conservatism Flashcards
what is classical liberal attitudes to the state?
state is necessary because it prevents social disorder and the exploration of the disadvantages and vunerable.
however state power is suspect because as human nature is self seeking people could use any position of power to benefit themselves at the expense of others.
the concentration of state power has to be opposed since it encourages people to pursue their own self interest and to use other people for their own ends.
as such limited government has to be established based on consitonalism the separation of powers checks and balances and a bill of rights
devolution and federalism could be used to prevent the concentration of state power.
what is pragmatism?
-does reject theory and ideology in favour of practical experience the approach to society should be flexible. decisions should be made on what works best.
-does also imply a flexible approach to politics in that what is in the best interest of the people, what is acceptable to the public and what would maintain social stability and cohesion.
how did Oakeshott summarise this?
- ‘to be a conservative is to prefer the tried to the untried’.
what is conservative preference for pragmatism strongly linked to?
-strongly linked to the view of human rationality.
would contend that humans do lack the intellectual ability and powers of reasoning to fully comprehend the complex realities of the world.
-conservative tend to dismiss ideas that claim to improve life. pricples such as human rights, classless society and equality are dangerous because they can promote a reordering of society that does lead to a worse rather than better condition.
-conservatives do try to avoid rigid ideological approach to issues, preferring to act in a pragmatic way that does emphasis caution, moderation and a sense of historical continuity..
what do critics say about pragmatism?
-does lack political pricples and encourage politicians to follow rather than lead public opinion.
what do traditional conservatives say about pragmatism?
-traditional conservatives such as thinker burks did argue that cautious pragmatism enables a society to adapt to changing circumstances by introducing moderate changes/reforms rather than reject change completely and risk revolution. A key to this aim is a change to conserve policy is to safeguard the essential features of society such as propoerty, tradition, order and established intuitions such as the monarchy.
Edmund burk did say that it is an essential element in facilitating natural or inevitable change within a society. the type of change should not be opposed as a state without the means of some change is without the means of its conservation. For the state to keep going it would have to adapt to some extent.
-burk view did maintain that it would bring about necessary change peacefully through evolution where the unbending pursuit of revolution or reaction would lead to conflict or chaos.
key features of society such as order propoerty, tradition and established institutions can only be preserved through pragmatic policy that does take into account shifting circumstances and recognise occasions when it is necessary to change to conserve.
what do one nation conservatives say about pragmatism?
-they do say that they hold similar attitudes to social reform. however more recently they have adopted a pragmatic middle way approach to the economy that combines market competition with government regulation.
these conservatives do argue that this moderate economic course promotes growth and social harmony by encouraging wealth creation through private enterprise and generating the funding for state welfare programmes.
what is tradition?
Does refer to the instiions, customs and belief’s of a society that has developed over time. the term does also implies that such practises will be passed on from generation to generation.
according to Chesterton ‘tradition does mean giving votes to the most obscure of all classes, our ancestors. it is the democracy of the dead. tradition does refuse to submit the small and arrogant oligarchy of those who merely happen to be walking about.’
what are the arguments in favour of pragmatism?
human nature, humans lack the intellectual ability to fully understand the complex realities of the world. theories abstract ideas or ideologies do claim that to explain or improve the condition of human life are rejected as potentially destabilising.
society, abstract ideas and pricples such as equality and rights are dangerous as they could lead to radical change (often through revolution) that does produce worse rather than better conditions.
the state a pragmatic approach that emphasise caution, moderation, gradualism and Contuity will introduce necessary change or reform without endangering social cohesion or stability.
the economy, the one nation conservative approach does justify pragmatism by saying that it does promote growth and social stability by creating wealth through the private sector.
what are the arguments in favour of tradition?
human nature, tradition does provide humans who are weak and security seeking with the social framework to make sense of society and their place within it.
society long established intuitions customs and practises give communities and nations a strong sense of identity that encourages social cohesion and security. any attempt to remove the traditional base of society will lead to insecurity and instability.
the state tradition does represent the accumulated wisdom of the past. state intuitions and practises have proved it to be fit for purpose over time examples include the monarchy, consition and the house of lords. should be preserved for the benefit of future generations.
the economy the capitalist market system has endured as an efficient, dynamic and productive form of economic organisation. it should be maintained as long as it does not undermine conservative values.
what do conservative say about tradition?
-some believe it as god given. human that therefore attempt to change these social arrangement are challenging the will of god and are likely to undermine society rather than improve it.
