different electoral systems Flashcards

(81 cards)

1
Q

what is voter choice

A

how much choice is given to a voter
how many votes they ger and how many candidates or parties they can vote for
is their vote wasted

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

what are two things to consider when weighing how representative a voting systsem is

A

what are the votes vs outcome is there a close correlation
what is the constituency link like

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

what is fptp

A

-single vote cast by constituent for their constituency. there are 650 constituencies so 650 mps will be voted

-it causes a SIMPLE PLURALITY SYSTEM, where the candidate wins the largest amount of votes to win, does not have to be majority

-re-elected every 5 y

for a maj gov u need 326mps

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

what is a simple plurality system?

A

where the candidate wins the largest amount of votes to win, does not have to be majority

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

what are some advantages of fptp

A

-simple system to understand as voters cast one vote, ams referendum was rejected with low turnout 42% 68% no

-it is quick 1997 blair was elected under 24h and ams in scotland takes 2weeks to find out gov

-leads to a strong singular gov and clear 2 party system, so the party who wins has a strong mandate to carry out manifesto, and most gov have maj vote so they have more legitimacy
> like thatcher quick economic policies or blair constitutional reforms like hra

clear alternative forces voters to face a fundamental choice, especially when it comes to single issue politics. in 2019 the main issue was brexit and many cast votes on that

-excludes extremist parties making it hard for them to win seats since you need concentrated geographical support : like reform uk got 4m votes but 5 seats, ukip 10% but small seats

-there is a strong mp constituency link
ex: lizz truss ban on fracking was met with 33 mp rebelling due to their constituencies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

what are some disadvantages of fptp?

A

-not proportionate ex reform uk won 5 seats with 4m of vote and 14% vote share but libdems won 72 with 12% a largely unfair disparity in seats even though in percentage it is trandlated fairly for libdems. in oakland and shetley they need 10k to win a seat in isle of wight they need 41k

-fptp discriminates against smaller parties creating a democratic deficit and wasted votes. this forces tactical voting so parliament is not representative. ex in 2015 libdems won 12% of vote and 2% of seats or UKIP won 13% of vote and one seat. in 2019 32 % of voters voted tactically

-votes are of different value due to different constituency sizes making it unfair.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

what is an evaluating argument against fptp?

A

innefective as it does not always lead storng single gov with high legitmacy or strong mandates. 2010 coalition is proof of this, and 2017 gov had small legitimacy and a weak mandate. may’s gov caused a weak brexit deal with a SC rule against her as she had a weak mandate and small majority to see brexit through. FPTP can be seen to have survived due to its history of working and benefiting large parties. this can be seen in 2022 where lab voted to introduce a new proportional system but in 2024 when they were voted in they abandoned this system completely. it also has pupblic support due to simplicity ex av ref 2011

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

what was the AV referendum

A

2011
42% turnout
68% said no

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

what is ams

A

used in scottish parliament elections, welsh assembly and greater london assembly

you get 2 votes one for yur fptp constituency and one top up for a party

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

how does the second vote in AMS work

A

meant to correct the fptp system using the dhont formula giving parties that are underrepresented more representation in a list vote/top up member.

in Scotland 76 constituency members are voted and 56 list members

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

what are some advantages of ams?

A

-top up members introduce an element of proportionality and corrects disproporionality of fptp
ex: 199 cons won 0 constituency seats but had 18 top up members correcting the fptp disadvantage

-constituency element ensures strong mp constituency link remains which is important for electorate representation in parliament

-less liekly to waste votes as you have a wider voter choice with two votes for a party and constituent mp
ex: greens won 1% of consittuent vote and 8% of top up and had 8 members through top up. this also shows a close correlation between votes and seats

-coalition govs can be strong in governing
ex scot raised income tax by 2% so they do have effective governing to pass new policies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

what are some disadvantages of ams?

A

creates 2 different types of members. one has an mp constituency link whereas one doesn’t, however there’s no evidence to prove that the top up has less legitimacy

-close party list for second vote this means voters do not know who they are voting for and the party chooses the candidate themselves. this disengages voter influence and preference as the [party leadership chooses the mp. this could cause underrepresentation in parliament. however, many voters in fptp do not know their candidate and vote rather for the party policies they embody not personal values so this is not alwyas evidence of ams being undemocratic.

