Post 1867 Flashcards
(226 cards)
Is Canada a Nation?
- Made non-emotionally
- Some think if we come together then probelms solved.
Initial Problems?
- Different identities: culture, class religion, language.
- How to preserve these and create unified country?
Confederation was a Political Event
- Not all recognized confederation
- Not all affected initially
- 1867 some would view as year they lost crops, not confederation year.
- People were not more political than they are now.
Lord Monck
- 1st GG congrats Canada parliament on laying foundation for new nationality
- July 1st - NS, NB, QB, and ON
- PEI and NFL did not want to join - less to gain.
How to Est. Domestic Peace?
- State confederation was political and would not touch your identity.
George Cartier (Canada East premier)
Statement
- Tried convincing French folks they would not lose their independence
- “now when we were united together, if union was obtained, we would form a political nationality with which neither the national origin or the religion of any individual would interfere”.
George Cartier Cont.
- Meaning
- We are not coming together because of ethnicity or geographical location, but because we choose to come together and have a shared loyalty to certain institutions.
Nationhood
- Did not mean independence (not a revolution)
- Canada still a colony, but a big one called a dominion
- Had more power for internal issues, but British parliament controlled external issues.
Views on being British Subjects
- Some ok with it as it made them feel part of something meaningful/powerful and not a small country.
- Alternatives were not great: Not big or strong and annexation issues.
1867 - Anti-Americanism
- Many believed to be different and superior to Americans
- USA politics inferior
- Uncomfortable with Republicanism and democracy.
- USA is a dangerous neighbor
Canada/USA Connections
- Dispite views we had strong connections
- Main trade partners
- Cultural similarities
- Constitution similar: federal system with provinces
- So complicated relationship become a theme.
Confederation an On-Going Process
- Started July 1st 1867 with plan to keep going
- 1870 - Manitoba joined
- 1871 - BC joined
- 1873 - PEI joined
- So continued to grow rapidly.
Confederation - Gov’t Parties
- Needed new federal gov’t and parties
- Parties of colonies came together to form federal parties. Difficult due to different views.
- Blue parties became conservatives and red parties liberal
Party Ideological Differences
- Fed vs. Prov Power
- Tariffs
- First 30 yrs cons about federal power and libs about provincial rights.
- Economics: Cons wanted protective tariffs and libs wanted free market.
- These views all change over time.
Population overview at Confederation
- 3.2 million
- 4/5 born here, but depended on area
- Quebec 10/11 people born here
- Ontario 1 in 3
Polulation Con’t
- FN
FN - 30,000 = 1%
- Kept seperate from people
-Sect. 91 of BNA created seperate lands and placed gov’t as responsible for them.
- Not included in confederation debates
- White people knew nothing about them and thought they were dying out - disease and assimulation.
Population Con’t
- French Canadians
- 1/3 of population until 1960s
- 80% lived in Quebec
- 10% in Nova Scotia and New Brunswick
- English and French Canadians did not interact in mid 19th century
Population Con’t
- British
- Northern/Western
- 60% of population
- Some been here a while and decsendants of loyalists
- Recent immigrants
- North/West Mixed and made up 10% of pop.
Population Con’t
-Africans
- Some from loyalists who fought in American Revolution
- Promised to live freely
- Some came escaping from USA slavery
- Many in NS
- Lots of racial predjudice - voting, schooling, etc.
Other Divisions
- Gender
- Different roles -Women at home
- Women roughly 50% of population
- women lacked basic rights
- Lacked all rights after marriage as legally one
- Focus on families and not individuals at the time
Other Divisons
- Religion
- Mostly Christian
- Most Catholic
- Religious differences affected politics
- E.g. Schools - Religious or not?
- E.g. Hospitals ran by churches
Other Divisons
- Location
- Lots of rural living
- Few cities
- Railway connected people and good for trading and settleing
- Historiography
- ## How historians have approached different ideas differently at different times. E.g. WWI viewed then vs. now.
What did confederation mean?
- Different interpretations
- Read differently based on contemporary issues facing people
- Look at the past differently based on what is happening presently.