Complex Case Simulation Questions Flashcards
(210 cards)
Q1: A psychologist is asked to assess an Aboriginal teenager in a juvenile justice facility. The referrer wants a cognitive score for court use. The young person avoids eye contact and gives short answers. What is the psychologist’s most ethical course of action?
a) Proceed with testing to meet the referrer’s legal deadline
b) Use the test but annotate that rapport was difficult
c) Delay testing to build trust and explore cultural safety
d) Substitute a behavioural checklist for cognitive testing
c) Delay testing to build trust and explore cultural safety
Rationale: Testing without appropriate rapport and cultural attunement undermines validity and ethical practice.
Source: [Week 4 Lecture Transcript - 00:15:40], [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 2]
Q2: A psychologist receives a referral to assess a refugee client’s parenting capacity. The psychologist realises the available tool is normed only on English-speaking populations. What should they do?
a) Use the tool and adjust scores manually for cultural context
b) Proceed with testing, noting the tool’s limitations
c) Refuse the referral due to ethical limitations
d) Seek consultation and explore alternative tools or qualitative data
d) Seek consultation and explore alternative tools or qualitative data
Rationale: Using non-validated tools without adaptation or consultation risks unethical misinterpretation.
Source: [Wright, 2021 - Ch. 3], [Fernández & Abe, 2020]
Q3: In a multidisciplinary team, a social worker insists on a behavioural diagnosis for a child. The psychologist has not observed the behaviours and lacks supporting test data. What is the most ethical action?
a) Defer to the team to maintain cohesion
b) Make a provisional diagnosis based on report
c) Decline to diagnose until further evidence is gathered
d) Record the social worker’s view as the working diagnosis
c) Decline to diagnose until further evidence is gathered
Rationale: Ethical practice requires conclusions to be evidence-based, even within team settings.
Source: [Lecture 2 - MDT Communication], [APS Code - C.2.3]
Q4: A psychologist uses an AI-generated summary for a child assessment report. They carefully edit the grammar but do not mention the use of AI in the documentation. What ethical principle is at risk?
a) Non-maleficence
b) Fidelity
c) Informed consent and transparency
d) Dual relationships
c) Informed consent and transparency
Rationale: Clients and recipients must be informed about how reports are produced, including non-human input.
Source: [Week 7 Reading - AI Ethics in Clinical Practice]
Q5: A psychologist’s report describes a parent as having “low empathy” and “poor relational capacity” based on a structured interview. The parent later says they felt attacked and misunderstood. What could have improved ethical communication?
a) Using more technical diagnostic language
b) Writing in third-person to reduce directness
c) Framing results in strengths-based, culturally aware language
d) Adding disclaimers to the report
c) Framing results in strengths-based, culturally aware language
Rationale: Report language must balance clinical accuracy with compassion and cultural respect.
Source: [Lecture 8 - Report Writing], [APS Code C.2.2]
Q6: A student psychologist is asked to complete a risk assessment on a client who discloses recent suicidality. They feel uncertain but do not want to appear incompetent. What is the most appropriate course of action?
a) Attempt the assessment and check with supervisor after
b) Defer responsibility to a senior team member
c) Immediately seek supervision and co-assess if needed
d) Follow an online risk template to ensure consistency
c) Immediately seek supervision and co-assess if needed
Rationale: Ethical competence requires knowing one’s limits and prioritising client safety.
Source: [APS Code - B.1.2], [Lecture 7 - Managing Risk]
Q7: A psychologist provides a diagnosis in court that was based on one unstructured interview and no psychometric testing. The client later challenges its validity. What is the likely ethical issue?
a) Insufficient clinical note-taking
b) Premature disclosure of private information
c) Failure to base conclusions on adequate evidence
d) Use of outdated diagnostic language
c) Failure to base conclusions on adequate evidence
Rationale: Ethical standards require that interpretations and diagnoses be grounded in reliable and valid sources.
Source: [APS Code - C.2.3], [Wright - Ch. 4]
Q8: A psychologist chooses not to ask a client about spiritual background to avoid seeming intrusive. Later, it emerges that the client’s distress was rooted in spiritual abuse. What is the most appropriate reflection?
a) Spirituality is outside the psychologist’s scope
b) The psychologist followed boundaries and should not feel responsible
c) Cultural and spiritual domains are essential to informed assessment
d) This issue could not have been foreseen
c) Cultural and spiritual domains are essential to informed assessment
Rationale: Avoiding cultural/spiritual context leads to ethical blind spots and limits formulation accuracy.
