RespoEpiDecko Flashcards
(81 cards)
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the Finnish “conscript” study show with regards to asthma prevalence between 1960 - 1980 in young men? Haahtela et al
Those conscripted had medical screening.
Prevalence of asthma went up from 0.1%-1.8% “at or before screening”
Prevalence (unsurprisingly) went up in those exempted from joining the army
BUT prevalence in those “discharged” because their asthma affected their ability to be in the army also went up.
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did Krause et al discover in 2002 about levels of IgE in 1987 and 1998 cohorts in Greenland?
Atopy roughly 20% in 1998 across all age groups
Ranged from 5-15 in each age cohort in 1987
Hygiene Hypothesis If changes (in anything) occur across short time spaces, what does this suggest?
Must be environmental rather than genetic
Hygiene Hypothesis
What would geographical variation in genetically similar populations show?
Likely to be due to environmental differences // lifestyle western vs non
Hygiene Hypothesis
List some factors affecting atopy // allergy?
Prenatal environment - Maternal diet/smoking/pollution/stress Birth - Weight - Mode of delivery Early Life - Exposure to: allergens, moulds, pets, endotoxins, damp, plastics - Infections - Outdoor exposure - NO2, ozone - Breast feeding - Diet - oxidants, vitamin D, BMI Adult Life - Occupation - Indoor exposure - ie domestic cleaning - Diet - allergens/fats/antioxidants etc - COCP - Hormone changes
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the 1958 British Cohort Study find with regards to older siblings?
What does this imply?
Increased older siblings = reduced prevalence of hayfever + eczema.
Implies having older siblings is associated with a protective factor for hayfever at 11,23/eczema
OR
Implies either that mothers who have atopic children don’t have any more children (selective fertility)
OR
Implies that as mothers have more children something INSIDE the mother changes
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the 1958 British Birth Cohort find with regards to YOUNGER siblings? What does this imply regarding the selective fertility//maternal changes interpretations?
Decreased prevalence of hayfever at 11/23 and eczema as an infant with increased amounts of younger siblings
As both older + younger siblings are associated with decreased atopy maternal changes/selective fertility interpretations cannot be explanatory for the findings
Hygiene Hypothesis
What was 1958 british birth cohort?
Cohort of babies born in 1958 followed throughout life -> answer questionnaires
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the 1958 british cohort show when correcting for father social class, housing tenure, shared household amenities and breast feeding?
Trend for decreased prevalence of atopy still existed
Hygiene Hypothesis
Systematic review for the association between family size (3+) and hayfever concludes what?
That 3+ in family is associated with dec hayfever
Hygiene Hypothesis
What do studies show with regards to “age of entry” at day-care/nursery in children from SMALL families <4 ppl @ home? Hay/skin/bronch
Kramer et al
Entering at 24+ months has 3.63x risk of developing hayfever if entering between 6-11months
Also 2.72x risk of positive skin-prick test
BUT trend to decrease 23% risk of getting bronchitis (NOT SIGNIFICANT)
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did Kramer et als cross sectional study show with regards to “age of entry” to daycare in children from large families? Hay/skin/bronc
Risks for each remained the same
Hygiene Hypothesis
What is the correlation between measles and atopy?
Guinea Bissau (had bad bout measles) (14-21yos)
But what could explain this?
With those who had measles there was a 64% reduction in atopy.
Could be explained though by “survival bias”
- Idea that atopic children more likely to die from measles
- Therefore appears “measles survivors” less atopic
- The results of this study haven’t been replicated in other countries/less severe epidemics
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the italian army recruits study depict with regards to siblings, and seropositivity to Hep A?
Prevalence of atopy decreased with increased older siblings IN SERONEGATIVE
Prevalence of atopy remained similar with increased older siblings in SEROPOSITIVE
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did Farooqui discover with regards to maternal atopy, pertussis and abx when <2?
Prevalence of hayfever, eczema and asthma increased with any one of these.
Having combinations/all further increases prevalence
Hygiene Hypothesis
What is a possible explanation for the positive association between ABx and allergic disease?
Asthmatics
- More likely to suffer severe infections
- More likely to go to doctor
- Doctor more likely to give them ABx
- Asthma may prevent with “infection” + be diagnosed subsequently
Hygiene Hypothesis
What correlations have been seen with Steiner schools and allergic disease?
What lifestyle differences are seen with steiner children?
Sig less atopy/asthma/hayfever
Greater prevalence: - Breast feeding - Measles - Fermented veg consumption - Organic foods Red prevalence: - ABx - Paracetamol - MMR vaccine
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the ALEX study show with regards to rural farming vs rural non-farming, and un-pasteurised milk consumption/been inside stable <1yr old?
For each asthma, hayfever and IgE sensitisation prevalence is:
Stable and milk < Stable no milk < milk no stable < Milk or stable AFTER 1 yr < Never milk/stable
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the systematic review show with regards living on a farm? Nasal symps, IgE sensitisation
Living on a farm (In UK belgium france NZ and sweden) does reduce atopy
Hygiene Hypothesis
What is the relationship between the range of microbes encountered and probability of asthma?
PARSFAL + GABRIELA studies?
The more diverse microbes encountered the smaller the probability of asthma
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did the ISAAC study show with regards to living on a farm and atopy though?
Protection from allergy/asthma is not present in ALL farming populations in ALL settings
Hygiene Hypothesis
What is the postulated hypothesis of BOWEL FLORA + allergy?
Gut flora crucial to immune development
- May not occur with C section
- May not occur with ABx
- May be altered by probiotics
Hygiene Hypothesis
What did a study in Sweden and Estonia depict, with regards to lactobacilli in allergic infants?
Reduced lactobacilli in allergic infants
Hygiene Hypothesis
What was seen with regards to association of atopy, asthma, hayfever, atopic eczema and C section?
What is a possible confounder?
3.2x risk of asthma if C section
No associations with others
Asthmatic babies potientially at risk more in utero? -> more are delivered by c section?