-ams can lead to weak minority and coalition governments which make policy passing and governing competancy limited. this is counterproductive and can be seen as a major issue amongst people who want to adress constituency issues or national issues like scottish 2nd referendum for european membership as a single state. so far 3 scot gov have bee coalition, 2 minority and one majority

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

so overall, what does AMS do?

A
  • corrects fptp underrepresentation with a close correlation of vote share and seat share, in the top up list element. it maintains constituency element while being proportional, it is not radical change like STV as it barely results in an overwhelming majority gov (? is this true )
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

what’s an issue with safe seat voters

A

happens in fptp in uk this means in safe seats voters do not have a choice in who will win as it is overwhelmingly obvious a lot of the time. however this can be seen as a weak argument due to red wall collpasing in 2019 with BJ.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

how is the mayor of london voted

A

usually through SV but from 2024 itll be fptp

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

what is STV?

A

used in NI assembly and Scottish councils

creates multi member constituencies

voters rank choices preferentially and in roder for a candidate to be selected they have to meet a qouta which is calculated by the droop formula which is number of votes/ number of seats plus one. first preference votes are counted. if a candidate meets the qouta their surplus votes are transferred to second preferences. if no one meets the qouta then the candidate with the fewest votes is elimanted and redistributed. this is repeated until all seats filled.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

what are some advantages of STV

A
  • it is highly proportionate due to the close correlation between votes and seats, less wasted votes

-voter choice is high as they can rank candidates from the same and different parties

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

what are some disadvantage of STV?

A

in large constituencies the mp consituency link is weak

  • it is a long complex process to count and results take a while to come out and it is long for the voter to rank they may give up
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

what is sv?

A

-used in london mayor election and police and crime

voters mark 1,2 choice and if the first gets over 50% automatically elected but if not then all but 2 get eleminated and their second prefrence votes are reallocated to the top two. whoever had the most after redistribution wins.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

what are some advantages of SV?

A

-ensures broad support for the winner so they have the largest personal mandate of all candidates.

-it is simple and does not waste votes

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

what are some disadvantages of SV?

A

-a majority is not neccesary to be voted in
-some may still vote tactically
-not fully proportionate

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

what was the scottish independence referendum

A

2014
85% turnout
55% yes 45% no

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

what was the good friday agreement

A

1998
a devolved power sharing coalition gov in NI

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

what are marginal seats?

A

seats help by an mp with a small majority so it can easily switch to the opposition