Source: [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 7], [Lecture 4 - Cultural Assessment]
Q9: A psychologist notices that their emotional detachment has increased over time when working with clients exposed to trauma. What schema mode might be operating?
a) Punitive Parent
b) Detached Protector
c) Vulnerable Child
d) Healthy Adult
b) Detached Protector
Rationale: Emotional withdrawal as a defence is consistent with the Detached Protector schema mode.
Source: [Lecture 11 - Schema Modes], [Wright - Ch. 5]
Q10: During an MDT meeting, a psychologist challenges a decision that they believe is not in the client’s best interest. The team becomes tense. What is the psychologist’s ethical responsibility?
a) Prioritise team harmony and step back
b) Document their dissent but follow the team’s decision
c) Advocate for the client while maintaining professional respect
d) Leave the meeting and report the issue to AHPRA
c) Advocate for the client while maintaining professional respect
Rationale: Ethical practice includes assertive, respectful advocacy in the face of disagreement.
Source: [APS Code - Principle A], [Lecture 2 - Interprofessional Communication]
Q11: A psychologist conducts a standardised parenting capacity interview with a recently arrived refugee mother. The client becomes visibly distressed and repeatedly asks, “Will this make them take my children?” What should the psychologist do?
a) Complete the interview and reassure her afterward
b) Continue while softening the language of questions
c) Pause the interview and clarify the purpose of the assessment
d) Refer the client to a lawyer for clarity on child protection issues
c) Pause the interview and clarify the purpose of the assessment
Rationale: Ethical communication includes ensuring informed consent is maintained throughout the process.
Source: [Lecture 6 - Bias and Misuse of Tools], [APS Code - A.3]
Q12: A psychologist supervises a student who writes in a report, “Client is intellectually limited, likely due to poor educational background.” The supervisor is concerned about what aspect of the report?
a) The lack of psychometric data
b) The ethically inappropriate language and potential bias
c) The grammar and tone
d) The over-reliance on background information
b) The ethically inappropriate language and potential bias
Rationale: Reports must be respectful, non-discriminatory, and free from biased assumptions.
Source: [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 3], [APS Code - C.2.2]
Q13: A psychologist working with a First Nations child uses a behavioural checklist without adapting for cultural context. The caregiver later complains that the results portray the child as “angry and defiant.” What was the psychologist’s main error?
a) Using a checklist instead of observation
b) Applying Western behavioural norms without cultural consultation
c) Not involving the caregiver in the test scoring
d) Reporting too quickly
b) Applying Western behavioural norms without cultural consultation
Rationale: Without culturally adapted tools or interpretation, assessments can misrepresent behaviour.
Source: [Week 4 Lecture Transcript - 00:19:10], [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 2]
Q14: A psychologist working in a hospital notices their responses to grieving clients have become robotic and emotionally numb. What is the most likely schema-related explanation?
a) Activation of the Healthy Adult mode
b) Over-identification with the client’s experience
c) Detached Protector mode as a coping response
d) Maladaptive Punitive Parent self-talk
c) Detached Protector mode as a coping response
Rationale: Emotional detachment and numbing are common features of the Detached Protector schema mode.
Source: [Lecture 11 - Schema Modes], [Wright - Ch. 5]
Q15: A psychologist in private practice designs a chatbot that uses AI to offer suggestions for anxiety. Clients are not told whether advice comes from the psychologist or the chatbot. What is the core ethical breach?
a) Use of unlicensed AI tools
b) Inaccurate billing practices
c) Lack of transparency and potential deception
d) Breach of client confidentiality
c) Lack of transparency and potential deception
Rationale: Clients must be informed about what part of their care is delivered by a human vs. AI.
Source: [Week 7 Readings - Ethics of AI Use in Therapy]
Q16: During a school assessment, a psychologist writes that a culturally diverse student shows signs of “poor motivation and low effort.” The teacher later reveals the student didn’t understand many of the test questions. What’s the key ethical failure?
a) The psychologist should not have worked in a school setting
b) The psychologist failed to consider language and cultural context
c) The test was too long for the student
d) The teacher should have informed the psychologist earlier
b) The psychologist failed to consider language and cultural context
Rationale: Assessors are responsible for ensuring comprehension and cultural fit in test administration.
