Flashcards in Soc 100 - Education Deck (40):
Formal vs Informal Education
Formal: Education in recognised and accredited schools.Highly-institutionalised�Informal: How we learn for ourselves outside of institutions.Less organised/controlled
How does education help prepare people for the wider world (in two ways)
Training in specific routines for jobs. (Foucault attacks this.)Learning values and norms of society – the hidden curriculum, and basic social interaction outside family�
Social rank should depend on your ability, not on your birth or wealth.By ensuring educational opportunities are open to all, those with greatest talent will have chance to rise to top�-Equality of Opportunity emphasized, everyone gets same chance to succeed, in contrast with equality of outcome, in which everyone gets the same reward regardless of input
Addition of qualification requirement to take a job, e.g. degree, medical school.Growing numbers of jobs have such requirements – including doctor, truck driver, acupuncturist�.
Who argues that credentials for jobs are not necessary for most of them? Why?
Frank ParkinEver more qualifications needed for jobs that previously had no such requirement�
Who adds these needless qualifications to requirements for jobs?
Interest groups band together to add these requirements for jobs, in order to minimise the number of people who can do them, and reduce competition for jobs�.
Higher educational institution focused on production of original research; professors evaluated by publication & citation.Often causes decline in importance of teaching�.
Who examined the emergence of the modern research university after WWII, and in what book?
Christopher Jenks & David Riesman, in Academic Revolution.
Summarize the work of Jenks & Riesman in Academic Revolution. How are universities now viewed?
Colleges & universities amalgamated into single cohesive system of national education, placed in hierarchies:Focus on producing research and PhD programs; colleges that do not do so are labelled as subpar.Professors assessed by research in peer-reviewed journals; teaching less important, and only an appendage to research. Leads to large classes taught by adjunct professors.Universities viewed as producers of knowledge: aim to generate as much research as possible, regardless of teaching�. (in contrast with PROVIDERS of knowledge)
Schooling that aims to teach ‘whole person’: focused on ability to read, write, argue.Not just ‘learning by rote’�.
it’s increasingly difficult to get a higher-status job without a university degree (however ‘useful’)�.
What are the consequences of a focus on research excellence and credential inflation for universities?
Consequently, universities have larger and larger classes of students, increasingly taught by lower-ranked academics & contract instructors:Tendency for senior academics to do less teaching; classes taught by non-tenure-track adjuncts.Funding focuses on high-reward areas like medicine, science, business, and less on all-round education�.
Small groups held together by self-defined set of norms and taboos.Often deliberately seek to exclude others or to set strict conditions of membership�-small groups in which students engage in exclusionary practices to limit membership, and follow certain strict rules.�
Who explored rules governing relations between teenagers in The Adolescent Society? What sociological approach did he take?
James Coleman.-Symbolic interactionist approach explains how adolescent norms are created and enforced�
How did he describe the different roles that students played? What happened when they moved between groups?
Sporty, good-looking teens were favoured; the ‘nerd’ was rejected and ostracised. Students attempt to be popular: Coleman observed role conflict as they moved between groups�.
How does Coleman argue that adolescent behavior constitutes a specific SUBCULTURE, distinct from mainstream life?
Whilst mainstream culture values e.g. good looks, it also requires self-discipline, learning, work. High school subculture ignores many of these: focuses only on immediate signs of success�.
What does Coleman think about how schools prepare students for adult life?
Coleman suggests that schools are bad at preparing students for adult life: whatever the formal system of education does, the subculture in which they live causes them to devalue education�.
What do some sociologists believe adolescent subculture reflects in adult life?
reflects same problems of conflict, inappropriate values etc as adult life�
How can a microsociological approach help us understand student success?
can help us understand why some students succeed and some don’t:Do the less successful hold to cultural values that prioritise looks over learning? Why this rejection of education?
The surreptitious way in which children are taught to expect a certain place in society.Seen in gendered classes (e.g. ‘cooking’ for girls), or in careers people are prepared for�. (Crit Th perspective)
What function do Crit Th think education has? How does it achieve this?
it prepares them for subordinate positions.� (students)-keeps kids of streets so can be closely supervised/monitored-lessons subtly prepare people's expectations about their life, in a way that makes them accept an inferior social status-classes may be gendered - cooking for girls, manual classes for boys; ‘tough’ sports for boys, ‘soft’ ones for girls�
Treating one’s child as a status symbol; valuing a child by its educational or sporting achievements alone�
Who wrote Crestwood Heights and what did it examine? What did it find?
John R. Seeley’s 1956 study Crestwood Heights examined the sorts of expectations inculcated in children of wealthier families through micosociological examination.-families wanted children as perfect and successful as their 'model' homes and careers-kids pushed to succeed, to focus increasingly on grades
What was the side effect of making children to focus increasingly on grades?
Teachers pressured to give higher grades, leading to grade inflation.Increased tensions in system as a whole due to extreme pressure for measurable success.
Foucault’s term for a micropolitics of power, manifest in numerous small institutions and everyday instances of control. Educational system is part of broad system to train you�.
In Foucault's Discipline & Punish, what does he compare the modern education system to? How? What is the consequence?
The prison system.Emphasis on measurement; constant scrutiny in pointless exams; clearly-defined boundaries of achievement�.The consequence is students who learn by rote in order to pass exams in which they only have to regurgitate facts.They are disciplined: they automatically produce the model response, without any critical engagement whatsover�.
'Banking' model of education
Students treated as ‘empty bank accounts’, to be filled with valuable knowledge by the teacher. Students are passive, teacher alone acts�.
Who is Paolo Freire and what model of teaching/education does he criticise. Why?
Radical philosopher.the traditional model of teaching ,for treating students as mere empty receptacle to have knowledge poured into them.Students remain passive in this model: teacher is the authority figure, who simply transmits facts to the class. (like banking model of education)
What did Freire want for oppressed groups?
To be freed from their subordinate position.
How had well-meaning education reformers failed before Freire?
Well-meaning reformers who sought to ‘educate’ the masses would actually leave them as passive as before, and therefore just as oppressed in reality�.
Teaching inspired by Freire that encourages students to think, to behave as problem-solvers, and to be critically aware in their own learning�.
Freire endorsed this: making students self-aware as learners, aware of own abilities.
What did Freire suggest about the teacher/student relationship?
That teachers themselves must learn from their students: they shouldn’t try to remain above the process of learning, as if they already know everything�.
Minority group that has much greater success in education and employment than most other groups.Often held up as a ‘model’ by dominant groups, for how others ‘should’ behave�.-Even when we control for other variables (e.g. whether parents have degrees), these groups still much more successful�
What kinds of qualities are model minorities thought to have?
said to have ‘strong work ethics’ or ‘good family values.�'
How are model minorities held up by dominant groups as evidence against racism?
‘If they can be so successful, then there’s obviously no problem, and no excuses for others.’-used to attack disadvantaged groups by blaming their lower achievement on ‘lack of work ethic.�'
How can much of the difference in success for underprivileged groups be explained (deliberate or inadvertent)
Segregation of Education.-Long history of deliberate segregation in US, but other countries see similar effects even without legalised racism�.
What report exposed systemic inequalities in US education? Who was it by? What did it investigate?
James Coleman's 'Coleman Report'-investigated opportunities available to people based on ethnicity
What kinds of schools does James Coleman think we need? Explain.
Integrated, Desegregated Schools!Students learn more than just facts at school: they make networks of connections, and learn ways of behaving.Students whose only access to schools in deprived areas wouldn’t acquire all the extra knowledge and opportunities�.