continually reinforces the commitment to the path, guiding all actions towards the ultimate goal of benefiting all beings.
100
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of the 'past'
'present', and 'future'?, "He demonstrates that each of these times is defined in relation to the others, meaning none can exist independently, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
101
What is the 'conventional self' according to Madhyamaka?
The conventional self is merely designated in dependence on the five aggregates and functions conventionally, without possessing any inherent, independently existing nature.
102
What is the role of 'analytical contemplation' in cultivating wisdom?
Analytical contemplation involves reasoned investigation of the Dharma teachings, especially those on emptiness, to develop a firm intellectual conviction before engaging in meditative realization.
103
How does the practice of 'rejoicing' (*muditā*) lead to the accumulation of merit?
Rejoicing in the virtues and happiness of others creates positive karmic imprints in one's own mind, similar to participating in their good deeds.
104
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'fearlessness'?
Fearlessness arises from realizing emptiness and developing profound compassion, allowing the bodhisattva to face any challenge or suffering for the sake of sentient beings without hesitation.
105
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'lying'?
It explains that lying creates negative karma and harms others, undermining trust and causing suffering, hence it should be abandoned.
106
What are the 'three types of vows' taken by a Mahayana practitioner?
Pratimoksha vows (individual liberation vows), bodhisattva vows (to benefit all beings), and tantric vows (samayas).
107
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'path of meditation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*) in detail?
It describes the progressive elimination of subtle obscurations through repeated habituation to the direct realization of emptiness, leading to higher bodhisattva grounds.
108
What is the difference between 'relative' and 'absolute' truth in the context of emptiness?
Relative (conventional) truth refers to the world of appearances and functionality, while absolute (ultimate) truth is the emptiness of inherent existence, transcending conceptual thought.
109
What is the significance of the 'mind of love' (mettā) in the Mahayana path?
It is the wish for all sentient beings to experience happiness and its causes, serving as a foundational aspiration for bodhicitta and an antidote to ill-will.
110
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of the 'sense fields' (āyatana)?
He argues that sense fields (e.g., eye, form) are mutually dependent and cannot inherently exist without each other, thus demonstrating their empty nature.
111
What is the purpose of contemplating the 'shortcomings of self-cherishing'?
Contemplating the endless suffering and obstacles arising from self-cherishing helps to reverse this ingrained habit and cultivate altruism.
112
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'validity of conventional phenomena' even when empty of inherent existence?
He asserts that while lacking inherent existence, phenomena are validly established conventionally by common consensus and function, allowing for karmic cause and effect.
113
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'purification of defilements'?
Purification involves eliminating mental afflictions and karmic obscurations through ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom, enabling clear insight and compassionate action.
114
How does Nāgārjuna address the concept of 'origination' (utpāda) and 'cessation' (nirodha)?
He argues that if origination and cessation were inherently existent, they would be illogical, demonstrating that they too are empty and dependently arisen.
115
What is the essence of 'non-conceptual wisdom' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*)?
It is a direct, non-dualistic cognition of ultimate reality (emptiness), free from all conceptual superimpositions, achieved through profound meditation.
116
How does Candrakīrti reconcile the appearance of suffering with its emptiness?
He explains that while suffering appears to exist conventionally and is experienced, it is ultimately empty of inherent existence, meaning it is not a fixed, independent entity and can be overcome.
117
What is the 'path of the Buddha' as distinguished from the paths of Śrāvakas and Pratyekabuddhas?
The Buddha's path is the full Mahayana path of boundless compassion and all-encompassing wisdom, leading to complete omniscience for the sake of all beings, transcending partial liberation.
118
What is the significance of the 'ten powers of a Buddha'?
They are the ten unique powers of a fully enlightened Buddha, such as the power to know all possible and impossible circumstances, and all paths to all destinations.
119
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'divisive speech'?
It advises against speech that creates discord and disunity among people, and instead encourages speech that fosters harmony and understanding.
120
What is the difference between a 'conceptual understanding of emptiness' and a 'direct realization of emptiness'?
A conceptual understanding is intellectual comprehension based on reasoning, while a direct realization is a non-dual, experiential apprehension of emptiness in meditation.
121
How does the *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* analyze the inherent existence of 'self and other'?
Nāgārjuna demonstrates that self and other are mutually dependent and cannot inherently exist independently of each other, thus they are empty.
122
What is the role of 'mindfulness' (smṛti) in meditative practice?
Mindfulness is the faculty that keeps the mind from distraction, preventing forgetfulness of the meditation object, thereby maintaining mental stability.
123
How does the practice of 'calm abiding' (śamatha) prepare the mind for realizing emptiness?
Calm abiding develops a stable and clear mind, free from mental agitation and dullness, which is the necessary foundation for penetrating insight into emptiness.
124
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great aspiration' (mahāpraṇidhāna)?
It is the immense, unwavering vow to liberate all sentient beings from suffering and lead them to full enlightenment, sustaining the bodhisattva throughout countless aeons.
125
How does the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) counteract the obscurations to omniscience?
The perfection of wisdom directly realizes emptiness, thereby eliminating the subtle imprints of ignorance (obscurations to omniscience) that prevent full Buddhahood.
126
What is the 'path of purification' in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
This refers to the progressive elimination of defilements and obscurations as the bodhisattva advances through the *bhūmis*, purifying the mind of all negativities.
127
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He analyzes each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) to show that none are inherently existent individually or as a collection, demonstrating their dependent nature.
128
What is the purpose of realizing the 'emptiness of all phenomena' (dharma-nairātmya)?
Realizing the emptiness of all phenomena, not just persons, is necessary to eradicate the subtle cognitive obscurations that prevent omniscience and full Buddhahood.
129
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'two stages' of the tantric path in relation to emptiness?
The generation stage (kye-rim) purifies ordinary appearances by cultivating pure vision, and the completion stage (dzog-rim) directly realizes emptiness through subtle energy practices, both based on Madhyamaka wisdom.
130
What is the 'supreme enlightenment' a bodhisattva seeks?
The unsurpassed, perfect, and complete enlightenment of a Buddha, which entails omniscience and the spontaneous ability to benefit all sentient beings.
131
What is the significance of 'taking responsibility' for others' suffering in bodhicitta practice?
It transforms the mere wish for their freedom into a firm resolve to personally achieve Buddhahood, as only a Buddha has the full capacity to liberate all beings.
132
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the characteristics of a wise ruler?
A wise ruler rules justly, protects the Dharma, acts compassionately towards all subjects, and ensures their material and spiritual well-being.
133
What is the 'meditation on the kindness of all beings as mothers'?
It is a foundational practice to generate bodhicitta, where one reflects on the countless times all sentient beings have been one's kind mother in past lives, nurturing gratitude and love.
134
How does the practice of 'equanimity' help to overcome prejudice and bias?
By meditating on the fact that all beings equally desire happiness and freedom from suffering, one dissolves artificial distinctions between friends, enemies, and strangers, fostering impartiality.
135
What is the primary function of 'right mindfulness' (samyak-smṛti) in meditation?
Right mindfulness keeps the mind firmly fixed on the object of meditation, preventing distraction and mental wandering, thereby supporting the development of concentration.
136
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'marks of a Buddha's body'?
It describes the 32 major and 80 minor marks of a Buddha, which are the result of accumulating immense merit and wisdom over countless aeons.
137
What is the relationship between 'compassion' and 'skillful means' (upāya)?
Compassion is the motivation that drives the bodhisattva, while skillful means are the methods (like the perfections) employed to fulfill that compassionate aim effectively.
138
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of the 'object of knowledge'?
He argues that an object of knowledge cannot inherently exist without a knowing subject, nor a knowing subject without an object, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
139
What is the significance of 'dedication of merit' in the Mahayana path?
It is the practice of dedicating all accumulated merits and virtues towards the enlightenment of all sentient beings, ensuring that one's practice is truly altruistic and universally beneficial.
140
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'designation' (prajñapti) itself?
He shows that even the act of designation is dependently arisen and lacks inherent existence, preventing one from reifying concepts into inherently real entities.
141
What is the difference between 'mental dullness' (ting-nge-'dzin 'gong-ba) and 'mental agitation' (rnam-par g.yeng-ba) in meditation?
Mental dullness is a state of mental heaviness and lack of clarity, while mental agitation is a state of distraction and scattering of the mind. Both hinder stable meditation.
142
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the importance of 'conventional validity' for ethical conduct?
He explains that while phenomena are ultimately empty, their conventional validity allows for the functioning of karma, ethical choices, and the cause-and-effect relationship between actions and happiness/suffering.
143
What is the purpose of analyzing the 'lack of inherent existence of time'?
Analyzing the lack of inherent existence of time helps to dismantle the conceptual framework that binds one to the cycle of birth and death, fostering liberation.
144
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of the path'?
It refers to the wisdom of a Buddha that knows all the paths and stages to liberation for all sentient beings, enabling them to guide others perfectly.
145
What are the ethical implications of 'senseless chatter' as a non-virtuous action?
Senseless chatter wastes time, distracts from virtuous activities, and can lead to engaging in other non-virtuous speech, hindering spiritual progress.
146
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'skillful means' (*upāya*) in the context of teaching Dharma?
Skillful means allows the bodhisattva to adapt the profound Dharma to the diverse capacities and needs of different sentient beings, making it accessible and effective for all.
147
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'movement' (gati)?
He demonstrates that movement cannot inherently reside in the mover, the moved, or elsewhere, showing that it is merely a dependent designation.
148
What is the 'perfection of meditative concentration' (*dhyāna pāramitā*) and its importance?
It is the ability to sustain a stable and clear mind in one-pointed concentration, which is essential for developing profound insight and manifesting enlightened activities.
149
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle imputation of the self'?
It is the subtle, ingrained habit of mind to apprehend a real, inherently existing 'I' or 'self', which is the root of afflictions and the primary object to be refuted by wisdom.
150
What is the ultimate benefit of the 'bodhisattva path'?
