Conversation Questions Flashcards
What were some BC conditions on your project?
Waiver of modification of the Building Code:
Stormwater Soakage System:
The property owner must maintain a stormwater system as per Council guidelines, with Council oversight and the ability to enforce compliance through an encumbrance registered against the land.
The typical one:
Under s.90 of the Act, agents (staff and contractors) authorised by the Building Consent Authority are
entitled at all times during normal working hours or while building work is being done, to inspect the
building work and ensure the provisions endorsed on the building consent are being carried out.
What were the conditions of engagement of the Architect in your project?
Normal as per AAS. Some stages were tbc until revised AAS
150m2 family home
$1.12M Dollars excl gst
18 months
No special conditions
What was the basis of the employment of other consultants in Apple Shed?
Decide who is needed from brief
Seperate consultants.
Non-engagement of planner - working within rules
We noted that from our previous experience the RFQ is reasonable. Stick to the facts
Let clients decide
Discuss the benefits and pitfalls of other strategies? (engagement strategies?)
AAS has a clear Architect role and defines responsibilities of Architect
CCCS has to use appendix to make roles clear
Tell us about copyright in the contract?
AAS VS CCCS
Architect owns copyright and gives the client a license to use if Agreement if followed
What were the roles and responsibillties of the parties in apple shed?
NZRAB terms of engagement
AAS’s scope of services shows responsibility clearly
Tell me about the “As Exisitng” Drawings for Apple Shed
Property file:
Old plans.
“Sunlover Module”
Approved 1978 (permanent homes ltd)
Measurements in feet and inches
Missing council information of the prefab extension
Garage has the most documentation incl RC (2011) - Versatile Buildings
Easements and ROW in the DP
Discuss the process of information gathering including use of specilist consultants?
GIS/Unitary Plan Rules
Branz Maps
Client documents
Brief
LIM
DP
Property File
CCTV
Surveyor
Geotech
Site Visits
Photos and Videos
What was the design development process like?
Design Development followed from sketch design to more and more detail. Once at Developed Design, the design should be mostly resolved including a layer of technical information (e2 risk matrix, g7 etc)
Tell me about the consideration of sustainability in the project?
Both SGA and Client were interested in Sustainable Design.
Mitigation of energy demand through:
Thermal Mass
Shading Devices
Proclima System - internal intelligent air barrier
Ultra-Low Emission Burner
PV system with Tesla Batteries
Water re-use
Were there any special environmental effects you had to consider and weathertighness issues?
High Wind Zone (Risk Matrix)
Flashings to suit
Direct Fix Cladding Okay
Climate Zone 1
Overland Flow paths (no assessment needed due to covenant/easement and stormwater report)
Earthquake zone 1
Corrosion Zone C (to do with Durability) (fasteners etc)
Explain your presentation and client response process
Generally:
a face-to-face meeting
meeting minutes
send presentation over email with minutes
Client email feedback
SGA email response
Request for permission to go to next stage
Feedback captured in next stage
Typically 50% and 100% presentations
50% presentations didn’t occur for Concept and Developed Design for Apple Shed
Preliminary Design Presentations did not occur face-to-face.
Why did you go for the presentation methodology you did?
Two fold:
-For client communication (Renders)
-For us to design precisely (BIM)
Best ways of communication. Some clients have limited technical understanding
Sketch design for speed
Workshop details for clarity
BIM allows us to coordinate with consultants in more efficient manner
Alterative sernarios. What if the clients wanted to push the RC? Bigger building coverage etc
Firstly look at H20 Waitakere Foothills Zone
Activities that do not comply with Standard H20.6.4(1) (300m2 max) are a restricted discretionary activity provided that the total building coverage on the site does
not exceed 25 per cent of the net site area.
Building coverage that exceeds 25% of the site area is NC
Communicate to the client that RC would be needed. Time + cost
Alterative sernarios. What if the clients wanted to operate a small farm, and add a farm building? What about a restaurant?
Farming is a permitted activity
Consider Building Coverage if a Barn is needed
Restaurants are are RD/D
Double Check with Council Planning desk
What does this mean for Building Coverage
Time and Cost added
RC. England Street. What do the new MDRS rules mean for your site?
Because there is a Special Character overlay it most likely will mean MDRS will not apply
Special Character Zones are considered Qualifying Matter
WOULD CHECK WITH COUNCIL AND PLANNER
Have you done a RC from the start before?
Be honest. Limited experience. Amendment done for England Street.
Worked on BCs that needed RC but only worked on BC
Worked partially on RCs
Discuss the process of co-ordinating and checking consultants work
timelines and availability are checked early on when RFQ goes out
Sharing our own timelines
SGA Checklist
Kick-Off meetings if required
sometimes 30,60,90% check-ins
Calls and Email follow-ups
Sketch details and mark-ups
Read all documents from Consultants
Consultants can stamp our drawings (JMA)
All client and consultant correspondence documents are clearly
labeled and stored in the SGA filing system.
Our job is not to supervise other consultants
Discuss the role of other consultants particualrly in generating budgetary information
QS:
Quantity surveyor’s report came back higher than original estimate
Meeting held with clients to discuss higher costs, potential reasons, and value engineering options. (Communication)
Project architect proposed Early Contractor Involvement (ECI) to mitigate unforeseen costs and allow for cost-saving construction methodologies
Some engineering decisions for budget reasons (steel portal removal)
Tell us how the SGA estimate and QS esntimate differed?
QS estimate higher
QS P&G higher
QS estimate had excluded some items as options when compared to SGA estimate
Pool Size difference adds cost compared to SGA estimate
I did a mark-up of QS estimate with DS help
Meeting held with client to discuss
Were there any special or specific conditions in the AAS?
No - no special condiditons
Some stages initially TBC (limited services)
Discuss the properties of the materials selected, details of their use and options for detailing common junctions and penetrations.
Desired aesthetics and preferences from prev stages/brief
Previous projects/precedents.
Sustainability (concrete thermal mass)
Site conditions, durability, maintenance, budget, and client preferences.
LRV
Codemark
Manufacturers, suppliers, and consultants.
Hidden gutter
Direct Fixed
6mm and 4mm shadow lines
E2 details
Discuss the structure of the drawing set
Bigger Scale to Smaller
In Order of Construction
A-00 - Plans
B-00 - Elevations and Sections
C-00 - Scheudles and Specialist Drawings
D-00 - Details
Schedules, stairs, pool and fireplace details are usually in Section C for ease of transfer.
Details in XYZ form
X- Ground/Floor Details
Y - Walls and WIndow details
Z - Roof Details
Sketch some typical details
Fasia with corrugate, window head and jamb