Lecture 6 (Chapter 10 + 11) Flashcards
What is the Neo-Analytic Movement?
Neo-Freudians followed Freud’s ideas and developed further. Most of these people had their own breakups with Freud, except his daughter Anna Freud.
Freud’s psychology was referred to as the Id psychology.
What did the Neo-Freudians think about Id Psychology?
They disagreed with it and instead focused on the development of the ego within reality.
Emphasized the role of identity, which is experienced by a person as a sense of self
Explored the narcissism trait, in part because of its complexities
What is the definition of narcissism?
An extreme preoccupation with the self, accompanied by inflated self-admiration (bragging), grandiosity (acting like one is better than everyone else), entitlement (deserving more than everyone else), and attention-seeking (to validate their sense of superiority)
- Also: bragging/boasting, arrogance, sensitivity to criticism, low empathy, derogation of others, bullying (to make themselves feel elevated).
- distinguish it from egocentrism: an inability to see other people’s perspectives and understand other people (self-centeredness)
What facets do people with moderate or low level of narcissism have?
At a moderate level (may be healthy): self serving bias; slightly unrealistically positive self-image; some drive to feel special.
At a low level: very modest; self-effacing.
What is narcissistic personality disorder?
Extreme expressions of traits: A pattern of grandiosity, need for admiration, and lack of empathy
Accompanied by functional impairments, especially impairment in empathy
There is also malignant narcissism - narcissism combined with psychopathy (make other people suffer, violate their rights)
People with high levels of narcissism do not see the negatives in themselves therefore it is nearly impossible for them to seek treatment
What are some things people high in narcissism display?
- may use more first-person singular pronouns (i.e., I-talk)
- look in the mirror more, watch recordings of themselves more often.
- interrupt others more during conversation.
But also… - become distressed and aggressive when insulted. (because their sense of superiority is fabricated and it’s vulnerable)
- make good first impressions
- boasting was found to be highly correlated (.59) with states/territories winning
How are people high in narcissism like on social media?
- are more active on social media (inc. Instagram, TikTok).
- post more about their accomplishments; take/post more selfies.
- enjoy debating more on social media; also trolling (esp. men). trolling: someone who intentionally upsets others online.
- receive more likes on their posts.
What is inferiority complex, according to Alfred Adler (1930)?
Inferiority Complex: lack of self-worth resulting from early development; low self-esteem.
Overcompensate through “striving for superiority” – making others unhappy.
– Foundation for narcissism.
What is the narcissistic paradox?
Although narcissists appear to have high self-esteem, they have doubts over their self-worth.
Therefore, narcissism is a complex defence mechanism.
“Narcissism is not self-love, it is self-loathing in disguise.”
Narcissists may have lower implicit self-esteem. They display insecurities if asked questions in a certain way.
- Explicit self-esteem is asking people to rate themselves on a Likert scale, whereas implicit self-esteem is unconscious manifestations of self-esteem, e.g., associating positive words with letters of their names, people’s sizes of signatures.
What is the difference between grandiose and vulnerable narcissism?
Both involve self-centeredness, entitlement, disregard for others,
and interpersonal antagonism/disagreeableness
Grandiose narcissism involves high self-esteem, social dominance, exhibitionism, overestimation of abilities; fantasies of superiority.
Correlated w/ high extraversion, low agreeableness, aggressiveness.
Vulnerable narcissism involves insecurities, hypersensitivity and vulnerability, anxiety, avoidance, hypervigilance for criticism.
Correlated w/ high neuroticism, low extraversion, low agreeableness.
- more likely to experience suicidal ideation, constant concerns of what other people are thinking about them
Which areas are narcissists more likely to succeed in?
- show business
- leadership
- job interviews
- initial interactions
But narcissists lose popularity over time
What are narcissistic leaders like?
Narcissists tend to seek out political positions more than non-narcissists.
Although they may be more successful, they’re more likely to abuse their powers and are at higher risk of impeachment
Biographical analyses of American presidents have concluded that most (if not all) have been moderate-to-high in grandiose narcissism
According to psychologists, most (if not all) dictators and
authoritarian leaders throughout history have embodied traits consistent with malignant narcissism
example毛泽东??
How do narcissists behave interpersonally?
- divide people to gain power over them.
- use threats and lies to influence people’s emotions/behaviours.
- distort reality by arguing fiction is fact; engage in gaslighting.
(煤气灯效应是一种心理操纵的形式,其方法是一个人或团体隐秘地让受害人逐渐开始怀疑自己,使其质疑自己的记忆力、感知力或判断力,其结果是导致受害者产生认知失调和其他变化,例如低下的自我尊重等。)
What is Erik Erikson’s ego development suggesting about the origin of narcissism?
Erik Erikson (1902-1994)
Focused on ego development over life.
Identified common/necessary tensions inherent to each stage of development.
Goal: struggle with tensions and grow, achieve ego integrity – acceptance of oneself and one’s life.