The ultimate benefit is the attainment of complete Buddhahood, characterized by omniscience and boundless compassion, enabling the perfect liberation of all sentient beings.
151
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (mahābhūta)?
He demonstrates that elements like earth, water, fire, and wind are mutually dependent and cannot exist inherently or independently, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
152
What is the significance of the 'ten stages' (daśabhūmi) for a bodhisattva's development?
The ten stages represent a progressive deepening of the realization of emptiness and the perfection of the pāramitās, culminating in full Buddhahood.
153
How does Candrakīrti differentiate between 'meditation on emptiness' and 'conceptual understanding'?
Meditation on emptiness leads to a direct, non-conceptual realization, whereas conceptual understanding is an intellectual apprehension that serves as a preparation for direct experience.
154
What is the relationship between 'compassion' and 'skillful means' (upāya) in the Mahayana path?
Compassion provides the boundless motivation, while skillful means are the diverse methods and abilities by which a bodhisattva effectively guides sentient beings to liberation.
155
What is the importance of 'aspiration' (praṇidhāna) in initiating the bodhisattva path?
Aspiration is the heartfelt wish to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, serving as the powerful initial motivation that sets one on the Mahayana journey.
156
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the consequences of 'taking what is not given'?
Taking what is not given (stealing) leads to poverty, loss, and suffering in future lives, and undermines trust in society.
157
What is the role of 'non-conceptual wisdom' in attaining Buddhahood?
Non-conceptual wisdom is the direct, unerring realization of emptiness that permanently cuts the root of ignorance, leading to the full liberation and omniscience of Buddhahood.
158
What are the 'sixteen aspects of the four noble truths' in the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras?
These are specific perspectives on suffering, its origin, cessation, and the path, each illustrating their empty and dependently arisen nature.
159
How does the practice of 'calm abiding' (*śamatha*) stabilize the mind?
Calm abiding stabilizes the mind by focusing it on a single object of meditation, gradually reducing mental agitation and dullness, leading to mental pliancy and sustained attention.
160
What is the 'path of final result' (niṣṭhā-mārga) in the context of the five paths?
This refers to the state of full Buddhahood, attained after traversing all the previous paths, where all obscurations are eliminated and all enlightened qualities are perfected.
161
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'appearance of inherent existence' as a cognitive imputation?
He clarifies that the appearance of inherent existence is not something truly existent in phenomena, but rather a subtle cognitive imputation or overlay arising from ignorance.
162
What is the significance of Candrakīrti's use of 'reasoning' to establish emptiness?
Candrakīrti primarily uses logical reasoning (prasanga) to lead the mind to the realization of emptiness, demonstrating that inherent existence is untenable under analysis.
163
What is the role of 'analytic wisdom' in the Mahayana path?
Analytic wisdom systematically investigates phenomena to ascertain their ultimate nature of emptiness, distinguishing it from merely intellectual understanding by being a direct counter to the root of ignorance.
164
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'past
present, and future'?, "He demonstrates that each of these times is defined only in relation to the others, meaning none can exist independently or inherently, thus they are empty.
165
What is the meaning of 'non-abiding nirvāṇa' (apratiṣṭhita nirvāṇa) in the Mahayana context?
It is the state of a Buddha who, having realized emptiness and overcome all obscurations, does not abide in either cyclic existence (due to wisdom) or in solitary peace (due to compassion), but spontaneously acts for the benefit of all beings.
166
How does the practice of 'rejoicing in virtue' contribute to one's own spiritual development?
Rejoicing in the virtuous actions of oneself and others generates immense merit and counters negative emotions like envy, fostering a joyful and altruistic mind.
167
What is the significance of the 'three bodies of a Buddha' (Trikāya)?
The three bodies (Dharmakāya, Sambhogakāya, Nirmāṇakāya) represent the fully enlightened qualities of a Buddha: the wisdom body, the enjoyment body, and the emanation body for the benefit of others.
168
What is the 'path of vision' (darśana-mārga) and its key characteristic?
It is the first of the five paths where a bodhisattva directly perceives emptiness for the first time, marking an irreversible entry into the true Mahayana path.
169
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* encourage 'right action' (samyak-karmānta)?
It advocates for actions motivated by compassion and wisdom, specifically avoiding the ten non-virtuous actions and cultivating their virtuous counterparts.
170
What is the role of 'vows' in maintaining ethical discipline on the bodhisattva path?
Vows serve as formal commitments and powerful reminders that prevent one from engaging in non-virtuous actions and instead encourage continuous virtuous practice.
171
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'object of realization' for a direct perceiver of emptiness?
The object of realization is the sheer absence of inherent existence in the observed phenomenon, which is directly apprehended without conceptual overlay.
172
What is the purpose of 'meditation on compassion' (karuṇā-bhāvanā)?
To develop an intense, heartfelt wish for all sentient beings to be free from suffering and its causes, serving as the essential foundation for generating bodhicitta.
173
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the elements' (e.g.
earth, water, fire, wind)?, "He demonstrates that elements are mutually dependent and cannot exist as independent, self-sufficient entities, thereby proving their emptiness.
174
What is the relationship between 'faith' and 'wisdom' in the Mahayana path?
Faith provides the initial trust and confidence in the teachings and the path, while wisdom, cultivated through analysis and meditation, provides the direct realization that liberates.
175
What is the significance of the 'pure lands' (buddha-fields) in Mahayana Buddhism?
Pure lands are special realms created by Buddhas through their immense merit and compassionate vows, where conditions are highly conducive for sentient beings to practice Dharma and attain enlightenment easily.
176
How does Nāgārjuna's *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā* address the inherent existence of 'the past'?
He argues that the past cannot inherently exist because it is defined only in relation to the present and future, demonstrating its dependent and empty nature.
177
What is the 'path of cultivation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*) and its main objective?
It is the path where the bodhisattva repeatedly habituates to the direct realization of emptiness, gradually diminishing and eliminating the subtle obscurations until full Buddhahood is achieved.
178
How does Tsongkhapa's commentary on the *Madhyamakāvatāra* serve as a guide for cultivating the view of emptiness?
It provides detailed logical arguments and refutations of mistaken views, leading the practitioner step-by-step to a precise understanding and realization of emptiness.
179
What is the ethical principle of 'contentment' (santuṣṭi) and its benefit?
Contentment is being satisfied with what one has, which reduces desire, attachment, and the suffering that comes from constant striving, fostering inner peace.
180
How does the practice of 'patience' contribute to inner peace?
Patience allows one to remain undisturbed by adverse circumstances, insults, or suffering, preventing the mind from being consumed by anger and resentment, thus preserving inner peace.
181
What is the 'aspirational aspect' of bodhicitta?
It is the fervent wish to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, a deeply compassionate resolve that is continually renewed.
182
What is the 'engaging aspect' of bodhicitta?
It is the actual commitment to engage in the specific trainings and practices of the bodhisattva path, particularly the six perfections, to fulfill the aspiration.
183
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'sensory perceptions'?
He argues that sensory perceptions cannot inherently exist without a basis (sense organ), an object, and a consciousness, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
184
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'non-conceptual mind' on the path of seeing?
On the path of seeing, the bodhisattva achieves a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, which is the direct antidote to the fundamental ignorance.
185
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (e.g.
earth, water, fire, wind)?, "He demonstrates that elements are mutually dependent and cannot exist as independent, self-sufficient entities, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
186
What are the 'sixteen aspects of emptiness' as presented in the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras?
These are sixteen ways of understanding emptiness, systematically applied to various phenomena like internal, external, composite, uncompounded, etc., to ensure comprehensive realization.
187
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'conventional existence' of the self?
He clarifies that the self exists conventionally as a mere designation upon the aggregates, without any inherent or intrinsically existing 'I' to be found.
188
What is the 'collection of wisdom' and why is it essential for Buddhahood?
The collection of wisdom is the accumulation of insight into emptiness, which is the direct antidote to ignorance and the cause for attaining omniscience.
189
What is the ultimate purpose of 'analytic meditation' on emptiness?
To directly realize the lack of inherent existence of all phenomena, thereby eliminating the root of cyclic existence and developing genuine wisdom.
190
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'sexual misconduct'?
It advises against sexual activity that causes harm, is non-consensual, or violates commitments, emphasizing respect and purity in relationships.
191
What is the role of 'vows and commitments' in the bodhisattva path?
Vows and commitments provide a clear framework for ethical conduct, motivate practice, and serve as protective factors to ensure consistent progress towards enlightenment.
192
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the knower' (perceiver)?
He argues that the knower cannot inherently exist without a known object, nor a known object without a knower, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
193
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great compassion' in relation to their wisdom?
Great compassion is the driving force that propels the bodhisattva to seek profound wisdom, realizing that only through such wisdom can they truly liberate all sentient beings from suffering.
194
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the mind' (citta)?
He examines the mind's moments (past, present, future) and its objects, demonstrating that no inherently existing mind can be found independently of these factors, thus it is empty.
195
What are the 'ten perfections' (pāramitās) in brief?
Generosity, ethical discipline, patience, joyous effort, meditative concentration, wisdom, skillful means, aspiration, power, and primordial wisdom.
196
How does the practice of 'equanimity' (upekṣā) differ from indifference?
Equanimity is a balanced, unbiased mind free from attachment and aversion, accompanied by a genuine concern for all beings, whereas indifference is apathy or lack of concern.
197
What is the ultimate purpose of 'meditative concentration' (dhyāna) in the Mahayana path?
To provide a stable and clear mind capable of realizing emptiness and manifesting enlightened activities, thereby serving the ultimate goal of benefiting all sentient beings.
198
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'path of seeing' in terms of realizing emptiness?
On the path of seeing, the bodhisattva directly and non-conceptually apprehends emptiness, which is the first time they fully sever the root of afflictive obscurations.
199
What is the significance of the 'three higher trainings' in the context of the bodhisattva path?
