Social Cognition Flashcards
Lectures 7, 8, and 9 (78 cards)
social cognition
- How we process social beings and social interactions
- How this differs from other things
- How human behavior involves mental state and is unique to how we think about people
theory of mind
the ability to think about mental states in ourselves and others; understanding that mental states influence behavior
theory of mind: critical aspects
must understand that:
○ People have mental states
○ Other people have mental states that are diff from our own
○ Mental states guide behavior (regardless of if those mental states are accurate)
§ They don’t need to be accurate to guide our behavior
False Belief: Sally-Anne Task
- Sally and Anne are friends! Sally has a basket and Anne has a box
- Sally puts her marble in her basket and walks away
- Anne takes the marble out of the basket and puts it in her box
- When Sally comes back, where will she look for her marble?
Children who don’t understand theory of mind assume that Sally will look for the marble in Anne’s box
False Belief: Smarties task
- A child will be presented with a box with a “Smarties” on the outside
- When they open the box, something that is not Smarties (maybe pencils) will be inside
- When asking children what their friends will think is in the box, they will think it’s pencils
theory of mind: age results
- children under 4 “fail” on traditional false belief tasks (no more than 25% 3 y/o in most countries were passing this test)
- children 4-5+ “pass” traditional false belief tasks
- Finding seems to be consistent across societies and cultures
- Developmental trend is strikingly consistent
theory of mind: controversy
what explains this development in theory of mind?
- Led to high debate of what explains this development to the false beliefs task
theory of mind development
changes in conceptual abilities to reason about mental states; children are changing the concept of other people’s minds and mental concepts
- “Theory” theory
- Modular theory
“Theory” theory
change in ways of thinking about mental states
- As kids develop, they change up their theories of theory of mind/mental state
§ What shifts is their intuition and move away from naive theories of mind
@ age 2: kids have theories that people have desires and desires guide behavior
@ age 3: kids shift their theories and change it up to now think that people have desires AND people have beliefs
@ age 4: kids shift their theories that people can have false beliefs
○ The qualitative shifts about people’s mental states
Modular theory
brain maturation
- all of us have an innate module for thinking about mental states
- What changes from 3 and 5 is brain maturation
- Good evidence that particular areas of the brain that are activated when we do this kind of thinking
○ areas become increasingly advanced and activated
○ allows us to conceptualize mental states and false beliefs
theory of mind development: changes in proccessing?
- younger children not able to pass false-belief tasks because they have difficulty with the processing demands of the task
- tasks too hard?
what’s required for Sally-Anne task (theory of mind development)
- Be able to speak
- Hold several concepts at the same time
- Memory capabilities
- Demands of keeping track of multiple things at the same time
- Prediction: need to be able to predict into the future, not just react to something
false belief: recent findings
Kids show the ability to reason about false beliefs earlier in development
- When we eliminate the difficulties of the Sally & Anne task, can children pass the test?
Broccoli and Goldfish experiment (theory of mind)
Most kids go for goldfish
Then: researcher will either say, “mmm, I love goldfish” and “bleh! I hate broccoli!”
○ Mismatch condition “bleh! I hate goldfish” and “mmm, I love broccoli!”
@ 14 months: babies will always share goldfish
@ 18 months: they’ll share what the researcher likes
○ Seem to understand that babies have different mental states from them
○ People can have mental states that are incorrect/inaccurate from their reality
theory of mind in infancy
longer looking times in True Belief and False Belief condition (i.e. putting objects in boxes and moving them)
- When adults do a surprising action, children look longer
theory of mind: task difficulty
- many studies show reasoning about mental states earlier in development
- some evidence infants can succeed in non-verbal false belief tasks
new Sally-Anne task (theory of mind)
- Instead of measuring a verbal response, looking time is measured
@ 15 to 18 months, they seem to respond accordingly
Controversy: is looking time an accurate measure of theory min
theory of mind development: executive function & inhibition?
- having to keep track of both reality and a person’s perception of reality
- having to inhibit your knowledge reality (curse of knowledge)
- an individual has to inhibit their own knowledge + answer from a 3rd party’s perspective
curse of knowledge
when we know something to be true, it’s hard to block that knowledge
- When we know something, it’s hard for us to override that and explain it in a way to those who don’t understand
- In regards to children: it may be difficult for children to eliminate the curse of knowledge
Sally-Anne task: outcome known vs. unknown condition
- When kids know where the ball is, they’re failing the test (curse of knowledge)
- When you eliminate the children’s knowledge, they pass the test
○ When the child doesn’t know where the ball is placed (i.e. they don’t know which box Anne placed the ball in), they will correctly answer and say that Sally will look where she initially placed the ball
Sally-Anne task: outcome known vs. unknown - age range
@ 3 y/o: most fail if outcome known; all succeed if outcome unknown
@ 4 y/o: almost all succeed if outcome known; all succeed if outcome unknown
@ 5 y/o: all succeed if outcome known; all succeed if outcome unknown
theory of mind: individual differences
- # of siblings
- pretend play
- parenting
- language
- autsim
theory of mind: siblings
kids who have more siblings tend to be better at theory of mind task
- More practice of thinking from other people’s perspective
theory of mind: pretend play
kids who engage in more pretend play do better at these tasks
○ When creating a world with other characters, you need to imagine things from different perspectives
○ You’re practicing stepping into other perspectives and minds