📘 Structured Summary: Silke (2009) – “Cheshire-Cat Logic” Flashcards
(31 cards)
What is the main theme of Silke’s 2009 article ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
The article explores the complexities and nuances of reasoning and argumentation.
True or False: ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’ refers to a type of logical reasoning that is straightforward and unambiguous.
False
Fill in the blank: The term ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’ is derived from a character in _________.
Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland
What does the Cheshire Cat symbolize in the context of the article?
Ambiguity and the elusive nature of truth.
Which philosophical concept is closely associated with the themes in ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
Relativism
Multiple Choice: Which of the following best describes ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
A logic that reveals only partial truths.
What does Silke suggest about the nature of arguments in ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
Arguments can be distorted and may not always lead to clear conclusions.
True or False: Silke argues that clarity in reasoning is always achievable.
False
What role does context play in ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
Context significantly influences the interpretation of arguments.
Fill in the blank: According to Silke, the ________ of a statement can change based on its context.
meaning
What is one implication of ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’ for critical thinking?
It emphasizes the need to question and analyze the context of arguments.
Multiple Choice: Which of the following is NOT a characteristic of ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
Absolute certainty
What does Silke identify as a common pitfall in reasoning?
Over-reliance on surface-level clarity.
True or False: The article suggests that all reasoning is inherently flawed.
False
What metaphor does Silke use to illustrate complex reasoning?
The disappearing Cheshire Cat.
Fill in the blank: Silke encourages readers to embrace ________ in their reasoning processes.
ambiguity
What is one suggested strategy for dealing with ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’?
Engage in deeper analysis and questioning of assumptions.
Multiple Choice: Which field does Silke’s analysis primarily relate to?
Philosophy and Logic
What does the article imply about the relationship between logic and language?
Language can obscure or clarify logical reasoning.
True or False: ‘Cheshire-Cat Logic’ advocates for rigid adherence to traditional logical structures.
False
What is a key takeaway from Silke’s article regarding argumentation?
Understanding the fluidity of meaning is crucial for effective argumentation.
Fill in the blank: The article highlights that understanding ________ is essential for navigating complex arguments.
nuance
What does Silke suggest about the role of the audience in interpreting arguments?
The audience’s perspective significantly shapes the interpretation.
Multiple Choice: Which of the following best summarizes Silke’s perspective on reasoning?
It is complex and often ambiguous.