The three higher trainings (ethics, concentration, wisdom) are fundamental practices that systematically purify the mind, develop mental stability, and cultivate insight, leading to liberation and omniscience.
200
How does Tsongkhapa's commentary clarify the 'mode of establishment' of phenomena in Madhyamaka?
He explains that phenomena are established solely through dependent designation and valid conventional cognition, without any inherent self-establishment.
201
What is the 'fundamental ignorance' (avidyā) that Nāgārjuna's teachings aim to remove?
It is the ignorance that apprehends phenomena as inherently existent, which is the root cause of all suffering and cyclic existence.
202
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the characteristics of 'right view' (samyak-dṛṣṭi)?
Right view is the understanding of karma, dependent arising, and emptiness, leading one away from wrong views and towards liberation.
203
What is the role of 'non-attachment to phenomena' in the bodhisattva's practice?
Non-attachment to phenomena (due to understanding their emptiness) allows the bodhisattva to engage fully in the world for others' benefit without being defiled or bound by worldly concerns.
204
What is the 'cause' for the 'effect' of generating loving-kindness in the seven-point instruction?
The cause is recalling the kindness of others and wishing to repay that kindness.
205
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the four elements' (earth
water, fire, air)?, "He argues that they are mutually dependent and cannot exist as independent, self-sufficient entities, demonstrating their empty nature.
206
What is the difference between 'calm abiding' (śamatha) and 'insight' (vipassanā)?
Calm abiding is the development of single-pointed concentration and mental stability, while insight is the penetrative wisdom that analyzes the nature of reality, particularly emptiness.
207
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'ten powers' (bala)?
These are the ten perfections cultivated by bodhisattvas that lead to the corresponding powers of a Buddha, such as the power of aspiration and the power of analysis.
208
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ultimate goal of the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras'?
The ultimate goal is to lead practitioners to the full realization of emptiness and the attainment of Buddhahood for the benefit of all sentient beings.
209
What are the 'four noble truths' as taught by the Buddha?
They are the truth of suffering, the truth of the origin of suffering, the truth of the cessation of suffering, and the truth of the path to the cessation of suffering.
210
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He shows that each aggregate is dependently arisen and not inherently existent, and that no 'person' can be found apart from these empty aggregates, thus demonstrating the self's emptiness.
211
What is the role of 'non-conceptualization' (*avikalpa*) in the realization of emptiness?
Non-conceptualization is the mind's ability to directly perceive emptiness without engaging in conceptual overlays or dualistic thought, which is the nature of ultimate wisdom.
212
What is the difference between a 'Buddha' and an 'Arhat' in the Mahayana tradition?
An Arhat achieves liberation from cyclic existence for themselves by eliminating afflictions, while a Buddha achieves full enlightenment and omniscience for the benefit of all sentient beings.
213
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the importance of 'compassion' in a ruler's governance?
It states that a ruler should govern with great compassion, seeing all subjects as their own children, ensuring their welfare and protecting them from harm.
214
What is the ultimate benefit of practicing the 'perfection of patience' (*kṣānti pāramitā*)?
Patience leads to the elimination of anger, the accumulation of immense merit, and the ability to endure any hardship on the path without discouragement, ensuring irreversible progress.
215
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the world' (loka)?
He argues that the world is merely a collection of dependently arisen phenomena and lacks any inherent, independent existence as a unified entity.
216
What is the significance of the 'three kayas' (bodies) of a Buddha?
They are the Dharmakaya (truth body), Sambhogakaya (enjoyment body), and Nirmanakaya (emanation body), representing the ultimate wisdom, communication, and compassionate manifestation of a Buddha.
217
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle imputation of inherent existence'?
It refers to the beginningless habit of mind to spontaneously superimpose an imagined inherent existence onto phenomena, which is the object of negation for the wisdom realizing emptiness.
218
What is the importance of 'generating the bodhicitta of aspiration'?
It is the foundational commitment, the heartfelt wish to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, without which the Mahayana path cannot truly begin.
219
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'action' and 'actor'?
He shows that neither action nor actor can inherently exist independently, as they are mutually defined and dependently arisen, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
220
What is the 'path of unexcelled wisdom' (*anuttara-prajñā-mārga*)?
It is the path where the bodhisattva cultivates the highest wisdom, leading to complete and perfect omniscience, which is the wisdom of a Buddha.
221
What is the primary function of 'meditative absorption' (samādhi) in the path?
Meditative absorption enables the mind to achieve profound stability, clarity, and one-pointedness, which is essential for penetrating insight into the nature of reality.
222
How does the practice of 'rejoicing in others' virtues' counteract 'envy'?
By actively cultivating joy in the good qualities and happiness of others, one directly undermines the root of envy and fosters a more expansive and altruistic mind.
223
What is the distinction between 'self-liberation' and 'Buddhahood'?
Self-liberation (Arhatship) is freedom from cyclic existence for oneself, while Buddhahood is complete enlightenment with omniscience and boundless compassion for the benefit of all beings.
224
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ten powers' of a Buddha?
It describes the ten specific powers (like knowing all phenomena, all karmic results, all paths) that a Buddha possesses, resulting from the perfection of their wisdom and compassion.
225
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'uninterrupted flow of compassion'?
Even after realizing emptiness, a bodhisattva's compassion remains constant and active, propelling them to work tirelessly for the benefit of all sentient beings without ever ceasing.
226
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* encourage 'right speech' (samyak-vāc)?
It advocates for speaking truthfully, kindly, meaningfully, and in a way that promotes harmony, avoiding lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and senseless chatter.
227
What is the primary difference between the 'Prasangika' and 'Svatantrika' schools of Madhyamaka?
Prasangika uses only *prasanga* (consequence) arguments to refute inherent existence, while Svatantrika uses independent syllogisms (*svatantra*) to establish the non-inherent existence of phenomena.
228
What is the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) in the context of the five paths?
It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all obscurations are eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn or abandon in terms of practice or realization.
229
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'motion' (gati)?
He demonstrates that movement cannot inherently exist within the mover, the moved, or elsewhere, because all these are mutually dependent and empty of inherent nature.
230
What is the significance of 'emptiness as dependent arising' for Nāgārjuna?
It means that phenomena are empty of inherent existence precisely because they arise dependently, and that dependent arising itself is the reason for their emptiness.
231
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'union of method and wisdom' on the Mahayana path?
The union refers to the inseparable practice of method (compassion and skillful means leading to the accumulation of merit) and wisdom (the realization of emptiness leading to the accumulation of wisdom).
232
What are the 'three types of wisdom' that a bodhisattva cultivates?
Wisdom from hearing (scriptural study), wisdom from contemplation (intellectual analysis), and wisdom from meditation (direct realization).
233
What is the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) and why is it paramount?
It is the direct realization of emptiness, which is paramount because it is the only antidote to ignorance, the root of all suffering, leading directly to liberation and omniscience.
234
How does the practice of 'ethical discipline' (*śīla*) provide the basis for higher meditations?
Ethical discipline purifies the mind of gross defilements, creating a sense of inner peace and freedom from remorse, which are conducive to sustained meditative concentration and insight.
235
What is the significance of the 'bodhisattva's aspiration' to achieve Buddhahood in relation to their compassion?
The bodhisattva's aspiration is the ultimate expression of their great compassion, as they realize that only a fully enlightened Buddha possesses the complete capacity to liberate all sentient beings.
236
What is the ultimate purpose of 'self-cherishing' according to Mahayana thought?
Self-cherishing is considered the root cause of all suffering and the primary obstacle to developing genuine altruism and ultimately to attaining Buddhahood.
237
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'agent and action'?
He argues that an agent cannot inherently exist without an action, nor an action without an agent; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent nature.
238
What is the 'perfection of meditative stabilization' (*dhyāna pāramitā*) in the context of the ten perfections?
It is the ability to maintain one-pointed concentration on any virtuous object, free from mental dullness or agitation, which provides the foundation for insight and profound realizations.
239
How does Candrakīrti use the 'sevenfold analysis of the chariot' to demonstrate emptiness?
He systematically searches for the inherent chariot in its parts, the collection of parts, or separate from the parts, concluding that it cannot be found, thus proving it is merely dependently designated.
240
What is the significance of the 'two types of selflessness' (person and phenomena)?
The selflessness of persons (pudgala-nairātmya) refutes an inherent self, leading to arhatship, while the selflessness of phenomena (dharma-nairātmya) refutes inherent existence of all phenomena, leading to Buddhahood.
241
How does Tsongkhapa emphasize the role of 'valid cognition' (pramāṇa) in understanding emptiness?
Valid cognition is crucial for correctly identifying the object of negation and for establishing the conventional existence of phenomena, preventing both nihilism and eternalism.
242
What are the 'four general pervasive features' of all conditioned phenomena?
They are impermanence, suffering, selflessness, and peace (or emptiness).
243
How does the practice of 'giving Dharma' differ from material generosity?
Giving Dharma (teaching) is considered the supreme generosity because it liberates beings from suffering by providing the path to enlightenment.
244
What is the ultimate goal of the 'path of meditation' (bhāvanā-mārga)?
To gradually eliminate all subtle obscurations (afflictive and to omniscience) through repeated habituation to the direct realization of emptiness, leading to full Buddhahood.
245
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great compassion' for their own enlightenment?
Great compassion is the engine that propels the bodhisattva to seek Buddhahood, as they realize that only a fully enlightened being can perfectly benefit all sentient beings.
246
How does Nāgārjuna refute the inherent existence of 'movement' (gati) in his *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā*?
He analyzes its three phases (going, gone, yet to go) and shows that none can inherently exist, as they are mutually dependent, proving movement's emptiness.
247
What is the 'mind of perfect enlightenment' (samyaksaṃbodhicitta)?
It is the mind of a Buddha, which is fully awakened, omniscient, and completely free from all defilements and obscurations, able to spontaneously benefit all beings.
248
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the senses' (indriyas)?
