2) class identity Flashcards
(10 cards)
(CI) Habitus definition
Way of life for social class
(CI) Symbolic capital definition
Being wealthy in terms of status
(CI) Symbolic Violence Definition
where the behaviour or habitus of others is devalued as inferior
(CI) Social Suicide Definition
Not conforming to style standards leading to negative responses from peers
(CI) Self Exclusion definition
Taking yourself out of a situation
(CI) Habitus
how pupils’ class identities formed outside school interact with the schools values to produce educational success and failure
Archer et al - working class identities in school and how it produces underachievement, drawing on Bourdieu’s habitus,
MC have power to define their habitus as superior, imposing it on education. schools put higher value on MC tastes, links to Bourdieu’s idea of cultural capital
(CI) Symbolic Capital and Symbolic Violence
Archer - found that WC pupils felt to be successful in education they had to change themselves. education success came at cost of ‘losing yourself’ couldn’t access posh MC places like uni - ‘not for likes of us’
Schools have MC habitus, MC socialisation gains ‘symbolic capital’ and status from school
WC habitus devalued, seemingly tasteless and worthless
Bourdieu calls this withholding of symbolic capital ‘symbolic violence’, reproducing class structure and keeps WC ‘in place’
(CI) Nike identities
Symbolic violence led them to seek alternative way of creating self
worth
meaningful class identities, investing in styles of branded clothes like Nike.
Style performances heavily policed by peer groups, not conforming ‘social suicide’
conflict with schools dress code
Archer - schools MC habitus stigmatises WC identity, reject higher education (unrealistic and undesirable) WC pupils could choose to self exclude from ed - doesn’t fit
(CI) Working-class identity and educational success
Ingram - some WC pupils succeed. 2 groups of WC Catholic boys from deprived area in Belfast. One went to grammar one went secondary. WC communities great emphasis on conformity, grammar school boys experienced most tension between WC home and MC school. Tracksuit at grammar school - symbolic violence, WC pupils had to abandon WC identity to succeed
(CI) Class Identity and Self Exclusion
WC at uni, experience clash between WC identity and higher education habitus, becoming barrier to success.
Evans sees this as ‘self-exclusion’
21 WC girls at SL comp, reluctant to apply to elite ones, wouldn’t fit in
only 4/21 intended to move away to study
Raey et al - self exclusion from elite unis narrows WC pupils success
MC education devaluing experiences of WC as worthless, WC choose between keeping WC identities or abandoning them to conform to MC habitus to succeed