U.S Healthcare exam 2 Flashcards
(142 cards)
Ethics in Practice
what does the Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) do
what do ethics committees do in hospitals
what do compliance officers do
what was first published in 1852
Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) –required to approve all investigational research involving human subjects to ensure their ethical treatment
Ethics Committees in hospitals can act as consultants for difficult or recurrent ethical cases
Compliance officers in corporations and managed agencies –report directly to the CEO
Code of Ethics for Pharmacists (first published 1852)
Principles of Medical Ethics
Beneficence is the duty of healthcare providers to do what
Nonmaleficence is the duty of healthcare providers to do what
Autonomy gives the patient the right to do what
Justice is the concept of treating people with what
Beneficence – obligation of healthcare providers to help people in need; duty to help others
Nonmaleficence – duty of health care providers to “do no harm”
Autonomy – right of the patients to make choices regarding their health care
Justice – concept of treating everyone in a fair manner
In the previous example, which ethical principle is being violated from the perspective of the patient?
Beneficence
Nonmaleficence
Autonomy
Justice
Autonomy
Ethical dilemmas
the provider is forced to do what
when does this often occur
Provider of medical care is forced to make a decision that violates one of the four principles of ethics
Often occur when you run out of options
Ethical Dilemma
From the earlier example, the medical resident’s desire to treat the patient with standard medical therapy demonstrates the principle of beneficence
Not giving proven effective therapy in this patient can cause serious harm – the resident wants to treat the patient and help them survive
This case is unique because the doctor is being prevented from giving care he would have given to almost any other patient in the same situation
what does the desire to not receive blood represent
For the patient, the desire to not receive blood products represents the principle of autonomy
Social-ethical dilemmas
what is connected to in reference to what
some patients are unable to receive needed care, why?
Connected to the concept of justice
Justice in reference to access to basic medical care
Some patients unable to receive needed care because they lack money and insurance or resources in their area
Distributive Justice
when does issue arise
what questions does it ask about right, care, taxes etc
all people should have what kind of access without financial barriers if healthcare was distributed based on what
what is always debated in the US about rights and privileges
Issue arises when money and resource become scarce
Allocation of the benefits and burdens in society
Is healthcare a privilege or a right? Who receives care? Who pays taxes? Who decides?
All people should have equal access to a reasonable level of care without financial barriers
If healthcare should be distributed based on need for care
In the US, the belief of healthcare as a right versus a privilege continues to be a debate
Rationing will be on exam
The limitation of resources, including money, going to medical care such that not all care expected to be beneficial is provided to all patients; and the distribution of these limited resources in a fair manner.
A conscious policy to equitably distribute limited resources
Urgent MRI scan versus an elective scan
Organ transplant waitlists
Available hospital beds
Drug shortages (or even IV bags)
Scarcity – not enough to go around
what is there a scarcity of
Scarcity of Commodity
Scarcity of Money (fiscal)
Scarcity of Resources
Scarcity of Commodity
what is one example of this matter
how is it address
what can impact the example
what is not donated enough
what question is always being asked
Organ transplantation
Addressed through macroallocation (society/large population) process, life style can affect candidacy – if you drink then you will probably not qualify because they see it as a waste
There are not enough organs donated to meet demand
135,000 patients waiting for an organ in 2015
Example of the interaction of ethics and rationing
Who should receive available organs??
United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS)
Rationing and microallocation
what is there is constraint on
for covid 19 and ventilators what was alway questioned
Brings ethical principles into focus, sometimes tragically
Older patients with co-morbidities and poor prognosis may not receive potentially life saving therapy due to a lack of resources
Resource constraints on an institution or physician level
COVID-19 and rationing on the institution level
Not enough ventilators for all patients requiring support
Who gets mechanical ventilation?
Not enough vent technicians to monitor the ventilators being used
Who gets moved from one department to fill the gap? Is this even possible?