He argues that the senses cannot inherently exist without their objects or corresponding consciousnesses, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness.
249
What is the significance of the 'illusory' nature of phenomena in Madhyamaka?
It means that phenomena appear to exist but lack inherent existence, like an illusion, which allows for their functionality without reification and serves as a key analogy for emptiness.
250
What are the 'four factors that cause one to fall back' from bodhicitta?
They include deceiving one's spiritual master, making others regret virtuous deeds, speaking disparagingly of the Mahayana, and deceiving sentient beings.
251
How does the practice of 'mindfulness of breathing' (ānāpānasati) function in calm abiding meditation?
It is a common object of focus to develop one-pointed concentration, observing the breath to stabilize and clarify the mind.
252
What is the distinction between the 'Mahayana path' and the 'Hinayana paths' (Śrāvaka and Pratyekabuddha)?
The Mahayana path is motivated by universal compassion for all sentient beings leading to full Buddhahood, while Hinayana paths aim for individual liberation from cyclic existence.
253
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the ethical imperative of 'non-harming'?
It states that causing harm to any living being, no matter how small, leads to negative karmic results, and that compassion motivates the abandonment of all harmful actions.
254
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in the context of the bodhisattva grounds?
It refers to the progressive stages of eliminating both the afflictive obscurations and the obscurations to omniscience as a bodhisattva advances through the *bhūmis*.
255
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* present the 'three omnisciences'?
The omniscience of all aspects (Buddha's omniscience), the omniscience of paths, and the omniscience of individual knowledge (Arhat's knowledge).
256
What is the 'wisdom of the ultimate' (paramārtha-jñāna) and its object?
It is the direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, and its object is the ultimate truth—the emptiness of inherent existence of all phenomena.
257
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the elements' (mahābhūta)?
He argues that elements like earth, water, fire, and wind cannot inherently exist because they are mutually dependent and cannot be defined independently of each other.
258
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great aspirations' (mahāpraṇidhāna)?
These are the immense, altruistic vows taken by bodhisattvas to work tirelessly for the liberation of all sentient beings until everyone is freed from cyclic existence.
259
How does Nāgārjuna address the concept of 'coming and going' in his *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā*?
He argues that 'coming' cannot inherently exist without 'going' and vice-versa, demonstrating their mutual dependence and emptiness of inherent nature.
260
What is the 'causality' (pratītyasamutpāda) of suffering according to the Four Noble Truths?
Suffering arises from causes, primarily grasping and ignorance, illustrating the principle of dependent arising.
261
How does the practice of 'meditative concentration' (dhyāna) facilitate the development of wisdom?
Meditative concentration creates a stable, clear, and pliable mind, which is essential for engaging in the analytical investigation that leads to the realization of emptiness.
262
What is the 'path of vision' (darśana-mārga) and its key characteristic?
It is the first of the five paths where a bodhisattva achieves a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, irreversibly entering the true Mahayana path.
263
What is the 'extraordinary intention' (adhiśaya) in the context of the seven-point cause and effect instruction?
It is the unique resolve to personally take responsibility for freeing all sentient beings from suffering, beyond merely wishing for their freedom, leading to bodhicitta.
264
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle selflessness of phenomena'?
It is the absence of inherent existence in all phenomena, meaning they are merely designated upon their basis and are not truly existent from their own side.
265
What is the purpose of 'rejoicing in others' merits' (muditā) for a practitioner?
It counters envy, generates merit for oneself, and expands one's altruistic heart by genuinely delighting in the good fortunes and virtues of others.
266
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the doer' and 'the deed'?
He argues that the doer cannot exist independently of the deed, nor the deed independently of the doer; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
267
What is the significance of 'purifying negative karma' on the bodhisattva path?
Purifying negative karma through ethical conduct, repentance, and dedication removes obstacles to spiritual progress and creates the necessary conditions for wisdom and higher realizations to arise.
268
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* address the ethical issue of 'consuming intoxicants'?
It advises against consuming intoxicants as they cloud the mind, hinder virtuous conduct, and lead to negative karmic results.
269
What is the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*)?
It is the final path of Buddhahood, where all obscurations are eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn or abandon in terms of practice or realization.
270
What are the 'two stages of the tantric path' and their relationship to emptiness?
The generation stage (kye-rim) purifies ordinary appearances and develops pure vision, while the completion stage (dzog-rim) directly realizes emptiness through subtle energy practices, both grounded in the Madhyamaka view.
271
How does the *Bodhisattvabhūmi* describe the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) in terms of its function?
It is the wisdom that directly realizes the emptiness of inherent existence, serving as the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the guide for all other perfections.
272
What is the significance of the 'conventional validity' of phenomena in Madhyamaka?
Conventional validity means phenomena appear and function effectively in the world, enabling cause and effect (including karma), without implying inherent existence, thus allowing for the path to exist.
273
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' (ātman) using the aggregates?
He demonstrates that the self cannot be found as inherently existing within any of the five aggregates, nor separate from them, concluding it is merely a dependent designation.
274
What is the role of 'analytic meditation' (*vipassanā*) in realizing emptiness?
Analytic meditation involves sustained, reasoned investigation of phenomena to determine their lack of inherent existence, leading to a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness.
275
What is the significance of the 'four immeasurables' (brahmavihāras) as a basis for bodhicitta?
They cultivate boundless loving-kindness, compassion, joy, and equanimity, thereby expanding the heart to genuinely wish for the happiness and freedom from suffering of all sentient beings impartially.
276
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ten stages' (bhūmis) of a bodhisattva?
It outlines the progressive levels of spiritual development where a bodhisattva increasingly perfects the pāramitās and deepens their realization of emptiness, culminating in Buddhahood.
277
What is the ethical implication of 'senseless chatter' in *Precious Garland*?
It is considered a non-virtuous action of speech because it wastes time, distracts from meaningful activities, and does not contribute to one's own or others' spiritual growth.
278
What is the 'three-fold purity' in the practice of generosity?
It refers to the purity of the giver, the gift, and the recipient, all being understood as empty of inherent existence, which perfects the generosity.
279
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the world' (loka)?
He argues that the world is merely a conceptual designation based on its components (aggregates, elements, sense fields), none of which inherently exist, thus the world itself is empty.
280
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the kindness of all beings' in the seven-point instruction?
To generate deep gratitude for the care and support received from countless beings in past lives, which naturally leads to the wish to repay their kindness.
281
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'causes and conditions'?
He shows that causes cannot inherently produce effects if they are either identical to or completely separate from effects, demonstrating their mutual dependence and empty nature.
282
What is the 'path of cultivation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*) and its primary objective?
It is the path where a bodhisattva repeatedly habituates to the direct realization of emptiness, gradually eliminating the subtle obscurations and perfecting the virtues.
283
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the distinction between 'negation of inherent existence' and 'negation of all existence'?
He explains that Madhyamaka negates only the imagined inherent existence of phenomena, not their conventional, functional existence, thereby avoiding nihilism.
284
What is the significance of the 'non-conceptual mind' (nirvikalpa jñāna) in realizing emptiness?
It is the direct, unmediated apprehension of emptiness that transcends all conceptual frameworks and dualistic thought, being the ultimate and unerring insight.
285
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the ethical imperative of 'non-stealing'?
It explains that taking what is not given creates negative karma, leads to poverty and loss in future lives, and undermines trust in society.
286
What is the role of 'aspirational prayers' (praṇidhāna) in sustaining bodhicitta?
Aspirational prayers reinforce and deepen the resolve to achieve Buddhahood for others' sake, providing a continuous source of motivation and direction on the path.
287
What is the significance of 'wisdom' (*prajñā*) as the 'mother' of all Buddhas?
Wisdom (the direct realization of emptiness) is called the mother because it is the essential condition for attaining Buddhahood; without it, full enlightenment cannot be achieved.
288
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He demonstrates that each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) lacks inherent existence when analyzed, and thus no inherently existing 'self' can be found within them.
289
What are the 'five paths' (pañca-mārga) in the Mahayana tradition?
They are the path of accumulation, path of preparation, path of seeing, path of meditation, and path of no more learning (Buddhahoood).
290
What is the primary function of 'calm abiding' (śamatha) in the context of meditative practice?
Calm abiding develops one-pointed concentration and mental stability, providing a clear and pliable mind that is free from agitation and dullness, which is essential for higher insight.
291
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'time' (kāla)?
He demonstrates that past, present, and future are mutually dependent and cannot inherently exist independently of each other, thus they are empty of inherent nature.
292
What is the difference between 'conceptual' and 'non-conceptual' understanding of emptiness?
Conceptual understanding is an intellectual apprehension based on reasoning, while non-conceptual understanding is a direct, experiential realization free from mental constructs.
293
What is the significance of the 'eight worldly dharmas' for a practitioner?
They are the pairs of opposites (gain/loss, pleasure/pain, praise/blame, fame/disrepute) that bind one to cyclic existence when clung to; transcending them leads to liberation.
294
How does the practice of 'rejoicing in virtuous deeds' benefit oneself?
Rejoicing in the virtuous deeds of oneself and others creates positive karmic imprints, counters envy, and increases one's own merit and spiritual growth.
295
What is the ethical imperative of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) according to Nāgārjuna?
Right livelihood involves engaging in occupations that do not cause harm to others and are consistent with ethical principles, thereby promoting a virtuous life.
296
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the self' (ātman)?
He exhaustively searches for an inherent self in the aggregates, finding none, and concludes that the self is merely designated in dependence on the aggregates.
297
What is the 'path of liberation' (mokṣa-mārga) in general Buddhist terms?
It is the path that leads to freedom from cyclic existence (saṃsāra) and all its sufferings, primarily through the elimination of ignorance and afflictions.
298
What is the role of 'skilful means' (upāya) in the bodhisattva's compassionate activity?
Skilful means refers to the bodhisattva's ability to adapt their teachings, actions, and methods to the diverse needs and capacities of sentient beings to effectively lead them to liberation.
