Chapter Twenty-two THE CARBOHYDRATE HYPOTHESIS, II: INSULIN Flashcards
What is a common belief about carbohydrates and weight gain?
Carbohydrate is fattening
This belief is widely acknowledged among women.
What role does insulin play in fat formation?
Insulin increases the formation of fat
This has been observed in both dogs and diabetic patients.
Who rejected the idea of an ‘endocrine abnormality’ as a cause of obesity in 1929?
Louis Newburgh
He insisted that all fat people had a perverted appetite.
What was the medical consensus regarding obesity and hormones in 1955?
Obesity was not attributed to endocrine disturbance
This view was held despite the inability to measure relevant hormones accurately.
What did Jean Mayer observe about the role of hormones in obesity?
Hormones may have been eliminated from consideration as a cause of obesity
Evidence continued to show insulin’s effect on hunger and fat deposition.
What is the reasonable position regarding obesity and hormonal influence?
Obesity requires eating more than expended energy
The influence of hormone concentrations is still uncertain.
What is ‘diabetogenous obesity’?
Obesity and diabetes are consequences of the same underlying defects
This concept was proposed by Carl von Noorden.
What is the primary symptom of severe diabetes (Type 1)?
Glycosuria
This occurs when the body cannot utilize blood sugar for energy.
What distinguishes obese patients from those with severe diabetes?
Obese patients can convert blood sugar into fat and store it
They do not excrete sugar in urine as diabetics do.
What did Wilhelm Falta argue about insulin in the treatment of underweight patients?
Insulin governs carbohydrate usage and fat assimilation
He believed a functional pancreas is necessary for fattening.
What was the reported weight gain of patients treated with insulin in the 1930s?
Patients could gain as much as six pounds a week
This was observed with carbohydrate-rich meals.
What was the clinical dilemma faced by diabetics regarding insulin therapy?
Weight gain from insulin therapy leads to reluctance in continuing treatment
Patients often desire to remain lean.
What did James Rosenzweig report about weight gain in insulin-treated patients?
Weight gains of 2.0 to 4.5 kg were reported
This led to increased insulin resistance.
What was the interpretation of insulin’s effect on weight by Louis Newburgh?
Insulin increases weight by lowering blood sugar
This causes patients to overeat to avoid hypoglycemia.
What hypothesis did Denis McGarry propose regarding diabetes and insulin?
Insulin’s primary role may be in fat metabolism, not just glucose metabolism
This challenges traditional views established by Minkowski’s observations.
Fill in the blank: The primary symptom of diabetes is _______.
glycosuria
True or False: Insulin was initially believed to have no role in fattening humans.
True
This belief persisted despite evidence to the contrary.
What did Rony’s review in 1940 question about insulin’s role in obesity?
Whether a latent form of hyperinsulinism exists that promotes fat deposition
This idea remained a working hypothesis without conclusive evidence.
What is produced in the liver from the conversion of fat into ketone bodies?
Acetone
Acetone is a key indicator of fat metabolism and can be detected in the breath.
What was the major conclusion of Banting’s work regarding insulin?
Insulin plays a preeminent role in the control of fat metabolism.
How has diabetes traditionally been perceived?
As a disorder of carbohydrate metabolism.
What was the focus of research on insulin from the 1920s through the 1960s?
Blood sugar regulation.
What erroneous assumption about fat tissue was overturned by research from the 1920s to the 1960s?
That fat tissue is relatively inert.
According to Hilde Bruch, what was the clinical investigators’ attitude towards fat metabolism research?
They were singularly uninterested.