Rationing Healthcare
If rationing a beneficial service is necessary, medical effectiveness can help guide what
Maximizing care for healthy/screening increases resources for who
when Managing chronic diseases Medication adherence, what is usually considered
Oregon Health Plan – Rational rationing
Prioritized care for certain diagnoses and expanded coverage to 100K more patients
Plan unraveled
If rationing a beneficial service is necessary, medical effectiveness can help guide choices
Providing care when healthy vs care when sick
Maximizing care for healthy/screening increases resources for those who are sick
Managing chronic diseases
Medication adherence (beneficence vs autonomy)
Rationing and cost control
Controlling cost does not equal rationing of healthcare
Difference between reducing unnecessary interventions or eliminating administrative waste and a compromise in truly beneficial services
Summary of lecture 1 of unit 2
what can be said about ethical dilemmas
what will healthcare always struggle with
Ethics and ethical dilemmas play a role in many healthcare decisions that are made on a daily basis
Healthcare always will struggle with balancing care to individual patients with responsibly managing resources
Cost of Healthcare
Last lecture you discussed cost trends, costs vs outcomes, price x quantity, and reviewed ways to control costs
Multiple drivers of health care cost
Overuse or inappropriate utilization
Inefficient payment systems
High prices
Excessive administrative cost
Medical liability
Declining health status in the population / chronic disease
Uncontrolled costs may lead to inaccessible and inequitable care
How to Contain Costs
Decrease use of healthcare services
Decrease reimbursement for service
Decrease overhead (payer and/or provider)
Cost Control – Follow the money
payers to health plan to providers
Financing Controls: Regulatory Strategies:
passing what or creating what
medicare part ___
affordable care ___
Passing laws or creating taxes
Medicare Part A
Social insurance systems
Regulated by Federal government
Medicare payroll tax 2.9%
Affordable Care Act (ACA)
Competition Considerations…
who’s buying
does it work?
Who’s buying?
–Employer based insurance blunts the high cost of insurance
–Cost of health insurance paid by employer not seen as lost wages
–A federal tax exemption increases value for the employee and savings for the employer
Does it work?
–Premiums continue to grow at about 5% per year
–Competition has not truly been implemented in most markets
Weakness of financing controls
To be successful, they must produce decreased flow on the payment side
If payment to physicians, hospitals, and other providers increases, the budget deficits must be offset by increased taxes
Insurers may raise premiums if they cannot control what they pay to hospitals
Competition places emphasis on private health insurance to regulate payment costs
Payment: Price controls
what is set
what is an example of this
these fees set by Medicare may impact what a patient
Set reimbursement rates (ie: Canada, Medicare)
–Uniform fee schedule (fee-for-service)
- A list of fees used to pay doctors/providers for services
- These fees set by Medicare may impact the care patients receive
Payment: Price controls
Predetermined pricing for services
Competitive bidding between private insurance plans
Reference pricing
Example:
Choice Ref PPO asks each hospital in its market region to submit a bid for the cost a knee replacement. Most bids are around $40,000. High Value Hospital submits a bid for $33,000. Choice Ref informs patients enrolled in their plan that they can choose any hospital for a knee replacement, but that they will only pay the hospital $35,000 and the patient is responsible for the rest. After this policy, 75% of Choice Ref patients get knee replacements at High Value Hospital.
Problems with price control
cost shifting
patient churning
why is it hard for patients to find providers who accept medicaid
what does it result in
Cost shifting – Increasing charges to other payers to compensate for lowering the cost for one payer
Problem often avoided using uniform fee schedules or single payers
Patient churning - Inducing higher use of services (more visits/procedures/etc) to offset the lower price with higher volume in order to maintain earnings
Example: Medicaid fee-for-service pays physicians far below private insurance rates
Difficult for patients to find providers who will accept Medicaid
Results in patient churning, reduced quality of care, reduced patient satisfaction
Utilization Controls
what do payers need methods to do
what are the 3 methods to consider
Payers (ie: the health insurance) need methods to contain how often their customers (ie: the patients) use healthcare resources
Three methods to consider
Unit of payment
Patient behavior
Physician behavior