299
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the elements' (e.g.
earth, water, fire, wind)?, "He demonstrates that each element is defined in relation to others and cannot exist independently, showing their mutual dependence and emptiness of inherent nature.
300
What is the significance of 'dedicating merit' on the Mahayana path?
Dedicating merit ensures that all positive actions contribute to the enlightenment of all sentient beings, preventing one's merit from being limited to individual liberation and strengthening altruism.
301
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'subtle imputation of inherent existence'?
It is the subtle, beginningless habit of mind to apprehend phenomena as truly existing from their own side, which is the primary object to be refuted by the wisdom realizing emptiness.
302
What is the 'perfect knowledge of all aspects' (*sarvākārajñatā*) of a Buddha?
It is the omniscience of a Buddha, who simultaneously and directly knows all phenomena, both conventional and ultimate, in all their aspects, without any obstruction.
303
How does the practice of 'forbearance' (patience) contribute to happiness?
Forbearance allows one to remain undisturbed by difficulties, criticism, and suffering, preventing anger and resentment from arising, thus fostering inner peace and mental well-being.
304
What is the role of 'equanimity' in developing impartial compassion?
Equanimity helps to overcome biases and partiality (attachment to friends, aversion to enemies), allowing one's compassion and loving-kindness to extend equally to all sentient beings without exception.
305
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the knower and the known'?
He argues that the knower (subject) cannot exist independently of the known (object), nor the known without the knower; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
306
What is the 'wisdom of the path' (*mārga-jñatā*) according to the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras?
It is the wisdom of a Buddha that comprehends all the different paths and stages that lead to liberation and enlightenment, enabling them to guide sentient beings effectively.
307
What are the 'three types of suffering' in detail?
The suffering of pain (physical/mental pain), the suffering of change (impermanent happiness that turns to suffering), and the pervasive suffering of conditioning (existence under the sway of karma and afflictions).
308
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' (ātman)?
He demonstrates that no inherently existing self can be found when analyzing the five aggregates, thus the self is merely a dependent designation and empty of inherent nature.
309
What is the significance of the 'mind of enlightenment' (bodhicitta) as an 'elixir'?
It transforms all ordinary actions into causes for enlightenment, purifies vast amounts of negative karma, and accelerates one's spiritual progress.
310
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'union of the two truths' (conventional and ultimate)?
He clarifies that the two truths are not separate entities but are two aspects of the same reality, inseparable like the two sides of a coin, with ultimate truth being the nature of conventional truth.
311
What is the 'path of accumulation' (*saṃbhāra-mārga*) and its main characteristic?
It is the initial path where one accumulates vast merit and develops a conceptual understanding of emptiness through study and contemplation, laying the groundwork for direct realization.
312
How does the practice of 'renunciation' (nekkhamma) serve as a foundation for the path?
Renunciation is the sincere wish to be free from cyclic existence and its sufferings, motivating one to abandon the causes of suffering and pursue liberation.
313
What is the ethical imperative of 'right speech' (samyak-vāc) according to Nāgārjuna?
Right speech involves avoiding lying, divisive speech, harsh words, and senseless chatter, and instead engaging in truthful, kind, harmonious, and meaningful communication.
314
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'non-abiding nirvāṇa'?
It signifies that a Buddha, having realized emptiness, does not remain in a solitary peace but, motivated by great compassion, manifests continuously in cyclic existence to benefit sentient beings without being defiled.
315
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the eye' (cakṣus) and 'forms' (rūpa)?
He argues that the eye cannot inherently see without forms, nor forms be inherently seen without the eye; they are mutually dependent and thus empty.
316
What is the 'path of preparation' (*prayoga-mārga*) and its main characteristic?
It is the path where the conceptual understanding of emptiness is refined, leading to an increasing proximity to direct realization, prior to actually seeing emptiness directly.
317
What is the significance of 'impermanence' in the context of meditative practice?
Contemplating impermanence helps to loosen attachment to worldly phenomena, reduces grasping, and fosters a sense of urgency to practice Dharma.
318
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'causes and effects'?
He demonstrates that if causes inherently existed before effects, they would cease to be causes when effects arise, and if they existed simultaneously, they would not be cause and effect; thus they are empty.
319
What is the ultimate aim of the 'perfection of wisdom' (*prajñāpāramitā*) for a bodhisattva?
To achieve the direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, which is the ultimate antidote to ignorance and the necessary condition for attaining omniscience and Buddhahood.
320
How does Tsongkhapa clarify the meaning of 'non-conceptual' in relation to realizing emptiness?
Non-conceptual means free from dualistic apprehension, from the conceptual overlay of subject and object, and from the reification of inherent existence.
321
What is the significance of the 'four immeasurables' (mettā
karuṇā, muditā, upekṣā) in generating bodhicitta?, "They are the boundless states of mind that cultivate universal love, compassion, joy, and equanimity, essential for expanding one's altruism to encompass all sentient beings without bias.
322
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'path of meditation' (*bhāvanā-mārga*)?
It describes the continuous cultivation of wisdom (realizing emptiness) and method (perfections) across the bodhisattva grounds, gradually eliminating subtle obscurations until Buddhahood.
323
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the pervasive suffering of conditioned existence'?
To recognize that even seemingly neutral experiences are tainted by suffering due to their impermanent and dependently arisen nature, motivating renunciation of cyclic existence.
324
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the ethical imperative of 'non-sexual misconduct'?
It advises against sexual activity that causes harm, is non-consensual, or breaks one's vows, emphasizing purity and respect in relationships.
325
What is the 'path of no more training' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*)?
This refers to the state of full Buddhahood, where there are no more obscurations to eliminate and no more practices to cultivate, as all enlightened qualities are perfected.
326
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the world' (*loka*) and 'time' (*kāla*)?
He demonstrates that they are merely conceptual designations based on dependently arisen phenomena and their relation, lacking any inherent reality.
327
What is the significance of the 'eightfold noble path' in the context of the cessation of suffering?
It is the practical path (right view, intention, speech, action, livelihood, effort, mindfulness, concentration) that leads directly to the cessation of suffering and the realization of liberation.
328
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He demonstrates that each of the five aggregates (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) is dependently arisen and lacks inherent existence, meaning no inherent self can be found within them.
329
What is the unique contribution of Tsongkhapa's 'systematic approach' to Madhyamaka?
Tsongkhapa's approach provides a clear, step-by-step methodology for understanding and realizing emptiness, integrating scriptural study, logical reasoning, and meditative practice.
330
What is the role of 'analogy' in explaining emptiness?
Analogies (like dreams, illusions, reflections) help to illustrate how phenomena appear vividly yet lack inherent existence, making the abstract concept of emptiness more accessible.
331
How does the practice of 'dedication of merit' (pariṇāmanā) contribute to the Mahayana path?
Dedicating all accumulated merit for the benefit of all sentient beings ensures that one's positive actions serve the ultimate altruistic goal of Buddhahood.
332
What is the significance of the 'four purities of the Prajñāpāramitā'?
They refer to the purity of the basis, path, practitioner, and result, all understood in terms of emptiness, signifying their non-inherent nature.
333
What is the ethical imperative of 'right action' (samyak-karmānta) according to Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
Right action involves abandoning killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct, and instead engaging in life protection, generosity, and pure conduct.
334
How does the development of 'great compassion' (mahākaruṇā) serve as a cause for bodhicitta?
Great compassion, the heartfelt wish for all beings to be free from suffering, gives rise to the extraordinary intention to personally bring about their liberation, which then culminates in bodhicitta.
335
What is the 'path of the Buddha' (buddha-mārga) in contrast to other paths?
It is the complete path of a bodhisattva, leading to full omniscience and liberation for all sentient beings, distinguished from partial or individual liberation paths.
336
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'movement' (gati) using the three times?
He demonstrates that movement cannot inherently exist in the past, present, or future, nor can it exist separate from them, thus it is empty.
337
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'vow' (praṇidhāna)?
The vow is a formal commitment to the bodhisattva deeds, providing a powerful structure and continuous motivation to fulfill the aspiration for enlightenment for others.
338
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the self' (ātman) through a lack of identity with the aggregates?
He states that if the self were identical to the aggregates, it would be multiple and impermanent like them; if different, it would be unobservable, thus neither holds true.
339
What is the 'union of method and wisdom' in the Mahayana path?
It refers to the inseparable practice of the accumulation of merit (method: compassion, skillful means, perfections) and the accumulation of wisdom (realizing emptiness), both essential for Buddhahood.
340
What is the purpose of 'meditating on the equality of self and others'?
To dismantle the ingrained habit of self-cherishing and foster a mind that values the happiness of others as much as, or more than, one's own.
341
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'ten powers' of a Buddha?
It describes the ten specific powers (such as knowing all phenomena, all paths, all defilements and purifications) that a Buddha possesses as a result of perfecting wisdom and compassion.
342
What is the ethical imperative of 'right livelihood' (samyak-ājīva) for a practitioner?
Right livelihood means earning one's living in a way that does not harm oneself or others, and that aligns with Buddhist ethical principles.
343
What are the 'three types of vows' (pratimoksha
bodhisattva, tantric) and their significance?, "They are progressive levels of ethical commitment, providing frameworks for individuals to purify their conduct and engage in increasingly profound practices for liberation and enlightenment.
344
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'causality' (hetu-phala)?
He demonstrates that causes and effects are mutually dependent and cannot inherently exist either as identical or as completely separate entities, thus they are empty.
345
What is the 'path of no more learning' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*) and its ultimate achievement?
It is the final path, representing full Buddhahood, where all obscurations are eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn, abandon, or accomplish.
346
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the perceiver' (draṣṭā) and 'the perceived' (dṛśya)?
He shows that neither can inherently exist without the other; the perceiver is defined by what it perceives, and vice versa, demonstrating their mutual dependence.
347
What is the significance of the 'non-duality of saṃsāra and nirvāṇa' for Nāgārjuna?
