lecture 18 - Using animal models to investigate genetic effects on behaviour Flashcards
(31 cards)
What is an animal model?
‘A living, non-human being used to understand the biological basis of healthy and pathological human phenotypes, and how to alleviate the latter, without the risk of harming
an actual human being during the process’
Criteria for a good animal model
* ‘Face validity’ (i.e. does the model resemble the human phenotype?)
* ‘Construct validity’ (i.e. do the model and the human phenotype share common
biological underpinnings?)
* ‘Predictive validity’ i.e. do therapeutic drugs have same effect in humans and model? Can model be used to screen for new treatments?
Types of animal model - surgical
- Occlusion of middle cerebral artery (stroke)
- Brain lesions
- Gonadectomy
Types of animal model - Administration of chemical or biological agents or radiation
- Metrazol (pentylenetetrazol) administration (epilepsy)
- Immunisation with auto-antigen (autoimmune disorders)
- Administration of pathogenic and non-pathogenic micro-organisms (infectious diseases) (effects of gut
microbiota on brain function) - Neurotransmitter agonists/antagonists or enzyme inhibitors (healthy/pathological behaviours)
Types of animal model - Genetic
- Manipulation of genomic DNA
- Administration of genetic material (to affect transcription/translation, as an experimental tool)
Advantages of using animal models to understand gene (dys)function
- Examine in vivo effects of manipulation on brain function/behaviour (emergent property
of integrated physiological systems) cf. cellular models; similarity of physiology to humans - Accessibility of neural tissue and amenability to procedures that would not be ethical in
humans e.g. interactions between drug administration and genetic lesion - Can be maintained in large colonies
- Good breeders with short generation times
- Experimental control (regulated genetic background, environment)
- Genomes amenable to genetic manipulation; similarity with human genome
- Wide repertoire of sophisticated behaviours
Disadvantages of (genetic) animal models
- Genetic and physiological divergence from humans
- Different evolutionary histories (e.g. sensory modalities, social groupings)
- Limited range of genetic modifications possible - now there are more technologies
- Relevance to complex human behaviours influenced by combined effects of many genes –
endophenotypes! Hard to look at age-related diseases e.g. AD or HD - Ethical issues regarding possible adverse effects (e.g. ‘psychiatric’ phenotypes)
- Inability to accurately model human-specific phenotypes e.g. language, psychosis
- Models rarely have true face, construct and predictive validity
Commonly used genetic animal models
- GM non-human primates are very rarely used for research,
but do exist (rhesus monkey ANDi, GFP transgene)
Chan et al. (2001) Science 291:309-12 - Caenorhabditis elegans (nematode worm)
- Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly)
- Danio rerio (zebrafish)
- Prairie (monogamous) and meadow (promiscuous) voles
- Mus musculus (and other mouse sub-species)
- Rattus norvegicus (rat)
C. elegans
- Molecular and developmental characterisation by Brenner (early 1970s); first multicellular organism to have its genome sequenced
- Well-defined developmental fate for every cell (1031 in adult male); transparent
- Simplest organism with a nervous system (302 neurons); ‘connectome’ characterised
- Many strains with defined genetic mutations; can be frozen and thawed for storage and transport
- Can be exposed to double-stranded RNAi (infusion, injection or through bacterial ingestion) to disable individual genes
- Can be administered drugs readily
- Exhibits chemotaxis, thermotaxis, learning and memory, mating behaviours
- Can be used to study complex processes e.g. nicotine dependence (acute response, tolerance, withdrawal and sensitisation)
D. melanogaster
- Used as a genetic model from early 1900s onwards; genome sequenced and published in 2000
- Have lots of mitochondria for flight - neurodegenerative diseases such as alchzeimers are caused by changes in mitochondria function - can use flies to see how to treat
- Only four pairs of chromosomes (3 autosome pairs, and one sex chromosome pair); used to
study fundamental mechanisms of transcription and translation - Genome can be readily manipulated (since 1987)
- Morphology (including ‘nervous system’) easily identifiable
- Used as a genetic model for neurodegenerative
disorders (PD, AD, HD) and effects of oxidative
stress/ageing - Also used to examine genetics of circadian rhythm,
sensory function, locomotor activity, courtship, pain,
and learning and memory
Zebrafish
- Used as a lab model from 1960s onwards; reference genome sequence published in 2013
- Genome can be readily manipulated
- Expression of specific genes can be acutely altered through use of ‘morpholino antisense oligonucleotides’
(bind to mRNA sequences and prevent translation to protein) - Embryos large, robust, transparent and able to develop outside of the mother
- Well-characterised, easily observable and testable range of (developmental) behaviours
- Diurnal sleep cycle
- Anxiety-related and exploratory behaviours
- Chemosensory behaviours
- Response choice and inhibition
- Social behaviours
- Cognitive and executive functions
- Similar response to mammals in toxicity testing – utility for high-throughput screening of novel therapeutics?