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
who are left behind voters?
voters from areas of low socioeconmic backgrounds and economic deprivation in north and middle eastern england. they are seen to be politically neglected through policy failiures and they are alineted voters.
26
what was leave.eu
the offical leave campaign for the brexit referendum run by ukip
27
what role did aggrevated iq play in leave eu campaign
used targeted marketing for online advertismenbts and social media ro get vote leaves content to different segments of the population who were more neo conservative or nationalistic/patriotic. especially targeted left behind voters
28
why did take back control mean a lot to voters
it was emotional and nostalgic for patriotism for a past before multicultural britian
29
how did gov and boris help the leave campaign
as political figures they added legitimacy to the campaign as the movement was made of unlected political advisors and right wing businessmen
30
what was the brexit bus
350M was the cost of being in eu and could be used on the nhs instead. it now costs 3bn more to leave the eu annually than it would've to stay. nhs was very popular for a lot of leave voters especially left behind or those in low deprived areas
31
what was the fear of immigrants in the leave campaign
evoked fears of immigration exploited by vote leave in dog whistle social media adverts and also by the unofficial leave to project fear implying false eu movement could mean mass immigration from turkey 17m people. even though turkey was not and did not intend to join eu
32
what is class dealignment
when people no longer vote according to social class
33
what is a core voter
voter who will always almost vote for one party
34
what is a swing voter
a voter who is willing to consider changing the party they voted for from election to election
35
whatis partisan dealignment
no longer voting for a particular political party you always voted for
36
what is social class
a group of people based on their social and economic status
37
what are c2 voters and why are they important in elections
they are skilled manual workers and thet can swing in large numbers between cons and labs and this can decide an election
38
why did class dealignment happen under thatcher?
thatcherite reforms meaning deindustrialization and a structural change in the economy to laissez-faire economics. shift from industrial to service economy.
39
why is the turnout significant considering age
turnout tends to be higher among 65=75% compared to just under 50% for 18-24 so political parties have a manifesto policies that appeal to older generations that benefit them over younger like protecting pensioners with the triple lock
40
how is ethnicity a significant factor when considering turnout in elections?
BAME have a lower turnout than white 52% to white 65% nin 2019 GE. BAME has less effect for labour outside urban areas (london)
41
how does class effect voter behaviour?
traditionally A, B, C , C1, MC - conservative C2, D, E (working class) - labour
42
how does age affect voter behaviour
in 2019 39+ and 2017 37+ there was a shift towards conservatives. the party tends to focus on concerns for older people more in their policie (pensions, limits on social reforms, low taxes as older people have secured more assests statiscally in life) as voter turnout for older ishigher than younger it makes sense for their policies to appeal more to older generations
43
how does gender affect voter behaviour
traditionally womeb skewed conservative due to trad family values and men tended to vote labour as the party of workers and traditional gender roles meant men went out to wortk. however in modern trends, gender is too large a criterion to judge effectively as an electoral factor perhaps more reated to age- younger women tend more to labourt, younger men conservative
44
how does ethnicity affect voter behaviour
BAME voters tends labour ge 2019 - 64% vote labour compared to white 29% bame a minority (13%)- also voter turnout lower than white eg 52% to white 63% in 2019 GE and BAME vote has less effect fort Labour outside some urban areas like london, birmingham bradford etc
45
what is rational choice theory in voting?
suggests voters will make a rational or logical judgement based on their own best interest. however this assumes voters are fully informed about the issue.
46
what is issue voting?
suggests voters place on issue above all others and cast their vote solely based on this.
47
what are valence issues?
an issue where voters share a common preference
48
what is the most common valence issue?
the desire for the country to be economically prosperous. voters cast their vote on who they believe is best placed to deliver this.
49
issue voting case study: Brexit
2019- Johnson harnessed to win the 2019 GE due to his focus on Brexit to 'get it done'. arguably the 2017 GE was not won as May did not focus strongly on Brexit and took a soft approach in contrast to boris Johnson's hard approach the party system almost broke down as labours voters wanted to leave 37% and even under cameron conservative politicians wanted leave 58%. the referendum exposed key social divisions and was highly disruptive to british politics.
50
what does ideological mean?
of belief/ philosphy
51
what are the two different wings of the conservative party called?
-one nation -tradtional and new right
52
what wing of the conservative party was thatcher ideologically part of?
new right/ thatcherite
53
how did thatcher hide her ideological views to win 1979 election?
she downplayed the role of her key advisor sir keith joseph
54
why did thatcher need to hide her ideological views to win the election
the country was more centre left at the time, many industries were nationalised under labour and 53% of workers belonged to trade unions
55
who was labour's 1979 prime minister and why is he to blame for loss of labour's vote share?
Callaghan who was unpopular due to winter of discontent which made electoral suffer. inflation ran higher than wages leading to strikes in public services. ex: bins were uncollected and even grave diggers striked meaning some people weren't buried. meanwhile callaghan was abroad in carribean and was mocked by the media for not handling the crisis 'crisis, what crisis'
56
who won the 1997
-john major lost while tony blair won
57
what were the new labour policies and manifesto of 1997
appealed to middle class abandoned commitments to nationalisation having strong trade unions and high taxes. this meant middle class were less put off by new labour as they shifted centre right. like cons he would be tough on crime
58
what was labours advertising slogan 1997?
'beacuse britain deserves better'
59
what valence issues helped blair win the 1997 election?
cons lost due to valence issues and low governing competancy, memories of poor economic policies 1992, the maastricht treaty