It means that from the ultimate perspective, cyclic existence and liberation are not inherently distinct; their difference lies in one's conceptual overlay and ignorance, not in their ultimate nature.
348
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'two truths' as being 'mutually inclusive'?
He clarifies that conventional and ultimate truths are not separate realities but two aspects of the same phenomenon, existing simultaneously; a phenomenon's conventional appearance is inseparable from its ultimate emptiness.
349
What is the role of 'non-conceptual wisdom' (*nirvikalpa jñāna*) in the realization of emptiness?
Non-conceptual wisdom is the direct, unmediated apprehension of emptiness, free from all mental constructs and dualistic appearances, serving as the ultimate antidote to ignorance.
350
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great compassion' being 'uncontaminated' by self-cherishing?
Uncontaminated compassion is purely altruistic, free from any subtle motivation of self-interest, making it boundless and truly effective in leading others to enlightenment.
351
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* advise against 'harsh speech'?
It explains that harsh speech causes discord, resentment, and negativity, leading to karmic consequences and hindering harmonious relationships.
352
What is the distinction between 'aspiring bodhicitta' and 'engaging bodhicitta' in terms of practice?
Aspiring bodhicitta is the wish, cultivated through methods like the seven-point instruction, while engaging bodhicitta is the active undertaking of the bodhisattva deeds, primarily the six perfections.
353
What is the purpose of 'contemplating suffering' (duḥkha-bhāvanā) in the path?
To recognize the pervasive nature of suffering in cyclic existence, which generates renunciation and motivates one to seek liberation for oneself and others.
354
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the elements' (*mahābhūta*)?
He argues that each element (e.g., earth, water) is defined in relation to the others and cannot exist independently, demonstrating their dependent and empty nature.
355
What is the 'path of purification' (*viśuddhi-mārga*) in general Buddhist terms?
It refers to the progressive elimination of mental defilements (afflictions and obscurations to omniscience) through ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom.
356
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the seen' and 'the seer'?
He demonstrates that the seen cannot exist without a seer, nor the seer without the seen; they are mutually dependent and thus empty of inherent existence.
357
What is the 'subtle imputation' that Tsongkhapa's Madhyamaka aims to refute?
It is the ingrained habit of mind to apprehend phenomena as truly existing from their own side, which is the object of negation for the wisdom realizing emptiness.
358
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'great intention' (adhiśaya) to liberate all beings?
It is the profound resolve to personally take responsibility for freeing all sentient beings from suffering, which is the direct cause for generating bodhicitta.
359
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'omniscience of individual knowledge' (*sarvākārajñatā-jñāna*)?
It refers to the Buddha's perfect knowledge of all aspects of all phenomena, allowing them to comprehend the unique dispositions and needs of every sentient being.
360
What is the ethical imperative of 'non-lying' according to Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland*?
It emphasizes the importance of truthful speech, avoiding lies that cause harm, undermine trust, and create negative karma.
361
What is the role of 'aspirational vows' (praṇidhāna) in maintaining the bodhisattva's motivation?
Aspirational vows serve as powerful commitments that continually reinforce the resolve to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings, sustaining the bodhisattva through immense difficulties.
362
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the five aggregates' (skandhas)?
He systematically analyzes each aggregate and shows that none can inherently exist independently or as a collection, demonstrating that any self imputed upon them is empty of inherent existence.
363
What is the 'path of no more training' (*aśaikṣa-mārga*)?
This is the final stage of Buddhahood, where all defilements and obscurations have been completely eliminated, and there is nothing further to learn or abandon.
364
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three realms' (triloka) of activity?
A bodhisattva works tirelessly in all three realms of existence (desire, form, formless) to liberate sentient beings from suffering, without being bound by these realms.
365
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the result' (phala)?
He demonstrates that a result cannot inherently exist independently of its cause, nor a cause independently of its result, thus they are mutually dependent and empty.
366
What is the meaning of 'non-conceptual' in the context of meditative realization of emptiness?
It signifies a direct, unmediated apprehension of the ultimate nature of reality, free from any conceptual or dualistic thought patterns.
367
What is the role of 'renunciation' (nekkhamma) in the Mahayana path?
Renunciation is the sincere wish to be free from cyclic existence and its causes, motivating one to engage in ethical conduct, meditation, and wisdom practices.
368
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* explain the 'perfection of wisdom' (prajñāpāramitā) in detail?
It outlines the specific ways in which the wisdom realizing emptiness is cultivated and perfected through the various stages of the bodhisattva's path, leading to omniscience.
369
What is the ethical imperative of 'right intention' (samyak-saṃkalpa) in the Mahayana path?
Right intention involves intentions of renunciation, non-ill-will, and non-harming, forming the basis for virtuous thoughts and actions.
370
What is the significance of the bodhisattva's 'three pure actions' (body
speech, mind)?, "They are actions purified by bodhicitta and perfected with wisdom, leading to the accumulation of vast merit and the elimination of defilements.
371
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas)?
He argues that if the aggregates were inherently existent, they would be either ultimately one or ultimately many, both of which are untenable under analysis, demonstrating their emptiness.
372
What is the difference between 'afflictive obscurations' (klesha-āvaraṇa) and 'obscurations to omniscience' (jñeya-āvaraṇa)?
Afflictive obscurations are mental afflictions (like attachment, anger, ignorance) that bind one to saṃsāra, while obscurations to omniscience are subtle imprints of dualistic appearance that prevent full Buddhahood.
373
How does Nāgārjuna argue for the emptiness of 'the past' (atīta)?
He demonstrates that the past cannot inherently exist because it is defined only in relation to the present and future, proving its dependent and empty nature.
374
What is the role of 'reasoning' in Tsongkhapa's Madhyamaka for realizing emptiness?
Reasoning is used to eliminate mistaken conceptual elaborations and to lead the mind to a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness by systematically refuting inherent existence.
375
What is the significance of the 'six perfections' (pāramitās) as the 'engaged bodhicitta'?
They are the actual practices (generosity, ethics, patience, joyous effort, concentration, wisdom) that a bodhisattva undertakes to fulfill their aspiration to attain Buddhahood for the benefit of all sentient beings.
376
What is the purpose of Chandrakīrti's *Madhyamakāvatāra* (Introduction to the Middle Way)?
It serves as an introduction to Nāgārjuna's Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, guiding students through the tenets of the Middle Way philosophy.
377
According to Chandrakīrti
what is the *Middle Way* (Madhyamaka) free from?,It is free from the two extremes of eternalism (śāśvatavāda) and nihilism (ucchedavāda).
378
What is the core philosophical concept elucidated in the *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
The ultimate nature of phenomena, particularly emptiness (śūnyatā), as taught by Nāgārjuna.
379
What are the two truths (conventional and ultimate) as explained by Chandrakīrti?
Conventional truth (saṃvṛti-satya) is the way things appear to ordinary minds, while ultimate truth (paramārtha-satya) is their true nature, emptiness, devoid of inherent existence.
380
How does Chandrakīrti differentiate between the two truths?
Conventional truths are valid for interaction in the world, while ultimate truths reveal the actual mode of existence of phenomena.
381
What is *emptiness* (śūnyatā) according to the Mādhyamaka school?
Emptiness is the absence of inherent existence (svabhāva) in all phenomena, meaning nothing exists by itself, independently.
382
How does Chandrakīrti assert that emptiness is not nihilism?
Emptiness does not mean that phenomena do not exist at all, but that they do not exist inherently; they exist dependently.
383
What is the primary method used by Mādhyamaka to establish emptiness?
Through rigorous logical analysis (prasanga), demonstrating that phenomena cannot exist inherently from any perspective (self-production, other-production, both, or neither).
384
What is *dependent arising* (pratītyasamutpāda) in Mādhyamaka?
The principle that all phenomena arise in dependence on causes and conditions, parts, and conceptual imputation.
385
How does dependent arising prove emptiness?
Because phenomena arise dependently, they cannot have independent, inherent existence; their existence is conditional and relational.
386
What is the significance of the *Madhyamakāvatāra* for practitioners on the bodhisattva path?
It provides the essential wisdom needed to perfect the *Prajñāpāramitā* (Perfection of Wisdom).
387
What is the relationship between compassion and wisdom in Mādhyamaka?
Compassion motivates the bodhisattva to liberate all beings from suffering, while wisdom (realizing emptiness) provides the means to genuinely do so by eradicating the root of suffering, which is ignorance of reality.
388
What is the *svātantrika* school of Mādhyamaka and its primary characteristic?
The Svātantrika school asserts that phenomena have a conventionally established inherent existence, proposing autonomous (svatantra) inferences to prove emptiness.
389
What is the *prāsaṅgika* school of Mādhyamaka and its primary characteristic?
The Prāsaṅgika school, championed by Chandrakīrti, rejects any form of inherent existence, even conventionally, and uses *reductio ad absurdum* (prasanga) arguments to demonstrate the absurd consequences of inherent existence.
390
What is Chandrakīrti's criticism of the Svātantrika approach to conventional truth?
Chandrakīrti argues that even conventionally, phenomena do not inherently exist, and that autonomous inferences are problematic because they assume an inherently existent subject and object.
391
What is the meaning of "selflessness of persons" (pudgala-nairātmya) in Mādhyamaka?
The absence of an inherently existent, independent self or soul in individuals.
392
What is the meaning of "selflessness of phenomena" (dharma-nairātmya) in Mādhyamaka?
The absence of inherent existence in all phenomena, whether internal (mind, body) or external (objects).
393
Why is understanding both selflessness of persons and phenomena crucial for liberation?
Understanding both is necessary to eradicate all levels of ignorance and attain complete liberation from cyclic existence and omniscience.
394
What is the role of *reasoning* in Chandrakīrti's approach?
Reasoning is used to dismantle misconceptions about inherent existence, thereby clearing the way for the direct experience of emptiness.