three- choice serial reaction time task for zebrafish - Parker et al
Rodents (mice and rats)
- Mice used as lab models since 16th Century by, inter alia, Harvey, Hooke, Priestley and Mendel; rats used as
models from early 1800s – first animal domesticated for purely scientific reasons - Mouse (C57BL/6 strain) genome sequenced and published in 2002 (second mammalian genome after
human); rat genome sequenced and published in 2004 - Mouse genome readily manipulated; rat genome less so, until recently (see later)
- Mammals, therefore high degree of genetic and physiological homology with humans
- Range of sophisticated behavioural phenotypes; can examine genetic effects on:
- Courtship and mating behaviours
- Dam-pup interactions
- Social behaviours
- Circadian rhythms
- Motor function
- Anxiety-related and exploratory behaviours
- Cognition and executive function
Genetic rodent models
The rodent genome may be modified in a number of ways to assess effects on brain and behaviour:
* Selective breeding (inbreeding/outbreeding)
* Gene ‘knockout’
* Transgenesis and ‘knock-in’
* Mutagenesis using chemicals or radioactivity
* Chromosomal mutations
selective breeding
Inbreeding (mainly mice): Selected members of a founder strain are repeatedly inbred over many generations to
(theoretically) ensure genetic homogeneity (→ less phenotypic variability, can dissociate genetic vs. environment
influences)
Commonly used inbred strains include C57BL/6, BALB/c, 129 and BTBR (autism), and Spontaneously Hypertensive
Rat (ADHD); inbred strains can differ significantly in appearance and behaviour (polymorphisms)
Outbreeding: Members of a founder strain are bred to unrelated individuals to ensure genetic heterogeneity
(→ more phenotypic variability (more like humans?), ‘hybrid vigour’)
Commonly used outbred strains include CD-1, MF1, Swiss-Webster (mice) and Lister Hooded, Long-Evans,
Sprague Dawley and Wistar (rats)
recombinant inbred strains
crosses between phenotypically-distinct inbred strains for several generations can
help identify regions of the genome affecting behaviour
Highly active Moderately active
* Examine activity phenotype for
hundreds of individual animals
* Examine origin of genetic material
at multiple genomic sites for all
animals
* Correlate the two to see which
genetic sites seem to influence the
behaviour most
less black = less active
genetic diagram in notes
Gene knockout: removal of gene function
Prof Sir Martin Evans (Cardiff University), Nobel Prize 2007
Genetic insert can be designed so that ‘knockout’ only occurs at certain developmental stages
or in certain tissues → ‘conditional knockout’
put genetically modified cell from C57BL6 mouse into blastocyst of another mouse - white fur
In some mice genetic change is passed into sperm or egg and then offspring so then offspring have genetic change in one of each pair of chromosome = hetereozygous then breed to together so have genetic change in all chromosome
Transgenesis
Function is to either: a) insert exogenous sequence into genome (e.g. gene from one species into another) or b)
to have more copies (i.e. higher expression) of a particular gene than normal
* Pronuclear injection of DNA sequence of interest; lack of specificity re target and copy number
Lots of control manipulations needed to work out where gene is inserted and what it is effecting
‘Knock-in’
- Delete target gene
- Insert altered version of the gene
containing mutation of interest
‘Knock-in’
These are genotype driven approaches
Mutagenesis using chemicals (‘phenotype-driven approach’)
Wildtype male mice treated with mutagen
e.g. N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) →
~1000 random mutations in genome;
breed to wildtype female mice
* Identify any progeny mice with interesting phenotypes and select for breeding
* Over several generations, selectively breed mice showing phenotype of interest
* Eventually, all phenotypically interesting descendants will theoretically possess just one point mutation
which is associated with the phenotype of interest; this can then be identified by genome sequencing
Where you look at behaviour and work out what caused it
New technologies
Custom-made genetically-altered animals can be readily easily and cheaply generated using new technologies
which selectively edit chosen parts of the genome
Zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs): ‘molecular scissors’ (Guerts et al. (2009) Science 325:433)
CRISPR (Clustered Regularly-Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats):
RNA-guided genome-editing tool based around the components of the prokaryotic immune system (Guan et al.