60
what other issues made people lose faith in conservatives during 1997 election period?
personal misconduct scandals for david mellor and financial sleeze 'cash for questions' concerning neil hamilton, tim smith major failed to regain competancy and faith and trust of public with his back to basics campaign
61
what was majors back to basics campaign about
- stressed social conservatism -undermined the cons party traditional family value thinking, shifting them socially left after a period of new right ideologies of the nuclear family. this caused confusion and discontent
62
what was the first ever event to happen in 2010 electuon
a peactime coalition since 1930s
63
who lost 2010 election and why
gordon brown- due to blairs financial crisis 2007-8 and its substantial gov debt, as well as the effects morally of the iraq war he had bad personality to appeal to voters and had a weak campaign as well as supporting blairs stances which was unpopular with the country
64
what was the result of the 2010 election seats wise
a hung parliament as cons won a lot of seats but not enough to be a majority party. thus they had to join with lib-dems where clegg agreed to the coalition
65
what was remarkable about the 2010 coalition?
-lasted a full five year term as clegg and cameron were ideologically closer than people assumed. clegg was an orange book classical liberal who sympathised with camerons one nation instincts
66
what was kier starmers labour like in 2020 before 2024 changes?
-move from soft left which he was intially voted as a leader for in 2020, where he wanted to abolish, UC,tuition fees,shift towards centre to make them more electable
67
what change was there to keir starmers 2024 manifesto?
-no increase to any income tax or tax for working people, centrist appealing to conservative voters too increasing their governing competency,, tarnished by a old left wing labour ideology of tax and spend manifesto under corbyn where 2019 lab did badly.
68
how was the conservative campaign poor and how did this affect their outcome
sunak made one blunder after the other lowering their governing competency as a party. he also tried to issue unpopular policies like national service, or rwanda plan which went against HRA
69
what wider economic issues played into the elections
from 2019 where 40 red wall seats were lost, starmer moved the party to centre focusing on valence issues like economic stability being the core. many conditional cons voters wo were previously labour shifted due to promises of levelling up that were not carried out so there was a shift back to labour. due to covid and ukraine this drove up govt spending and borrowing meaning inflation rose to 11 and fell back down around 2.3% by 2024, but many were still under a feel bad influence not trusting the conservative rule
70
how did partygate and orher scandals play into the conservative vote in 2024
party gate led to a feeling that cons had lost their social conservatism appeal to its core voter as well as political instability led by party rebellions. furthermore, the matt hancock issue made voters upset and there was an uproar.
71
what happened to the red wall
all but 2 seats were won back in the 2024 election. one was retained as a labour mp moved to reform due to his anti-mass migration ideology, where he won the seat with a strong mandate.
72
how did reform uk gain seats due to sunaks failed stop the boats plan
sunaks failiure to implement this plan meant that there was a loss of core and red walla voters who were conservative and moved to reform. reform gained 4more mp conservatives after 2024.
73
what is mass media
as venues for messages that are created for consumption by large numbers of people. the media has a remarkable impact on politics.
74
how has the nature of the media changed over time
the printing press a traditional media has significantly declined in readership especially amongst young people. newspapers sitll have influence setting the agenda for that days news. new forms of communication such as social media has become more important with many young and older generatuons primarily consuminf their political news through mediums like facebook an twitter. this has led to a concern over the surge of fake news . this can have a major effect on voter choice in elections
75
what bias exists in uk media
terrestrial broadcasters maintain impartiality and balance in political broadcasting, however newspapers and internet websites do not need to comply to this. most national newspapers except the gaurdian, independant generally support right wing conservative values, and many readers still read this even if they do not buy newsoapers for its politics. this can impact and shape young people's political views unknowingly.
76
what impacts do newspapers have during election campaigns
newspapers endorse particular politcal paeties and spend their time supporting and prasing that party and attacking and negatively shapiing the opposititon. in 2015 ed miliband was shaped negatively, his father was shown as an enemy of britain due to his left wing views and his own presentaitional style was criticised
77
2015b impact of the newspaper during election campaigns labour
in 2015 ed miliband was shaped negatively, his father was shown as an enemy of britain due to his left wing views and his own presentaitional style was criticised
78
1992 impact of newspapers on election campaigns labour
neil kinnock was shaped to be negative for british politics with the sun printing slogans like 'will the last person to leave britian turn the lights out' to portray him in a negative light
79
what is the effect of the media on politics
the media often adds cynicism surrounding uk politics and politicians. tabloid press focuses on political scandals and allegations of incompetence and failures. as a result politicians emphasise a duty to deal with this through extensive media training which leads to the impression that they are avoidant of questions, appearing carefully staged to avoid rephrasing or misquoting. this makes them seem robotic and out of touch the way politicians present themselves to the media may impact what people think of them, whereas newspapers and media ain general portray politicians and parties in a particular way
80
what influence does the media have as in how does it not sway people in different directions
people tend to consume and belibe newspapers that support their existing point of vieqw and they recognuse the bias in the media which may not reflect their view , any media that reflects their view is seen as the truth or common sense on social media platforms people follow friends and journalist who are in line with their views creating a false impression that people are in line with a psrticular view/ echo chamber
81
how has social media transformed media and politics