395
What is the ultimate aim of the Mādhyamaka philosophical analysis?
To lead the practitioner to a non-conceptual realization of emptiness, which is the wisdom that frees from suffering.
396
How does Chandrakīrti describe the *buddha-nature* (tathāgatagarbha) in relation to emptiness?
The Buddha-nature is the inherent purity of the mind, which is ultimately empty of inherent existence, yet possesses the potential for all enlightened qualities.
397
What is the importance of engaging with the Mādhyamaka view for a bodhisattva?
It perfects the wisdom aspect of the bodhisattva path, allowing for effective and non-reverting progression towards Buddhahood.
398
What is the *conventional valid cognition* according to Chandrakīrti?
Cognition that is valid within the realm of conventional appearances, even if those appearances lack ultimate inherent existence.
399
How does Chandrakīrti refute inherent existence from the perspective of causes and conditions?
If phenomena existed inherently, they would not need causes and conditions, as inherent existence implies independent existence, which is contradicted by observation.
400
What is the example of a *chariot* used to illustrate emptiness?
A chariot is merely a collection of parts and a label; there is no inherently existing "chariot" separate from its parts. This illustrates the lack of inherent existence through part-whole analysis.
401
What is the significance of *deception* (moha) in Chandrakīrti's view of conventional truth?
Conventional truths, while functional, are ultimately deceptive in their appearance of inherent existence to an ignorant mind.
402
What is the meaning of "reality as it is" (*yathābhūtam*) in the context of ultimate truth?
It refers to the ultimate mode of existence of phenomena, which is emptiness, free from all conceptual elaborations and inherent existence.
403
How does the *Madhyamakāvatāra* guide a bodhisattva through the ten *bhūmis* (stages)?
It correlates the increasing realization of emptiness with the progress through the bodhisattva stages, highlighting how wisdom perfects each stage.
404
What is the role of *renunciation* in the Mādhyamaka path?
Renunciation of cyclic existence is the initial motivation, providing the foundation for engaging with the deeper teachings of emptiness.
405
What is the relationship between *emptiness* and *compassion* in the *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
The deeper one realizes emptiness, the greater one's compassion becomes, as one understands the illusory nature of suffering and the true potential for liberation for all beings.
406
What is the *ultimate bodhicitta* from a Mādhyamaka perspective?
The direct realization of emptiness, free from all conceptual elaborations, which is the wisdom aspect of a Buddha's mind.
407
How does Chandrakīrti establish the non-inherent existence of the *mind*?
By analyzing the mind's constituents and moments, showing that no inherently existing "mind" can be found separate from its parts or moments.
408
What is the *illusion-like nature* of phenomena in Mādhyamaka?
Phenomena appear to exist inherently but are ultimately empty of inherent existence, similar to an illusion which appears real but is not.
409
What is the purpose of understanding the illusion-like nature of phenomena?
It allows a practitioner to engage with the world with compassion without being conceptually entangled by its appearances of inherent existence.
410
What is the *Prāsaṅgika* view on establishing ultimate truth versus conventional truth?
Prāsaṅgikas establish ultimate truth by refuting inherent existence, and conventional truth is what remains after this refutation, functioning without inherent existence.
411
What is the *twofold lack of identity* (anātman) as explained in Mādhyamaka?
The lack of inherent identity in persons and the lack of inherent identity in phenomena.
412
What is the significance of the *seventh chapter* of the *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
It focuses on the *Prajñāpāramitā* (Perfection of Wisdom) and the direct realization of emptiness.
413
How does *analytical meditation* lead to the realization of emptiness?
By repeatedly searching for inherent existence in phenomena and failing to find it, one eventually develops a direct experience of its absence.
414
What is the ultimate aim of the Mādhyamaka practice?
To eradicate the deepest level of ignorance, which is the grasping at inherent existence.
415
What is the role of *scriptural authority* in Mādhyamaka
alongside reasoning?,While reasoning is paramount for understanding emptiness, scriptural authority provides the initial guidance and framework.
416
What is the meaning of "freedom from conceptual elaboration" (prapañca-śūnyatā)?
The state where the mind is free from all mental constructs and dualistic perceptions, directly perceiving ultimate reality.
417
How does Chandrakīrti address the objection that emptiness leads to the non-existence of everything?
He clarifies that emptiness means non-inherent existence, not absolute non-existence, allowing for dependent conventional existence.
418
What is the importance of *accumulating merit* (positive force) alongside wisdom in Mādhyamaka?
Merit accumulation creates the conducive conditions and the enlightened form body, while wisdom leads to the truth body of a Buddha.
419
What is the *Mādhyamaka-kārikā*?
Nāgārjuna's root text on the Middle Way, which the *Madhyamakāvatāra* is an introduction and commentary to.
420
What is the significance of *non-dual wisdom* in Mādhyamaka?
It is the wisdom that perceives emptiness directly, without the duality of subject and object, or any inherent distinctions.
421
What is the *analogy of the moon in water* for emptiness?
Just as the moon's reflection in water appears to exist but is not inherently real, phenomena appear to exist inherently but are ultimately empty of inherent existence.
422
What is the *analogy of a dream* for conventional reality?
Experiences in a dream appear real while dreaming but are ultimately empty of inherent existence, illustrating the nature of conventional reality.
423
How does Chandrakīrti demonstrate that *inherent production* from self or other is impossible?
If things inherently produced from themselves, they would never need to be produced. If from others, there's no inherent connection, leading to absurdities like anything producing anything.
424
What is the *result* of cultivating the wisdom of emptiness for a bodhisattva?
It leads to the complete eradication of mental afflictions and the full development of all enlightened qualities.
425
What is the *object of negation* in Mādhyamaka analysis?
The inherent existence (svabhāva) of phenomena.
426
What is the relationship between *ignorance* and *inherent existence*?
Ignorance is fundamentally the grasping at inherent existence, which is the root of all suffering.
427
How does Mādhyamaka explain the arising of suffering?
Suffering arises from actions motivated by mental afflictions, which in turn stem from ignorance, the grasping at inherent existence.
428
What is the *ultimate liberation* from a Mādhyamaka perspective?
The complete cessation of all suffering and its causes, achieved through the direct realization of emptiness.
429
What is the role of *emptiness* in the perfection of patience?
Understanding emptiness helps one to see that harm and suffering are not inherently existing, allowing for greater patience and equanimity.
430
How does *emptiness* perfect generosity?
By realizing the emptiness of giver, recipient, and gift, one's generosity becomes pure and free from attachment.
431
How does *emptiness* perfect ethical discipline?
By realizing the emptiness of self, action, and object, one's ethical conduct becomes spontaneous and effortless, free from self-grasping.
432
How does *emptiness* perfect joyous effort?
By realizing the emptiness of effort and its object, one's perseverance becomes untiring and free from discouragement.
433
How does *emptiness* perfect meditative concentration?
By realizing the emptiness of mind, meditation object, and the act of meditating, concentration becomes stable and profound.
434
What is the unique feature of Chandrakīrti's Mādhyamaka-Prāsaṅgika approach?
Its rigorous insistence on the utter non-existence of inherent nature, even conventionally, and its exclusive use of *prasanga* (consequence) arguments.
435
Why is the *Madhyamakāvatāra* considered a commentary on the *Ten Bhūmis*?
It systematically explains how the understanding and realization of emptiness are cultivated across the ten bodhisattva stages.
436
What does the "path of accumulation" entail from a Mādhyamaka perspective?
Accumulating merit and beginning to intellectually understand emptiness.
437
What does the "path of preparation" involve in Mādhyamaka?
Intensifying the conceptual understanding and analytical meditation on emptiness.
438
What defines the "path of seeing" in Mādhyamaka?
The direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness for the first time, achieving the first bodhisattva ground.
439
What is the significance of the "first ground" (Pramuditā) in the Mādhyamaka context?
Upon reaching this ground, the bodhisattva sees emptiness directly and is no longer subject to falling back into lower paths.
440
What is the focus of the "path of meditation" in Mādhyamaka?
Repeatedly meditating on the emptiness seen on the path of seeing, gradually eliminating subtle defilements.
441
What is the "path of no more learning" in Mādhyamaka?
The final attainment of Buddhahood, where all defilements are eliminated and all enlightened qualities are perfected.
442
How does Chandrakīrti argue against the self-inherent existence of *atoms*?
Even the smallest part, an atom, can be divided conceptually or spatially, demonstrating its lack of inherent, indivisible existence.
443
What is the meaning of "relative truth appears as real to the ignorant"?
To those not realizing emptiness, conventional phenomena appear to exist inherently, which is an error in perception.
444
What is the role of *compassion* (karuṇā) as the *root* of Mādhyamaka practice?
It is the initial motivation that propels one to seek enlightenment for the benefit of all suffering beings.
445
What is the Mādhyamaka critique of *inherently existent consciousness*?
Consciousness, like other phenomena, is dependently arisen and lacks inherent existence; it is not a singular, permanent entity.
446
How does the Mādhyamaka view reconcile emptiness with the functionality of conventional reality?
Conventional reality functions precisely *because* it is empty of inherent existence; its dependent arising allows for cause and effect.
447
What is the meaning of "two truths of existence" for Chandrakīrti?
The way things appear to be (conventional) and the way things actually are (ultimate, emptiness).
448
What is the *analogy of the magician* in understanding Mādhyamaka?
A magician creates illusions that appear real but are not inherently so, akin to how phenomena appear to exist inherently but are empty.
449
What is the significance of *Prajñā* (wisdom) being the sixth perfection?
It is the culminating perfection that guides all the others and is the direct antidote to the fundamental ignorance of inherent existence.
450
Why does Chandrakīrti emphasize *prasanga* (consequence) arguments?
Because they force the opponent to see the absurd conclusions of their own inherent existence claims, without positing a counter-thesis.
451
What is the *ultimate aim* of studying the *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
To directly realize the ultimate truth of emptiness and thereby achieve liberation and full enlightenment.