(2014) Methods Enzymology 546:297-317)
Potential ethical
issues re humans?
fragile X syndrome
caused by a genetic change in a gene on the X chromosome called FMR1 and the genetic change is the repeat of this cgg sequence so you get lots of CGGs repeating which causes the gene to become dysfunctional as this gene sequence is extensively methylated
animal models have should you can use crispr technology to get rid of the extensive silencing and can restore gene function that is typically lost
that might have clinical benefits in terms of treatment of fragile X
Chromosomal mutations
- Occasionally, spontaneous chromosomal mutations may occur in rodents (e.g. due to impaired segregation of
the chromosomes at meiosis); rates may be increased by mutagens e.g. radioactivity - Some of these animals may be fertile and can be bred from e.g. 39,XY*O mouse - mutant mice where the x chromosome and the y chromosome have become stuck together which causes a deletion of the STS gene - this may predispose to ADHD - to test this looked at activity across 24 hours in these mutant mice compared to normal male mice - found mutant mice tend to be more active during the night which is mirroring one aspect of ADHD some degree of face validity
Trent et al. (2012) Psychoneuroendocrinology 37:221-9
constraint validity in the deletion of STS in humans is associated with the conditions called X-linked theosis associated with an increased risk or likelihood of being diagnosed with ADHD
then went on to test mice in the mouse version of the zebrafish behaviour test - test of attention so in mice its the five time serial reaction time task. a light flashes on briefly and mice have to poke the light when it appears, if they respond correctly they a condensed milk award. you can alter the attentional demands of the task by varying the duration for the light stimulus is presented - it was varied from 0.7 seconds to 0.1 seconds. you look at the number of time that the mice missed the stimulus. the chromosomal mutant mice tended to miss the stimulus more under the most attentionally demanding conditions when the light flashed on for 0.1 seconds.
these mice seem to be hyperactive, inattentive so may be a viable model for understanding the neurobiology of ADHD. chromosomal mutant mice can slo be used to study human chromosomal conditions like down syndrome
mouse model for Down syndrome (trisomy 21) (O’Doherty et al. (2005) Science 309:2033-2037)
In humans down syndrome is caused by having 3 copies of chromosome 21 rather than the usual 2
in this Tc1 (‘transchromosomic 1’) model, mice have a human chromosome 21 (inserted at ES cell stage) in
addition to their own set of chromosomes
* These mice exhibit phenotypes relevant to DS including altered:
* behaviour
* synaptic plasticity
* cerebellar morphology
* heart development
* mandible size
- Model may now be used to investigate molecular
pathways resulting in DS→ potential therapeutic
approaches e.g. ‘inactivation’ of additional
chromosome (Jiang et al. (2013) Nature 500:296-
300) - Overlap between DS and AD → common
underlying mechanisms?
can use it to explore new clinical approaches
individuals with DS have massively increased likelihood of getting early onset dementia - in chromosome 21 gene called APP and if DS you overexpress the APP gene which might make it more available for abnormal processing so increases risk of alzheimers
using the animal model we can look at the relationship between DS and vulnerability to early onset alzheimers disease
Administration of molecules affecting gene/protein expression
‘Transient gene knockdown’ to characterise function of poorly-annotated gene
* Molecules (e.g. antisense oligonucleotides, short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) or morpholinos) introduced into
the brain (directly or via viruses) to inhibit transcription/translation of a specific gene
* Issues with poor permeability/diffusivity in adult brain but technique is routinely done in utero
Zhang et al. (2013) The X-linked intellectual
disability protein PHF6 associates with the PAF1 complex and
regulates neuronal migration in the mammalian brain Neuron
78(6):986-93
* Drugs altering epigenome e.g. sodium butyrate
you can take a pregnant mouse and give it a C-section and full out its womb and the lumps are the pups typically get 6 or 7 and you induce a little electrical charge across the head of each these mice, inject a particle genetic construct which inhibits the functions of a particular protein in the brain of that animal. once you have done that it inhibits the function of this protein transiently you then put the womb back into the mum. let her give birth normally let the pups grow up and behaviourally test the pups when their adults and you can look to see whether this transient disruption of expression to proteins which you think might be important in brain development in these mice has impacted upon their later behaviour and later brain structure. these techniques are used to study genes that are associated with neurodevelopmental conditions such as ADHD, autism, intellectual disability. we can see whether those particular genes, those particular proteins are important in early prenatal Brain development and whether they are associated with similar types of phenotypes when these pups group up and become adults.