7. + 8. Social Influence Flashcards
(35 cards)
Milgram investigated o____
Obedience
__ volts point in Milgram’s experiment is often referred to as the big dramatic point of the experiment - the learner has e____ asked to l____
150 v
explicitly asked to leave
At __ volts, th learner indicates that they will no longer p____ a____ (Milgram). After this point there is n____ r____ from the learner
300 v
provide answers
no response
Four experimenter prods in Milgram are:
1. Please c____, or, please g____ o____
2. The experiment r____ that you c____
3. It is a____ e____ that you c____
4. You have no o____ c____, you m____ go on
- continue, go on
- requires, continue
- absolutely essential, continue
- other choice, must
In the voice feedback condition of Milgram, the mean level of shock applied was 24.53 (1 = 15v, 30 = 450 v). What level did the following predict people would stop at?
1. Psychiatrist predictions
2. College student predictions
3. Middle class adult predictions
- 8
- 9.35
- 9.35 (just under I think by graph)
In Burger (2009) modern replication of Milgram’s study, p____ predicted when people needed the p____, but not overall c____. Similar findings were found to the original in this more e____ version.
personality, prods, compliance
ethical
In Milgram’s original experiment, about __% of pts in the voice-feedback condition go to 450v
65%
People u____ how much others will shock in the Milgram paradigm
underestimate
Milgram’s s____ perspective on his results refer to the a____ s____
Situationist, agentic shift
Haslam et al. (2014) meta-analysis of all Milgram’s conditions found v____ v____ of obedience rates between conditions - __% obedience rates to __% obedience rates.
vast variation
10% - 90%
Milgram wasn’t very s____ - he didn’t hold c____ certain elements while c____ only o____. Therefore hard to tell which precise elements of the situation actually have an influence on obedience rates
systematic, constant, changing, one
Reicher an Haslam (2012) criticisms of Milgram:
1. Milgram d____ obedience, but doesn’t e____ it
2. It’s not just about a____, people are very responsive to o____ v____
3. They frame these variations in terms of s____ d____, or r____
4. How e____ can we investigate obedience/disobedience… in the r____ w____
- describes explain
- authority, other voices
- social distance, relationships
- else, real world
Muzafer S____ (1936) a____-k____ effect was early work on s____ i____. It utilises an o____ i____ to assess group n____ f____ and t____
Sherif, auto-kinetic
social influence
optical illusion, norm formation, transmission
In Sherif’s condition A, pts started a____, then move to g____. In condition B, pts start in g____, then move to a____
alone, group, group, alone
Asch’s perspective on social psychology emphasises the importance of s____ r____ and s____ l____ for social interaction. His experiments show what happens when that is v____ - people try to r____ a s____ r____ and feel really s____ about it
shared reality, shared logic
violated, renegotiate, shared reality, stressed
When group size is 1, conformity rate is __%
When group size is 2, conformity rate is __%
From group sizes 3 - 7, conformity is in the __%s
3%
12%
30%s
(Asch) in the consensus condition, conformity rates were __2%, with 2 true pts conformity rates were __0.4% and with one true pts and one confederate who also dissents conformity rates were __.5%. This shows that as soon as consensus is b____, conformity drops c____
32%, 10.4%, 5.5%
As soon as consensus is broken, conformity drops considerably
In Asch’s conformity studies, __% of pts conformed __ times:
1. 0 = __4%
2. 1-3 = __3%
3. 4-6 = __4%
4. 7-9 = __8%
5. 10-12 = __1%
- 24%
- 33
- 14
- 18
- 11
Giving in to the majority isn’t ‘m____’ - it involves showing m____ and c____ to those around you
mindless
mindfulness and consideration
Qualitative findings from Asch’s studies suggest people were trying to make s____ of a w____ s____ - not just b____ f____. Also, there was nothing to l____ by conforming in this setting. E____ conformity is not a clearcut as this. People may conform because of differences in o____ over differences of r____.
sense, weird situation, blindly following
lose, everyday, opinion, reality
The Social comparison theory (Festinger, 1954) has ideas about why we are influenced by groups:
1. I____ d____ to know o____
2. Opinions are ‘v____’ when we discover a____ with others
3. O____ sources are not always available so we turn to s____ sources
4. D____ implies u____ and is t____
5. Other group members are an important source of s____ c____, hence p____ to u____ in groups
- Intrinsic desire, ourselves
- validated, agreement
- Objective, social
- Disagreement, uncertainty, threatening
- social comparisons, pressures, uniformity
The social comparison theory states that we are influenced by groups in two situations:
1. Group c____ - the more i____ a group is to us, the s____ pressures to uniformity, clear group g____ usually increase cohesion
2. S____ a____ - the more u____ or a____ the situation, the greater the r____ on others and hence the greater the conformity
- Group cohesion, important, stronger, goals
- Situational ambiguity, uncertain, ambiguous, reliance
According to Deutsch and Gerard (1955), we are influenced by groups for two different reasons:
1. N____ influence - wanting to be l____
2. I____ influence - wanting to be r____
Cialdini and Goldstein (2004) refer to these as a____ and a____ goals – which then also act to support a third underlying motivation of m____ a p____ s____-c____: Self-esteem protection and self-categorisation
- Normative, liked
- Informational, right
Cialdini and Goldstein (2004) refer to these as accuracy and affiliation goals – which then also act to support a third underlying motivation of maintaining a positive self-concept: Self-esteem protection and self-categorisation.
Deutsch and Gerard (1955) found:
1. Normative influence r____ when response more d____ from the s____
2. Increased d____ in the task results in i____ c____
3. N____ influence stronger when in a ‘r____’ group
4. M____ sources of n____ influence
- reduced, distant, self
- doubt, increased conformity
- Normative, ‘real’
- multiple, normative