452
What is the relationship between *emptiness* and *compassion* in the mind of a fully enlightened Buddha?
They are inseparable; the Buddha's boundless compassion arises spontaneously from the perfect wisdom realizing emptiness.
453
How does the Mādhyamaka teaching prevent falling into the extreme of *nihilism*?
By asserting that while phenomena are empty of inherent existence, they *do* exist conventionally and functionally.
454
How does the Mādhyamaka teaching prevent falling into the extreme of *eternalism*?
By refuting any inherently existing, permanent self or phenomena.
455
What is the primary *affliction* (kleśa) addressed by the wisdom of emptiness?
The grasping at inherent existence (sva-bhāva-grāha), which is the root of all suffering.
456
What is the *meaning* of "ultimate" (paramārtha) in "ultimate truth"?
It refers to the highest meaning or purpose, transcending all conventional distinctions and conceptualizations.
457
How does *meditative stabilization* (samādhi) support the realization of emptiness?
It provides the mental clarity and stability necessary for deep analytical meditation on emptiness.
458
What is the Mādhyamaka view on the *nature of phenomena*?
They are like illusions, dream-like, and appear to exist but are empty of inherent existence.
459
What is the *initial motivation* for engaging in the Mādhyamaka path?
The desire to alleviate the suffering of oneself and all others, rooted in compassion.
460
What are the *four types of logical fallacies* (catuṣkoṭi) that Mādhyamaka often uses to refute inherent existence?
Existence, non-existence, both existence and non-existence, and neither existence nor non-existence.
461
How does the *Mādhyamaka* path differ from the *Śrāvakayāna* path in terms of wisdom?
While both paths realize selflessness, the Mādhyamaka path realizes the selflessness of *all phenomena*, not just persons, leading to full omniscience.
462
What is the role of *Ju Mipham's commentary* in understanding Chandrakīrti's *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
Mipham's commentary provides extensive clarification and contextualization, making Chandrakīrti's complex arguments more accessible to Tibetan students.
463
Why is the *Madhyamakāvatāra* considered a critical text for the study of *Prajñāpāramitā*?
It systematically explains the ultimate meaning of the Perfection of Wisdom Sutras, emphasizing the non-inherent existence of all phenomena.
464
What is the Mādhyamaka understanding of *conventional reality*?
It is functional and causally effective, even though it lacks inherent existence. It is not an illusion in the sense of being non-existent.
465
What is the relationship between *dependent arising* and *causality* in Mādhyamaka?
Causality is understood as a form of dependent arising; effects arise dependently on causes, but neither causes nor effects exist inherently.
466
How does Chandrakīrti's view of emptiness differ from an *absolutist* or *nihilist* interpretation?
He avoids both extremes by asserting that emptiness is not a void or an absolute ground, but merely the absence of inherent existence, allowing for conventional functioning.
467
What is the significance of *equanimity* in approaching the Mādhyamaka view?
It helps one to remain impartial and open-minded when analyzing phenomena, freeing the mind from bias.
468
What is the "reasoning of the four alternatives" used by Mādhyamaka to analyze production?
Whether phenomena are produced from self, from other, from both self and other, or from neither.
469
What is the *Prāsaṅgika* view on *valid cognition* (pramāṇa) in relation to ultimate truth?
Valid cognition refers to what is consistently experienced, but ultimate truth is beyond ordinary conceptual valid cognition; it is realized non-conceptually.
470
What is the *effect of realizing emptiness* on mental afflictions?
The direct realization of emptiness eradicates the root cause of all mental afflictions, leading to their complete cessation.
471
How does Chandrakīrti's *Madhyamakāvatāra* contribute to the understanding of *Buddhist epistemology*?
It profoundly critiques inherent existence even at the conventional level, impacting how knowledge and perception are understood.
472
What is the Mādhyamaka argument against *inherently existing motion*?
Motion requires a moving object and a path, and analysis shows no inherently existing "motion" separate from these dependently arising factors.
473
What is the meaning of "relative appearance" in Mādhyamaka?
The way phenomena appear to exist to ordinary, unanalyzed perception, which includes an illusory overlay of inherent existence.
474
What is the ultimate aim of the "union of compassion and wisdom" in the Mādhyamaka path?
To achieve full buddhahood, which is characterized by perfect wisdom (realizing emptiness) and perfect compassion (acting for all beings).
475
What is the significance of *Mādhyamaka* for a lay practitioner?
Understanding these principles, even conceptually, can reduce grasping, foster greater compassion, and provide a clearer view of reality.
476
What is the Mādhyamaka view on *suffering* itself?
Suffering, like all phenomena, is empty of inherent existence, meaning it is not a fixed, independent entity but arises dependently and can be ceased.
477
How does *Chandrakīrti's* work compare to *Nāgārjuna's*?
Chandrakīrti's *Madhyamakāvatāra* systematically elucidates and clarifies Nāgārjuna's terse and profound *Mūlamadhyamakakārikā*.
478
What is the meaning of "irreversible" (avaivartika) for a bodhisattva on the first bhūmi?
Once a bodhisattva directly perceives emptiness on the path of seeing, they are guaranteed to reach full enlightenment.
479
What is the *analogy of space* to illustrate emptiness?
Space is not a concrete entity, yet it allows for the existence and movement of all phenomena, similar to how emptiness is the lack of inherent existence, yet allows for dependent phenomena.
480
What is the Mādhyamaka view on the *nature of the self* (ātman)?
The self is merely a designation on the aggregates (body, mind, etc.) and lacks any inherent, independent existence.
481
How does the Mādhyamaka philosophy support the practice of *bodhicitta*?
By revealing that suffering beings lack inherent existence, which deepens compassion and prevents discouragement, as liberation is possible.
482
What is the *Prāsaṅgika* argument against a *self-sufficient
substantially existent self*?,Analyzing the self as separate from or identical to the aggregates shows it cannot be found, proving its lack of inherent existence.
483
What is the *importance of studying the commentaries* (like Ju Mipham's) for texts like the *Madhyamakāvatāra*?
Commentaries provide essential context, clarify difficult points, and elaborate on the subtle nuances of the root text, making it understandable for practitioners.
484
What is the ultimate benefit of internalizing the Mādhyamaka view of emptiness?
It leads to the eradication of all mental afflictions and the full development of wisdom and compassion, culminating in Buddhahood.
485
What is the 'object of negation' in Madhyamaka philosophy
and why is it crucial to identify correctly?,"The object of negation is inherent existence (svabhāva), the imagined intrinsic reality of phenomena. Correctly identifying it is crucial to avoid nihilism (negating even conventional existence) or failing to eliminate the root of ignorance.
486
How does the practice of 'great compassion' lead to the generation of bodhicitta?
Great compassion, the heartfelt wish for all beings to be free from suffering, gives rise to the extraordinary intention to personally take responsibility for their liberation, which then culminates in the aspiration for Buddhahood (bodhicitta).
487
According to Nāgārjuna
why is it illogical for 'causes' to produce 'effects' if they inherently exist?, "If causes inherently existed, they would either be identical to their effects (no production) or entirely separate (no causal connection), thus demonstrating their empty and dependent nature.
488
What is the 'perfection of joyous effort' (*vīrya pāramitā*) and its importance on the bodhisattva path?
It is the enthusiastic and sustained exertion in all virtuous activities without discouragement or fatigue, enabling the bodhisattva to persevere through countless difficulties for the sake of sentient beings.
489
How does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the aggregates' (skandhas) in detail?
He analyzes each aggregate (form, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, consciousness) individually, showing that none can inherently exist on its own or as a collection, and thus the self imputed upon them is also empty.
490
What are the 'three types of wisdom' a practitioner cultivates and their progression?
Wisdom from hearing (scriptural study), wisdom from contemplation (intellectual analysis), and wisdom from meditation (direct, non-conceptual realization), progressing from conceptual to experiential.
491
How does the *Ornament of Clear Realization* describe the 'Buddha's omniscience' (*sarvākārajñatā*)?
It is the perfect and simultaneous knowledge of all phenomena, both conventional and ultimate, in all their aspects, attained by a Buddha.
492
What is the ethical implication of 'right mindfulness' (samyak-smṛti) in daily life?
Right mindfulness involves being aware of one's body, feelings, mind, and phenomena, which helps one to avoid unwholesome actions and cultivate virtuous ones.
493
How does Tsongkhapa explain the 'conventional existence' of things like 'chariots' or 'persons'?
He states that they exist merely by conventional designation, imputed upon their parts or aggregates, without possessing any inherent reality from their own side.
494
What is the ultimate benefit of understanding the 'two truths' (conventional and ultimate)?
Understanding the two truths prevents extreme views and provides the correct framework for practicing the path: conventionally, actions have results; ultimately, all phenomena are empty of inherent existence.
495
What is the significance of the 'bodhisattva vow' (*praṇidhāna*) for engaging in the Mahayana path?
Taking the bodhisattva vow is a formal commitment to practice the six perfections and dedicate all efforts to the enlightenment of all sentient beings, providing a powerful structure for the path.
496
How does the 'path of seeing' (*darśana-mārga*) transform a bodhisattva?
On this path, a bodhisattva achieves the first direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness, leading to immense joy and making their return to cyclic existence irreversible.
497
Why does Candrakīrti refute the inherent existence of 'the knower' (pramātṛ) and 'the known' (prameya)?
He demonstrates that neither can inherently exist independently, as they are mutually defined and dependent, thus showing their emptiness.
498
What are the 'four reliances' in the context of Buddhist study?
Rely on the Dharma, not the person; rely on the meaning, not the words; rely on the definitive meaning, not the interpretable meaning; rely on wisdom, not consciousness.
499
How does Nāgārjuna's *Precious Garland* describe the ethical imperative of 'non-lying'?
It stresses the importance of truthful speech, stating that lying causes harm, undermines trust, and leads to negative karmic results, advocating for speech that is honest and beneficial.