Source: [Wright - Ch. 3], [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 4]
Q17: A psychologist is pressured by an agency to deliver an assessment report within 48 hours, even though they have not yet scored all measures. What is the most ethical response?
a) Submit a partial report with a disclaimer
b) Ask a colleague to help finalise scoring
c) Explain the importance of data integrity and negotiate a later date
d) Submit the report and finish the analysis later
c) Explain the importance of data integrity and negotiate a later date
Rationale: Professional responsibility includes ensuring that all data are analysed appropriately before reporting.
Source: [APS Code - C.2.3], [Lecture 8 - Ethical Reporting]
Q18: A psychologist begins working with a traumatised child who does not speak for the first two sessions. The psychologist interprets the silence as “resistance.” What is a better formulation?
a) The child is being non-compliant
b) The child needs discipline
c) Silence may reflect trauma-related protective behaviour
d) The child likely has a language disorder
c) Silence may reflect trauma-related protective behaviour
Rationale: Trauma-informed practice interprets silence as a possible survival mechanism, not resistance.
Source: [Lecture 7 - Trauma, Risk and Grief], [Routledge Handbook - Ch. 2]
Q19: A psychologist working in aged care assumes that an older client cannot provide informed consent due to their age and dementia diagnosis. They do not ask the client directly. What is ethically problematic?
a) The psychologist failed to document the assumption
b) The psychologist should have asked the client about other diagnoses
c) Assumptions about incapacity should be based on assessment, not age
d) Dementia always precludes informed consent
c) Assumptions about incapacity should be based on assessment, not age
Rationale: Age or diagnosis alone does not justify presuming a client lacks capacity.
Source: [APS Code - A.3], [Lecture 5 - Professional Judgment]
Q20: A psychologist notices that every time they assess clients from one particular CALD group, they feel unusually anxious and second-guess their findings. What is the most ethical response?
a) Avoid taking further referrals from this group
b) Acknowledge potential bias and seek supervision
c) Dismiss the reaction as performance anxiety
d) Focus more on diagnostic accuracy in future assessments
b) Acknowledge potential bias and seek supervision
Rationale: Ethical self-reflection and consultation are necessary when cultural bias is suspected.
Source: [Fernández & Abe, 2020], [APS Code - B.1.2]
Q21: A psychologist is assessing a client who speaks English as a second language and has limited literacy. They provide a long written consent form and ask the client to sign. What is the most ethical approach?
a) Simplify the form to a one-paragraph summary and skip formal consent
b) Proceed if the client signs and seems cooperative
c) Explain the form verbally and assess understanding before proceeding
d) Ask a support worker to witness the client’s signature
c) Explain the form verbally and assess understanding before proceeding
Rationale: Informed consent is not valid unless the client truly understands the information.
Source: [Wright - Ch. 1], [APS Code - A.3]
Q22: A psychologist feels emotionally numb and detached but continues working with clients in high-risk trauma settings. They begin cutting corners on documentation and avoid difficult cases. What is the ethical concern?
a) Boundary violation
b) Impaired professional judgment due to burnout
c) Role confusion with clients
d) Lack of administrative skills
b) Impaired professional judgment due to burnout
Rationale: Burnout can compromise ethical competence and judgment, requiring action or supervision.
Source: [Lecture 11 - Schema & Burnout], [APS Code - B.1.2]
Q23: A psychologist working with a young woman from a collectivist culture interprets her deference to family opinion as a lack of autonomy. What’s the main ethical issue?
a) Ignoring legal frameworks
b) Misinterpreting cultural norms and applying Western values
c) Under-diagnosing a personality disorder
d) Overlooking transference
b) Misinterpreting cultural norms and applying Western values
Rationale: Misjudging collectivist behaviour through an individualistic lens introduces cultural bias.
Source: [Routledge - Ch. 3], [Lecture 4 - Cultural Sensitivity]
Q24: A referral requests assessment for school readiness, but the psychologist instead conducts a full cognitive and personality battery without discussing the scope. What is the ethical failure?
a) Use of excessive testing hours
b) Inadequate test selection
c) Failure to clarify the referral purpose and obtain informed consent
d) Lack of culturally appropriate tests
c) Failure to clarify the referral purpose and obtain informed consent
Rationale: Scope creep without shared understanding violates client rights and professional boundaries.
Source: [Wright - Ch. 2], [APS Code - A.3]