According to Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development,
narcissism would most likely result from a sense of inferiority during the ‘Industry vs. Inferiority’ stage (ages 4–12). Kindergarten and Elementary school
* A lack of competence; not feeling “good enough.”
Example: Donald Trump’s dad
What are the 8 stages of ego development?
- Trust vs. Mistrust: The first stage, which begins at birth and lasts until a baby is about 18 months old
- Autonomy vs. Shame and Doubt: The second stage, which occurs between 18 months and about 3 years
- Initiative vs. Guilt: The third stage, which occurs between about 3 and 6 years
- Industry vs. Inferiority: The fourth stage, which occurs between about 5 and 11 years
- Identity vs. Role Confusion: The fifth stage, which occurs between about 12 and 19 years
- Intimacy vs. Isolation: The sixth stage
- Generativity vs. Stagnation: The seventh stage
- Integrity vs. Despair: The eighth stage
What is the object relations theory?
Examines the process of developing one’s psyche in relation to others in the environment.
Internalized representations of parents (unconscious) become basis for relating to others in life. (similar to attachment development)
First social attachments form prototypes for future relationships.
Possible introjection (the unconscious process of internalizing the beliefs, attitudes, or values of others, often significant figures like parents, and incorporating them into one’s own sense of self, essentially “taking in” aspects of another person’s personality as if they were your own)
According to the object relations theory, where does narcissism arise from?
Narcissism arises from the internalized dilemma of whether the parent is good or bad. Failure to solve this dilemma leads to low self-worth and splitting.
- They grow up seeing themselves as all good because they don’t believe a person can be both good and bad.
Splitting – extreme, black-and-white thinking (a defence).
Individuals see themselves as “all good” and others as either “all good” or “all bad.”
This protects the narcissist’s inflated self-image.
Who introduced the attachment theory? What is the theory about?
John Bowlby (1969)
Infants must form a healthy relationship with a caregiver for successful development.
Main factors in parenting are sensitivity and responsiveness.
What are the four types of attachment in children?
- Secure well-adjusted, trusting; caregivers responsive to needs
- Anxious-Ambivalent anxious, clingy; caregivers inconsistent
- vulnerable narcissism - Avoidant uninterested, emotionally distant; caregivers neglectful
- grandiose narcissism - Disorganized erratic; caregivers depressed, traumatized, or abusive
What are four styles of adult attachment?
- Secure Style comfortable w/ intimacy; autonomous & dependent
- Preoccupied (Ambivalent) Style crave intimacy; worried about partners
- emotional instability - Dismissive-Avoidant Style minimize closeness; intimacy = loss of independence.
- correlated with grandiose narcissism - Fearful-Avoidant Style want relationship, but difficulty trusting others
- Vulnerable narcissism is correlated with 2 and 4
What parenting styles are associated with narcissism?
Authoritarian, which insists on perfection, winning, and toughness.
- children display narcissism to compensate for the feeling of not being enough
Neglectful, which can result in a lack of empathy and warmth.
- narcissism to compensate for the lack of empathy and warmth
Permissive/Indulgent, which can promote entitled attitudes.
- The child learns in a direct way that they are the best no matter what
Karen Horney (1942) agreed that narcissism involves low self-esteem.
Suggested that indulgence (via over-permissive parents) in childhood leads to excessive self-idealization.
What is the study done by Brummenlman et al. (2015) suggest about childhood narcissism (age 7-12) and parental behaviours?
Methods:
Children completed questionnaires assessing narcissism (e.g., “kids like me deserve something
extra”) and self-esteem (e.g., “kids like me are happy with themselves as a person”).
Parents completed questionnaires to assess parental overvaluation (e.g., “my child is more special than other children”) and parental warmth (e.g., “I let my child know I love him/her”).
Results: Support for social learning theory — Higher narcissism was predicted by parental overvaluation, not by lack of warmth.
- lack of warmth predicted low self-esteem in children
Is narcissism rising among young people?
In studies of American college students…
Meta-analysis by Twenge et al. (2008):
From 1982 – 2006: 30% increase in those
scoring above the mean on the Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI) (N = 16,475).
Meta-analysis by Konrath, O’Brien, & Tsing (2016):
From 1979 – 2009: 48% drop in empathic concern, 34% drop in perspective-taking (N = 13,737)
Potential reasons:
competition over resources
materialism to make oneself look superior in front of others
What did Kaufman find out about characteristics of self-actualizers?
Kaufman (2018) – Developed a 30-item self-report measure of 10 characteristics of self-actualizers proposed by Maslow.
Those reporting more characteristics of self-actualization…
Were more motivated by growth, exploration, and love of humanity than
the fulfillment of deficiencies in basic needs.
Reported greater life satisfaction, self-acceptance, positive relations, environmental mastery, personal growth, autonomy, purpose in life, and
self-transcendent experiences.
Displayed more creativity across multiple domains of achievement.
Even in early adulthood, the traits of self-actualization are normally distributed.