paper 1 evaluations Flashcards
(76 cards)
Positives of Asch (1)
Research support
Limitations of Asch (2)
Artificial tasks and situations and Limited application
Counter point to the positive of Asch
Lucas found it to be more complex
Positives of types of conformity (2)
Research support for NSI and ISI
Negatives of types of conformity (1)
individual differences
The counterpoint in types of conformity
Unclear whether it is NSI or ISI
Zimbardos positive (1)
control
Zimbardo negative (2)
Lack of realism, exaggerates power of social roles
zimbardos counterpoint
They did believe that it was real
Milgrams positives (1)
Research support
Milgrams negative (2)
Low internal validity and alternative interpretations of findings
counterpoint in milgrams research
Puppy shocks- Sheridan and King.
Milgrams variations positive (2)
research support, cross cultural replications
Milgrams variations negative
Low internal validity
Agentic state positive
research support
Agentic state negative
Limited explanation
Legitimacy of authority positive
Explains cultural difference
legitimacy of authority negative
Cannot explain all disobedience
Authoritarian personality positive (1)
research support
Authoritarian personality negative (2)
Limited explanation, Political bias
Authoritarian personality counterpoint (1)
all had unusual characteristics
Social support Positives (2)
dissenting peers, real world research support
LOC positive
research support
LOC negative
contradictory evidence