TOPIC: RESEARCH METHODS Flashcards
(173 cards)
What is laboratory experiment and how can reliability be improved?
Defined by the high level of control the researcher has over all the variables in the study except the independent variable which what you alter to see what the effect is
The reliability of lab experiments can be improved by:
ensuring that all aspects of the procedure are controlled and standardised to test the reliability of the method
ensuring that the IV and DV are operationalised
testing participants using conditions which differ slightly from the original procedure to test the reliability of a specific finding
What are the pros and cons of laboratory experiments?
PROS:
- Control - the effects of confounding variables of interest are minimised
- Replication - strict controls mean you can run the study again to check the findings
CONS:
- May lack ecological validity ( experiments might not measure real-life behaviour )
- Demand characteristics - participants may respond according to what they think is being investigated = bias
- Ethics - deception is often used, making informed consent difficult
What is field experiments?
These are conducted outside of the laboratory
Behaviour is measured in a natural environment
Where the researcher manipulates the IV and records the effects of the DV
What are the pros and cons of field experiments ?
PROS:
- High ecological validity, so they can realte to real life better
- Demand characteristics - can be avoided if participants don’t know they’re in a study
CONS:
- Less control - confounding varaibles may be more likely in a natural environment
- Ethics - Participants who didn’t agree to take part might experience distress and often can’t be debriefed. Observation must respect privacy
What is a natural experiment ?
Looks how an independent variable, which isn’t manipulated by the researcher affects the dependent variable
What are the pros and cons of natural experiments ?
PROS:
- Ethical - possible to study variables that wouldn’t be ethical to manipulate
- Demand characteristics - They don’t know they are in the study»_space; so acts more natural
- High ecological validity
CONS:
- Ethics - deception is often used, making informed consent difficult
- Can’t be replicated exactly to test for reliability
What is the quasi experiment ?
Where the researcher isn’t able to use random allocation to put partcipants in and the naturally occurring IV is a difference between people that already exists (i.e. gender, age). The researcher examines the effect of this variable on the dependent variable (DV).
e.g. gender or the existence of a mental disorder
What is the pros and cons of quasi experiments ?
PROS:
- Control - often under controlled conditions
- High ecological validity
CONS:
- Participant allocation - can’t randomly allocate participants to each condition, and so confounding results may affect results
» hard to say what’s caused by what as you have no control over these variables
- Casual relationships - hard to establish cause and effect because the independent variable isn’t being directly manipulated
SELF REPORT:
What are questionnairs and how can reliability be improved ?
A set of written questions that can be answered easily»_space; useful in gathering information from large number of people
The reliability of questionnaires can be improved by
running the test-retest method and excluding any questions which do not show consistency
running the split-half method and excluding any whole questionnaires that do not show consistency
What are closed questions ?
Where there is a pre-determined set of answers to choose from
Produce quantitative data
e.g. Do you exercise ? Yes/No
What are open questions ?
Where there are no restrictions on how participants make their response
Produces qualitative data
e.g. How does the sight of seeing dogs in a public place without a lead make you feel
What are the pros and cons of open questions ?
PROS:
- Qualitative data ( descriptive )
- Very rich in detail
CONS:
- No fixed range
- Can answer in any way
What are the pros and cons of closed questions ?
PROS:
- Produces both quantitative and qualitative data
CONS:
- Fixed number of responses
What are the types of closed questions ? ( Give detail )
Likert Scale - Their agreement or disagreement with a statement using a scale of usually five or seven points. Produce ordinal data
Rating scale - A value that represents their strength of feeling about a particular topic. Produce ordinal data
Fixed choice options - A list of possible answers and the respondent has to indiacte which applies to them. Produce norminal data
What are the things to consider when designing a questionnair ?
- Length
- Pilot study
- Question order
- Terminology
- Ethical issues
What the pros and cons of self-reports ?
PROS:
- Cost effective
- Easy to analyse
- Can collect large amounts of data
- Convient to carry out
CONS:
- Social desirability bias
- Response bias
- Low response rate
- Acquiescene bias
What are unstructured and structured interviews ?
Unstructured - Can be formal or informal with no set questions and the interviewee is encouraged to expand on their answers
Structured interviews - Comes with pre-determined which are asked in a set order
What are things to consider part of the interview design?
- Gender and age
- Personal characteristics
- Ethnicity
- You develop an interview schedule, or a list of questions you intend to cover»_space; this should be standardised to avoid interviewer bias
- They should be reminded that that the information will be kept confidential ( especially sensitive issues )
- They should be aware that they can leave at any time
What are the pros and cons of interviews ?
PROS:
- More detailed information can be gathered than by a questionnaire
- Flexibility - Can tailor questions to the response of an interviewee so that issues can be explored in depth
- Unstructure are more fexible as points can be followed up on
- The person being interviewed can ask for clarification if they don’t understand a question
- Structured interviews are easy to replicate due to standardised form so can check reliability easily
CONS:
- Senstive topics - the interviewer can explore complex issues that maybe difficult to study any other way
- Training - Interviewers often need to be trained. Can take time and money
- People may be embarrased to speak face to face to someone
- It is harder to analyse unstructure data compared to structured so drawing conclusions can be difficult
- Time and effort - needed by the person being interviewed
CORRELATIONS:
What is a correlation and what are the different types?
- A correlation checks to see if two sets of numbers are related
- In psych = the numbers being analysed in relation to behaviour
- Positive correlation - where they both coordinate and rise
- Negative correlation - where one variable rises other falls
- Zero correlation - no relationship between co-variables
CORRELATIONS:
What is the difference between correlations and experiments?
- The most fundamental difference between experiments and correlations is that experiments assess the effect of one variable, (I.V.) on another variable which is measured (D.V.)
- Correlations assess how much of a relationship exists between two co-occurring variables which are related.
CORRELATIONS:
What are the pros and cons of correlations ?
PROS:
- Useful as a preliminary research technique, allowing researchers to identify a link that can be further investigated through more controlled research.
- Can be used to research topics that are sensitive/ otherwise would be unethical, as no deliberate manipulation of variables is required
CONS:
- Only identify a link; they do not identify which variable causes which. There might be a third variable present which is influencing one of the co-variables, which is not considered.
E.g. stress might lead to smoking/ alcohol intake which leads to illness, so there is an indirect relationship between stress and illness
CASE STUDIES:
What is a case studies ?
A case study is a method involving the detailed study of one individual, institution or event. They provide rich information about that particular individual.
Data = qualitative but can be quantitative
Data = primary or secondary
Case studies usually take place over a long period of time
CASE STUDIES:
What are the pros and cons of case studies?
PROS:
- Data gathered is detailed and in-depth so more valid conclusions can be drawn
- Can be used to investigate rare behaviour or behaviour that can’t be studied an other way as it would be unethical to do so
CONS:
- Can be time consuming and it can be years before conclusions can be drawn
- Sample is limited and not representative of wider population. Difficult to generalise results from the individual as each case is unique
- Important ethical issues regarding privacy and confidentiality - which is why initials are often used. Also, psychological harm can be caused by repeated testing over decades as in the case of HM