-drawing on edmund bruk , conservatives do maitain that tradition consititues the accumulated wisdom of the past. they have demonstrated their value to earilers societies and showed that they are fi for purpose.
-for this reasons they should be preserved so that current and future generation can also benefit from them. for example the monarchy has prmoted a sense of national unity and pride over the centuaries as seen in 2011 royal wedding.
-tradition does establish a conuity and social stbaility.
what does bruke say to back the argument of tradition?
he did state that society was a partnership not only between those who are living but between those who are living those who are dead and those who are born. each generation had a Solem duty to safeguard and pass on accumulated wisdom of tradition to the next generation.
how can change be justified according to conservatives?
reform or change could only be justified if it evolves naturally in a peaceful, gradual way in order to strengthen existing instions, customs and practises.
conservatives say that by seeking to destroy all traditional political and social isntiions.
the French in 1789 and Bolsheviks were cutting themselves off from their past and paving their way for regimes that were more tyrannical that the one they had toppled.
why do they put forward tradition?
- does provide society and the individual with a strong sense of identity.. long established instions, customs and practises are familiar and provide individuals with sense of belonging to society.
-it does foster social cohesion and security as it does offer humans a reassuring collective sense of who they are and establish ties between people and specific societies.
-any attempt to cut of traditional basis of society will lead to instability, insecurity and anxiety.
conservative opponents of the labour government in late 1990s did argue that devolved assemblies and house of lords reform would undermine the consitional stability of the uk and create a mood of public uncertainty.
what are the conservative view of human imperfection?
-do argue that human are flawed and incapable of reaching a state of perfection.
-conservatism does also stress that human nature is immutable.
-human perfection has to be kept in check due to the human capacity of evil.
conservatives do stress that
-a tough stance on law and order is required
-foreign policy had to be based on national security rather than liberal notion of international co operation and harmony
-human behaviour is competitive, self interest is more powerful than altruism.
for conservatives humans are flawed psychologically, morally, and intellectually.
three aspects of human imperfection
phycological
-an ordered society does provide security, predictability, and stability. liberty bring choice change and uncertainty.
-people need social order rather than liberty
-they need safety and security knowing their place in society
what is the moral aspect of human imperfection?
humans are morally imperfect.
-human nature does account for anti social or criminal behaviour, not social or economic deprivation
-tough law and order system that punished conduct is the only Deterrent capable of taking human moral imperfection
what is the intellectual aspect of human imperfection?
-all humans lack the intellect and power of reasoning to understand a complex world
-conservative reject theories and ideologies that claim to explain or predict the development of human society.
-humans should be pragmatic and rely on history
-humans should draw on history experience to understand their place in the world
-humans do not posses the mental faculties to make sense of a complex world
what is the conservative view of the organic society or state?
-people cannot exist separately from society as a whole or from social groups such as the family or local community.
-society and social groups do provide individuals with a sense of Secuity and purpose and prevent the development of an anomie. which is a condition of instability affecting individuals and societies produced by a breakdown in social standards and values by a lack of purpose or ideals.
-humans accept the duties, responsibilities that go with belonging to a society such as being a caring parent.
what does an organic state or society say it repsents?
- for conservatives it does represent true freedom, a willing acceptance of the value of social obligations and ties. if people did not acknowledge these reasonability’s human society would lack social cohesion and descend into atomism.
what do conservatives endorse?
organsicim, the idea of an organci society or state. this perspective views society as a lving organsim, with all parts working together to ensure that the body does reamin healthy.
what do conservatives endorse?
organismic, the idea of an organic society or state. this perspective views society as a living organism, with all parts working together to ensure that the body does remain healthy.
what do conservative believe underpin the idea of an organic society?
belief in hierarchy and authority. conservatism had traditionally argued that society is naturally hierachal , based on fixed social ranks and inequalities.
individuals vary in terms of their talents, intellect, skills and work rate.
what do conservative say about an organic society inequality?
-they do maintain that however an organic society must rest on inequality, different classes and groups do have to perform specific roles. for example some do have to provide leadership or manage commercial Enteprises.
-it does produce natural inequalities in terms of financial rewards and social status
-it is justified by for example manager and employers enjoy high living standard than their workers but they carry the burden of protecting jobs and economic well being of their workforces.
-it is therefore argued that organic society does encourage paternalism as a mean to ensure social cohesion..